by Rob Cornell
A PI without ethics is nothing more than a low-class hustler.
Boy did Bobby know how to hustle.
I didn’t find much else from the board that I didn’t already know. After all, this was my life. Nothing about my daughter, not even the pictures he’d emailed me. Most likely he had a laptop around here where he kept that additional information.
I started to turn away to look for it when one last picture on the board caught my attention. I’d initially skimmed over it because it sat among a collage of photos tracking my whereabouts and frequented locals. But this one didn’t fit. I looked closer and a tremor and buzz shot through me as I realized what I was looking at.
The photo featured the outside of Eddie’s apartment building. The angle was similar to other photos taken of the place, a couple with me entering and exiting. This one, date-stamped November 12—the day Eddie was killed—showed someone else exiting the building. Someone I recognized…just as Bobby had promised I would.
Bobbie’s cousin, Shawn.
The knowledge made my continued search hard to focus on. I did my best to force it to the background. But even when I didn’t think about it directly, my body hummed like an electrical transformer, the voltage within desperate to lash out.
In the bedroom, on the dresser, I found the laptop and Bobby’s camera. A new wave of jitters hit me. The laptop sat before me like an ancient artifact, the secrets within possibly life-changing.
I found it hard to move forward. I pushed. The answers were here. Either Bobby had faked his information about my daughter, or he had evidence of who and where she really was.
I went to the dresser, flipped open the laptop, and powered it on. It felt like an age while I waited for the computer to fully boot.
It took no time at all to find what I was looking for. A folder on his desktop was labeled Ridley’s Spawn. The derogatory label suggested what was inside just might be true.
I clicked open the folder and found out once and for all.
Chapter 31
I took his laptop. It was mine now, simple as that.
Back at the house, I found Paul in the wine cellar. He was tending to Bobby’s broken and bloody nose. The blood had rolled over his mouth and down his chin and had started to coagulate into crusty red goatee. More blood ran from jagged cuts on his bare chest. His shirt was tossed onto the floor. A broken wine bottle lay close by. Some of the shards had a deeper red on the edges than the wine it had held. The smell of the spilled wine permeated the cellar.
Paul dabbed at Bobby’s bloody face with a damp rag. He stopped and turned when I came in. His gaze went to the laptop I carried under my arm like a school book.
Bobby saw it too and groaned. “You ruined all the fun, Rid.” His voice sounded stuffy and clogged as if he had a bad cold.
I glared at him, the frost fire burning inside my belly chilling my bones and beading my skin with sweat.
Paul twisted the rag in both hands. “Ridley?”
“It’s true,” I said. “He found her.”
Bobby grinned, showing off the gap in his teeth where Paul had apparently knocked one out. “See? I wouldn’t lie to you. You’re my best friend.”
I approached him, held the laptop out to Paul. “Can you hold this?”
Paul tossed aside the rag, took the computer from me, and stepped back. He knew what was coming.
Bobby stared into my eyes. “You don’t have the balls. You wouldn’t have sent down your goon to work me over if you did.”
“Circumstance has changed.” I rolled up my sleeves. “You threatened my daughter.”
He jerked against the cuff, scraping the chain across the pipe. His body smelled of sweat and blood. “She isn’t your daughter. You didn’t raise her. You didn’t even know what she looked like until I showed you.”
“I’ve been looking for her for three years—”
“And doing a piss poor job.”
“I wasn’t willing to con and torture people to get to her.”
He bellowed laughter, the sound echoing through the cellar. “Oh, no?” He tucked in his chin so he could look at his chest. Then he lifted his gaze back to me. “Oh, no?”
“You’re the exception, Bobby. You made me stoop because you were taking out your daddy issues on me.”
He thrashed, clinking the handcuff chain against the pipe again and again as if he thought he could break the pipe or chain if he kept yanking. “You God damned son of a bitch. You ruined my life.”
“I didn’t ruin anything. You ruined it yourself when you took advantage of Mort one too many times.”
“I took care of him till the end. I did everything for him. Bathed him, dressed him, sat with him for hours at a time. I even wiped his damn ass.”
“You’re his son. That’s your duty.”
“That’s rich coming for the guy who abandoned his parents because he didn’t want to sing. Where are they now? Did you spend the last six months of their life with them?”
I unleashed. My fists pumped like pistons, slamming into his abdomen over and over until Bobby started coughing blood and sprayed my face with it. I staggered back, panting, the muscles in my arms and shoulders burning.
Bobby hung limp, eyelids drooping, swath of hair stuck to his sweaty forehead.
Paul startled me when I place a hand on my shoulder. I hadn’t seen him approach. “Come on,” he said. “We’re done.”
I gave Bobby one last hateful look. Then I let Paul guide me out of the cellar.
I ran for the bathroom and puked in the toilet. My sides cramped from my heaving so hard. I felt clammy, shaky, and the image of Bobby’s bloody and beaten body kept flickering across my mind’s eye, prompting another heave each time. I would never wash what I had done to him off my soul.
Eventually I regained control over my quivering stomach, washed my face, and met Paul back in the kitchen. He had the laptop open and was perusing the files about my daughter.
