by Mary Swan
Wee Alan, she told me, was the first-born, but he’d died on the ship, just days after leaving the Old Country. So long ago that my father was a baby himself, and now no one living would have seen the white shroud or heard the splash, would remember the way the ocean stretched all around, under the chilly sky. Which meant that I couldn’t have remembered, as I thought I did, my father telling stories about him, the way he sometimes did about Ben and Charlie, who were clearly very much alive. That was a puzzle, but even stranger was the second thing Kez said—that these were the first words I’d spoken since the fire. At first I thought she was teasing, the way I’d learned she often did, but Aunt Nan put her soft hand on my shoulder, and said that it was so. And the red wool scratched as it wound again from my fingers.
I had to look at everything differently then, every outing, every conversation; I had to understand that I was somehow not the person I thought I was. I thought about how quickly I’d come to know the house and its people, the sounds of the city and the different look to the light. How little time it had taken before I could walk without even noticing the lump of hard-packed earth still tucked in my shoe. That night, before I slept, I thought about how everything was starting again, and I vowed to be good and kind, as if I always had been.
February
In the mornings the children call out to each other, as they make their way to the school, and it’s really not that long ago that Edie was one of them, linking arms with her friends with no thought at all that there might be someone trapped behind a window. Not long since my aunts’ last visit, when we hired a buggy for a drive in the countryside and Edie fell asleep with her cheeks flushed with health, not fever, while over her bobbing head Nan whispered about Charlie’s latest trouble. It’s been months, not years, yet that day seems as distant as a story, and I suppose that’s the only way to bear it. People get used to all kinds of things, don’t they? They move house, lose limbs, lose their sight, and if the time before was just as clear, I don’t suppose they could go on. Each time a new building rises in the city, raw and strange, it quickly becomes familiar, and when people walk by they may still have the idea, but only the idea, of what was there. The tall trees or the row of houses with painted front doors.
It’s like that when I think of the time before Edie got sick, and it’s hard to imagine our days back then, the routine of shopping, of cleaning and cooking. I do the minimum now, needing to be within earshot, and the grocer’s boy brings what I’ve ordered, speaking into our new telephone that’s meant to be only for station business. I don’t know what Angus is doing about all his paperwork, but he’s home now in the evenings, and sits and talks with Edie, or reads to her, while I clear up what’s left from our meal. I sleep quite comfortably on the parlour sofa, that we moved into the kitchen to make space for Edie’s bed; when I climb the stairs now it’s only to run the duster quickly around or to fetch something that I need, and it’s like another world. So empty and still, so abandoned.
“Tell me again about my name,” Edie says. “How it jumped right into your head when you saw me.” And it’s true, I knew right away I would name her for Aunt Edith, so sunny and strong, the best charm I could imagine. When she was six months old we rode the train to the city for Easter, and everyone made such a fuss over her chuffie cheeks, her two sharp teeth. Aunt Edith had a little cough she was afraid of passing on, and just watched while my aunts took turns holding her, watched Uncle Charlie dance her around, waving her wooden rattle. My cousins clapped her hands and bounced her on their bony knees, pulling faces to hear her gurgling laugh and tiring her out so she slept right through the night. In the morning Angus touched my cheek and said, “Maybe that’s the secret, maybe we need to have a whole houseful of children.”
I can hardly bear to think of that giddy time, when we still thought everything was possible. As foolish as the boastful tailor, sewing his magic coat and not hearing the Elfin Queen’s laughter, her plan unfolding with every stitch. We had two sons in the years that followed, but they didn’t survive. The first I held and wept over, touched the smooth blue eyelids that never opened. With the second I heard a thin mewl and the midwives’ shocked whispers, as I sank into a dark place of pain and fever. When I came back to myself I understood that no other child of mine would be allowed to live, and even without the doctor’s warning to Angus, everything between us would have changed. And it torments me still, that the charm I intended was really a curse.
Aunt Edith’s cough got worse and it wore her out; she could barely leave her bed by the time our Edie let go of our fingers and began to walk on her own. When the latest doctors told Ben that the only hope was a warmer climate, he found a new position in California, and everything changed so quickly. It was an expensive business to move them all, and my aunts convinced him that the only thing was to sell the double house, and most of the heavy old furniture that they wouldn’t need. With Clare married and settled in Washington there was just more empty space in the old house, and Charlie could squeeze in anywhere if he needed to. So really, they told Ben, their new small place was just right, and only a trolley ride away from everything.
At first it seemed that the doctors had been right. Aunt Edith wrote that she was a bit tired still but so much better, and the children were running wild and sounding like little Yankees already. Kez and Nan began to talk about taking a trip out there to see the white house on the hillside, dip their toes in the ocean. But then there was a telegram from Ben, followed by a long letter describing how Edith had slipped away. They buried her, as he said she’d wanted, under that strange, bright sun.
My aunts assumed that they’d all come back, that something close to the old life would start again. Perhaps, Ben wrote, but there’d been so much upheaval for the children already. Perhaps, but first there were projects he had to see through. He talked about coming to visit, or sending Daisy and George for the summer, though it was such a long way for them to travel on their own. There were notes from the children inside every letter, that of course became shorter and shorter. One from Sandy was just a scribbled drawing of their new dog; “Looks more like a donkey,” Kez said, when she took it from her bag to show me.
