by Ken McClure
Almost as soon as he had parked the car and started to walk towards the prison his sub conscious started searching for excuses not to proceed. Prisons had that affect on him. They were more than just grey, forbidding buildings; they were monuments to human failure, housing a hellish mix of wasted lives and broken dreams, often spiced with evil and violence. They were Pandora’s boxes with the lids wide open.
He glanced at his watch. So far, it had taken him fourteen minutes to reach the office of an assistant governor. His path had been impeded by bureaucracy at every step of the way. The natural response of officialdom to any out of the ordinary request was to set up a wall of obstruction. His ID card had been passed around like a parcel at a party. He had been told by one man that he would have to go through official channels and apply in writing and by another that his request was simply not possible… ‘Because it wasn’t, that’s why.’ It was only his insistence that a phone call to the Home Office be made that eventually paid off and he found himself in the office of Assistant Governor, John Cummings, an angry-looking man with short red hair and a clipped moustache. He had the florid complexion of a heavy drinker but the build of a gym teacher although perhaps a little on the short side.
‘ Little doesn’t see visitors,’ said Cummings.
‘ Has anyone ever asked to see him?’ asked Steven.
‘ That’s beside the point,’ insisted Cummings. ‘He has his books and that’s all he needs. He doesn’t speak to anyone he doesn’t have to. ‘He reads and makes notes. That’s it. He’s shut himself off in his own little world.’
‘ What kind of stuff does he read?’
‘ Journals mainly, scientific journals.’
‘ I’d still like to see him,’ said Steven.
Cummings shrugged and said sourly, ‘And you have friends in high places, right?’
‘ Not friends,’ said Steven acidly. ‘Employers; I believe they just might be yours too if I’m not mistaken.’
Cummings thought for a moment before conceding. ‘Well, don’t blame me if it’s a waste of time and he refuses to say anything. You can take a horse to water etc.’ He picked up the phone and gave instructions that David Little be brought to an interview room. He and Steven sat in silence until the phone rang to confirm that this had been done. A prison officer with a badly repaired harelip and impaired speech because of it was detailed to escort Steven to the meeting with Little. He didn’t say anything en route but Steven was aware of several prisoners along the way affecting a speech impediment as they passed. Most of them did it almost out of earshot but one did it too close for the officer to pretend that he’d not heard.
‘ You’ll be sorry, Edwards,’ the officer spat out the corner of his mouth.
He said it with such venom that Steven had little doubt that the man would, but then he didn’t doubt that life in Scotland’s toughest jail would be anything other than a constant battle of wills with an undercurrent of threatened violence.
The room allocated for his meeting with Little seemed little different from a cell. It had four bare walls and a high, barred window affording glimpses of passing clouds. Perhaps the rough table and two plastic chairs altered its status, he surmised. ‘I want to speak to him alone,’ he said to the accompanying officer. The man opened his mouth as if to protest but changed his mind and said, ‘I’ll be right outside.’
Steven was shocked at David Little’s appearance when he was finally brought in. He had only seen a photograph of him, taken at the time of his arrest but all trace of youth had now disappeared from the man standing in front of him. His head was shaven, his cheeks were sunken and his eyes had retreated into large dark hollows. He was painfully thin. The officer escorting him undid his handcuffs and Steven asked the man to wait outside. He indicated to Little that he should sit opposite him at the table.
‘ My name’s Dunbar,’ said Steven, showing his ID card. ‘I work for the Sci-Med Inspectorate. I’m looking into certain aspects of the Julie Summers case.’
Little looked Steven in the eye but didn’t say anything. Steven thought it was a classic ‘You-didn’t-ask-a-question-so-I’m-not-replying’ response.
‘ I’d appreciate if you would answer some questions,’ said Steven.
Little got out of his chair as if to indicate that the interview was at an end.
‘ Sit down,’ snapped Steven.
Little sat down and resumed his stare.
Steven found it unnerving. It wasn’t dumb insolence; it was something more detached. It was the look of a man who had given up on life, someone who was no longer a participant but merely a disinterested spectator.