About Lisa.
He looked up as I sat at the table. “You sure this isn’t faked?”
He obviously hadn’t gotten to the most conclusive evidence. “Click open the file marked ‘Insurance.’”
Paul swiped at the touchpad then tapped it. His brow furled. “I don’t get it. Who are these people?”
He was looking at a scanned photograph, the image of which had seared itself permanently to my brain. I could see it as clear as if I were looking at it myself. Either Shwineski had lied about not giving information to Bobby, or Bobby had found some other way to get at Shwineski’s records. “The one on the far left is Lincoln Rice, Autumn’s father. The woman to his right is Dr. Lee. The guy on his left is Dr. Kahn. The couple holding the baby are Lisa’s adoptive parents, for lack of a better term. I imagine Shwineski took the photo.” The picture had a date stamp too—about two weeks after Autumn gave birth.
“How do you know that’s your daughter or those are her parents?”
“Now click into the folder labeled ‘Spawn Pics.’”
Paul made a face and shook his head. He used the touchpad again to open the folder. His eyes scanned the screen. He was looking at a series of thumbnail photos.
“If you look through them, you’ll find a picture of Lisa with her parents.”
I watched his eyes move until they stopped. He tapped open a photo. He mouth opened, eyes widened. “Holy shit.”
“It’s the same couple,” I said.
“So the first photo? That was what?”
“Insurance, just like the label says. Shwineski was the record keeper. Playing it smart meant making a record of those involved in the…transaction. I’d bet money Lee and Kahn have, and Rice had, a similar photo, only with Shwineski in them.”
“Wouldn’t someone have found it going through Rice’s things after his death?”
“Who knows where he kept it? Maybe there’s a safety deposit box somewhere out there with the photo in it. I’d doubt Lee or Rice would have let Shwineski take this picture without getting one of t
heir own. If fact, I bet there’s a slew of pics like it featuring the other parents.”
“Gotta make sure everyone’s ass is covered in case the parents’ had second thoughts.”
“Yep.”
Paul shook his head. He closed the laptop and folded his meaty hands on top. I noticed his knuckles looked a little pink and raw. “Now what?”
I sucked in my lower lip and bit down. The magic question. I had done what I had strove to do for three years. I had found her. But I had never thought what I would do once that day came. Approach her? Tell her who I was? Confront her…I didn’t want to call them parents, but what else were they after all this time raising her? What would that accomplish? Did I want to take her away? Claim her like a piece of stolen property? From the pictures I saw, she wasn’t in any duress. Her parents looked like they loved her like real parents do. She had a whole life without me. Would letting her know I even existed do her any good? Or would it only disrupt what looked like a normal, happy life?
I ran my fingers through my hair and sighed. “I don’t know. I do not know.”
What I did know? I had other business to attend to. Another case to focus on, giving my subconscious time to noodle with what to do about Lisa. (Not a name I would have chosen; not that there was anything wrong with the name.)
First things first, we had to deal with Bobby. Paul offered to take him back to his car over by Angie’s. We unhooked him from the pipe and half carried him up out of the cellar and out to Paul’s car. Bobby could barely walk on his own. The whole thing reminded me of a time we’d been out drinking together and I ended up having to carry him out of the bar.
We flopped Bobby into the backseat and re-cuffed his hands behind his back.
He gave me a bleary eyed look. “We’re not done.”
“I’m done,” I said. “Get out of Hawthorne after you heal up. Go home. There’s people there worried about you. They think you’re still worth saving.”
He chuffed. “You don’t have a clue.”
I didn’t want one. I slammed the door shut and turned to Paul. My breath puffed in the cold air when I spoke. “You’ve gone above and beyond, my friend.”
That got me his signature sideways smile. “You can thank me with that raise we talked about.”
“Consider it done. Double what you make now sound fair?”
“Are you fucking shitting me?”
I patted him on the arm. “See you tonight.”
I watched him drive off, then got into my own car and headed to Shawn’s place. On the way I called Detective Shanks.
I no sooner introduced myself and she asked, “Find anything?”
“What? No small talk?”
“You know, witty quips don’t work when you sound like someone just kicked you in the balls.”
Perceptive. I liked that. I really wished she and I had met under different circumstances. “Metaphorically, you’d be right. But that’s another issue. I have a photograph of the guy I suspect killed Eddie.”
“You suspect how?”
“It shows him exiting Eddie’s apartment with a date stamp that puts it on the day and around the time Eddie had his so-called accident.”
“And you’re headed here with the photo I assume?”
“No,” I said. “It’s not enough for you to act.”
“It’s enough to give us something to push with.”
“I know. But I’d probably have better luck with the pushing, seeing as I have a little more leeway with the rules.”
“No,” she said, drawing out the word. “No leeway. You bring that photo here and we’ll do this right.”
I turned the corner onto Shawn’s block. “I’ll let you know what he tells me.”
“Don’t do anything stupid. Who is it? Who’s in this photo?”
“If I told you that, you’d try to come help.” I pulled right into Shawn’s driveway. The time for subtlety and sneaking had ended. “Or stop me.”