“Look who I found,” Angus says, kicking snow off his boots as he comes through the door with Ida and Becky right behind him, unwinding their long scarves to reveal their healthy pink faces.
“We made a cake,” they say together, holding it out, still warm through the white cloth that wraps it. Much too rich for an invalid’s diet, but no one hears me say that. Angus rubs and claps his hands as he leads the way to the parlour, where Edie squeals and the giggling starts; I know those girls, they can keep it up for hours.
“What?” Angus says, back in the kitchen, and I turn away with the cake knife. “They’ll cheer her up.”
When I say that they’ll wear her out, he makes a little tch through his teeth and says that then she’ll rest, as if it was that easy. “I don’t want to argue,” he says, touching my cheek with his still-cold hand, and he drapes the dishtowel over his arm and carries the cake into the parlour. He pretends to stumble in the doorway, the plate waving wildly and the little forks rattling, and the girls all laugh and Edie says, “Oh, Daddy.”
Something eases in me then, and I remember what a revelation it was, when she was born, to watch him pacing the floor with her, bending to whisper in her tiny ear. The two of them in their own magic circle, with the songs and jokes and rituals that still aren’t for anyone else. When Edie was two or three they played a game they called Schedule, that started with Angus reading out the names of places from the list tacked up by the back door. “Where are you going today, madam?” he’d say. “Hamilton? Yp-si-lan-ti? Pough-keep-sie?” Adding outlandish names until she could barely breathe for laughing. Then he dropped to his hands and knees, saying, “Last call for Schenec-tady. All aboard for Kalamazoo!” and that was the signal for Edie to fling herself on his broad back, and they went round and round the kitchen and the parlour like that, until
he chuffed them into a heap on the Turkey carpet. His own laughter as free as hers and his face, when he looked up at me, wide open like the boy I never knew.
I’d like to believe that I somehow discerned that boy from the start, and recognized an essential goodness beneath his confident look, his practised, flirting talk. But I know that I was besotted, and not capable of any kind of sober thought like that. I would have followed him anywhere, borne anything; I would have clung to his feet as he tried to shake me off, if that was the way it had been. That hunger is gone and I don’t exactly miss it, though I miss feeling anything so strongly that isn’t dread. It’s hard not to think of her as another person, the girl I was, clinging to each glance, each smile. Our hands so close to touching, when I laid the message slips down on his desk, that I could feel the leaping spark.
I was seventeen that spring, and time played tricks. The new buds on the trees seemed to hold forever, unopened, as I walked through the soft light to the office on Wellington, and through different light, home again. In between was a strange world, with its own language to learn, new faces and names, and the other girls like cruel sisters, letting me make errors and be chastised for them, while they watched with their sly little eyes. I told myself that it was because I was the manager’s niece that they left space around me in the tiny room where we ate our dinner, and there was so much going on in our house on Pembroke Street that I didn’t need to be included in their talk, or in their Sunday outings.
Then one day I met Angus by chance, on King Street, surprised that he knew who I was. The next day, in the park, he said that he liked that I wasn’t a chatterbox, and I realized that everything had been transformed once again, that I was living a new, charmed life where even my tongue-tied state was a choice, and something in my favour. His strong fingers worked the pins from my hair and combed it out; before long he was saying that he adored everything about me and I became that girl, the one that Angus adored. The one who wasn’t anything like the others. Away from him the hours dragged, but the hands on his pocket watch raced when we met on Sundays, making our way to the deepest thickets in the park, or following the sandy stream back from the place where it spilled into the lake. All the secret places he led me to, and sometimes, at the office, he would whisper, Tonight, when we passed in the stairway, and that was the slowest time of all. The long way home and the longer evening, listening to the settling house until it was safe to make my silent way down the back stairs.
I was right about the girls’ visit, all that whispering and laughter. Edie fell asleep not long after they’d gone, and though her forehead stayed cool, she didn’t wake properly until the next afternoon. She said that she’d dreamt she was in California, though she didn’t know how she knew that’s where it was. But the streets were narrow and all the houses were white and then a dream-thing happened and she was up above, looking down, and California became an island with a collar of sand; she could see the white waves breaking all around. Then everything changed again and it became a painting she was looking at, in a sunny room. “Because we were talking about it, I suppose,” she says. She wants to see the postcards and the pictures of her American cousins, and I tell her I’ll fetch the album and her keepsake box, if she promises to eat the broth I’ve heated.
It might have been a year after Aunt Edith died, or not even that long, when Ben wrote that he’d decided to marry again, a widow they’d both known, with a young son of her own. Her name was Robina, a thing that made Kez sniff and say she and Nan had best go out there after all, and see for themselves how things were. They sent postcards from the station stops along the way. Buffalo and Chicago, Omaha. On the back of one, Nan drew a stick figure saying Ow! to show how she kept falling from her berth.
