by Dara Girard
Until forty years later when two friends are forced to keep their vow no matter the price.
Dorcas
Everybody knows that Dorcas Mortag burns everything she touches. If you want your house to still be standing you wouldn't let her set foot in your kitchen. She could burn water if given the chance. But she was never a bright woman—not thick mind you, just not brilliant. I don’t say this to be mean. I say it because it’s true. I found out how true it was when I made a foolish promise to her over forty years ago.
Secrets are hard to keep. I know. I've never been able to keep one, which is why people don't tell me things and I don't want them too. I have plenty of my own business in which to manage and I don't have time for someone else's mess cluttering up my mind. Promises are also hard to keep, but, unfortunately, easier to make. That's what got me into trouble. I’d made a simple promise a long time ago, never thinking much about it until I was asked to honor it.
It was little comfort that I wasn't the only one who'd made this promise. We were three girls of twelve when we made our binding vow. I remember it was a rainy day in Port Antonio. My mother had gone to the shop and I was looking after my little sister when Dorcas, Aletta and Terry stopped by.
Dorcas wasn’t much to look at, although she was best friends with her opposite, Terry, who had looks that had turned heads since the age of five and she had wealthy parents. Terry was cheery, small and kind. Dorcas was big and sweet. On the other hand, our friend, Aletta, had a face that looked like a truck had backed over it several times. People whispered that she’d come into the world crying and had never found a reason to smile. She was usually irritated or miserable, but she was clever and helped us with our homework, which was the main reason why we kept her in our circle.
They came to my house because I had the most space and adults were not usually around. My mother was always working. I didn’t know where my father was--or to be honest who he was--and my uncle, who had a room down the hall, was always leaving some woman’s bed before her husband showed up. That day, aside from the light patter of rain, I remember the smell of fish fritters and sorrel juice I’d made for my sister. Aletta sat and lit a cigarette.
I snatched it from her and stomped it out. “Yuh mad? You can’t smoke here.”
“Mi sorry,” she said not sounding sorry at all.
I didn't let her attitude bother me as long as she didn’t dare try to smoke again. My mother could smell the residue of anything—liquor taken from her cabinet, another woman’s perfume on her boyfriend’s shirt and definitely cigarette smoke in her prized sitting room.
“I want you to do something for me,” Dorcas said. She had a sweet voice like pink candyfloss or an ice lolly. She could make you forget that sometimes what she said made no sense. “I want you to promise to lie for me.”
“Why?” I asked.
Aletta scrunched up her face. “Lying is a sin.”
“Not all lies,” Dorcas said.
“Yes, they are.” Aletta held her hand out. “Get me a bible and I'll prove it.”
“She's right,” I said. “Sometimes you have to lie.”
“You should never lie.”
I folded my arms and glanced at the bag where Aletta hid her cigarettes. “What do you tell your sister when her fags go missing?”
“I don't say anything.”
“That's the same as lying.”
“Why promise to lie for you?” Terry asked Dorcas before Aletta could challenge me.
Dorcas lowered her voice as if she were sharing a secret. “I want you to promise me, just in case I do something bad.”
I laughed. “You’d never do anything bad.” Out of the four of us, she was the least likely to get into any trouble.
“But just in case.”
“I'll do it,” Terry said.
I shrugged. “Me too.”
We looked at Aletta.
She frowned. “What do we have to lie about?”
“I don't know yet,” Dorcas said.
“All right.”
Dorcas smiled and then her face grew serious and her gaze slowly went around the room as if assessing us. “You have to keep the lie or else.”
Aletta sniffed. “Or else what?”
“You’ll die.”
She was a silly girl, but so were we and very dramatic back then. We’d read several English classics that told of undying loyalty and they added some adventure to our dull, ordinary lives. “We'll keep it,” Terry said. Aletta and I nodded.
Dorcas' smile returned. Then she took out three marbles and held them in the palm of her hand. “I’ll give one to each of you when I want the promise kept.”
When I think of it now, I don't know whether to laugh or cry. How silly it was that we’d later do something so dangerous for a promise and a ritual of receiving a marble we'd discussed as children. I quickly forgot about it. I was sure all of us did. I was wrong.
After that rainy day, our thoughts turned to boys and dreams of leaving Jamaica. Well three of us dreamed about it, Aletta never did. She thought it was the height of foolishness and a waste of time. None of us saw her leaving and for years she didn’t. She ended up working in town as a teacher at a private school. However, the rest of us did dream. Terry said a sailor would come and whisk her away. Instead she married a clerk who took her to England and she had two children.
Dorcas did once say she’d marry a man who’d take her off the island far away to England. And surprise, she did finally meet some man who’d said he’d take her. He was a good worker, simple, but kind and I’ve nothing against that. She was so happy, boasting how he was going to take her to Cambridge and how much she’d learn there. But the Cambridge to which he took her wasn’t the one in England. It wasn’t even close. It was in Massachusetts. Yes, he took her to America. She never did see England. None of us had thought of going to America, a place where they mangled the English language so much so sometimes one wasn't sure they were speaking English at all.
