“Yer not stupid, Zach. Or at least that’s what errybody’s always telling me. You never seemed that fucking smart to me. Specially not if you managed to get pussywhipped into going back to that school. You could’ve been something, done something, but look at you. And trynna drag Caleb into it. Shame on you. Here I was, thinking you went to a faggot school. You think I’m gonna let you take the only son I have left and turn him into a prissy-ass cocksucker like you? No fucking way.”
My mom’s been spluttering over herself, apologizing to Erin and trying to get my dad to shut up. I want to shove Erin out the door and haul my brother back to our room to wedge ourselves between the beds until the fighting stops. I knew this was a bad idea. I never should’ve let her come here. I’m trapped and I can’t protect her. I’m a kid again and I can’t even protect myself. My dad rages on but I barely hear him. I’m too busy trying to figure out how to crawl under this table. Then there’s the most surprising sound in the world.
“Mr. Shepherd, Zach is a really fine man. He’s a wonderful teacher and a great coach. The boys love him, and he works hard. Hawthorn is fortunate he came back.”
“You would say that, Mrs. Fucking Robinson. Were you fucking my son while he was yer student? I should have you arrested for statutory rape.”
He’s stumbled over the word “statutory.” For some reason that brings my blood to a boil but I’m frozen.
“Of course not. Zach and I, we never—”
“Is that why yer so hot to have Caleb come up there? Zach getting a little old for your tastes?”
“Stop. Stop. Stop it. Stop it.” The words are coming out of my mouth but not loud enough for anyone to hear them. I can’t believe I’m letting Erin fight this battle all by herself while I stare at the tablecloth with the faded stains my mom’s never quite been able to scrub out.
“Zach wants Caleb to come to Hawthorn for the same reason he wanted to come to Hawthorn. Because it’s the best boys’ school in the country. Having a diploma from there will open doors for him. Doors that won’t be open if he stays in Shamokin. He’ll get into a good college.”
“So he can be another fucking teacher?”
“Maybe. If he wants. Or maybe he’ll want to be a lawyer, or a stockbroker or an architect. But in the meantime, he’ll meet a lot of important people. He’ll get a really good education. And not for nothing, but he’ll always have as much food as he can eat. He won’t want for anything. Zach is in a position to give that to him.”
That’s when my dad loses it. He knocks his chair back from the table and leans over, meaty palms planted on either side of the half-empty bowl of coleslaw to yell in her face. “Get the fuck out of my house, you uppity little bitch. You come into my home, eat my food, fuck my son, and you have the nerve to say I can’t provide for my family? Fuck you, you fucking cunt.”
That shakes me out of my stupor enough to grab her hand. “Erin, come on. Let’s go.”
“Zach—”
“No, it’s not worth it. He’s never going to change his mind no matter what you say. Or what I say. I can’t take this anymore. Please, let’s go.”
The stubborn set of her chin and the fire in her big brown eyes tells me she’s ready to go another few rounds with my asshole father. In that second I know I’m going to ask her to marry me.
My beautiful, sweet, supple girl with a spine of steel. She wants to stomp her tiny foot and scream back at him, but it would end badly, so I say quietly, “Come on, lamb. Be a good girl for me and let’s go.”
The emotions rage behind the soft curves of her gently upturned nose, her pink cheeks, and her pretty mouth, but she reins it in and then squeezes my hand. “Yes, Zach.”
My father is still ranting, something about calling off my attack bitch, but I don’t care. “Mom, I’m sorry. We gotta go.”
She nods tightly. “Probably best.”
I’m turning the key in the ignition when there’s a knock on my window. Caleb’s standing there, scrawny arms crossed over his narrow chest. I roll down the window and he leans in, his hair brushing the roof. “I wanted to say thank you before you go. It was fun.”
“When this blows over, I’ll see if you can’t come up for a couple of weeks this summer, okay? I’m sorry. I know what he’s going to be like when we leave, and I—”
Caleb shrugs. “I’m used to it. Besides, it was kind of awesome.”
