The boys huddled their heads closely to one another and whispers were exchanged.
“Katya, we had no idea…” Conner said gently.
“We just assumed.” Eric added.
If not my virginity, then what? What did I really have to offer anyhow? I was just a poor girl living lavishly on their daddies’ dime.
Matthew leaned in towards me, his lips nearly touching my own.
“We want to settle a bet. We have always wondered which of us is the manliest, the most virile. If you agree to help us settle our bet, we will promise you a very comfortable life… You, and the baby.”
My jaw dropped. They wanted to use me to settle a bet? Not just any bet either, one that would leave me pregnant. But then… I swallowed hard as I thought about the two hundred and six days that remained until I turned twenty. Maybe this was the answer. Besides, I had always seen myself as a mother.
I shook my head trying to shake the thoughts before I let them go any further. I was their sister for god sakes. ‘STEP SISTER,’ my subconscious chimed in eagerly. I couldn’t do this, it would be oh so wrong… Despite scolding myself the place between my thighs was aching at the thought of the three of them making me their plaything. I had fantasized about each one of them and I couldn’t help it if the thought of having them all was turning me on…
Conner’s fingers slid a bit further and I could feel him at the fold of my thigh, just where my panties ended. His thick fingers slowly massaged my thigh and I could feel my sensitive clit trying to take hold of my body and give in to his touch.
“Do you want it Katya?” Conner asked, his voice deep and strained.
I nodded. I couldn’t control myself; it was exactly what my body wanted.
The boys rushed me out of the restaurant and across the street to a fancy hotel. It was like a whirlwind of motion as they quickly ushered me to a bedroom. I might have lost my nerve by then had it not been for the quick action they’d taken, and now, they were all over me. Kisses planted on every surface of my body, hands roaming freely over my sensitive flesh.
I closed my eyes and let my senses take in their touches. My clothes were stripped away from my body and there before them I was exposed.
“Absolutely perfect Katya,” Conner groaned as his hand firmly gripped the wet spot between my thighs.
Eric was at my foot, his hands massaged me and I could feel the pleasure of both Conner and Eric’s touch as it lit up the entire bottom half of my body. I’d never felt anything so intense. Matthew had his mouth on my nipples and sucked hard as his hands traced my backside, spreading my asscheeks in his grip. So many hands, so many mouths. My body was buzzing at such a high frequency of pleasure that I thought I might cum before we even got started.
“You are so wet Katya. Can I eat your pussy?” Conner asked.
A chill ran up my spine at the words alone. His hands split my reluctant thighs. I’d been fingered once in the past, but otherwise this whole experience was new to me. I bit my lip as his dove into my secret spot.
“Oh god Conner,” I moaned as he pulled me by the hips forward and spread me wider.
His lips softly sucked on my clit and I felt as Eric lifted my toe to his mouth. It tickled at first but the pleasure between my thighs someone drowned out the urge to pull away and soon it was pure heaven. Matthew’s mouth had found its way to my own and our lips met in a passionate and hot kiss.
I felt Conner slide a finger up between my hungry slit and as he devoured my clit his finger plunged deep within me. My hips rose and fell as I bucked against his strong fingers. He knew exactly what I needed and his fingers flittered strongly against the inside wall of my pussy pulling me harder into his lips.
“Damn it Katya, I might cum just tasting you.” Conner’s fingers were still inside of me as he looked up at me.
I stared back, deep into his eyes and something seemed to be on fire within him.
“I want a taste,” Matthew said, moving down between my thighs as Conner stood up and our lips met. His kiss was more passionate, and my hands instantly went to his belt and unstrapped him.
“Will you suck it Katya?” Conner begged me, his lips pressed close to my ear.
I felt the hot air and the vibration of his words as he spoke, and my body shivered. I peeled the fabric of his jeans from his hips, exposing the thick rod that was already rock hard. I hadn’t realized just how BIG my brothers really were until that moment when I saw Conner naked. My hands were dwarfed by the sheer size of him a wave of insecurity washed over me. What if I couldn’t handle them? Staring down his shaft I doubted myself.
“What if it doesn’t fit?” I blurted out before I had time to filter myself.
“Don’t worry,” Conner assured me, “We can make it fit…” His hands wrapped in my hair and he pulled me forward until the swollen head of his cock pressed my lips.
I licked my lips and as I slowly slid them around him I felt his body tense. Matthew was still between my thighs and I felt as two thick fingers slid inside of me. Eric had stood up and he took one of my hands. I couldn’t keep track with so much going on around me. Eric took my hand as he slid his cock free. He placed my hand around his shaft. I struggled to focus on anyone but myself and the big cock that was now pressing further into my little mouth.
“Just like that little sis. Do you like sucking on my cock?” He thrust himself a little harder and I could feel my gag reflex trigger each time he pushed himself harder against me.