I married too. A man who took me off the island and settled us in Canada. I was lonely, I admit it, and the gray days settled heavy on my soul, but I loved my husband and our growing family.
Terry kept in touch with all of us. She was like the glue that tied us together. Her letters were always a welcome sight in the post box. She was so full of life, we didn’t expect the cancer to take her so quickly. Her husband was unable to cope, and her parents were dead and none of her siblings wanted two extra mouths to feed, leaving her two little ones all alone. Dorcas offered to take them in, even though she'd been newly married. Lucky for her, her man didn’t mind.
In the seventies, my husband's job took him to Virginia where I reconnected with Aletta. She'd married and divorced. She never mentioned her ex-husband and I never asked. Two years later Dorcas and her family moved to Maryland and we had a reunion. We gathered at my house because I still had the best food and the perfect space. I felt as if nothing had changed and half expected Terry to come through the door. And, for one brief moment, I thought she had when Deena, one of her daughters, came to greet me and then the other one, Lois. They both had their mother's beauty and kind, cheery nature.
Dorcas also had two little girls Michaela and Teresa—not pretty mind you—but sweet. She did dress all four girls as if they were princesses and doted on them. Her husband did too until him up and die on her only twenty-five years into the marriage. Fortunately, he left them enough money, which allowed the girls to educate themselves and find proper men to marry. Terry's two girls had no problem and both married right after college. It took another decade for Dorcas' eldest daughter to do so, but she did at last. Her younger daughter had a devil of time finding the right match (I even considered my own son for her, but my husband laughed at the idea). She was not only plain but shy, her mother prayed for a man to see her for who she was and she eventually did catch one. A fine looking man.
Aletta was sour, as usual, at the wedding. “I don’t like him eyes,” she said.
S
he always said strange things like that. “His eyes are fine,” I said, wishing that Dorcas' daughter could have made a prettier bride.
“Then why him look 'pon the bridesmaids instead of the bride?”
I didn’t know what to say. Michaela looked so happy and I was glad she was spared the lonely state of being single. A woman should marry. And if the man can be handsome that’s good. “Don't make up stories.”
“I'm not.”
I ignored her and looked at Dorcas. She glowed. Six months later that glow was gone. I'd spotted her in a local shop and waved, but she looked right through me. I walked up to her and nudged her.
“Yuh not see mi wave?”
“Mi sorry I have troubles 'pon mi mind.”
“What troubles?”
“Deena, is worried about Michaela and I haven’t heard from her either. I have to see what’s going on.”
“How long has it been?”
“Two weeks.”
“No need to worry.”
“She calls me every week and we come here. Last time she told me she was sick and I asked if I could go see her and she said no. This time she didn’t call.”
“They’re newly married. Perhaps she wants time alone.”
“No, something’s not right. That’s not my daughter.”
“She’s a grown woman now.”
Dorcas didn’t listen to me. “Come with me.”
Michaela lived in a lovely colonial house. Her new husband made a handsome income. It still surprised me that such a plain girl could have gotten herself a man who was both handsome and well off. But she was a good soul, so I was happy for her. What I didn't like was the garden, it was choked by weeds and I know Michaela wouldn't have allowed that to happen. Dorcas knocked. It was few moments before someone came to the door.
“Who is it?” Michaela asked.
“It's me darling,” Dorcas said. “Your Mum.”
Michaela seemed to hesitate then she opened the door.
I screamed first then her mother after me or it may have been the other way round, I'm not quite sure. But I do know that when I saw Michaela's face I let out a sound I didn’t know I could make. I couldn't recognize her. And at that moment we knew that the fine looking man with a slow smile had a quick temper. He'd kept that temper well hidden. No one knew about it until that day.
Michaela looked around like a frightened mouse, pulled us inside and closed the door. “What do you want?”
“We wanted to see you.”
“What happened?” I demanded.
Michaela lowered her gaze. “I was clumsy.”
We knew that was a lie. She may look as dull as dishwater but she had the grace of a swan. “He did this to you?”
“He'll be home soon. You can’t be here. Go.”
“I can't leave you here.”
“It will only make him angry. Please Mummy.”
“No. Get your things.”
“I can't leave him. He loves me. I just made him angry.”
I stiffened with anger. “Your father never touched you and you let a man you lay with do this?”
Dorcas touched my sleeve to calm me. “You won't come with me?”
“No. It won't happen again.”
“He promised you that?”
She nodded. Michaela froze when she heard a car door close. “He's home early. Don't say anything. Please.”
I opened my mouth, but again Dorcas touched my sleeve, this time with more force. “We won't.” She went into the living room and sat down, as if nothing had happened. That was how Michaela's husband found us when he came in carrying two dozen red roses and a gold necklace. I smiled at him and had to admit that Aletta had been right. I didn't like his eyes either.
A year later Michaela gave her husband a son and four months after that he put her in the hospital with three fractured ribs, two black eyes and a broken nose. By that time it had become a family crisis. Dorcas' three daughters, Aletta and myself got together in the waiting room wondering what to do next.