‘ I won’t bullshit you,’ said Steven. ‘I don’t feel any sympathy for you. What you did to that young girl was beyond the pale. But why you did it is another matter and I’m willing to concede that there are all sorts of mental aberrations that medicine knows very little about. Maybe you’re sick. Maybe you couldn’t help yourself. But whatever the reason, you can help lessen the aftermath of what happened by answering my questions.’
Little made no response. He simply maintained his stare.
‘ I’ll be straight with you,’ said Steven. ‘I’m here because a man in the State Hospital at Carstairs, a convicted killer named Hector Combe, confessed on his deathbed to the rape and murder of Julie Summers.’
Although Little didn’t say anything Steven saw a change of expression in his eyes. It was only there for a moment but he was almost certain that he saw the veil lift to be replaced by… what? He found that harder to interpret. Sadness was the best that he could come up with but he suspected it was far deeper than that. It was as if, in an instant, Little had caught a glimpse of what his life might have been like had things been different. ‘Did you ever meet Hector Combe?’ Steven asked.
Little shook his head slowly.
‘ You’re absolutely sure?’
A nod of the head.
‘ Julie scratched you on the arm,’ said Steven. ‘Tell me about it.’
Little behaved as if he hadn’t heard. His gaze moved off to the middle distance.
‘ Did you hear what I said?’ prompted Steven.
Little remained silent.
‘ Come on man,’ urged Steven. ‘You’ve got nothing to lose by telling me now.’
‘ I can’t help you,’ said Little, speaking for the first time and taking Steven by surprise. The voice was calm and cultured.
‘ Why?’ demanded Steven. ‘What’s the big silence all about? Does shutting yourself off make the guilt easier to bear? If you maintain you’re innocent you don’t ever have to face up to the guilt? Is that it? If you don’t say the words it can’t be true? Christ man, you’ve got a lot of years ahead of you to keep that up.’
Little seemed unimpressed. He looked down at Steven’s ID card lying on the table. ‘You’re a doctor,’ he said.
Steven nodded.
Little leaned forward and planted the index finger of his right hand on his right cheek and held it there. ‘What do you think this is?’ he asked.
Steven took a closer look and saw there was a small purple lesion there.
‘ And here,’ said Little, moving his finger to the side of his neck.
Steven saw another purple mark. His blood ran cold as he recognised what the lesions were. ‘Good God,’ he murmured. ‘Kaposi’s sarcoma.’
‘ Well done,’ said Little, without emotion.
‘ Are you telling me you’ve got AIDS?’ asked Steven.
‘ I think we can both agree on that,’ said Little.
‘ But… how?’ asked Steven.
Little let a long silence elapse before he said, ‘When I first came here some of my fellow prisoners — fine upstanding chaps that they are — felt I should be taught a lesson. They decided that I should know what it felt like to be raped — just like my “victim”. At least, I think that was the rationale behind it.’
‘ My God,’ whispered Steven. ‘And you finished up with AIDS.’
Little’s
silence was more eloquent than any reply. Eventually he said, ‘So you see, I won’t have all the years you imagine.’
‘ But you must be getting treatment,’ said Steven, although it was more of a question. The look on Little’s face made his blood go even colder. ‘The authorities don’t know?’ he asked almost incredulously. ‘You haven’t told anyone?’
‘ No point,’ said Little. ‘And they haven’t noticed although they probably will when the next little pathological ‘treat’ for me arrives. What d’you reckon? Pneumocystis pneumonia? Tuberculosis? Some creeping fungal infection? Maybe a brain tumour?’
Like Little, Steven knew there was no way of predicting what a person with AIDS would fall prey to next once their immune system had packed in and left them open to the myriad invading forces of the microbial world. ‘But surely the prison doctor noticed these marks on you?’ he said.
‘ He might spot a broken leg on a good day,’ said Little.
‘ But my God man, there’s a lot they can do to help these days. You should be on combination therapy,’ said Steven.