Conner's words were pleasure in their own right. Something about it being him saying such nasty words made it hotter than I would have ever imagined. My whole body was alive and I pressed forward onto Matthews’ face.
Eric’s hand slid behind my head and he held it firmly in place and Conner thrust hard against me letting out a gasp as his cock plunged further than before. I felt tears welling up in my eyes and suddenly couldn’t breathe. I tried to pull away but my head was locked in my Eric’s strong grip. Conner gave three more small thrusts and my throat expanded around him, as I tried to swallow him down.
“Mmmm. Her pussy squirted all over me when you did that!” Matthew said from between my thighs as Conner pulled his hips back and away.
“That was so fucking hot Katya.” His lips made their way back down and I whimpered at the touch.
“More!” I begged. I wanted Conner to keep going. I knew I could take it again, and this time I knew what to expect. I wanted to take him all the way down.
His cock pressed forward again and this time I relaxed, letting him in further than before. I pressed forward and slid him even deeper as I heard him let out a guttural sound. I bobbed my head up and down on him until I couldn’t hold my breath any longer. His body was tense and his hands were softly stroking my hair as I sucked him.
“I want you now.” I choked out, looking directly into Conners’ eyes.
“What do you want Katya?”
“I want your…Cock…” I replied timidly.
“How do you want it Sis? Why don’t you tell me exactly how you want it?” Conners’ eyes blazed as he spoke and I couldn’t look away.
“Like this,” I said seductively, sliding a finger into my tight slick hole. I let my hips draw down further onto my finger, slowly, until it disappeared inside.
The three of them were all watching me now, their eyes locked on the show between my legs.
“But I want you to be first.” I grabbed Conner by the dick and pulled softly until he was standing right there in front of me.
Our lips met and his arms wrapped around me, embracing me and lifting me up and into his arms. He held me close to him and he laid me down softly. I had almost forgotten entirely about the other two even being there. It was him that I wanted, I knew it from the moment he first touched me, from the look in his eyes that I saw now.
“I can’t… I can’t do this, not with all of you… I am sorry.” I pleaded. “I thought that I could, but I just can’t. Please go.” I covered myself with my hands and tears ran down my
cheeks.
My three brothers stood there momentarily dazed. As if they never expected anything but my compliance.
“But what about your future?” Matthew asked.
“Your security.” Eric added.
“I SAID GO!” I screamed as I realized just how terrible this whole situation could have been. I was glad that I came to my senses, I only wished it would have been earlier.
I ran into the bathroom and washed my face and listened for the sounds from the other room to quiet.
A knock at the door startled me, I was just about to draw a bath.
“Don’t you get it? I can’t do this, I can’t throw away my values for money, and I surely don’t want to give up the most valuable thing I have to someone who doesn’t love me.
“Open the door Katya.” Conner called out softly. “It’s just me now, and I don’t want to leave things like this. I want to talk.”
I let out a sigh and my heart felt heavy with regret. I opened the door and let him in. His arms wrapped around my naked body and I felt his fingers slowly tracing my body, comforting me.
“I don’t know what happened Katya. When we were boys you, having you was all we fantasized about. When the two of them suggested we use our money to finally have you I guess I convinced myself that it was somehow helping you. I’ve always loved you Katya, from the moment that I saw you I thought you were the most beautiful creature I’d ever laid eyes on. When I saw you on your birthday, things were… Different. Getting to know you one on one had changed my fantasies for you. You were no longer the unobtainable little sister; you were a beautiful young woman with all of the characteristics I’ve wished for in a woman. Things got out of control today, but if you’ll give me a chance to make it up to you, I know that I can.” His eyes were full of sorrow and regret.
Was it true? Had he really wanted something more with me? Had I destroyed every chance I’d ever had by nearly fucking all of them? I felt the weight of the world suddenly on my shoulders.
“Do you think it’s possible?” I asked him solemnly.
“Us? I think it’s more than possible Katya, I just wish I’d have never let things go so far today. I never meant to hurt you this way but somehow my lust got in the way of my head and heart. Please forgive me, let me try again with you…”
I agreed to put the past behind us, to move forward and to let our story play out the way that nature intended it. For the next six months he proved it to me, never once did I hear of the incident from any of them again, and they all seemed only too happy to see the two of us growing closer. If there was one thing I could appreciate, it was their ability to move forward without ever holding it over my head.
Our parents found it uncomfortable at first that we’d been spending so much time together, but Conner told them the truth. He’d found himself falling in love with me, and as unconventional as it might seem, love knows no boundaries. We took our time, letting ourselves grow closer to one another emotionally without ever re-embarking on the journey of physicality.
It was two months from my twentieth birthday when things suddenly began to change. I had been accepted into every university I’d applied to, and I was eager to share the good news. He however seemed somewhat distant, and even downright secretive as occasionally he would quickly fold his computer closed when I unexpectedly entered the room; twice he had gone out and wouldn’t tell me where he was going or who he was seeing. I wondered what it was that had made him act so oddly, but he refused to even acknowledge the irregularity of his behavior.
