How Not to Be Wrong : The Power of Mathematical Thinking (9780698163843)

Home > Other > How Not to Be Wrong : The Power of Mathematical Thinking (9780698163843) > Page 48
How Not to Be Wrong : The Power of Mathematical Thinking (9780698163843) Page 48

by Ellenberg, Jordan


  Condorcet paradoxes, 387, 391–92

  confidence intervals, 157–60

  conic sections, 322–24

  consistency of math, 404–12

  conspiracy theories, 183–84

  contradiction, 404–12, 432–36

  Conway, John, 281

  Cornfield, Jerry, 355

  correlation, 7–8, 319, 325–27, 329–30, 335–62

  Berkson’s fallacy and, 357–62

  Bertillon system and, 325–27, 329–30

  binary variables and, 347–49

  causal relationships and, 335–36, 349–62

  cigarette smoking/lung cancer, 350–55

  drug efficacy studies and, 343–44

  geometry and, 336–44

  HDL cholesterol/heart attacks, 343, 349–50

  hormone replacement therapy/heart disease, 344

  public health decisions and, 354–57

  uncorrelated variables, 344–46

  coxcomb graphs, 312–13

  “Crack-Up, The” (Fitzgerald), 434

  Cramer, Gabriel, 214, 247

  creation, divine. See divine creation

  cubic equations, 109–10

  Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, The (Haddon), 224

  D’Alembert, Jean le Rond, 389

  Darwin, Charles, 116, 117, 186, 298, 299–300, 336

  dating advice, 361, 382

  Daubechies, Ingrid, 330

  Davis, Martin, 405

  Davis, Philip, 411

  Dawkins, Darryl, 126

  Dayton, Mark, 80

  De la Vallée Poussin, Charles-Jean, 139

  dead salmon, 102

  Deligne, Pierre, 222

  De Moivre, Abraham, 71–72, 73

  Denniston, R. H. F., 285–86

  derivatives, 40

  Descartes, René, 268, 311, 336–37

  Dewey, Melvil, 278

  Dewey Decimal System, 278

  Dial, The, 122

  Dickson, J. D. Hamilton, 325

  Diogenes the Cynic, 42

  disasters

  as partially ordered set, 75–76

  proportional comparison of, 62–65, 74–75

  divergent series, 48

  Divergent Series (Hardy), 47

  divine creation

  argument by design, 185–91

  faith, utility of, 239–42

  significance testing and, 115–16

  Torah codes and, 89–95, 99–101, 111, 114–15

  Doctrine of Chances, The (De Moivre), 71

  Doll, Richard, 350–51, 359

  Doll & Hill study, 350–51, 359

  Drosnin, Michael, 93–94, 101

  drug efficacy studies

  and correlation, 343–44

  interpreting, 113–14

  ears, cutting off of, 372

  eccentricity of an ellipse, 319–20

  Economist, The, 77

  Edgeworth, Francis Ysidro, 72

  Eighth Amendment, 371–72

  Einstein, Albert, 171–72, 416–17

  Elements (Euclid), 395

  ellipses, 311–25

  data sets exhibiting, examples of, 320–22

  eccentricity of, 319–20

  Galton’s, 311–20

  as quadrics, 322–24

  Ellsberg, Daniel, 248–52, 288

  Ellsberg’s paradox, 250–51

  Emanuel, Simcha, 100

  employment statistics

  job growth, state versus national, 79–80

  job growth by sector, 77–79

  women, and job loss statistics, 82–84

  entrepreneurship, 290–91

  equidistant letter sequence (ELS), 91–95

  error-correcting code, 271–79

  error-detecting codes, 276

  Erving, Julius, 126–27

  An Essay Towards Making the Doctrine of Chances Easy to those Who Understand Vulgar Arithmetic only . . . . (Hoyle), 71

  Essay on the Application of Analysis to the Probability of Majority Decisions (Condorcet), 387–88

