The Argumentative Indian

Home > Other > The Argumentative Indian > Page 45
The Argumentative Indian Page 45

by Amartya Sen


  9. Fraser, Iron and Steel in India, p. 1.

  10. Perin wrote that when Jamsetji came to interview him, this ‘stranger in a strange garb’ asked: ‘Will you come to India with me?’ ‘ “Well,” I said, “yes, I’d go.” And I did’ (quoted in Lala, The Creation of Wealth, p. 20).

  11. There is, furthermore, a significant distinction between import substitution and endogenous domestic expansion. In a joint paper with K. N. Raj, ‘Alternative Patterns of Growth under Conditions of Stagnant Export Earnings’ (Oxford Economic Papers, 13, 1961), I was concerned with the latter, whereas it has sometimes been interpreted, quite mistakenly, as a defence of import substitution against export promotion – an issue that was not even addressed in the paper. The so-called Raj–Sen model considered neither import substitution nor export promotion, and concentrated instead on alternative patterns of endogenous development, focusing in particular on issues of growth theory and the implications of stock-flow relationships.

  12. Harris, Jamsetji Nusserwanji Tata, p. 118.

  13. From a letter to C. F. Andrews, dated 13 March 1921, published in Rabindranath Tagore, Letters to a Friend, with essays by C. F. Andrews (London: Allen & Unwin, 1928).

  14. See Michael Sandel, Liberalism and the Limits of Justice (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2nd edn., 1998), pp. 150–52.

  15. Rabindranath Tagore, The Religion of Man (London: Unwin, 1931; 2nd edn., 1961), p. 105.

  16. This is how the issue was presented by its distinguished chairman, Lord Parekh, in ‘A Britain We All Belong To’, Guardian, 11 Oct. 2000. See, however, the much richer analysis of social identity presented by Bhikhu Parekh himself in Re-thinking Multi-culturalism: Cultural Diversity and Political Theory (Basingstoke: Palgrave, 2000).

  Index of Names

  Abul Fazl 25, 75, 288–9, 320, 331, 360n, 368n,387n

  Ade Ajaayyi, J. F. 387n

  Agarwal, Bina 220f, 235, 363n, 383n

  Agnihotri, Satish Balram 220f, 383n

  Ahluwalia, Isher Judge 380n

  Ahluwalia, Montek Singh xvi

  Ahmad, Aijaz 367n

  Ahmed, Qazi Hussain 258

  Akbar, Emperor xiii, 16, 17–19, 25, 32, 39–42, 47, 59–60, 75–6, 81, 90, 134, 136, 287–93, 313, 314, 318–19, 320 picture, 328, 330–32, 359n, 360n, 368n, 375n, 386n, 387n, 390n

  Akbar, Prince, Aurangzeb’s rebellious son 61

  Alberuni 29–30, 39, 58, 78–9, 84, 144–5, 148–9, 157, 172–3, 292, 314, 314f, 315, 361n, 365n, 369n, 373n, 374n, 376n, 378n, 388n, 389n

  Alexander the Great 14, 15, 15f, 39

  Ali, Hakim 291

  Ali, M. Athar 368n, 387n

  Allchin, Bridget 367n

  Allchin, Raymond 367n

  al-Sabhadi 160

  Ambedkar B. R. 36, 80–81, 305, 309, 362–3n

  Anand, Sudhir xvi

  Anderson, Benedict 131

  Andrews, C. F. 86, 92, 106, 349, 367n, 391n

  Apollonius of Tyana 39, 151, 154–5, 328

  Appadurai, Arjun 362n

  Appiah, Anthony 369n

  Aristotle 136, 284–5

  Arnett, Eric 265, 385n

  Arrian 15, 15f, 151

  Arrow, Kenneth 382n

  Āryabhaṭa 28–30, 78–9, 148–9, 158, 178, 179, 323, 374n

  Ashoka, Emperor xii-xiii, xix, 15–16, 17–18, 21, 40, 46–7, 75, 81, 82–3, 136, 182–3, 284–5, 286, 288, 289, 308, 313–14, 328, 359n, 360n, 369n

