“Yes,” she wailed, the sensation overpowering her.
His finger lifted and she sighed in relief, but she knew it wouldn’t be for long. They had told her what they would do. They had told her, and she knew that they would be doing that tonight. They would take her together, and she was scared. She closed her eyes, and remembered the night when Leif had pushed the glass plug into her ass, the foreign object sliding in and out that had finally made her feel so good, so decadent. Then the even better feel of his warm, plush and hard cock breaching the barrier of her muscles and entering her, the sting and pleasure so overwhelmingly wonderful.
“Are you scared because of what we’re doing now? Or, are you afraid of what we’re going to do, Bella?” It was Caleb’s soft, sweet molasses tone and it poured over her, calming and soothing. It made her think through all of her emotions, made her want, made her trust.
“I’m nervous, but I want both of you so much, you make me need.” She realized that was the truth, the heart of her being. She needed both men, she needed this closeness. She could no longer stand to just be Caleb and Bella, or Isabella and Leif. She needed to be all, she needed them to fuse.
“Please make us a complete union.” All four hands that had been caressing her stopped. She felt Leif. She knew his kiss, as it brushed against her lower back.
“Bella, when you do finally speak, your words are perfection. Thank you from the bottom of our hearts. This is the start of our life together, the union of our souls.” Then she felt all four hands begin to move again, touching her with love.
She felt her juices pulse.
Fingers gently parted her folds. She could feel warm breath, then the curl of a warmer tongue thrusting inside her. She shivered, and felt herself grow even wetter. “Yes, Isabella, give me more,” Leif’s tongue speared deeper, causing more cum to leak out of her pussy. She thrust against his mouth. As she did, she felt Caleb’s slick fingers circle the ring of her anus. She bit the side of her hand, but she couldn’t contain her hum of arousal.
“Bella likes all this attention, Leif.”
“Let’s give our girl more.”
She felt the lips of her pussy spread wider, and the circling fingers pressed against her hole, pushing for entrance. As one, she felt fingers inside of her, both of her orifices breached. She cried out as she pushed up and out, trying to get both to go deeper, she needed them deeper.
“That’s it. You’re such a good girl.”
“Jesus, look how pretty her ass is being stretched.”
“Think how good it’s going to look when your cock is fucking her ass, Caleb.” Isabella quaked and moaned.
“Leif—” Caleb started and then paused.
“She wants this, Caleb.” Isabella thought about Caleb’s thick penis and shuddered in anticipation. Leif was right. She wanted this. She wanted everything they had to give.
“Please, Caleb.” She felt him leave her, and then each man pierced her with more fingers. “God, yes,” she cried out her pleasure.
“What color are you?”
“Bright green. Please give me more. Please so much more. I need you both. I know what you want. I want it, too. I need you both in me.” Deep down she wasn’t really sure, but she was sure that they would keep her safe, that they would do nothing to truly hurt her. She knew that her care and safety would always be of utmost importance to these two men.
“I love you, please don’t deny me this.”
“Isabella!” Leif’s voice was sharp. “What color are you?” How did he know? Then she realized he knew her soul. She was quiet for a long time, as she luxuriated in the sensations that they were providing. Right now, it was all so good, in and out. She tingled and she wanted this to go on forever. Then she realized that something was missing. She needed that next level, she needed her clit to be touched, or Leif’s fingers to curl and touch that wondrous place inside of her. “You need more. You want to come, don’t you?”
“Yes, please let me come.”
“Then tell the truth, Bella.” Caleb’s voice was as hard as Leif’s.
“Yellow. I’m scared. But not really, I know I can trust you. I know that with everything in me. But it’s new. I’m scared because it’s new, but I’m not scared, because it’s you. Please, please, be inside me, please, now. Don’t make me wait.” Isabella felt the first tear fall. The waiting was too much. Caleb left her, and Leif’s arms surrounded her.