“Awesome?”
“Yeah, I thought Erin was going to punch Dad when he called her a cunt.”
“Caleb!” We’ve both shouted at him and he smirks.
“I know, I know, I won’t say that word again. Promise. Thanks for the cookies, Erin. Bye, Zach.”
He scrubs a hand through my hair in a weird reversal of our usual roles and I watch him walk back toward the house, wishing I could throw his lanky frame in the backseat and drive off. Instead I grip the wheel and back out of the driveway, onto my street, through town and onto the highway.
Erin doesn’t say anything during the ride home, but keeps a hand above my knee; a reminder she’s still here and has no intention of leaving no matter what she saw. When we get back to campus, I park behind Sullivan and we trudge up the stairs to her apartment, where I strip her naked and bury myself in her until I forget my name.
Chapter 20
Erin
Now I know. How Shep grew up, how Caleb is growing up. Why Shep is so quietly desperate to get him out of there. Blue-collar living doesn’t bother me, but the way his dad talked to me? I’m a stranger. I can’t imagine how he must talk to his sons. Or their mother. And for how long? How a man like Shep came out of a house like that, I don’t know. The chances of Caleb coming out as well are a long shot, but those Shepherd boys seem to be defying the odds.
Shep’s been so quiet since we got back, barely getting out instructions last night. Sometimes he was rough with me, but more often it seemed like he wanted to lose himself and forget everything. I don’t want him to forget everything. I want him to remember his life here, with me, but I’ll do whatever I can to help him bury the rest, leaving a trail of cookie crumbs should Caleb be able to follow.
Shep has to leave tonight for Fort Lauderdale and today was supposed to be one long play session I’ve been looking forward to. It’s hard enough to steal time to be together at all, never mind to find the time and space for him to do rude things to me that—despite my fears about the translations of fantasy into reality—I’ve really enjoyed.
But after yesterday… He’s wrapped around me, still asleep after a fitful night. I slide a hand from the cut of his hip, up the muscles of his back, and grip the top of his shoulder. I kiss his neck and he stirs, holding me tighter.
“I’m so sorry about yesterday—”
I hush him with a finger over his lips. “I don’t want to talk about it. Can we have our day like we were planning to? Pretty please?”
The corner of his mouth tugs up and I trace the curve with my fingertip. “Since you’ve said pretty please, how can I say no?”
We eat breakfast and then Shep guides me to the bathroom, telling me to strip and get in the shower. “Are you coming, too?”
“Yes, I’m coming, too.”
I climb under the spray and wet down my hair before Shep pushes the curtain aside and steps in. He leans against the far wall and crosses his arms over his chest.
“Go about your business. I want to watch you.”
“Yes, Zach.”
I soap up my hair, rinse it out and then slather on my conditioner and rinse that out, too. When I wipe the water that’s streamed over my face from my eyes, Shep’s pressed against the tiles, but his arms aren’t crossed anymore. Oh, no. Instead, he’s closed a fist around his…his cock and he’s stroking himself idly.
“You’re so pretty, Erin. Did you know that?”
It’s not something many people have said to me but I don’t want to sound like I’m fishing for compliments, either. “You’ve said so, Zach.”
“I’m not the only one who
thinks so. You have beautiful eyes and the cutest nose. And your mouth…” He sucks a breath between his teeth and grips himself harder, sliding faster. “Every time I look at your mouth, I think of you sucking me off.”
That’s what I’m thinking of, too, watching him. I’m jealous of his hand. I want to smack it away, hold it behind his back so I can be the one making him feel good. I drop to my knees and reach for him, but he stops me by gripping my shoulder, pushing me back on my heels. “Not yet. I’m not done. You have these perfect breasts, and the way you react when I play with your nipples…”
His head drops back and he fists his cock harder still. Such rough strokes. All the times I imagined this, this is so much better. And worse because I’m aching for him and he won’t let me touch. I whimper and he looks down. Smiles. He must know how hot I am for him, how wet, how desperate.