  Aston, W. G. 369n

  Attenborough, Richard 92

  Augustine, St 36, 284–5

  Aurangzeb, Emperor 60–61, 61f, 134, 314

  Austin, Granville 194f

  Azad, Maulana Abdul Kalam 307, 389n

  Bacon, Francis 27–8, 361n

  Bagchi, Prabodh C. 377n, 378n, 379n

  Bailly, Jean-Sylvain 324

  Baird, Robert 388n, 389n

  Balfour, Lady Betty 390n

  Bānạ 167

  Bardhan, Pranab xvi, 383n

  Barker, D. J. P. 247–8, 384n

  Bary, Wm. Theodore de 183–4, 378n, 379n

  Basu, Alaka M. 383n

  Basu, Kaushik xvi, 294f, 365n, 376n, 380n

  Baxi, Upendra 365n

  Bayly, C. A. 32f, 368n

  Beal, Samuel 377n

  Bechert, H. 354f

  Behrman, J. R. 384n

  Berlin, Irving 130

  Berlin, Isaiah 105, 135, 371n, 373n

  Bernstein, Richard 377n

  Béteille, André 362n, 380n

  Bhabha, Homi xvi, 372n

  Bhandare, Sunanda 220f

  Bhāravi 9

  Bhargava, Rajeev 359n, 365n, 375n, 376n

  Bhāskar 28

  Bhattacharji, Sukumari xvi, 23f, 360n, 361n

  Bhattacharya, Dipak 23f, 361n

  Bhattacharya, Sabyasachi 294f, 390n

  Bidwai, Praful 255, 385n

  Bilgrami, Akeel xvi, 89f, 139f, 294f, 297f, 369n, 375n

  Blackburn, Bonnie 390n

  Bloom, Irene 378n, 379n

  Bok, Sissela 89f, 273f

  Bose, Abala 108

  Bose, Jagadish Chandra 108

  Bose, Nandalal 130

  Bose, Rashbehari 110

  Bose, Subhas Chandra 7f, 110, 111, 371, 378

  Bose, Sugata xvi, 89f, 139f, 161f, 294f, 353f, 365n, 373n,376n, 389n

  Bose, Supratik 89f

  Bouquet, A. C. 22, 360n

  Brahmagupta 26, 28–30, 67, 79, 144, 148–9, 178, 179, 292, 323, 374n

  Brannen, J. 384n

  Brecht, Bertolt 109

  Brennand, W. 390n

  Brown, Judith M. 194f

  Brown, Murray 383n

  Bruno, Giordano 76, 287

  Buah, F. K. 387n

  Buchanan, James M. 14, 359n

  Buddha, Gautama 15, 23, 23f, 27, 75, 167, 170–74, 180, 286, 378n

  Bukharin, Nikolai 275–6, 291

  Bunin, Ivan 112

  Caldwell, J. C. 384n

  Cārvāka 23, 24, 24f, 25, 26, 75, 159, 288–9, 308, 331, 355, 361n

  Chaitanya 287

  Chandoke, Neera 365n

  Chandra, Bipan 364n

  Chandra, Lokesh 377n

  Chatterjee, Partha 80, 123, 131, 156, 369n, 372n, 376n

  Chatterji, Nimai xvi

  Chattopadhyaya, Debiprasad 360n, 361n

  Chengzu, the Yongluo Emperor 180

  Chirol, Sir Valentine 96

  Churchill, Winston S. 39, 261, 261f, 327, 328

  Clinton, President Bill 265, 267

  Clive, John 368n

  Clive, Lord 42

  Coale, Ansley 226, 382n

  Cohen, Joshua 108f

  Coleridge, Samuel Taylor 152

  Confucius 136, 286

  Corbridge, Stuart 381n

  Cornford, Frances 94

  Cowell, E. B. 361n

  Croce, Benedetto 112

  Curzon, Lord 338

  Dadu 11, 19, 45, 136, 316

  Dalrymple, William 368n

  Dara Shikoh xi, 61, 61f, 375n

  Das, Gurcharan 380n

  Das, Veena 365n, 389n

  Das Gupta, Monica 383n

  Datta, Deependranath xvi

  Datta, Supurna v, xvi

  Davidson, Basil 387n

  Davis, William 375n

  De, Barun 139f, 364f

  Deaton, Angus 380n

  Desai, Meghnad xvi

  Devi, Mahasweta 358n

  Devji, Faisal 389n

  Dev Sen, Antara xvi

  Dev Sen, Nabaneeta xvi, 95f

  Dhrombres, Jean 379n

  Diodorus 151

  Dirks, Nicholas 362n

  Drew, John 375n

  Drèze, Jean xvi, 35, 37f, 38f, 42f, 83f, 139f, 188f, 198f, 201f, 212, 213, 213f, 214, 220f, 225f, 243–4, 245, 251f, 277f, 363n, 372n, 375n, 380n, 381n, 382n, 384n