  Estes, Andrea, 227

  Euclid, 17, 34, 139, 262, 390–91, 394–95

  Eudoxus of Cnidus, 34, 37, 221

  eugenics, 334–35

  Euler, Leonhard, 45

  evidentiary standards for assessing results, 102–30, 145–62

  Bayesian inference (See Bayesian inference)

  confidence intervals, use of, 157–60

  dead salmon fMRI study, statistical results from, 102–4

  probability theory and, 110–30

  replication of results, 161–62

  reverse engineering and, 105–10

  significance testing and (See null hypothesis significance test)

  ex falso quodlibet (principle of explosion), 433

  exhaustion, method of, 34–39

  existence, 363–420

  consistency of math and, 404–12

  formalism and, 400–412

  genius cult, 412–16

  parallel postulate and, 394–99

  political logic and, 416–18

  public opinion and, 365–92

  expectation, 193–291

  coding theory and, 269–87

  lotteries and, 195–232

  projective geometry and, 261–69

  utility and, 233–52, 288–91

  variance and, 253–61

  expected utility theory, 248–52

  expected value, 197–206

  additivity of, 212, 214–22

  of bets, 198–99

  of religious belief, 239–42

  insurance pricing and, 199–200

  of lottery tickets, 197–98, 201–13

  and public health decisions, 354–57

  explosion, principle of, 433

  “Exposition on a New Theory of the Measurement of Risk” (Bernoulli), 243

  Facebook, 166–71

  face-centered cubic lattice, 280

  faith, utility of, 239–42

  false linearity, 23

  false positives, in significance testing, 147–48

  Fano, Gino, 267

  Fano plane, 267–269

  Fermat, Pierre de, 143, 237, 239

  Fermat conjecture, 143

  Ferris Bueller’s Day Off (movie), 24–25

  Feynman, Richard, 182

  file drawer problem, 152

  financial collapse of 2008, 255–56

  fingerprinting, 327

  finite symmetry groups, 281

  Fisher, R. A., 99, 112, 114, 115, 116, 131, 136, 156, 159, 160, 162, 171, 180, 181, 351–53, 357, 394

