by Glenn Cooper
Crossing City Island Bridge and gazing out toward East-chester Bay, he found himself thinking about his old man the moment the first marina came into view, an aluminum forest of masts bobbing in the stiffening afternoon breeze. City Island was a small, curious oasis, a part of the Bronx from a municipal perspective, but geo-culturally, quite a bit closer to Fantasy Island, a speck of land that led visitors to free associate about other places and other times because it was so unlike the city on the other side of the causeway.
To the Siwanoy Indians, the island had been for centuries a fertile fishing and oyster ground, to the European settlers, a ship building and maritime center, to the current residents, a middle-class enclave of modest single-family houses mixed with fine Victorian seafarers' mansions, its coastline dotted with yacht clubs for wealthy off-islanders. With a rabbit-warren of small streets, some almost country lanes, myriad ocean dead ends, the incessant infantile cries of gulls and the briny smell of the shore, it was evocative of vacation spots or childhood haunts, not metropolitan New York.
Nancy could see he was slack-jawed over the place. "Ever been here before?" she asked.
"No, you?"
"We used to come here for picnics when I was a kid." She consulted the map. "You need to take a left on Beach Street."
Minnieford Avenue was hardly an avenue in the classic use of the word, more like a cart path, and it was another poor spot for a major crime scene investigation. Police and emergency vehicles and media satellite trucks clogged the road like a thrombosis. He joined the long single file of hopelessly stuck cars and complained to Nancy they'd have to walk the rest of the way. He was blocking a driveway and was expecting a fracas from a thick-limbed fellow in a wife-beater who was giving him the once-over from his steps, but the guy just called out, "You on the job?"
He nodded.
"I'm NYPD, retired," the man offered. "Don't worry. I'll watch the Explorer. I ain't going nowhere."
The jungle drums had beaten loud and fast. Everyone in law enforcement and their uncles knew that City Island had become ground zero in the Doomsday Killer case. The media had already been tipped off which ratcheted the hysteria. The small lime-green house was surrounded by a throng of journalists and a cordon of cops from the 45th Precinct. TV reporters jockeyed for angles on the crowded sidewalk so their cameramen could frame them cleanly against the house. Grasping their microphones, their shirts and blouses fluttered like maritime flags in the stiff westerly winds.
When he spotted the house he had a mental flash of the iconic photographs that would blanket the world should it prove to be the place where the killer was captured. Doomsday House. A modest 1940s-era two-story dwelling with warping shingles, chipped shutters and a sagging porch with a couple of bicycles, plastic chairs and a grill. There was no yard to speak of-a spitter with good lung power could lean out the windows and hit the houses on either side and to the rear. There was just enough paved space for two cars-a beige Honda Civic was crammed between the house and the neighbor's chain-link fence and older red BMW 3-series was parked between the porch and the sidewalk, where a patch of grass might otherwise have been.
He wearily checked his watch. It was already a long day and it wasn't going to end anytime soon. He might not get a drink for hours and he resented the deprivation. Still, how superb would it be to wrap the case up here and now and coast to retirement, reliably hitting the barstool by 5:30 every night? He quickened his pace at the thought, forcing Nancy into a trot. "You ready to rock and roll?" he called out.
Before she could answer, a babelicious reporter from Channel Four recognized him from the news conference and shouted to her cameraman, "To your right! It's the Pied Piper!" The video cam swung in his direction. "Agent Piper! Can you confirm that the Doomsday Killer has been captured?" Instantly, every videographer followed suit and he and Nancy were surrounded by a baying pack.
"Just keep walking," he hissed, and Nancy tucked in behind and let him plow through the scrum.
The kill zone was in their faces the instant they walked inside. The front room was a bloody mess. It was taped off, perfectly preserved, and Will and Nancy had to peer through the open door as if they were viewing a cordoned museum exhibit. The body of a thin open-eyed man was half-on, half-off a yellow love seat. His head was lying on an armrest, well and truly caved in, his brown hair and scalp cleaved, a crescent of dura mater glistening in the last golden rays of the sun. His face, or rather, what was left of it, was a swollen pulpy mess with exposed shards of ivory bone and cartilage. Both his arms had been shattered into sickeningly unnatural anatomical positions.