“I love how you’re so soft. It’s like an invitation.”
I’d scrawl calligraphy on the wall with my bar of soap if I thought it would get him to give in sooner. “Please, Zach.”
“Hands behind your back, naughty girl.”
He may as well have run a finger over my clit. His words have the same effect, a tightening, heaviness, and I weave my fingers together.
“Has anyone ever fucked your face, Erin?”
I squeak. God, could I be any less sexy? But I close my eyes and take a breath. “No, Zach.”
“Have you ever sucked cock before?”
“Yes, Zach.”
“Did they come in your mouth?”
I shake my head tightly.
“Did they come on you?”
Again, a shake of the head. It had been foreplay, not the main event. But this talking, the dirty words, this is foreplay and it won’t take much to set me off. He’s slowed down his pace, loosened his grip and reaches out to stroke my cheek.
“I’m going to teach you to take my cock down your throat and then I’m going to come on your perfect tits. Would you like that?”
My clit is throbbing with want, so yes, yes. “Yes, Zach.”
“Open your pretty mouth.”
He directs his cock between my lips and I slick my tongue over the tip, tasting a drop of moisture that’s leaked out. He grunts as I lap at him, and I hold my hands tightly. “That’s nice, lamb. But you’re going to stop and let me tell you what to do.”
Though I want to keep licking, sucking—and having something in my mouth that I’m not supposed to do anything with is torture—I stop and look up, the head still between my lips, warm, smooth and heavy. “Good girl. Breathe through your nose and relax. I’m not going to hurt you, I promise. If you get scared, tap my leg and we’ll stop.”
I give a lick in response and he cradles the back of my head, his fingers twining with my hair, his palm at the nape of my neck. He draws me forward. I take more of him in my mouth, closing my eyes and trying to breathe. Using his other hand, he strokes my neck, tips my chin up and starts to edge into my throat. I choke and he eases back. “Relax, Erin. You’re doing so well. I’m so pleased with you.”
I blink my eyes open and it’s true. It’s written all over his face. “Try again.”
He rocks back into my throat and this time I’m ready, expecting the brief airlessness. It doesn’t scare me, though I still gag and my eyes water. After a few more strokes, he thumbs the few tears sliding down my cheeks. “You’re so pretty when you cry.”
Then he withdraws from my mouth, leaving me wanting. I stare hungrily as he fists his cock, pumps a few times before his release hits me in the chest. The density is different, thicker, than the spray of the shower pelting my back. It’s hotter somehow, and slides over my skin like gravity doesn’t affect it the same way. His other hand is planted on the tiles, fingers spread and tensed, and he hangs his head, spent. A low glow of pleasure spreads from my chest knowing I was the one who made him lose control.
When he comes back to himself, he studies me where I’m kneeling, hands clasped behind my back, evidence of his pleasure still visible on my chest and across my breasts. He grabs a washcloth, soaps it up and runs it over where he’s marked me. Though it washes away, it’s like the strands are still hot on my skin. When he’s finished he leans back against the tile. “You’ve had your show, now I’d like mine.”
I blink at him, uncertain, and wait for him to be more specific.
“I want you to get yourself off, lamb. Show me how you touch your pussy. Go on, I want to watch while you make yourself come.”
I release my hands from behind my back and slip one hand around my hip and he grins.
“What?” I’ve frozen in panic. Is he laughing at me? Am I doing this wrong?
“I was right. You do masturbate with your right hand.”
All the air in my body makes a break for it as blood rushes to my face. “You’ve thought about me…”
“Yeah. Lots of times.”
“And that…”
“Got me off? Yeah, lots of times. I want to see it for real.”
My fingers inch forward and when I reach my mound, I tease myself with a press of the heel of my hand and rock against it. I close my eyes and find my clit, circling slowly at first and then faster, harder, grinding against my palm. I’m driven on by the idea that when I open my eyes, Shep is going to be standing naked in front of me. I wouldn’t be surprised if he’s getting hard again from watching me.
