‘I wouldn’t know,’ he replied curtly. ‘That’s a question for the folks at the Stock Exchange and the Securities and Exchange Commission.’
‘Would it worry you if they were?’
‘What would worry me is if people believed we had some kind of a problem when we don’t.’ He pointed at another journalist. ‘Yes?’
‘Mr Chairman, you referred to your report to Congress last week and I wonder whether you think in any way that your comments have actually helped to create uncertainty in the market.’
Strickland shook his head. ‘How would that have helped to create uncertainty?’
‘Well, you talked about certain asset classes that you felt were overvalued and more or less threatened to … clamp down in some way on activity around those. When you say you won’t tolerate irrational exuberance or anything approaching it people immediately think we’re looking at monetary tightening. I just wonder whether you think that kind of talk may actually have been counterproductive and whether you may regret having said that.’
Strickland felt his irritation rising again. ‘Look, first, when you talk about my remarks, let’s get them accurate. I did not say that any asset classes were overvalued. I said that price and volume data showed increasing activity in certain classes of equity derivatives and we were watching that and we would intervene as appropriate. That doesn’t mean we’re going to intervene. It just means we have the weapons.’
‘Mr Chairman, you’ve just said you had price data, surely that’s saying they’re overvalued.’
‘It’s not saying they’re overvalued. It’s not my role to say whether they’re overvalued. I’m simply saying that we look at the activity levels.’
He glanced at Weissman, who was standing a few yards to the side. But the president of the National Press Club had no intention of ending the questioning. The coverage of this, she knew, was going to be fantastic.
‘I’ll take one more,’ said Strickland. He pointed.
Bernard Tobin of the Economic Review took the microphone. ‘Mr Chairman, can you comment on Fidelian Bank?’
‘No, Bernard,’ he replied impatiently. ‘I can’t comment on Fidelian Bank. I can’t comment on any individual bank and I think you know that.’ Strickland hadn’t been pointing at Tobin, but at the woman behind him. Tobin had a huge bee under his bonnet about the banking failures in the last financial crisis, having lost a personal investment of some hundreds of thousands in Bear Stearns stock. Everyone knew he was always looking for an excuse to slam the Fed, which he held responsible. ‘Bernard, I was actually pointing at–’
‘Okay, so here’s my question. Let’s say I’ve got a thousand dollars to invest and I’m thinking maybe I should be putting it into Fidelian Bank. And let’s say with all the scrutiny you’ve been talking about you know that Fidelian Bank is this far away from being bankrupt. Don’t you think you ought to tell me before I put my thousand bucks in?’
‘Bernard, I said I was pointing at–’
‘Is that a question you don’t want to answer, Mr Chairman?’
‘Of course I’ll answer it,’ retorted Strickland angrily. ‘Let’s just get everything very clear. I’m not saying Fidelian Bank is near being bankrupt. In fact, although I don’t comment on individual banks, I can tell you that as far as I’m aware Fidelian Bank is nowhere near being bankrupt. And by the way, you couldn’t put a thousand dollars in there, because it’s not a deposit-taking bank. It’s an investment bank with investment bank activities.’
‘Then let’s say it was another bank.’
‘Well, if there was a bank like that – and I’m not saying there is – if I came out and said it was close to bankruptcy, effectively that would make it bankrupt, wouldn’t it? You know that perfectly well.’
‘And if I put my thousand bucks in, and it goes bankrupt tomorrow, I lose it.’
‘No, you don’t, because it’s FDIC protected.’
‘Say I put my thousand bucks into its stock.’
‘Well, all I can say is that’s your choice. In that case you choose to take a risk. If you don’t want to take a risk, deposit your money into a bank. It’s FDIC protected. It’s a hundred per cent safe.’
‘But what I’m saying is–’
‘Bernard, I think you’ve had more than a couple of questions.’
‘But I’m just saying–’
‘What? What are you saying?’