He read the room like a manuscript-red splatter all over the paint, teeth scattered on the carpet like popcorn from a messy party-and he concluded that the sofa was where the man had died but not where the attack had begun. The victim had been standing near the door when the first strike landed, an upwardly arcing swing that glanced off his skull and splashed blood onto the ceiling. He had been struck again and again as he reeled and spun around the room, unsuccessfully fending off a hail of blows from a blunt instrument. He had not gone easily, this one. Will tried to interpret the eyes. He had seen that wide-eyed stare countless times. What was the final emotion? Fear? Anger? Resignation?
Nancy was drawn to another detail in the diorama. "You see that?" she asked. "On the desk. I think it's the postcard."
The Commanding Officer of the precinct was a young turk, a spit-and-polish captain named Brian Murphy. His athletic chest proudly bulged under his crisply-ironed blue shirt as he introduced himself. This was a career-altering collar for him, and the deceased, one John William Pepperdine, surely would have been irritated at how much ebullience his passing had engendered in this policeman.
On their drive over, he and Nancy had fretted about the 45th Precinct trampling another crime scene but they needn't have, because Murphy had taken personal charge of this one. Fat, sloppy Detective Chapman was nowhere to be seen. He complimented the captain on his forensic awareness and it had the same effect as stroking a mutt while cooing "good dog." Murphy was now his friend for life and he giddily briefed them how his officers, responding to a neighbor's 911 about shouts and screams, had discovered the body and the postcard and how one of his sergeants had spotted the blood-soaked perpetrator, Luis Camacho, wedged behind the oil tank in the basement. The guy wanted to confess on the spot and Murphy had the good sense to videotape him waiving his Miranda rights and giving his statement in a dull monotone. As Murphy disdainfully put it, it was a fruit-on-fruit crime.
Will listened calmly but Nancy was impatient. "Did he confess to the others, the other murders?"
"To be honest with you, I didn't go there," Murphy said. "I left that for you guys. You want to see him?"
"As soon as we can," he said.
"Follow me."
Will smiled. "He's still here?" Instant gratification.
"I wanted to make it easy for you. You didn't want to go hauling around the Bronx, did you?"
"Captain Murphy, you are a fucking all-star," he said.
"Feel free to share your opinion with the Commissioner," Murphy suggested.
The first thing he noticed about Luis Camacho was that he was a dead-match of their physical composite: dark-skinned, average height, slight build, around 160 pounds. He could tell from the stiffening of her lips that Nancy pegged him too. He was sitting at the kitchen table, hands cuffed behind his back, tremulous, his jeans and swooshed Just Do It T-shirt starched with dry blood. Oh, he did it, all right, he thought. Look at this guy, wearing another man's blood like something out of a tribal ritual.
The kitchen was tidy and cutesy, a collection of whimsical cookie jars, pasta shapes in acrylic tubes, place mats with hot-air balloons, a baker's rack stacked with floral china. Very domesticated, very gay, Will thought. He loomed over Luis until the man reluctantly locked eyes.
"Mr. Camacho, my name is Special Agent Piper and this is Special Agent Lipinski. We're with the FBI and we need to ask you some questions
."
"I already told the cops what I did," Luis said just above a whisper.
Will was redoubtable in interrogation. He used his tough-guy size to threaten then counterbalanced it with a soothing tone and gentle Southern drawl. The subject was never completely sure what he was up against and Will used that as a weapon. "We appreciate that. It's definitely going to make things easier for you. We just want to broaden the investigation."
"You mean the postcard John got? Is that what you mean by broaden?"
"That's right, we're interested in the postcard."
Luis shook his head mournfully and tears started streaming. "What's going to happen to me?"
Will asked one of the cops flanking Luis to wipe his face with a tissue.