  Dugger, Celia 239f

  Dumont, Louis 34, 362n

  Dutta, Krishna xvi, 89f, 113f, 370n, 371n

  Dyson, Ketaki Kushari 371n

  Dyson, Tim 383n

 
; Einstein, Albert 104, 371n

  Eliot, T. S. 4, 357n

  Elmhirt, Leonard 93, 102–3

  Embree, A. T. 361n, 365n, 369n, 373n, 378n, 388n, 389n

  Engineer, Asghar Ali 388–9n

  Epstein, Barbara 89f, 385n

  Eves, Howard 379n

  Farmer, Steve 68

  Faxian (Fa-Hsien) 82, 145, 164, 168–9, 172, 173, 184, 377n, 378n

  Ferber, Marianne A. 236f, 384n

  Fernandes, George 258, 265, 385n

  Fitch, Ralph 363n

  Folbre, Nancy 236f, 384n

  Fordyce, James 233

  Formichi, Carlo 111

  Forster, E. M. 41, 95, 96, 154, 330, 363n, 390n

  Foster, William 363n

  Fraser, Antonia 8, 358n

  Fraser, Lovat 339–40, 390n, 411n

  Fraser, Nancy 362n

  Frazier, Mark W. 266, 386n

  Freed, Fred 357n

  Freeman, Samuel 280f

  Fu-yi 189

  Gandhi, Indira 117, 194f, 209, 253–4, 358n, 365n

  Gandhi, Mohandas 7f, 32, 51, 64, 91–3, 99–107, 109, 114, 117, 150, 252, 286, 288, 352n, 365n, 370n, 371n, 374n