“Mr. Brone, I like you. Don’t make me change my mind.”
“Be honest. Your superior has already got you working a different case. A real homicide. Not some bullshit this cop killing private dick is ranting about.”
“No one has come out and called you a cop killer.”
“Comforting.” I drew my gun and checked the load. Good to go. “Even if I bring the photo, you can’t act on it. You know that. As nice as you were to me at the scene, you can’t follow up on this because the department’s already classed it an accident.”
“That doesn’t mean I can’t do a little digging on my own time.”
I slid my gun back into my holster, cut the car engine, and climbed out from the heated car into a cold that bit extra hard. Twilight had night close on its tale. The last blue-gray light would give way to darkness in an hour at most.
“This is going to take more than a little digging,” I said, staring at that darkening horizon. “This calls for more of a jackhammer approach.”
“If you’re off on your own, why are you bothering to call me?”
“In case something happens to me. I have a copy of the photo on my home computer. I labeled it ‘My Killer’ just in case.”
“Not funny.”
“I know.” I hesitated a second, a few words on my mind I wanted to say and felt just reckless enough to say them. “Next time I see you, I’m going to ask you out. If I come out of this a little bruised, you’ll feel so sorry for me, you’ll have to say yes.”
“Quit screwing around and tell me where you’re going.”
“Nowhere,” I said. “I’m already there.” I hung up before she could try again to talk me out of this.
Shawn must have heard me pull in because he stared at me through the glass of his storm door.
I tucked my phone in my pocket and approached the house.
He let me in on the pretense that I only wanted to ask a few more questions about Eddie. He had no idea why I was really there. I could tell from his confident demeanor, he didn’t even suspect I might know what I did.
That is, if what I knew amounted to anything. The photo was circumstantial at best. Though it did raise the question—why hadn’t he mentioned the visit when I told him about Eddie’s death? Something like: What do you mean he’s dead? I was just over there and he was fine!
Shawn invited me into his living room. A wide screen television was tuned to ESPN. They were recapping the recent Lions versus Bears game. Bears won, twenty-one to zip.
“I’d offer a beer,” he said, “but my wife doesn’t let me drink in the house. You want a pop?”
“I’m good.” I jerked a chin at the TV. “Fucking Lions.”
“I know. The Rapture will happen before they see the Super Bowl.” He crossed the room and dropped into an easy chair. He picked up a fifteen pound barbell from the floor and started doing curls. “So what do you need to know?”
“You made funeral arrangements yet?”
“Yeah. Viewing on Thursday. Funeral’s Friday.” If he was a killer, he knew how to keep his cool, and lie like a snake. “Cops said it was an accident. You still think it wasn’t?”
I shrugged. I could play cool, too. “Eddie was a client who died in the middle of an investigation. I like to tie up loose ends and that’s a whopper.”
“Why’s that?”
“Because it steps over the line from coincidence to pattern. See, the whole time I was looking into things for Eddie, I kept assuming something. But assumptions can kill an investigation as quick as anything.”
He stopped mid curl, eyes full of fake interest. “What were you assuming?”
“That his problems were the same as mine, and anything that contradicted that had to be a weird coincidence. Then I found a pattern that just seemed too ridiculous to be true. So I let myself get sidetracked.”
“I don’t follow.”
The volume on the TV was on the low side, but the incessant chattering about this amazing play and that failed pass distracted me. “Can we turn that off?”
He set down his barbell, picked up his remote from an end table, and clicked the TV off. “What pattern are you talking about?”
“Did you know that nearly every member of the Arndt side was killed by unnatural means?”
His eyebrows went up and his eyes went wide. “Wow. I didn’t.”
I wondered how much of that surprise came from his realizing where I was headed with this. I pulled my left arm close to my body so I could feel the bulge of my gun under my coat. I unzipped the coat, but made sure to keep my weapon covered. “Nice and warm in here.”
“I hate the cold. Winter time comes, I crank the heat. Drives my wife nuts. Swear she’s got an internal heat source. She wears shorts outside in December. You believe that?”
“Must be nice.” I shifted on the couch so I could reach under my coat if I needed to. Small talk aside, we were only a few words from the crux of this conversation. “Anyway, yeah. Almost all of Eddie’s immediate relatives killed by some freak accident or tragedy, like the murder-suicide.”
“Eddie used to say he thought he was cursed. Now I wonder if he wasn’t right.”
“He wasn’t.” I watched his face, looking for a tell. Nothing yet. “There’s no such thing as curses. But Eddie did have a whole lot of heartbreak in his life. A whole lot of torture. Everyone he loved taken from him, sometimes brutally.”
“I know, right?” He wrinkled his brow. “Unluckiest bastard I ever met.”
“I don’t think so.”
“Huh?”
“Luck had nothing to do with it,” I said. I lifted my eyebrows. “Isn’t that right?”
Now his gaze hardened. The hinges of his jaw bulged under his skin as he clenched his teeth. “If I didn’t know any better—”
“You do. You know damn well.”
A vague accusation like that was just the thing to shove him into a staggered confession. But he didn’t trip. “Are you accusing me of something?”