"Ultimately, that'll be up to a jury, but if you keep on cooperating with the investigation, I believe that's going to have a positive impact on the way things play out. I know you already talked to these officers but I'd appreciate it if you'd start off by telling us about your relationship with Mr. Pepperdine and then tell us what happened here today."
He let him talk freely, tweaking the direction from time to time while Nancy took her usual notes. They had met in 2005 in a bar. Not a gay bar but they had found each other efficiently enough and they had started dating, the temperamental Puerto Rican flight attendant from Queens and the emotionally-blocked Episcopalian bookstore owner from City Island. John Pepperdine had inherited this comfortable green house from his parents and he had let a succession of boyfriends move in with him over the years. With his 40th birthday in the rearview mirror, John had told friends that Luis was his last great love, and he had been correct.
Their relationship had been tempestuous, infidelity an ongoing theme. John had demanded monogamy, Luis was incapable. John regularly accused him of cheating but Luis's job, with its constant travel to Vegas, carried a certain carte blanche. Luis had flown home the evening before but rather than return to City Island, he went to Manhattan with a businessman he had met on the flight who bought him an expensive meal and took him home to Sutton Place. Luis had crawled into John's bed at four A.M. and didn't awake until one that afternoon. Hung over, he had shakily descended the stairs to make a pot of coffee, expecting to have the house to himself.
Instead, John had stayed home from work and had camped out in the living room, an emotional wreck, almost incoherent and sobbing with anxiety, his hair uncombed, his complexion pasty. Where had Luis been? Who had he been with? Why hadn't he picked up his urgent phone and text messages? Why, of all days, had he abandoned him yesterday? Luis shrugged the tirade off, wanting to know what the big deal was. Couldn't a guy go out after work and have a couple of drinks with friends? It was beyond pathetic. You think I'm pathetic, John had shouted. Look at this you son of a bitch! He had run off to the kitchen and had come back with a postcard pinched between his fingers. It's a Doomsday postcard, asshole, with my name on it and today's date!
Luis had looked at it and had told him it was probably a sick joke. Maybe the idiot clerk John had recently fired was getting back at him. And anyway, had John called the police? He hadn't. He was too frightened. They had argued back and forth for a while until Luis's cell phone had gone off on the hall table with its campy "Oops I Did it Again" ring tone. John had leaped for it and had cried out, Who the fuck is Phil? Answer, truth be told, it was the guy from Sutton Place, but Luis had dodged the truth unconvincingly.
John's emotions had red-lined and, according to Luis, the normally mild-mannered fellow had lost it, grabbing the aluminum softball bat that he had abandoned by the front door a decade earlier after tearing an Achilles tendon in an adult-league game in Pelham. John had wielded it like a lance, pushing the end into Luis's shoulders, screaming obscenities. Luis had screamed back at him to put it down but the jabbing continued, inflaming Luis beyond his ability to control what would happen next when somehow the bat wound up in his hands and the room began to get painted with blood.
Will listened with rising discomfort because the confession had the ring of authenticity. Still, he didn't bring papal infallibility to the table. He'd been duped before, and God willing, he was being duped now. He didn't wait for Luis to stop crying before aggressively and suddenly asking, "Did you kill David Swisher?"
Luis looked up, startled. His instinct was to wave his arms in protest which made his wrists chafe against the handcuffs. "No!"
"Did you kill Elizabeth Kohler?"
"No!"
"Did you kill Marco Napolitano?"
"Stop!" Luis sought out Nancy's eyes. "What's this guy talking about?"
By way of a response, Nancy continued the battery, "Did you kill Myles Drake?"
Luis had stopped crying. He snorted his nose dry and stared at her.
"Did you kill Milos Covic?" she asked.
Then Will, "Consuela Lopez?"
Then Nancy, "Ida Santiago?"
And Will, "Lucius Robertson?"
Captain Murphy grinned, impressed at the rat-a-tat.
Luis shook his head vigorously. "No! No! No! No! You guys are crazy. I told you I killed John, in like self-defense, but I never killed these other people. You think I'm the fucking Doomsday Killer? Is that what you think? Come on! Get real, man!"
