Present, Summer 2001
Oz: 26
Adrienne: 21
1
It was raining the day I laid my wife to rest. I had been watching her die for months, and it was hard to accept she died of something other than what had been killing her.
Water poured down from the heavens in sheets, forming puddles all around us in the shallow Louisiana ground. I supposed it was appropriate and what I could have expected, if one can ever truly prepare for such an event.
Huddled together near the elaborate tomb, in a sea of mourning smocks and matching black umbrellas. The rain echoed our somber mood, beating down mercilessly. Her friends, family, co-workers, and of course my own people, came to say goodbye. I felt hands on my back and shoulders, whispering their condolences in low, cautious voices.
Naomi, our daughter, took her first steps not long before her mother died. She now stood bravely at my side, her tiny hand firmly ensconced in mine. Normally lively and talkative in the spirited way of a toddler, Naomi said not a word to me, or anyone else, the entire day. Her reaction to the disposition of those around her was limited to an occasional glance at me with confused, pain-filled replicas of her mother’s big blue eyes.
It struck me as funny, despite the somber overtone, how even the loudest, most garrulous person could be rendered speechless at a Metairie funeral. Crisp suits and dresses, stickers on their cars that granted them access to the country clubs, and appointments to keep for later in the evening with manicurists and clients. Life did not stop for the dead here the way it did only a few miles away in New Orleans. We did not celebrate the deceased in this cold, crisp suburb. None of the laughing, the gaiety, the sense of family and togetherness like the funerals I was used to, in the Garden District. It would be entirely improper.
And to think, I had gone through this yesterday at the wake. I found it inhumane our traditions demanded I publicly mourn my wife over and over again. My own grandfather had done this not so very long ago after over fifty years of marriage. We had been far too concerned with his well being, so it was months later before we truly began to mourn her ourselves. Yet no one, not even my grandfather, could possibly understand what the last week had been like for Naomi and me, despite the amount of people who came to my side claiming they did. I loved them all for being there, but at the same time hated them for the sense of relief they must feel at knowing when they went home most of this disappeared for them.
During the service, Naomi cried because everyone around her did. The sorrow of the adults standing around in the rainy cemetery traumatized her. One of Janie’s many aunts would burst into sobs and Naomi reacted by curling her tiny lips around each other and wailing into the musty air. Someone would notice this, commenting, “Poor, sweet darling,” they would say. Oh, how I loved and needed her.
I stood motionless as those part of the service moved like programmed animals around me. Was this really happening? I kept my eyes on Naomi. I would hear someone call my name or move in my direction and I would kneel down in front of my daughter, tending to her. I’m not listening, my actions said. Don’t talk to me about this.
It was not, however, the last week that had produced this effect on the two of us; we had been little more than existing since Janie was diagnosed, too late, with breast cancer. “Six months,” said the doctor.
What could she possibly do in six months? The doctor delivered the message as if it were better than he expected. Better than three months, two weeks? How does that change the end result? The fact Janie would not live to see her twenty-seventh birthday was inevitable with those words. And beyond that, the milestones of Naomi’s life would happen while Janie’s simply ceased to exist. Was six months supposed to warm our hearts with relief?
“Suicide,” people whispered, far from me but still within earshot. I had expected they would talk about it. How could they not? It wasn’t every day the daughter of a cigar magnate from the “good side of town” decided to throw herself into the raging Mississippi. When she drove her car through the break in the levee out on the west bank of River Road, it had been nothing short of a miracle that Naomi, sitting in her car seat in back, emerged without even a scratch.
So grateful I was the man had stopped his car to help; so completely indebted to him he had pulled my crying daughter from the car as the powerful torrent threatened to take it from where it lay barely wedged on the muddy bank.
“I tried to get your wife out, Son,” the man had said. “The river was just too strong for me.”
He and his wife had come to the service. The man blamed himself for not being able to save them both. I wished I had the presence of mind to disagree, to tell him if it weren’t for him, my daughter would also be gone. I knew the man had risked his own life to save her.
Was it selfish to wonder how no one, save this kind man and his wife, stopped to wonder why a woman was driving her car through the levee break going twice the speed of other drivers? Had there come a point when even Janie realized the insanity? These questions would likely torment me until my dying day.
For the service, and especially for Naomi, I swallowed back the anger and confusion encircling my heart. All the “whys”: Why wouldn’t she try any of the experimental drugs the doctor offered? Why had she turned from me in the end? Why had she taken our daughter? Did she even realize Naomi was there?
And what about the “hows”: How could someone of sound mind drive a vehicle over a levee and into a raging river with a twelve-month old baby in the back? How could I not have seen the signs? Read them for what they actually meant?
You did not love her enough. You did not love her enough to give her what she wanted, and you did not love her enough to let her find someone who would.
I looked down at Naomi and pushed the thoughts away.