‘I’m just saying you have some knowledge that I don’t have, and which may make quite a big difference to a lot of people’s lives, taxpayers, and you’re a publicly paid figure, so don’t you think you should give that knowledge to the people who pay your salary? You know, you’ve mentioned 2008 quite a lot, and one of the things about 2008 is a lot of people lost a lot of money because no one was telling them until it was way too late what kind of institutions they were investing in. And I’m not talking about rich people here. I’m not talking about the guys who took the bonuses. I’m talking about retirement savings. I’m talking about people who are living in poverty today because of what Mr Greenspan and Mr Bernanke allowed to happen back then. So all I’m saying is, you’re standing here in front of the National Press Club. You’ve got a huge economy of scale here, like you said yourself. You must know there are certain banks in trouble, it’s clear the market thinks there are, but we don’t know who they are and that uncertainty is bringing the whole market down, the good with the bad. So here’s your chance to clear it up. Mr Chairman, tell us straight. Who’s in trouble?’
Ron Strickland stared at him. Bernard Tobin made him sick. Tobin wasn’t living in poverty and all that stuff about people who were was just so much showboating. The question put him in an impossible position and Tobin knew it. He couldn’t have given an answer even if he wanted to. The banks on his watch list were the same ones that had been there two, three months ago. He had no idea why the market had taken fright. For all he knew it might have been a bunch of short sellers placing bets, as the press themselves seemed to think. He still couldn’t believe that his report to Congress had anything to do with it. If anything, he thought, the situation would have been worse without it.
The room waited for his response.
Strickland shook his head. ‘I can’t make a comment on that.’
13
ED ABRAHAMS TOOK the call. He was in the car with the president, who had just come out of a lunch for major Republican donors in Miami with Florida governor Rick Martinez. In forty-five minutes Knowles was due at a town hall meeting in Fort Lauderdale with Senator Jeff Logan, before going on to Gainesville to give a speech that evening at the University of Florida. Both Martinez and Logan were fighting tight midterm races against strong Democratic challengers.
It was Roberta Devlin on the phone. Abrahams listened to what she had to say as the president looked over the Q&As Josh Bentner had prepared for him for the town hall meeting. Then Abrahams put his phone down and logged onto the screen in the back of the limo. He got up the Economic Review website and clicked on a headline.
Fed chairman refuses to name failing banks
‘Tom, you’d better have a look at this,’ said Abrahams. Knowles looked up from his Q&As.
Federal Reserve Chairman Ronald J Strickland today refused to name failing banks within the American banking system.
In a speech at the National Press Club, Strickland confirmed that a number of banks were under close scrutiny by the Fed, and did not rule out the possibility that takeovers by the Federal Deposit Insurance Commission would be required. Drawing a number of direct parallels with 2008, Strickland remarked that similar action would be taken if required.
Referring to Fidelian Bank, which has recently seen sharp falls in its stock price, Strickland remarked that he was unaware of any immediate threat of bankruptcy. However, in response to a direct request to name the banks in question, Strickland refused, thereby adding to the uncertainty rocking the financial markets.
‘What’s this?’ murmured Knowles.
&nbs
p; Abrahams was busy with his tablet getting the latest Dow Jones figures. The index was down two per cent.
Knowles glanced at him. ‘Did he really say that stuff?’
‘He must have said something.’ Abrahams gazed at the screen again. ‘I’ll get Dean on the line.’
A moment later the voice of Dean Moss, the White House press secretary, was on the speakerphone.
‘Looks like we got a mini crisis going here.’
‘What the hell did Strickland say?’ demanded the president.
‘I’m still waiting on the transcript. From what I understand, he’s been taken out of context. Some journalist from the Economic Review pushed him to name the banks the Fed thinks are weak and he obviously refused and they’ve taken that and built this so-called story. I think he got into some kind of a shouting match, which didn’t help.’
‘But this is bullshit?’ said Abrahams.
‘Absolutely. This journalist has a thing about the Fed. The others are hyping it to see where it’ll go. It’s election fever. What can you say? Anything for a headline.’
‘You still haven’t got the transcript?’
‘I’m waiting on it, Ed.’