  Gandhi, Rajiv 305

  Gandhi, Sonia 7f

  Ganeri, Jonardan 357n

  Gates, Henry Louis L. 369n

  Gautama (Qutan Xida in Chinese), Indian astronomer 161, 179–80, 379n

  Geertz, Clifford 281–2, 387n

  George, Asha 383n

  Gernet, Jacques 379n

  Ghosh, Amitav 256, 258, 385n

  Ghosh, Manmohan 11f, 45f

  Ghosh, Ramendranath 361n

  Ghosh, Sankha 102

  Giovannitti, Len 357n

  Glazer, Nathan xvi, 374n

  Glazer, Sulochana xvi, 374n

  Glover, Jonathan 273–6, 277, 278–80, 282, 290, 291, 386n

  Gluckman, P. D. 384n

  Godfrey, K. M. 384n

  Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von 155

  Gombrich, Richard 354f

  Goodwin, Neva R. 386n

  Gopal, Sarvepalli 204f

  Gordon, Leonard A. 371n

  Gough, A. E. 361n

  Gray, John 386n

  Green, Peter 15f

  Greene, Graham 89, 90

  Griswold, Charles 386n

  Guha, Ramachandra 366n, 380n

  Guha, Ranajit 77, 368n, 376n

  Guio, Anne Catherine 244, 245, 384n

  Gujral, I. K. 43

  Gupta, Dipankar 362n

  Gupta, S. P. 367n

  Habermas, Juergen 182, 358–9n

  Habib, Irfan 359n, 360n, 368n, 386n, 387n, 390n

  Hajime, Nakamura 369n

  Halbfass, Wilhelm 373n, 375n, 376n

  Han, Yu 170

  Haq, Abdul 18, 289

  Haq, Mahbub ul 268

  Harasym, Sarah 86f

  Harding, J. E. 384n

  Harris, F. R. 336, 390n, 391n

  Harris, Jonathan M. 386n

  Harriss, John 381n

  Hassan, Moinul 23f, 361n

  Hastings, Warren 77

  Hegel, George 35, 94, 141, 152

  Herder, J. G. 40, 94, 151–2, 155, 328, 375n

  Himmelfarb, Gertrude 283, 387n

  Hiuan-tsang, see Xuanzang

  Hobsbawm, Eric 361–2n, 386n

  Holford-Strevens, Leofranc 390n

  Honneth, Axel 362n

  Hoodbhoy, Pervez 42f

  Horney, M.J. 383n

  Hucker, Charles O. 171, 378n

  Hui Li 173–4

  Humboldt, Wilhelm von 4, 357n

  Hume, David 279, 387n

  Huntington, Samuel 54, 62, 76, 164–5, 165n, 281, 284, 289, 365n, 367n, 387n

  Hurvitz, Leon 171, 378n

  I-Hsing, see Yi Xing

  I-tsing, see Yi Jing

  Ifrah, Georges 160, 374n, 376n

  Inden, Ronald 375n

  Isaacs, Harold 150, 374n

  Isherwood, Christopher 4

  Jacobsohn, Gary Jeffery 389n

  Jaggi, O. P. 390n

  Jahan, Rounaq 89f

  Jahan, Salim 89f

  Jahangir, Asma 43

  Jain, Devaki 220f

  Jalal, Ayesha xvi, 70f, 139f, 251f, 301f, 353f, 364n, 365n, 369n, 373n, 376n, 389n