I wasn’t entirely grounded during the service itself, and as it came to an end and everyone slowly filtered out, I picked up only bits and pieces of the sentiments passed on to us.
“She was an amazing woman Oz.”
“Oz, you and Naomi are in our prayers.”
“No one thinks badly of you for not giving the eulogy. We know this must be devastating for you and the family.”
“Your beautiful darling girl will bring you through this.”
Coupled with this came a handful of invitations, many from people I barely knew, who offered to “be there if you ever want to talk about this.” I wasn’t ungrateful; this just wasn’t an experience I was ready to share with anyone. It was mine, and it was Naomi’s, and I wanted more than anything to be home in my bed finding my own way to deal with this (you did not love her, how do you deal with that?), through the guilt, not standing among people who meant well but were only making it harder.
It occurred to me at some point it was their attempts at making it somehow acceptable that I couldn’t handle. Through their kind words and soft gestures they were trying to help me forgive her.
Ahh, forgive her? First you have to forgive yourself, Oz.
The longer the day stretched on, the more reality began to take hold.
Please just get me out of here before I scream, I thought. I cannot lose it in front of my little girl.
“I’m so sorry Oz.”
I turned to see my father Colin with my mother Catherine, who seemed to have aged ten years overnight. Janie’s suicide had really affected her. Of all the girls I dated in my twenty-six years, Janie was really the only one my mother wanted as a daughter-in-law. From the day she introduced us, I knew she was already envisioning the wedding: Janie and I exchanging vows, the first dance, shoving cake in each other’s faces. Janie’s own mother had died when she was four.
“Oh Darling…” my mother sobbed and knelt down in the gravel in front of Naomi. “How is she?”
“I don’t know how to explain this to her.”
Naomi looked such the young lady; when you met her thoughtful gaze it was easy to forget how little she actually was. At my age, I still didn’t fully understand
the meaning and impact of death, and certainly not the death of someone close to me. I didn’t know the magical words that would explain it as a part of life rather than something which would plague us for years to come.
“Oz, your mother and I were talking last night.” They exchanged a glance; one I wasn’t sure I liked. It was the look I saw often when I was still living at home. One that typically preceded them making a decision for me I disagreed with, but usually ended up allowing for one reason or another.
As always, I let them talk. I hadn’t the energy to do much else.
“Given the circumstances, maybe you and Naomi could stay with us for awhile. It might help if you didn’t have to watch her all the time. She’s starting to walk and it’s a huge responsibility you don’t need right now. You know, just for awhile until you can collect your thoughts-”
“Dad, no. Naomi needs me right now. She needs to be in her own house with her Daddy. She’s never going to see her mother again, and it would further confuse and scare her if we took away everything she was used to.” I pulled Naomi closer to my side, protectively. I didn’t say it, but I needed her. I needed to coddle her, and somehow make it up to her. I needed to be close to her so I could mourn her mother, too.
Because you are afraid only the sight of your daughter’s pain can bring you to sadness over Janie’s death.
My mother cupped my face in her warm hands and kissed my forehead. “Colin, you are so young, and I fear this experience will change you forever.”
My mother called me Colin, my given name, only in times of crisis- or, more specifically, at times when she felt a loss of control; an inability to fix something. I knew in her heart she was already staging an intervention for me, but even that was beyond her ability at this point. There were times even a mother’s touch could not heal wounds.
The rain came down harder, and the rest of the mourners were rushing to get out of Metairie Cemetery. My mother picked up Naomi, who was now sobbing uncontrollably, and started carrying her to the car as if I had already given in. All the sadness of the day had finally taken its toll on her; she was the picture of pure exhaustion.
When I made no move to seek shelter, I felt my father take my arm. “Oz, come on, let’s go home, Son.”
I didn’t look at him. With the crowd dissipated, I could see her family’s tomb clearly now. Her will had clearly expressed her unbending refusal to be entombed at Lafayette Cemetery No. 1 where my family had been interred for generations, choosing instead to lay at rest in the Metairie neighborhood where she was raised. This had been a bone of contention between us in the last months of her life, as we sat in front of the stoic lawyer and divvied up our future. My future.
Right under her grandmother’s name were words I morbidly imagined would be embossed in my mind forever. Words of sadness? Regret? Guilt?
Janette Lynn Masters-Sullivan
Beloved Mother, Wife, Sister, and Daughter
1975-2001
“Give me a few minutes. I’ll meet you at home.” Although I didn’t turn around, I knew my father stood, indecisive a moment, before I heard him turn to leave.
As I stared at the tomb, and the words on my dead wife’s epitaph rolled over and over in my mind, I finally allowed myself to cry freely. Yet I didn’t know if my tears were any different than the contagious ones Naomi had wept.
Why like this? Anything but this. “You don’t understand what it’s like!” She screamed at me the last time I saw her. “You are going to be here to see her graduate, to see her get married! Damn you, Oz!”