‘Well, get it down to us as soon as you’ve got it.’
‘Sure. And in terms of what we’re going to say …?’
‘We’ll get back to you,’ said Abrahams, and cut the line.
Knowles looked at him. ‘What do you think?’
Abrahams frowned. ‘Not sure.’
‘Do we ignore it or do we try to nip it in the bud?’
‘That’s the question.’
Knowles glanced out the window at the view of north Miami rushing by. ‘Is this the kind of thing Strickland thinks is helpful? He’s supposed to provide reassurance, not start a panic three weeks before the midterms.’
Abrahams was silent.
‘What the hell has he been saying?’
‘I’m sure we’ll find he put forward a very sensible position. His problem is he’s an academic. The guy doesn’t see what people are doing to him until he reads it in the papers the next day.’
Knowles thought about the speech he was giving just about every day now in support of one Republican candidate or another. Trust. Rectitude. Stability. Scrutiny. Prosperity and growth without the fear of a crash.
‘Before we overreact,’ said Abrahams, ‘let’s find out whether there’s anything going on. Let’s talk to Strickland. And the Treasury secretary. I’ll set up a call. You go in and do your town hall with Logan. Chances are no one in there will have heard about this.’
‘They’ve got cell phones. The Democrat plants will know all about it.’
Abrahams smiled. ‘Then do the presidential thing you do so well.’
‘And then?’
‘Then,’ said Abrahams, ‘I’ll have figured out whether we should ignore it or not.’
AIR FORCE ONE was on the tarmac at Jacksonville, having flown the president from the Fort Lauderdale meeting. Marine One, the presidential helicopter, waited to take the president the sixty-mile hop to the University of Florida at Gainesville for his next speech. It should have left twenty minutes previously, but the president still hadn’t emerged from the plane.
He sat in his office on Air Force One with Ed Abrahams and Josh Bentner. On the line from various places in Washington were Ron Strickland and Treasury Secretary Susan Opitz as well as the president’s senior aides.
By now Knowles had seen footage of the key parts of Strickland’s remarks, including his exchange with the Economic Review journalist. The Fed chairman hadn’t said anything wrong in itself, but it had been a hamfisted performance. He could have handled the questions with a lot more grace and sophistication. Instead, he had looked tetchy, impatient and uncomfortable, and in the end had almost blown his top. He had handed anyone who wanted to distort his remarks a choice selection of lines.
The Dow had closed three per cent down. First off, Knowles wanted to be sure there was no genuine crisis underlying what was happening in the markets.
Opitz and Strickland were both confident. Neither of them knew anything to suggest that a crash was coming.
‘I think the market’s just saying things have been a bit too good for a bit too long,’ said Strickland, ‘and we’ve got a modest correction going on.’
‘Mr Chairman,’ said Abrahams, ‘it doesn’t feel modest.’
‘They never do when they start. There’s always the fear of how far they’re going to go.’
‘And you’re saying this isn’t going to go far,’ said the president.
‘There’s no reason for it to.’
Knowles glanced at Abrahams, who rolled his eyes. ‘Well, Ron,’ said the president, ‘I think we all need to use language that’s a little more respectful of people’s fears.’
‘There’s nothing to fear,’ said Strickland. ‘Hand on heart, Mr President, I’m telling you that I know of nothing out there that’s comparable. Unless someone’s hiding something, and hiding it well, we don’t have a Bear Stearns, we don’t have a Lehman.’
‘Can you be sure?’
‘I don’t see one. And even if there is something, we don’t have the level of insane systemic risk exposure that we had in ’08. We just don’t have it.’
‘Well, let’s be sensitive in the way we say that,’ said Knowles. ‘If journalists are going to bait you, Ron, you’re going to have to deal with it.’
‘Alright,’ said Strickland. ‘Okay. Fine. I don’t mean to cause any problems.’
There was silence for a moment ‘Marty,’ said the president. ‘You there?’
‘Yes, sir,’ said Marty Perez, his economic advisor.
‘You agree with Ron and Susan?’