“I’m so proud of you, Isabella. Thank you for telling me the truth.” Leif rolled them to the side so they could face one another, and she was soon lost in their kiss. Then she felt Caleb’s hands and lips on her neck and back, brushing and stroking her.
She looked down, and saw that Leif was wearing a condom. She ran her hands over his chest, and breathed in his scent at the side of his neck, anchoring herself in all aspects of the man. He seemed to understand, and breathed words of love into her ear, just another gift. Then she felt Caleb lift one of her legs over Leif, so that she was straddling him. It felt so good to have her core next to his shaft. She stroked herself up and down against him, loving his hot, firm length. His words changed.
“Jesus, Isabella, you’re fucking killing me. I can feel how wet you are. You’re dripping, all that hot cum for me.” Leif spread his legs, so that her buttocks split wide.
“Christ, Bella, you have the prettiest asshole I’ve ever seen. Right now it’s shiny and stretching open just the tiniest little bit to welcome me.” As he said those words, Leif positioned his penis and started the stinging slide into her vagina.
* * * *
Caleb watched as Leif’s cock shoved its way into Bella’s beautiful pink cunt. He could see how she seemed to push down and pull up. God, she was so delicate, but so strong in the way she made love. The woman they loved had a core of steel. He needed to remember that. He worried. He knew that he was thicker than Leif, but he couldn’t deny himself the pleasure of her ass. He had made sure she was stretched and he had seen how she responded whenever she was penetrated. Her whimpers of pleasure were unmistakable. Leif had informed him of her intense response, so despite his trepidation, he knew that Bella’s expression of desire was sincere.
Still, Caleb waited. His partner was good. Leif brought Bella to an almost mindless place of pleasure and then he stopped.
“No…” she wailed.
“Easy, Isabella. Easy. There’s more. Don’t you want more?” There was a long pause, as she slumped against Leif’s chest.
“God, yes, more. I want Caleb. Please, Caleb. I need you.” He smiled. That was his girl. He could see even more of her cream dripping down from her cunt. She was obviously so aroused at the thought of them both taking her, that it made him even harder. He spread more lube on his condom-covered cock, ensuring that whatever pain she felt would only result in memorable pleasure. He looked over her head, into Leif’s eyes. Leif nodded. He pulled Isabella even closer to his chest, pushing her lower back deeper into his stomach, so that her ass was arched up higher.
“Bella, you’re beautiful. Are you ready?”
“I’m so ready, Caleb. I’ve never been more ready for anything.” Caleb watched as his friend pushed down into the mattress, pulling out slightly from Isabella’s body, causing her to mew in protest.
“Isabella, I’m right here. Just let us take care of things for a bit, okay?” Leif stroked his hands down her back and it seemed to calm her. Caleb looked down at the star of her anus, and spread the cheeks of her ass even more, watching as the skin thinned and pulled tauter, spreading her open. He positioned the head of his cock to her lubricated opening, and began to press with a steady pressure.
“Oh God, Oh God, Madre de Dios.”
“What color, baby?”
“Not red.”
Caleb stopped.
“Don’t stop! Oh God, don’t stop. I need more. It hurts. It feels good. It hurts good. I don’t know, but don’t stop.” The last came out as a wail, and Caleb understood because she was hurting him. She was gripping him so ti
ght it hurt, but it hurt good, and he had to keep moving.
“Good girl.”
“Good, Bella.” The words were said at the same time.
Caleb kept pressing until he was embedded inside her, and she moaned in relief.
“Yes, oh yes. Thank you, Caleb. Now you, Leif, please fill me. I need you both to fill me at the same time.”
“No, Isabella, it will be too much.”
“No! You listen to me. I say now!” Caleb barked with laughter at both her tone of voice and the look of shock on Leif’s face. Then she moved her arm, wrapping it partway around Caleb’s back, shoved down on Leif’s cock, and cried out in pained pleasure.
“Goddamn it.” Once again both men yelled out simultaneously.