I feared that I was going to lose him, but I knew deep down that for me, life would go on as it was intended, and I settled on letting life take its course. But to my complete surprise it wasn’t long before I found out one day exactly why he had been acting so strangely. All this time he had been planning a secret getaway weekend trip out into the mountains, and rented a beautiful, remote alpine cabin in the woods. He had even planned a gorgeous hike to the top of a high mountain peak where we watched the sunset over the water.
That special evening, as we watched the last glimmer of the sun disappear into the blue green waters of the horizon he suddenly dropped to one knee. From his pocket he pulled the most gorgeous ring I had ever seen in my life, the setting sun shining brilliantly, almost mystically, through it as he held it up to me. His eyes locked onto mine, with a deep burning passion that made me wonder why I had ever doubted him.
“I want to make you mine, Katya,” he proposed earnestly. “Forever. Tell me that you’ll have me. Make me the happiest man alive.”
Tears streamed down my cheeks as I choked out, “I do, baby! I absolutely do!” This was a man I knew I could truly love. I never wanted it to end in the first place, and now I knew for certain it never would.
He slid the ring onto my finger, and our lips met in a passionate kiss. The moment was unlike anything I’d ever dreamed, our love now deeper than even the blue green waters that had just accepted the setting sun.
We ran like happy children back to the cabin. A light drizzle was coming down now, but we laughed and joked and were in high spirits all the way. It was dark by the time we returned, but the cabin was warmly lit with candles and a roaring fire in the fireplace. The inside of the cabin positively glowed with the sensuous blending of the wood decor and colors of passion.
I wanted him to take me, to own my body they way that he owned my soul. Conner caressed me softly in an embrace and our lips met in the most sensual passion. I’d fallen hard for those hungry blue eyes, and when they seemed to be asking for permission I smiled and gave him a gentle nod.
HIs hands made their way beneath my blouse and they caressed the skin as he pulled the fabric up and over my head. Goosebumps rose like mountains on my arms as a shiver followed his touch. His fingers ran through my hair and traced my neck as his lips followed their passionate trail.
Lifting me and carrying me in his arms Conner took me into the bedroom and laid me down on the bed, standing over me looking down on my bare body.
“It has been a long time that I’ve been planning this day Katya, the first day our lives together as one. I still can’t believe that I almost lost you… Never again,” he proclaimed sternly.
He crawled into the bed on top of me and he showered my naked skin with his kisses. I undressed him as he explored me until it was just skin that kept our bodies from molding into one.
“Take me Conner.” I pleaded softly, my body aching for his.
His knees moved between my thighs and he spread me open as he gently pressed his shaft against my innocence.
“Softly,” I whispered.
I felt every inch of him, bare and rock hard, as it spread me in two. Conners' eyes never left mine as he slowly pushed through my cherry. Deep inside of my belly our connection was forever sealed with a gift that I could never give to any other man but him.
“I’m yours now baby, take me how you want me,” I encouraged.
The heat and pleasure of his cock as it slowly began to pick up speed and settle on a steady rhythm made me moan. I’d known that sex was supposed to be fun, but this, with him, it was utter bliss. I cried for him to give me more, I wanted to feel him deeper.
His strong grip pulled my hips up and into the air as he drilled his cock hard into the pit of my stomach. I could feel his pulse deep within me, quickening with every passionate thrust.
“Don’t stop baby. Don’t ever stop.” I cried as he let out a guttural moan.
My body arched as his hands pulled my from the back. His hips had picked up the pace and I met his thrusts equally with bucking hips. I pushed him back as I heard his breath growing ragged.
“Not yet.” I told him.
I rolled over, pushing him down onto the bed on his back. His cock stood at attention as he stared up at me wondering what I was up to.
“Mmmm… What are you up to you?” He asked, his eyes drunk with lust.
His skin glistened with a faint trace of sweat. I drank the sight of him momentarily. He
was absolutely gorgeous, and now, I knew, he was mine. His ruffled brown hair complimented his deep blue green eyes. I’d seen those eyes a million times, but never like this. It was like I was looking at someone entirely different than the boy I’d lived with for over four years. He was a man now, and I was looking into his soul, into his heart even, and here he was looking back.
Crawling to my knees I straddled him. I felt his hardness against me as I let my hips softly press into him. His hand ran up into my hair and our mouths met. The taste of salt met with my tongue as we kissed. Not letting our lips part I arched my back and reached for his stiffness. I wanted his bare shaft inside of me again. I’d been fantasizing about this moment for months now, and I wasn’t going to stop until I’d satisfied my cravings. His hips gave a little thrust as his lips curled into a smile.
A smile that I knew would be looking back at me, forever.
Taboo Step Surrender (Steamy Twenty Book Box Set) Page 34