‘Yes, I do. The market’s ripe for a minor correction. It’s October. This is the month when it always happens. A few people are taking profits. Once they’ve done that they’ll come back in and buy the stocks back. In a few weeks it’s going to look a lot less bad than it feels now.’
Knowles glanced at Abrahams. There was only one date that concerned him, November 6. It wasn’t possible for this correction, as everyone kept calling it, to have happened at a worse time.
‘What about that bank? What’s it called, that bank I keep hearing about?’
‘Fidelian,’ said Abrahams.
‘It’s getting slammed,’ said Strickland. ‘There’s no doubt about that. You get that in any correction. Rumors go round and a couple of companies get it in the neck. As far as we know, Fidelian’s okay. It’s not great, but it’s okay.’
‘Has anyone talked to them?’
‘The New York Fed talked to them a couple of days back. The CEO’s a guy by the name of Bill Custler. Jerry Rabin knows him. He’s a good guy. He’d tell us if there was anything we needed to know.’
‘Maybe you should talk to him yourself.’
‘I could.’
‘What about you, Susan?’
‘I’m planning to,’ said the Treasury secretary.
‘Okay.’ Knowles paused. ‘We have to get control of this.’ He looked at Abrahams. ‘I don’t care if it’s October or whatever the heck it is. We’re not having a panic now.’
‘I don’t think we should ignore this,’ said Abrahams. ‘Whatever the Economic Review would like us to believe, there’s no story here. It’ll blow itself out, but so close to the midterms we can’t take the chance that it blows up first. We need to put this to bed. I think you should use your speech tonight to make a strong statement.’
‘Anyone disagree with that?’
There was silence.
‘Okay, let’s go back to the start. I want to be a hundred per cent clear on this. First of all, Susan, Ron and Marty, you’re all saying we don’t have a significant concern?’
‘That’s right, Mr President,’ said Opitz. ‘We have the normal range of activity and no systemic risk beyond what we would expect to see.’
‘Ron, you comfortable with that statement as well?’
; ‘Yes, sir.’
‘You got that, Josh?’ said Knowles to his speechwriter, who was sitting on the other side of the Air Force One office.
Bentner nodded.
‘So I’m going to say my number one priority is the stability and growth of our economy, that all my administration’s policies are geared towards that.’ He glanced at Bentner, who was taking notes. ‘Josh, can we fill that out with some examples?’
Bentner nodded again.
‘Then given the recent movements in the markets, I’ve asked the Treasury secretary and the chairman of the Fed to undertake a thorough review of the financial system and they …’
‘Sir,’ said Abrahams, ‘I would say you have today had discussions with the Treasury secretary and the chairman of the Fed to discuss in depth the financial system and you’re satisfied that they’re exercising strong supervision … no, they have assured you that the system remains in sound health and there’s no risk of disruption such as we saw in 2008.’
‘You think we get it out there like that? 2008? Ron did that and look what happened.’
‘With due respect to the chairman,’ said Abrahams, ‘it’ll be the president who’s speaking. I would take 2008 head on. I would show the seriousness and gravity with which you’re addressing this.’
Knowles glanced at Bentner. ‘You got that?’
Bentner nodded.
‘Then I would say something about continuing scrutiny so we’re ready to take action at the first sign of any need …’ Abrahams paused. ‘No, actually, I wouldn’t say that. It sounds like you think there is a problem.’
‘I think we should recognize that people are concerned about volatility,’ said Marty Perez. ‘They’re concerned about stock prices going down. I think we need some words about that because that’s what’s really worrying people. Let’s address it and not minimize it.’
‘So what does the president say?’ said Bentner. ‘That he recognizes it’s happening and he understands the anxiety it causes but the fundamentals are sound?’
‘Something like that,’ said Perez.
‘Look,’ said the president, ‘basically I want to say there’s no underlying problem, but in case there is one, I’m here, and if there is, we’ll deal with it right away, but there isn’t one.’ The president paused. ‘Something like that. Josh, figure out how to say it. That’s what you do, right?’
End Game Page 10