I touch myself for another minute before I let myself look at him. There he is, like I thought he would be, but he’s taken himself in hand again with slow, leisurely strokes.
“Holy fuck, Erin. Do you put your fingers in your pussy when you jerk off or just play with your clit?”
“It depends.”
Sometimes I want penetration and sometimes I don’t. Right now, I do, so I slip a couple of fingers inside. I moan and layer my other hand over the one inside me, giving me more to rock against as my hips buck and my cheeks clench.
“That’s right. I want to see you finger-fuck yourself. Did you ever think of me while you were doing this?”
“Yes, Zach.”
“Are you thinking of me now?”
“Yes, Zach.”
“Will you come for me, Erin? I want to see you come all over your own hand while you think about how hard I’m going to fuck you as soon as you’re finished getting yourself off.”
I nod desperately, thrust my hips harder, wishing he were fucking me now, and change the angle of my hands to give better contact with my clit. That’s when it hits me.
“Oh, oh, god…”
“That’s a good girl.”
Then Shep’s on his knees in front of me, his hand covering mine as I rock the rest of my orgasm out. When I’m done, I rest my head against his shoulder. He rubs my back before helping me ease my fingers out of my body. Then he brings my hand to his mouth and sucks the fingers that were inside me.
“You taste so fucking good. When I get back, I’m going to strap you down on your bed with your legs spread wide and I’m going to lick your pussy until you come.”
I whimper, because the idea of coming again is overwhelming.
“But for now, I’m going to get you cleaned up so I can get you dirty all over again.”
And he does.
Shep
The next week in Florida with the guys is torture. I miss Erin like crazy even though I talk to her every night. Sometimes in the morning, too, if I wake up early enough.
It’s hard to tell from fifteen hundred miles away but she sounds unsettled sometimes and not just from missing me. I couldn’t quite put a finger on what might be wrong until I remembered Will used to go on Model UN trips. If the guy couldn’t keep it in his pants while he was on campus, I’m pretty sure he didn’t even try while he was in a different time zone. I wish Erin would trust me more than that because I’d never cheat on her, but I get it. Will did a lot of damage and it’s going to take time to repair. I’m totally up for the job.
So I tell her about the grueling three-a-day practic
es, making sure the guys don’t get into too much trouble in their off-hours, shutting down a food fight in the making at a steakhouse, and what goofballs they are in the hotel pool. It makes her feel better to hear how busy I’ve been. Our conversations aren’t all work and no play, though. Oh, no. I gave her a homework assignment while I’m away. Every day, she reads one of her books and finds something she’d like to do. When I call at night, she reads it to me. She’s less shy about it than when we’re face-to-face and by the end of the week… Let’s just say Mordecai would be impressed.
She’s under strict instructions not to come while I’m away, and it’s killing the poor thing. I’m a terrible, horrible, very mean Master. She’s told me so. I delight in the pouty pleading and can’t wait to get home and put her out of her misery. Her horny, horny misery.
Also while I’ve been away, I called Headmaster Wilson to tell him Caleb wouldn’t be coming in the fall.
“I’m sorry to hear that. It would have been nice to have another Shepherd on campus.”
Yeah, it would’ve been. I thank him again for the opportunity and throw my cell hard against the bed, wanting to hurl something through the air but knowing I can’t afford to replace it. Especially after the present I’d given Erin right before I left. Caleb had helped me pick it out after we’d gotten him new sneakers at the mall.
She hadn’t want to accept the box I’d given her when she was dropping me off at the airport. “It’s too much,” she’d said.
“I want you to have it. It’ll make you think of me while I’m away.”
“I’ll think of you anyway.”
“I hope so.”
I’d looped it around her neck, fastening the clasp, and she’d sighed. Despite her protests, I think she liked it.
“Thank you. You didn’t have to do this.” I know I didn’t, but I’ve pictured her fingering the silver lock on the chain while worrying her bottom lip with her teeth and pressing her thighs together while she’s doing her homework. That’s more than enough in exchange.
Taming His Teacher Page 23