“You see how he eats,” Dorcas said. “That could work in our favor.”
Aletta frowned. “How so?”
“A man like that can be poisoned.”
Deena shook her head. “She wouldn't have the nerve.”
“And it's against God,” Aletta added.
Dorcas raised her voice. “Don't talk to me about God, when a man like that can be deacon in a church and not be struck down by lightning the moment he enters.”
“There are other ways to get her away from him.”
“She's too afraid. He said he'd kill her.”
“She has to go to the police.”
“Someone has to convince her.”
“I will,” Deena said.
And to my surprise she was able to persuade Michaela to press charges.
I held Dorcas' hand throughout the trial and Hudson's acquittal. Yes, the judge let him go because of his slow smile and charming ways. He said that hitting a woman was common where he came from and that he didn’t know American ways and wouldn’t do it again. He told lies about Michaela and made his actions seem justifiable. He walked out. Dorcas didn’t move. But she began to smile.
“Yuh gone mad?” I asked her.
She only stood and turned to leave.
Michaela tried to get a divorce, but Hudson wouldn’t let her. He threatened to take full custody of their son.
Dorcas went through her savings, trying to help her daughter with her legal fees. But no matter how disappointing the defeat, Dorcas’ smile never left her.
“She has me worried,” I told Aletta one evening after Dorcas had left us. We'd just had tea together at Aletta's flat. We usually meet at my house, but for some reason my husband decided to catch a cold and stay home that week.
“It's that smile,” Aletta said.
“You noticed it too?”
Aletta set her tea cup down with a clatter. “How can you miss it?”
“If you didn't know her, she just looked calm and happy.”
“Yes, but we do know her,” she said, her tone grave.
“What could it mean?”
“I don't know.” Aletta sighed. “But she worried me with her talk about God.”
“She was just angry.”
Aletta shook her head. “And yet she smiles.”
I thought about that smile all night and I thought about it even more the next week when Hudson went missing.
Dorcas came to my house and the smile was gone, but her candyfloss voice was pleasant. “If anybody asks. I was not with you and Aletta last Thursday.”
I still remember the cool round feel of the marble as she placed it in my hand.
“Did you get it?” Aletta asked me that night, her voice tense.
“Yes. You?”
“You gone daft? Why would I be asking you if I hadn't?”
“We must do as she asked us,” I said.
“It’s not right. She was with us. Why should we lie?”
“We made a promise.”
“We were children,” Aletta countered.
“Doesn't matter.”
“She won’t change her mind. I’ve tried.”
“What if we don’t?”
“Do you want to risk it?”
I remembered Dorcas' words that we would die if we broke our promise. I didn't believe it, didn't want to, but an icy shiver of fear swept through me. “No.”
Aletta sighed. “I wonder why she's asking us to do this now.”
Two weeks later we found out. A body was found burned beyond recognition. Through dental records it was identified as Hudson. Dorcas confessed to the murder. She admitted to poisoning Hudson and then dumping his body and setting it alight. Naturally the police were skeptical. How could a woman of Dorcas' age and build have carried his body to a clearing and then torched it? However, no matter how long they questioned her, she didn't waver. The police were certain Michaela was somehow involved, but they could find no evidence to support their suspicions an
d she had a solid alibi--a broken wrist that Hudson had given her--that had sent her to the ER. Dorcas gave no other names and took full responsibility.
Michaela was just as distraught by her mother's confession, but there was an air of resignation when I visited her. Her plain little face was eerily composed. Her broken wrist in a sling. I helped care for her son and tidied up her place. When I glanced out the window I was surprised to see her garden was blooming. All the weeds were gone. I wondered how she had managed that after surviving such a severe beating.
Dorcas was indicted and later convicted. I remember the look between Deena and Dorcas and I thought of Michaela's garden and how the weeds were gone. I knew that Michaela couldn't have tended to the garden herself, and how as children Deena and Michaela had been so close, just as their mothers had been. Although they were not related by blood their souls, at times, seemed to be as one.
Although, I didn't want to, I imagined Deena being angered by Michaela's latest hospital visit and deciding to do something to stop him. I imagined her poisoning Hudson and then discarding the body somewhere. I imagined Deena telling her mother what had happened and Dorcas coming up with a plan. I imagined Dorcas burning his body. But of course, that's all just an old woman's conjecture. What could I know of such things? The truth could be vastly different.
The investigation is closed, but I know the truth: Dorcas was with us the night Hudson disappeared. But it's a secret I have to keep. I won't dare let it escape, even though I hate keeping it. Besides, it's not such a stretch to believe Dorcas' story. Everybody knows that Dorcas Mortag burns everything she touches.
The One Certainty
The One Certainty
About the story
Sylvia loved her cat Rossetti.
And Rossetti loved her.
But Sylvia’s friends said that wasn’t enough.
Until the day Rossetti proved them wrong.
A short story about betrayal and unconditional love.