  Fitzgerald, F. Scott, 433, 434–35

  flash drives, 276

  flogarithm, 139–40

  Florida 2000 presidential election, 378–80, 383–84, 400–401, 430–31

  fluxions, 40

  Foreign Affairs, 62

  formalism, 400–412

  Fosdick, Raymond, 326

  Foster, Edward Powell, 278

  franc-carreau, 214–22

  Franken, Al, 431

  Franklin, Benjamin, 432

  Frege, Gottlob, 407–8, 433

  frequentist view of probability, 111

  Friedman, Milton, 5, 28, 288

  Frost, Robert, 122

  Galton, Francis, 298–302, 308, 311–20, 324–25, 326–27, 329–30, 334–35, 336, 436

  Galvin, William, 231

  Garcia, Rich, 403

  Gascoigne, George, 124–25

  Gauss, Carl Friedrich, 16, 396

  Gelman, Andrew, 341

  gendarme’s hat, 68–74
/>   generalized Fermat equation, 143–44

  Genesis, 93, 100

  genius, cult of, 412–16

  geometry, 336

  Buffon’s needle, 214–22

  correlation and, 336–44

  ellipses and, 311–25

  Euclid’s axioms, 390–91, 396–97

  of Hamming code, 274–75

  non-Euclidean, 394–99

  plane, 58

  projective, 261–69

  Pythagorean Theorem, 32–33, 35, 132–33

  sphere packing problem and, 279–81

  Gilovich, Thomas, 125–28, 129, 134–35

  Gingrich, Newt, 62

  Girshik, Abe, 5

  global thermonuclear war, 249, 252

  Gödel, Kurt, 410, 416–17

  Godfrey, Thomas, 432

  Golay, Marcel, 276

  Goldblach conjecture, 143

  Gombaud, Antoine (Chevalier de Méré), 237

  Google, 164, 166

  Gore, Al, 341, 378–80, 383–84, 400–401

  governmental waste, cost of eliminating, 236–37

  Grandi, Guido, 45

  Grandi’s series, 45, 48

  Gravity’s Rainbow (Pynchon), 324

  Great Big Book of Horrible Things (White), 74

  Great Square of Men, 361

  Green, Ben, 143, 144

  Grothendieck, Alexander, 222, 223

  Grundgesetze (Frege), 409

  Hadamard, Jacques, 139

  Hadamard code, 275–76

  Haddon, Mark, 224

  Hales, Thomas, 282

  Halley, Edmond, 199–200, 318

  Hamming, Richard, 272–73, 276, 277, 284, 436

  Hamming code, 273–75, 283, 284–85

  Hamming distance, 277–79

  Hamming sphere, 279

  hand, horribly severed, 55

  Hardy, G. H., 47, 48, 142, 400

  Harkness, Jon, 354

  Harmelin v. Michigan, 375

  haruspicy, 145–46

  Harvey, James, 210, 225–26, 227, 228–29, 230, 231, 253, 260, 291

  HDL cholesterol/heart attacks, and correlation, 343, 349–50

  height, and regression to the mean, 301–2, 311–20

  Hereditary Genius (Galton), 298–99, 300

  Hersh, Reuben, 411

  Hick, W. E., 160

  Hilbert, David, 405–7, 410, 411–12, 416–18

  Hill, A. Bradford, 350–51, 359

  Hipparchus, 340

  Hippasus, 34

  Hlatshwayo, Sandile, 77, 79

  Home Run Derby, curse of the, 305–6

  homotopy theory, 411

  Horace, 24

  hormone replacement therapy/heart disease correlation, 344

  Hotelling, Harold, 306–8

  “hot hand,” myth of the myth of, 125–30

  The Housemartins, 425

  Hoyle, Edmond, 71

  Huizinga, John, 129

  human behavior, algorithms predicting, 163–71

  Target’s pregnancy predicting algorithm, 163, 166, 170

  terrorist-finding, 166–71

  hyperbolas, 324

  Ibn al-Haytham, ‘Ali al-Hasan, 262

  improbability, 89–102. See also probability

  Baltimore stockbroker parable and, 95–99, 152

  lotteries and, 98–99, 112, 137

  Torah codes and, 89–95, 99–101, 111, 114–15

  wiggle room and, 99–101

  incubation of mutual funds, 97

  independence of irrelevant alternatives, 377–83

  indifference, principle of, 187

  inference, 87–191

  Bayesian, 171–91

  evidentiary standards for assessing results, 102–30, 145–62

  human behavior, algorithms predicting, 163–71

  improbable occurrences and, 89–102

  null hypothesis significance test and, 112–130, 145–57

  reductio ad unlikely and, 133–44, 157

  Infinite Jest (Wallace), 242, 265

  infinitesimal quantities, 41–49

  In Re Troy Anthony Davis, 402

  inscribed square, 35

  instant-runoff voting, 383–86

  insurance pricing, and expected value, 199–200

  intelligent design, 186

  investment advisor performance, 129

  Ioannidis, John, 147, 150, 161

  Iranian election vote totals, analysis of, 173

  isobars, 317

  isogons, 318

  isonephs, 317

  isopleths, 317

  isotherms, 317

  Jefferson, Thomas, 388

  Jeter, Derek, 305, 402–3

  job growth, 77–79

  Johnson, Armon, 69, 70