Caleb stayed perfectly still, not wanting to do anything that might hurt her further. Leif did the same thing.
“Bella? Talk to me, Bella.” Caleb reached around and found her swollen clit, and she made the slightest move. Leif lifted up and took the tip of one breast in his mouth, and the other in his hand, and she made another slight move.
Caleb had never felt anything that could compare to this moment, either emotionally or physically. He knew when this was over, after they were done taking care of this incredible woman and they slept, that she would be in so much trouble for having put herself at risk by pushing them. Then all thoughts flew out of his head, as he felt the slippery bud of her sex swell and she started to moan.
“Leif! Caleb! Help me.” Her hair lashed all around and then Leif grabbed her head.
“We’ve got you, baby.”
“This is glorious.” It came out as a long cry. All Caleb could think of for that moment was that he was grateful. He felt the warm, tight clasp of her muscle milking him, and the silky depths of her body welcoming him. Then, unbelievably, he felt the thrust of Leif pushing against him through the thin barrier of Bella’s body, causing another riot of sensation that was going to make his head explode.
Right before he closed his eyes, he looked down and caught Leif’s glittering eyes that were filled with the same out-of-control knowledge and passion. They had found their nirvana, and it was buried inside the woman they loved.
Caleb concentrated on not coming, but pushing Bella over the edge. He knew her body, knew that in this one area of her life, she could be greedy, and he intended to make sure she drowned in pleasure. Her clit was so slick it was difficult to grasp it, so instead he circled and pressed, until he felt her begin to tremble. He opened his eyes just a little and saw that Leif was kissing Bella, and that was the reason for her silence. They kept up their rhythm as Caleb continued stroking her clit, until her body bucked.
“Yes.” It came out as a long hiss, and he couldn’t help but laugh. Then he felt Leif begin to change his caresses inside her cunt, so he stopped moving, knowing that Leif intended to plunder until he found just the right spot inside her, and send her over the edge again. Again and again, stroke after stroke, Leif took Bella up higher, and Caleb realized Leif was taking him up higher, too, as sweat broke out over his entire body. He wasn’t going to last much longer.
“Stop, I can’t take any more.” Her words were a raspy sigh.
“Are you using your safe word, Isabella?” Caleb was getting ready, too, and then she screamed out her release. Before she could slump down on Leif’s chest, Caleb lifted her up so that one arm was banded just below her breasts, plumping them up for Leif, and the fingers of his other hand were still there to move through her juicy folds.
“So good.” She just kept repeating those two words, and Caleb was determined to make it even more so. He watched as Leif took one of her succulent nipples into his mouth, rejoicing as she cried out. Then Caleb squeezed the plump knot of nerves as he pushed deeper, and “so good” turned into just one word, “good.” She said it over and over again. Then her ass clamped down on his cock, so tight he careened off into space, and he was yelling.
“Good! So good, Bella.”
“Perfect, baby, you’re perfect.”
Their words and limbs tangled as they all sank sideways onto the bed. Caleb wasn’t sure, but he thought he might have died.
It took him three long deep breaths before he could think again. He stroked back Isabella’s hair, loving the riot of brown and black curls that seemed to wrap their way around him and Leif. As he kissed her warm temple he traded a glance with his brother who gave him a quick nod. Caleb smoothed both of his hands down the supple lines of Isabella’s waist and clasped her hips.
“Steady, Bella.” He slowly withdrew, missing the heat of her body, before he had even left her. He waited until Leif had her securely wrapped in his arms, before he left for the bathroom. When he returned, she was almost asleep as Leif raised her supple body toward him. He lifted her and was almost at the bathroom before she roused.
“Caleb?”
“Right here, baby.”
“S’good. Missed you.” She snuggled closer to his chest. He could feel she was already getting chilled so he was glad that he had made the bathwater as warm as he had. There were candles glowing, and they made Bella smile. He’d known they would. He heard Leif come in as he lowered her into the bubbling tub.