"Okay, Luis, I hear you. Take it easy. You want some water?" Will asked. "So how long have you been flying the New York-Las Vegas route?"
"Almost four years."
"Do you have a diary, some kind of flight log handy?"
"Yeah, I've got a book. It's upstairs, on the dresser."
Nancy hurried out the door.
"You ever mail any postcards from Vegas?" Will demanded.
"No!"
"I heard you say loud and clear that you didn't kill these people but tell me this, Luis, did you know any of them?"
"Of course not, Man!"
"That includes Consuela Lopez and Ida Santiago?"
"What? Because they're Latino, I should know them? What are you, some kind of an idiot? You know how many Spanish there are in New York?"
He didn't break stride. "You ever live in Staten Island?"
"No."
"Ever work there?"
"No."
"Got any friends there?"
"No."
"Ever visited there?"
"Maybe once, for a ferry ride."
"When was that?"
"When I was a kid."
"What kind of car do you drive?"
"A Civic."
"The white one out front?"
"Yeah."
"Any of your friends or relatives drive a blue car?"
"No, man, I don't think so."
"You own a pair of Reebok DMX 10s?"
"Do I look like I'd wear some jive-ass teenage sneakers, man?"
"Did anyone ever ask you to mail postcards from Las Vegas?"
"No!"
"You admitted you killed John Pepperdine."
"In self-defense, man."
"Did you ever kill anyone else."
"No!"
"Do you know who killed the other victims?"
"No!"
He abruptly halted the interview, went looking for Nancy and found her on the upstairs landing. He had a bad feeling and her crimpled mouth confirmed his fears. She was wearing a pair of latex gloves, leafing through a black 2008 day planner. "Problems?" he asked.
"If this diary is legit, we've got big problems. Except for today, he was in Las Vegas or in transit during every other murder. I can't believe it, Will. I don't know what to say."
"Say fuck. That's what you should say." He leaned wearily against the wall. "Because this case is completely fucked."
"Maybe the diary's been doctored."
"We'll check the records with his company, but we both know this guy's not Doomsday."
"Well, he killed Victim Nine that's for sure."
He nodded. "Okay, partner, here's what we're going to do." She put Luis's diary down and opened her notebook to take down his instructions.
"You don't dr
ink, do you?"
"Not really."
"Good, consider yourself designated. We're going to clock out and go off duty in about five minutes. Your assignment is to take me to a bar, talk to me while I get drunk then drive me home. Will you do that for me?"
She looked at him disapprovingly. "If that's what you want."
He knocked back his drinks quickly, shuttling the waitress between the booth and the bar. Nancy watched him slip the bonds of sobriety while she moodily sipped a diet ginger ale through a bendy straw. Their table at the Harbor Restaurant overlooked the bay, the calm waters blackening as the sun began to set. He had spotted the restaurant before they made it off the island, muttering, "That place's bound to have a bar."
He wasn't drunk enough to miss the fact that Nancy was uncomfortable having an after-work drink with her superior, a guy who happened to have a reputation as an office scoundrel and souse. She was literally squirming with discomfort.
She wasn't talking so he amused himself by doing a boozy profile. She probably felt like an enabler, helping him lube up as fast as he could.
And she was probably falling for him. He could see it in her eyes, especially the first thing in the morning when she came into his office. Most women succumbed eventually. It wasn't boasting, just a fact.
Right now she probably hated him for who he was and wanted him simultaneously. He did that to women.
In the small glow of a kerosene table lamp, his body compressed and softened like an unfired clay mold left outdoors on a scorching day. His face sagged, his shoulders rounded and he slumped on the shiny vinyl banquette.
"You're supposed to talk to me," he slurred. "You're just sitting there, watching me."
"Do you want to talk about the case?" she asked.
"Fuck no, anything but."
"What then?"
"How about baseball?" he suggested. "You like the Mets or the Yankees?"
"I don't really follow sports."
"That so…"