The look on Little’s face made Steven suddenly realise that he was overlooking the now obvious fact that Little didn’t have much interest in slowing down the condition that was going to kill him.
Little read Steven’s mind and said quietly, ‘I’ve really nothing left to lose. My job, my wife, my children, my freedom, my self-respect — all long gone. Ironic really but AIDS is going to be my saviour, my get-out-of-jail card. No more hell on earth, just sweet, beautiful, endless sleep.’
‘ I don’t know what to say,’ said Steven.
‘ Just as long as you don’t start suggesting it’s God’s way of punishing me,’ said Little.
‘ No,’ replied Steven. ‘I won’t do that but I’d still like you to answer my questions if it’s all the same to you.’
‘ I can’t.’
‘ Why not?’
‘ Because I had nothing to do with Julie Summers’ murder.’
Steven shook his head in exasperation but he still felt disconcerted when he saw that the man clearly believed what he was saying. ‘For God’s sake man,’ he protested, ‘the prosecution came up with a perfect DNA match for you.’
‘ So they did,’ said Little sarcastically.
‘ So what are you suggesting? That they made the whole lot up?’
Little’s slight shrug seemed to suggest an affirmative.
‘ How? Why?’
Little shrugged again.
‘ I’m sorry, I don’t believe you,’ said Steven.
Little did not show any reaction. He said simply, ‘Neither did my wife, the police, the prosecuting counsel, the judge and the jury,’ replied Little. ‘It really doesn’t matter any more. It’ll soon be over.’
Steven felt uneasy. Although he felt that continuing denial must be Little’s way of dealing with the burden of guilt, the fact that the evidence against him — however good — had come from Lee’s lab was still a worry. He got up from the table and Little did the same.
The Prison officers came back into the room on hearing the sound of the chairs moving back and Steven watched as Little was led away.
As he left the room, Little turned and said, ‘I really didn’t kill her.’
‘ Like fuck you didn’t,’ growled the officer escorting him.
‘ Some of them are like that,’ said the man with the harelip. ‘They go to their grave insisting they were innocent.’
‘ If I want Mickey Mouse psychiatry, I’ll let you know,’ snapped Steven, almost immediately regretting it. He was on edge.
‘ Get what you wanted?’ asked Cummings.
‘ Not exactly. Did you know David Little has full-blown AIDS?’ replied Steven.
‘ Christ, you’re kidding!’ exclaimed Cummings.
Steven’s accusing look removed any doubt.
‘ Jesus Christ, that’s all I need,’ complained Cummings as he picked up the phone and punched in four numbers. ‘Is the Doctor still there? Gone? Shit.’ Cummings slammed down the receiver and looked at Steven. ‘You’re sure about this?’ he asked.
‘ He’s got Kaposi’s sarcoma on his face and neck. It’s usually a sure sign.’
‘ How on earth would he get…?’
‘ Male rape,’ interrupted Steven.
‘ Christ,’ murmured Cummings. After a moment he thought he saw an objection and said, ‘But he’s been on rule 43 for years.’
‘ AIDS can take several years to develop,’ said Steven.
‘ Of course,’ conceded Cummings. ‘I wasn’t thinking straight. Look, I’ll get on to the doctor at home and tell him to get his bloody finger out and organise some treatment for Little. Best I can do.’
‘ He may refuse. He wants to die.’
‘ I’ll have to see what the rule book says.’
‘ I want to take a buccal swab from Little,’ said Steven.
Cummings seemed shocked. ‘What for?’
‘ I want to check his DNA profile.’
Cummings stared at him as if he couldn’t believe his ears then he said, ‘That’s all we need, a rumour starting that Little is innocent. You do know what you’re doing?’ he asked.
Steven remained impassive.
Cummings made a steeple with his hands and covered his mouth and nose for a few moments before seeming to conclude that any argument would be pointless. He simple asked, ‘What do you need?’
‘ Just a cotton swab and a sterile tube.’