  James, Robert Rhodes 261f

  Jamieson, Craig xvi

  Jayaraman, T. 385n

  Jayarishi 24

  Jha, D. N. 23–4, 361n, 367n

  Jha, Natwar 67, 367n

  Jha, Prem Shankar 380n

  Jinnah, Muhammad Ali 51, 299, 301f, 307, 364n

  Joffe, Roland 128

  Jones, William 61f,145–6, 147, 148, 154, 373n, 374n, 375n

  Jung, Anees 363n

  Jungk, Robert 385n

  Kabir 11, 19, 45, 45f, 75, 119, 134, 287, 316, 389–90n

  Kalam, Abdul 253, 253f, 255

  Kālidāsa 19, 41, 167, 330, 355, 363n

  Kangle, R. P. 361n

  Kant, Immanuel 280

  Kaplan, Robert 346f

  Karve, Irawati 230, 383n

  Kāśyapa (Chiayeb in Chinese), Indian astronomer 179–80

  Kāśyapa Matanga 167

  Kauṭilya xiv, 25, 158, 166, 284–5, 361n, 369n

  Kawabata, Yasunari 94, 111, 370n, 371n

  Kelly, Erin 358n

  Khan, Ali Akbar 57, 75

  Khan, Iqtidar Alam 360n, 387n

  Khan, Marufi 89f

  Khilnani, Sunil 364n, 365–6n

  Khusrau, Amir 19, 287

  Kieschnick, John 176, 180, 183, 379n

  Kipphardt, Heiner 357n

  Kishlansky, Mark A. 377n

  Kishwar, Madhu 363n

  Klasen, Stephan 226, 382n

  Kohli, Atul 194f

  Krausz, Michael 25f,376n

  Kripalani, Krishna 371n

  Krishnan, Rajaram 386n

  Kumāra (Cumolo in Chinese), Indian astronomer 179–80

  Kumar, Dharma 139f

  Kumar, Radha 363n

  Kumārajīva 82, 183, 183f, 369n

  Lahiri, N. C. 390n

  Lal, B. B. 367n

  Lala, R. M. 390n, 391n

  Laplace, Pierre-Simon 324–5, 390n

  Latham, R. E. 367n

  Lawrence, D. H. 107

  Lebra-Chapman, Joyce 358n

  Legge, James 377n, 379n

  Lennon, John 152

  Little, I. M. D. 380n

  Lloyd, Geoffrey 161f

  Lukács, Georg 109

  Lundberg, Shelly 383n

  Mabbett, Ian 23f

  Macaulay, T. B. 77, 78, 79, 149, 154, 368n

  McElroy, M. B. 383n

  McEvilley, Thomas 82–3, 369n

  McMullen, David 161f

  Madan, T. N. 388n

  Mādhavācārya 24, 309, 376n

  Mahmood, Tahir 388n

  Man Singh, Raja 19, 288

  Mandela, Nelson 30–31, 361n

  Manser, Merilyn 383n

  Mansfield, John H. 388n, 389n

  Martzloff, Jean-Claude 175–6, 379n

  Marx, Karl 157–8f, 235

  Massarenti, Armando xvi

  Matilal, Bimal xvi, 25f, 357n, 360n, 361n 375n

  Mayo, Katherine 150, 154

  Megasthenes 39, 151

  Mehta, Gita 160f

  Menon, Krishna 3

  Mill, James 78–9, 140, 142, 146–9, 147f, 154, 316, 316f, 368n, 369n, 374n

  Mill, John Stuart 150, 182

  Miller, Barbara 383n

  Miller, Barbara Stoler 363n

  Mira Bai 11, 19

  Mirrlees, Patricia xvi, 161f

  Mishra, Pankaj 256, 385n

  Mitchener, John 359n, 366–7n

  Moore, Charles A. 369n

  Moore, Mick 383n

  Moore, S. A. 360n

  Moosvi, Shirin 290, 359n

  Mouzi 171

  Muirhead, John 11, 375n

  Mukhopadhyay, Pranati xvi

  Mukhopadhyay, Shyama Prasad 307

  Müller, Max 77, 152, 368n

  Mumtaz Mahal xi

  Murthi, Ma
mta 244, 245, 384n

  Mussolini, Benito 111–12

  Nāgārjuna 158

  Nagel, Thomas 279, 371n, 387n

  Naidu, Sarojini 5–6

  Nair, Meera 127, 127f

  Nanak, Guru 75, 287

  Nanda, B. R. 100–101, 371n

  Nanda, Meera 367n

  Nandy, Ashis 150, 299–300, 312–14, 365n, 374n, 388n

  Nash, John 241, 241f, 383n

  Needham, Joseph 82f, 175–6, 177, 178, 183f, 379n

  Nehru, Jawaharlal 80, 91, 93, 106, 116, 155, 193, 195, 202, 204, 204f, 218, 288, 308, 343, 357n, 369n, 370n, 371n, 375n, 380n

  Nelson, Julie A. 236f, 384n

  Newton, Isaac 26, 165

  Nietzsche, Friedrich Wilhelm 273, 274

  Nobili, Roberto 145

  Noguchi, Yone 111

  Noorani, A. G. 365n

  Nussbaum, Martha xvi, 25f, 108f, 248f, 376n, 387–8n

  Nzinga Mbemba, King 287

  Obeyesekere, Gananath 282, 387n

  Ocampo, Victoria 102–3, 371n

  Oe, Kenzaburo 253, 253f, 255, 276, 385n, 386n

  O’Flaherty, Wendy Doniger 22f

  Oppenheimer, J. Robert 5, 255–6, 357n

  Osmani, Siddiq xvi, 381n, 384n

  Ostlin, Pireska 383n

  Owen, Susan 96

  Owen, Wilfred 96

  Owens, J. A. 384n

  Pal, Radhabinod 110

  Pandey, Gyanendra 364n

  Panikkar, K. M. 365n, 366n

  Pāṇini 84, 181, 325

  Papandreou, Andreas 386n

  Parekh, Bhikhu 365n, 391n

  Parry, Jonathan P. 380n

  Patterson, Orlando 135, 373n

  Patwardhan, Anand 42f

  Paz, Octavio 44, 44f

  Perin, Charles Page 340, 391n

  Perkovich, George 385n

  Peterson, Indira Viswanathan 358n

  Pettit, Philip 359n

  Philostratus, Flavius 151

  Plato 136, 284–5

  Plattner, Stuart 388n

  Pol Pot 275, 278

  Pollak, Robert 383n

  Pollock, Sheldon 85f

  Polo, Marco 68, 367n

  Pons, Father 145

  Pound, Ezra 90, 94–5, 111, 153

  Prabhavananda, Swami 357n

  Prajñadeva 174–5

  Prasad, Pushpa 387n

  Proffitt, Stuart xvi

  Putnam, Hilary 104, 371n

  Qizilbash, Mozaffar xvi, 273f

  Radhakrishnan, Sarvepalli 357n, 360n

  Radice, William 370n

  Rafique, Abdur 216f

  Rahman, Anisur xvi

  Raj, K. N. 391n

  Rajaram, N. S. 67, 367n, 386n

  Ram, N. 256–7, 385n

  Ramachandran, V. K. xvi, 38f, 139f, 220f 251f

  Ramanujan, Srinivasa 75

  Rana, Kumar xvi, 216f

  Ravi-das 11, 19

  Rawls, John 14, 182, 280, 280f, 358n

  Ray, Kumkum 23f, 361n

  Ray, Satyajit xv, 98f, 109, 115, 121, 121f, 122, 124–31, 138, 371n, 372n

  Raychaudhuri, Tapan 139f, 364n, 368n

 

‹ Prev