“I could have walked.” Caleb saw the frown overtake her face and that made him smile. He wondered if she was ever going to get used to being cared for. Before one tendril of her hair could touch the water, Leif scooped it up in his hands, and put one of her hair ties in place so that it was all mounded on top of her head.
“I know you could have, Isabella. We like taking care of you.” Caleb and Leif climbed into the over-large Jacuzzi tub they had installed when they bought the house. They sat side by side, arranging Bella across them, spending gloriously long minutes stroking and caressing this gentle spirit with a core of steel.
“I still wish I had told you together,” she said in a soft voice. And wasn’t that just her?
“Do you know what makes me happy?” Caleb asked, and then brushed his lips against her moist brow. “It makes me happy that you’re so spontaneous. That you love us and it comes pouring out.” Caleb felt her fingers trace across his arm and then watched her smooth them over Leif’s chest. The three of them connected. “But do you know what I loved the best, Bella?” She looked up at him. “I love that you busted Dane’s balls.” She let out a giggle that mingled with his and Leif’s chuckles, ending the night with love and laughter.
Epilogue
“I can’t believe you’re not engaged yet,” Conn said, shaking his head sadly. Leif looked at his Pops and felt a surge of frustration, which he worked to tamp down. He looked over at Caleb, who gave a small shake of his head.
“What are you talking about, Conn? I can’t believe these two aren’t married already,” Clint Samuels, Caleb’s dad, said. Leif watched as Caleb struggled against his own annoyance. God, their fathers were like gossipy little old church ladies. They just didn’t understand Isabella, but he and Caleb did.
She loved them, there was really no doubt about that, and hadn’t been since she had agreed to live with them. Leif looked over at Isabella as she stood with his mom and Caleb’s mother, along with many of the other women of Fate Harbor. They were busy setting up the food table for the grand opening of Restoring Fate. Leif didn’t know why they were bothering to have the grand opening, since they had already been doing business for two months. In fact, Restoring Fate was currently booked solid for the next three months and they were already recruiting for another restoration specialist. But, today was the grand opening, so there was food, there was a party, and there were two rings.
Isabella had been seeing Dr. Anderson regularly for the last few months and she had actually gotten worse before finally getting better. Isabella had been so sure she was damaged goods unworthy of their love, that there had been two weeks when they feared they might actually have to tie her to the bed to make sure she didn’t leave. After that small crisis, she was finally able to cry for the loss of her parents. She got out old photo albums
and told him and Caleb wonderful stories about her childhood for the first time.
Gazing at the beautiful woman standing under the white awning, he reflected again on how blessed he and Caleb were to have found her. Thank God Olivia had needed bodyguards and Special Forces protection at the Cesar Chavez School those many months ago. It was good to see Isabella having so much fun with the ladies, seeing her laugh with Olivia and his sister Kara.
Yep, now their woman was at a point that she would say yes to marriage. He and Caleb had even ironed out who would be her official husband with a game of rock, paper, scissors. Today was going to be a good day.
THE END
WWW.CAITLYNOLEARY.COM
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Caitlyn O’Leary was raised in a small town in the Pacific Northwest. She has been an avid reader. Her earliest creative writing endeavors consisted of “ghost writing” exercises in which she pretended to be her younger brothers and sisters when she did their homework assignments before they turned them in as their own.
Years in corporate America honed her ability to manipulate words by day, and at night she read everything she could get her hands on, including many, many steamy romances!
Now happily married to her long, tall Texan and living in Southern California, Caitlyn has finally found the time to write erotic happily ever afters for Siren. She enjoys swimming, traveling, babysitting her nieces and nephews, spending time with friends and family, and doing lots of “research” for upcoming novels with her husband.
Website: Caitlynoleary.com
E-Mail: [email protected]
Twitter: CaitlynOlearyNA
Facebook: Facebook.com/Caitlyn.Oleary.35
Isabella's Submission [Fate Harbor 4] (Siren Publishing Ménage Amour) Page 27