Harelip was detailed to take Steven first to the sickbay to pick up supplies and then to David Little’s cell.
‘ I thought we’d said our good byes,’ said Little who was sitting reading a copy of the science magazine, Nature.
‘ I’d like to take a buccal smear from you,’ said Steven.
‘ What for?’
‘ DNA fingerprinting.’
‘ Is this some kind of sick joke?’
‘ I want to compare it with samples taken at the crime scene of Julie Summers’ murder. A second opinion if you like. Something your lawyer should have done.’
‘ He believed I was guilty from the outset. That was obvious.’
‘ So what was your defence?’ asked Steven.
‘ My lawyer said he was willing to enter a plea of insanity but that there was no point in arguing about technicalities: the evidence against me was so overwhelming.’
‘ Who was your lawyer?’
‘ Paul Verdi of Seymour, Nicholson and Verdi.’
‘ What did you say to that?’
‘ I said it was all some awful mistake. There must have been some mix-up in the lab but no one would listen, not even Charlotte. I’ll never forget the look on her face when…’
‘ About that swab?’ said Steven, wanting the conversation to end.
‘ There’s no point,’ said Little.
Steven looked at him. ‘Scared of what I’ll come up with?’ he asked. ‘Think you might have to face up to your guilt after all?’
Little didn’t reply. Instead he opened his mouth and allowed Steven to rub the cotton-tipped swab around the inside of his right cheek.
‘ Tell me one thing,’ said Steven as he carefully placed the swab inside a sterile tube, making sure that the tip did not touch anything else. ‘How did you get the scratch you had on your arm when you were arrested?’
‘ Our cat, Romeo, did it.’
TEN
Ronald Lee’s murder made it into all the papers next morning. The story was generally presented as a highland tragedy, a mindless killing followed by the death of the victim’s wife, suggesting a devoted couple who clearly couldn’t live without each other. Two of the nationals however did note that Lee had been the forensic pathologist involved in the murder investigation of Julie Summers. One of them also recalled that he had taken early retirement in the aftermath of the case.
‘ Lothian and Borders Police have been on to the Home Office again,’ said John Macmillan when Steven called Sci-Med. ‘Suffice to say they’re
hopping mad about your latest exploit.’
‘ And what would that be?’ asked Steven.
‘ They say you’ve visited David Little in prison and taken a sample from him for DNA analysis. They’re complaining that you’re giving everyone the impression that there was something wrong with the original one.’
‘ Well, that certainly got around fast,’ said Steven. ‘That’s actually why I’m calling. I do want the DNA fingerprinting done again if only for my own peace of mind. I’d also like it to be done locally rather than send the samples to London so I need a name, someone independent of the police and forensic services up here.’
‘ You don’t really think that Little could be innocent, do you?’ said Macmillan.
‘ I don’t know what to think right now,’ said Steven.
‘ But the DNA evidence against him was…’
‘ Overwhelming, yes, I know,’ interrupted Steven. ‘But all the same, I just know there’s something badly wrong with the Summers case. I keep looking for reassurance but so far I haven’t found any. There are just too many question marks.’
‘ All right,’ sighed Macmillan. ‘We’ll make arrangements for the sequencing and get back to you. Anything else?’
‘ I’d like to know the current whereabouts of a man named John Merton who was on the staff of the forensic lab at the time of the murder. He left when Ronald Lee was put out to grass and worked in the medical school for a while but then he moved on.’
‘ We’ll do our best,’ said Macmillan.
Next Steven called McDougal the current head of forensics in Edinburgh to ask if he had any objection to giving him access to the semen samples recovered from Julie Summers.
‘ I personally don’t have any objection,’ said McDougal although he sounded puzzled. ‘Is there a problem?’
‘ I hope not,’ said Steven.
‘ I dare say you won’t be alone in these sentiments,’ said McDougal. ‘I read about the deaths of Ronald Lee and his wife in the papers this morning. I even had a journalist phoning me to ask if I had anything to say on the matter.’