  Johnson, Kirk, 156

  Jones, William, 370

  Jordan, Josh, 427

  Journal of the American Medical Association, 353

  Journal of the American Statistical Association, 306, 308

  Jungle, The (Sinclair), 171

  jury theorem, 387–88

  Kahnemann, Daniel, 288–89

  Kane, Thomas, 70

  Kass, Robert, 93, 99

  Kazhdan, David, 94

  Kemp, Jack, 27

  Kemp, Matt, 304, 306

  Kennedy, Anthony, 326

  Kepler, Johannes, 279–80, 282, 322–23

  Kerrich, J. E., 66–67

  Kerry, John, 320

  Keynes, John Maynard, 181

  Kiss, Bob, 384–86

  Kitab al-Manazire (Ibn al-Haytham), 262

  Klein, Felix, 417

  Klem, Bill, 402, 403

  known unknowns (risk), 251

  Korb, Kevin, 128

  Kronecker, Leopold, 104

  Krugman, Paul, 366

  Kumar, Abhinav, 281

  La Condamine, Charles-Marie de La, 227–28, 389

  Laffer, Arthur, 25, 30

  Laffer curve, 24–30, 235

  Laplace, Pierre-Simon, 248

  Latty, Tanya, 376, 381

  law of averages, 73–74

  Law of Large Numbers, 67–74, 111

  Lawson, Donald, 202, 203

  Lebowitz, Fran, 247

  Leech, John, 281

  Leech lattice, 281

  Leibniz, Gottfried W., 45

  Le Peletier des Forts, Michel, 227

  Less Like Sweden fallacy, 21–24

  Life on the Mississippi (Twain), 55

  Liggins, DeAndre, 69

  limit, 47

  linearity, 19–85

  false, 23

  Laffer curve and, 24–30

  linear regression, 51–55, 59–61

  negative numbers, impact of, 77–85

  nonlinearity distinguished from, 23–24

  ranking systems and, 62–76

  straight locally, curved globally, 31–49

  linear regression, 51–55, 59–61

  college tuition/SAT scores and, 51–53

  missile flight and, 54–55

  obesity and, 50–51, 59–61

  lineocentrism, 63

  Littlewood, J. E., 142

  Livermore, Samuel, 371–72, 376

  Lobachevskii, Nikolai, 396

  logarithm, 139–40

  Lojban, 279

  Long Beach Press-Telegram, 50

  Long-Term Capital Management, 255

  Lorenz, Edward, 164–65

  Los Angeles Times, 62

  lotteries, 112, 137, 195–232

  additivity of expected value, 212, 214–22

  Cash Winfall, 206–13, 224�
�32, 253, 256–61, 258–60

  Denniston’s code and, 258–60

  expected value and, 197–98, 201–13

  Fano plane and, 267–69

  improbability and, 98–99

  Powerball, 201–6

  Transylvania lottery, 258–60

  utility of playing, 288–89

  variance and, 253, 256–61

  Lowenstein, Roger, 255

  Lu, Yuran, 224, 253, 287, 291

  lung cancer/cigarette smoking correlation, 350–55

  McKay, Brendan, 99–100, 101

  McNamara, Robert, 63

  Maier, Jeffrey, 403

  Maimonides, 89–90, 91–92

  Malkiel, Burton, 256

  Mallat, Stéphane, 330

  Malthus, Thomas, 420

  Mankiw, Greg, 27–29, 246–47

  Many Labs project, 162

  Mariner 9 (Mars orbiter), 275–76

  Maryland v. King, 326

  Mason & Dixon (Pynchon), 324

  “A Mathematical Theory of Communication” (Shannon), 271

  “Mathematician, The” (Von Neumann), 13–14, 17

  mathematics

  as common sense, 9–14

  complicated facts of, 14–16

  existence (See existence)

  expectation (See expectation)

  four quadrants of, 15

  inference (See inference)

  linearity (See linearity)

  regression (See regression)

  teaching, 56–58

  understanding of, and insight into everyday problems, 1–3

  Wald, and bullet hole problem, 3–10

  “Math Melodrama” myth, 223

  math education, 56–58

  Matijasevic, Yuri, 405

  Matrixx, 155–56

  Maynard, James, 141

  Melville, Herman, 101

  Menaechmus, 17

  Mental Radio (Sinclair), 171–72

  Meyer, Yves, 330

  Michell, John, 133, 135–36, 137

  Mill, John Stuart, 384

  Million Act, 199–200

  Minard, Charles, 312

  Minkowski, Hermann, 412

  Mirman, Eugene, 50

  Mishneh Torah, 89–90

  missile flight

  linear regression and, 54–55

  quadratic equation and, 105–9

  missing bullet hole problem, 5–8, 9–10

  Mitchell, Daniel J., 21, 23

  Mitchell, John, 133–34

  Moby Dick (Melville), 101

  Mona Lisa (painting), 327

  money, utility of, 242–48

  Montroll, Andy, 384–86

  Moor, Ahmed, 62

  Morgenstern, Oskar, 3–4, 249, 416–17

  Morlet, Jean, 330

  Mosteller, Frederick, 5

  multiple comparisons correction, 104

  Mumford, David, 58

  mutual fund performance

  Baltimore stockbroker parable and, 97–98

  survivorship bias and, 8–9

 

‹ Prev