Our first son was not long in his grave when they went away and I was distracted, settling into our bigger house and keeping track of Edie, who was of an age where everything was a danger. But still it shames me to realize how little thought I gave to their journey, to how difficult it would have been, in all kinds of ways. “Didn’t we have a time,” they said when they were back, giving Edie a beautiful big shell, and showing the photographs they’d taken, which, they said, didn’t give you any idea of the heat.
One photograph was of the new house, taken from far away to fit it all in. One was of Robina with her son, who was, they said, a sturdy, frowning little fellow. Robina wore a large hat and it was difficult to make out her face, but she was quite pleasant, Nan said, and the children seemed easy enough with her. They were settled enough, happy enough, each with his own room, and the yard so long you’d need one of Clare’s telescopes to see the end of it. Of course the older ones were long past coddling and fussing over, and they seemed to be always coming and going, to school or to parties or lessons of some kind. In fact, my aunts said, everyone was very busy in California; they saw the ocean and they saw mountains, but they hardly saw Ben at all, and when they did he didn’t seem like himself, somehow. Though one night when Robina was too tired they sat up late, telling old stories that made them all laugh and teasing him about the way he talked now, like some kind of mongrel.
Kez and Nan came back, with their photographs and souvenirs and stories; Didn’t we have a time, they said. And I looked and I listened, but I wish I’d spared a thought for how overwhelmed they must have been there, how out of place. I’d lived in their household for years, after all; I knew how they talked, all the meaning that hummed just beneath what was actually said. I should have thought about how it was for them, to find that the younger children didn’t remember them at all, that the older ones were polite but not very interested, caught up in their new lives, new friends. In California, Kez said, there wasn’t even time for stories. Robina didn’t want the little ones frightened, and the others preferred to run around in the yard, or hit a ball with a stick.
I wish I had thought about that, and acknowledged it in some way, though if I’d actually said, Kez wouldn’t have thanked me for it. Spilt milk, she would have said, in her matter-of-fact way, as if it had never been important to her. As if she never thought about those grey afternoons on Pembroke Street when the children piled onto her bed, and she took off her shoes and stockings and let the smallest ones play with her crooked, bony toes.
She told them stories in the rainy light, about fiddlers and enchanted rivers and trees, about magic shoes, and instead of ending the usual way, the clever children in Kez’s stories always outsmarted everyone who had wished them harm. One of their favourites was the one about the boy who had been stolen by the Water Horse, how his father smacked his own face, while his mother sank to her knees and keened on the shore of the loch. Kez had the children keen with their loud little voices, and when they fell silent she said, Then … Then a ripple, spreading wider and wider, and they emerged, the gentled horse with the boy on his back, high-stepping out of the water. And the water sparkled as it flowed from their bodies, and the sun cast colours through the droplets flung wide when they shook their sleek, wet heads.
Maybe it’s because I have too much time to think, these past months, or maybe the stories I’ve been telling have stirred things up. The things I leave out, with Edie, that have poked through from wherever they’ve been lurking, the things that torment me. From the time I began to speak again on Pembroke Street there were things I could have said, things I could have told them about my father, about our life, which I knew they wondered about. One of those nights around the kitchen table, when they were remembering the tree house he had once tried to build, I could have told them how he’d described it to my brothers, a grand structure all the neighbourhood children admired, and they would have laughed, but it would have brought him closer. And they would have thought better of him if I’d told about the saplings he planted and tended so carefully, one for their father and one for their mother.
The good and kind girl I had vowed to be would have shared those things, and she wouldn’t have said that she didn’t remember when Charlie asked about the fiddle. That gi
rl would have told him that from the day my father opened the package it sat on a shelf with our Bible and the picture of Isabella. No one else was allowed to touch it, but every so often he would take it down and press in different places, pluck each string. Once my mother said why on earth didn’t he ride over to Talbots’ and ask Linc to show him; how hard could it be, if a fool like that could play. “I just might,” my father said, but he never did.
I didn’t tell them any of that, and I lied to them, too, when I’d been with Angus, made up stories to explain the grass stain on my blouse, the trail of sand when I took off my shoe in the kitchen. The worst thing, I see now, was not that I fooled them, or thought I did, but that my mind somehow turned them into people who deserved to be fooled. How ridiculous they became then, with their penny-pinching and their silly jokes. Aunt Clare lost in her reading while the supper burned on the stove, and the annoying way her glasses slid down her nose. Aunt Kez poking her nose into everyone’s business, but not caring enough to notice mine, and how she tried to make an adventure out of her dull life, telling every little detail of her walk to the butcher. I even felt scorn for poor Jack, his clumsiness, and when Aunt Nan said, “Be careful, Bella,” as I left the house, I saw nothing but a silly old woman, one with no idea what it was to burn like I did. How little time it really took, in my new life, for me to become again the selfish and deceitful girl I had been before.
March
“I can do it myself,” Edie says, so I leave the basin and cloth, and wait in the kitchen in case she gets dizzy and falls. The house is quiet except for the soft trickle as she dips and squeezes, and the falling water reminds me quite suddenly of the little creek not far from our clearing. The sound of clear water moving over mossy stones, and how often I stole away from my chores to sit there, dreaming about a grown-up life, far away.