In all the commotion, no one but I had realized today would have been our one-year anniversary. We had been married right after Naomi was born because Janie had wanted to look good in her wedding dress. I always told her she would look beautiful no matter what. She was beautiful, always.
But that wasn’t enough for you, was it? Nor was her kindness, or intelligence, or wit, or anything else that she gave to you without reserve.
As I turned to leave my wife, I had the distinct feeling someone was watching me. It occurred to me I had felt it all throughout the service, but had been too consumed to notice or really care.
“Hello?” I called out.
I heard the rustle of leaves and a twig snap. A squishing of footprints in the flooding Louisiana mud. I turned toward the sound and saw a figure advance from behind another family’s tomb. A woman’s figure.
“Who’s there?”
As she approached, I knew immediately. The last person I ever expected to see at all, at any point again in my life. Thoughts of her had almost prevented my marriage to Janie (certainly prevented you from loving her properly), who had had no inkling this woman even existed, let alone what role she had played in my life. I had carefully seen to that.
I could not believe she was there.
She had on a long black mourning cloak, so typical of a distinguished Southern woman; the hood engulfing all but a few rebel strands of her long, thick red hair. Her eyes, two cobalt orbs staring back at me from under the cloak, seemed to glow.
“Oz.”
Her voice was soft and inviting. What compelled me was not what was left of my love for her, if any even existed, but the need to believe I was wrong; that I had loved Janie. After spending a few moments with her I would realize it was my own fears that held me back, not a lack of love for my wife. And if I was wrong…well, I could do Janie no greater justice than my own misery. I would not fall into this girl’s arms, but I would walk away this time done with the charade forever.
In bringing closure to both chapters of my life, I could enter the next one alone, with Naomi. The timing was not ideal, but then, timing never was.
It was my first moment of clarity since Janie died.
2
She pulled off her cloak, carelessly tossing it across the back of my sitting room leather sofa. Neurotically, I was one step behind her, wiping the raindrops off of the couch and hanging her cover on the oak coat rack, where it belonged.
“Some things never change,” she whispered, under her breath, voicing my own thoughts.
When she didn’t wipe her feet, or make any indication of removing the muddy shoes, I politely asked her to do just that and ignored the roll of the eyes she sent in my direction.
On the ride over to the house I owned in the Garden District, neither one of us said a word. She stared out the passenger window; I stared straight ahead. My thoughts were a slideshow of the past few days, every scene playing out in Technicolor, slightly surreal but happening to an outsider, not me. I could not guess at her thoughts.
I placed a call to my father, letting him know I needed some time to tend to my thoughts and I would be over in the morning. He sounded relieved.
I went to put on a pot of coffee, but my eyes never left her as I rinsed out the dusty filter, then measured two spoonful of the only grounds in the cupboard. I was grateful I had them, though. They would most likely go out with the trash on Tuesday. Janie was the coffee drinker, not I.
She flitted from bookshelf to mantel, perusing the archive of photos we had taken to preserve Janie’s memory. Her interest seemed sincere, yet betrayed no true emotion. She could have been looking at her English professors’ credentials.
When the doctor delivered the news Janie would not be around to see Naomi grow into a woman, we purchased a top-of-the line camera with all the bells and whistles a lawyer’s income could buy. We took over fifty rolls of film in a three-month period, before she became so sick she didn’t want any more pictures taken. The house was currently a shrined to Janie. This way, Naomi would never have to look far to see her mother.
And you can simply torture yourself without really having to address the issue.
“How do you take it? Black, sugar, cream?” I asked her as the coffee pot chimed, announcing its finish. The purchase of said coffee pot was a departure from my normally frugal spending habits. It was the lesser of two evils with Janie, who had an affinity for four dollar lattes. By the time we u
npacked it, however, her diagnosis was certain and she gave up coffee altogether. Something compelled me not to return it to the store, or even put it in the pantry for storage. Most likely it had been the sense of finality, as if to say, “Well, you won’t be needing this anymore.”
My guest smiled. It was a careful smile. “You know how I take it.”
I suppose I did, but such knowledge was no longer welcome in the front of my mind.
“It’s been a long time.”
She turned back around to the mantel and drew her finger over a picture of us in Corsica.
In this particular photo, Janie had run out from the beach, splashing into the warm waters of the Mediterranean. I had followed her, scooping her up into my recently tanned arms. The water sprayed up and foamed around us and we were both wearing those no-holding-back huge toothy grins; ones that said we were happy as hell. Who were you trying to convince more: her or you?
She pulled her hand back, but didn’t turn around. “Black,” she said.
We sat on opposite sides of the couch, coffee in hand, and I waited for her to say something. For a long time, she just sat there, drinking and staring in my general direction, not exactly looking at me.
Flourish: The Story of Anne Fontaine (A La Famille Lagniappe) Page 5