Mademoiselle Paradis’s case awakened his old complexes about his inferior social class and his all-consuming need for social recognition. He had thought that treating her would be the crowning achievement of his career. Now he understood that it might in fact be his downfall. He could, without anyone second-guessing him, obtain satisfactory results on weaker minds or members of the lower classes. But succeeding where his illustrious colleagues had failed, on someone they had been unable to treat—this was unacceptable. By taking up interest in her, he had overreached himself. He was accepted as an original, an eccentric, a patron of the arts doubling as a man of science who afforded himself the luxury of exploring the fringes of medicine. But not as a scientist revolutionizing his era.
It became apparent that his peers were refusing to associate with him. The Court doctors snubbed him. Even the Baron von Stoerck, his mentor and supporter, avoided crossing paths with him and spoke of him to colleagues with references to his “imagination.” Fewer people came to his parties. They invited him less to their own. He was no longer in the uppermost stratum of high society.
He decided to restore his reputation. He was seen, with Madame Mesmer at his side, at every concert, every opera. In his home he welcomed illustrious musicians, singers, and dancers. He held sumptuous banquets. Mademoiselle von Paradis was no longer anywhere to be seen. She was kept out of the Mesmers’ social picture. Her poor health, after all, placed such festivities off-limits to her.
Mesmer beat her at her own game.
He spent less time with her during the day. At night he visited her less often. He was still enamored of her youth, fascinated by her innocent yet lucid state of mind. He was still convinced that he could wrench her from her shadows, but with his own future now at stake, he was less sure that he wanted devote all his energy to her recovery.
“I am no longer your favorite patient,” sighed Maria Theresia when they were alone together in her room.
Mesmer protested her use of irony.
“You govern my thoughts and my future lies in your hands.”
“This is what I deplore! Why must I offer proof of my recovery when it is still incomplete? I would be better off in the pavilion with your anonymous patients. At least no one comes to monitor their health!”
“I informed your father of the reason for your relapse. I also told him that you have started making progress again but that it is too soon to plan a concert.”
“The Empress has to see the progress I’ve made so that you can take credit for it and I can be spared further torment. If I ask her for an audience, she cannot refuse, can she?”
She was sitting at her writing desk. Mesmer turned his back to her, too moved to confront her.
She stood up and came beside him at the window, putting her arm in his, staring at the sky.
“I don’t see any light, not even the moon. Does it mean there is bad weather coming tomorrow ... or have we fallen from grace? Is our lucky star no longer shining on us?”
Mesmer was on the verge of tears. He took her hands, held her against him.
“I wanted to protect you, but I cannot keep any secrets from you. We’re going to have to fight. A rumor has spread through Vienna that is sullying your reputation as well as mine. People are saying that we are lovers and that your so-called progress is the effect of ‘amorous suggestion,’ that is, some power I purportedly have over you. In other words, in my presence you can see things that you wouldn’t be able to see alone. Something along the lines of the sorcerer and his willing victim. They say our work is a hoax.”
She let him pull her closer.
“So our love is no more than a premeditated power play on your behalf? An attempt to manipulate me? That in addition to being blind, I am stupid and impressionable? You are well-versed in the rules of high society—tell me how to fight against an enemy who has no face.”
“Your father hinted that if you went home, it would put an end to the gossip.”
She clutched onto him, begging him, abandoning all restraint.
“I don’t want to. I can’t. I can no longer live without you. My father rules over his house with an iron hand. He terrorizes everyone. He loves me, but he keeps me under his thumb, in a way you would never do, even out of love! If the gossipmongers knew what life was like in the Paradis home, my father would have been stripped of his privileges long ago!”
“That is exactly the other rumor being spread. If you get better, your father will be deprived of the generous annuity the Empress allotted you.”
Maria Theresia laughed bitterly.
“There we go! Barth’s threat is finally being acted out! So let him be deprived of that annuity! Why should money be worth more than my health? My father will not let such rumors be spread because he is the first person sullied by them.”
“Think again! He is terrified at the idea of losing this godsend that has changed your lives for fifteen years now. The taste for this manna is very easy to acquire and very hard to lose. He will never give up his two hundred gold ducats.”
Maria Theresia slid onto the bed and buried her head in the pillows.
“Cursed! I am cursed! My blindness made them suffer and my recovery has made them mad. Even you prefer me ill to cured. Life is so cruel! It allows me to discover passion and harmony, then steals it away as if it were a mirage! What good is seeing if all it does is open your eyes to the truth of human nature? Have I been through all this just to come eye to eye with cowardice, lies, and trickery? To see you run away from me because I’ve become a burden? It is better to die than to be confronted with greedy, wicked men incapable of love!”
She was screaming, banging her head and beating her chest. She let him subdue her, then she collapsed, howling her turmoil.
Mesmer held her against him, ashamed. He knew her words rang true.
She had asked for nothing. She had listened to the doctors, to her father, and now to Mesmer. They had all betrayed her trust.
His sincerity was beyond reproach. But feelings evolve quickly. Depending on circumstances, what was true one minute may no longer be true the next.
Now he was ready to forgo Maria Theresia in order to save his career.
Chapter 20
MARIA THERESIA THREW HERSELF INTO HER exercises at the piano. She had removed her blindfold and was rehearsing tirelessly the same movement, a Mozart adagio. Losing her temper, she would rail aloud against her fingers when they hesitated at the keyboard or hit two keys instead of one. She couldn’t separate her eyes from her hands when she was playing; if she was not intrigued by her short fingernails as she struck the black and white keys, she was distracted by the light reflecting off the piano’s polish. She forced herself to act blind by keeping her eyes off the piano and staring at a point in the distance, near the window with its curtains drawn.
She was determined to regain control of the keyboard so as to be able to play for the Empress. She wanted to prove that her talent was intact even if the added allure of her blindness had been lost. She wanted to continue receiving the annuity, not as compensation for a handicap but to make up for the years she had invested in trying to become a world-renowned virtuoso.
Having fully recovered the sight that Barth’s examination had put in jeopardy, she had come to the conclusion that her progress remained extremely fragile because the slightest agitation could send her back into the world of shadows. Informed that her mother wanted to visit her, Maria Theresia responded that the emotions provoked by such a meeting would be harmful to her health. In truth, she had no desire to be confronted with the discomposure of this woman for whom she felt little affection. She had no recollection whatsoever of any tenderness she’d received from a mother who was so decidedly not maternal.
So, when Anna knocked at her door to tell her that she had a visitor in the drawing room, Maria Theresia refused to go, complaining that she had been interrupted in her work and could not be seen in her dressing gown with her face red and her hair uncombed. Rather than giving in to her
refusal, however, Anna insisted, arguing that Mademoiselle would be very happy indeed to meet the person awaiting her.
Anna shifted from foot to foot, trying to convince her, when all of a sudden Maria Theresia heard a footstep that made her bolt from the piano stool, rush to the door, and run open-armed into the familiar scent of starch that characterized the refuge of her childhood. Nina laughed joyously, spinning her in her arms as she had when Maria Theresia was a child. The two of them shed tears, kissed, pulled back to contemplate each other’s faces, and then fell back into each other’s arms, their embrace magical.
“Your eyes are lighter. They are pale green now!” marveled the servant.
“Nina ... Here you are ...”
Overwhelmed, Maria Theresia touched Nina’s curly hair, her round cheeks, her cool, callused hands, as if she were getting her bearings.
“How is Runter? Remember how you hid him under your apron? You put ribbons in my hair. I would fidget just to annoy you. I’d get money for every knot that came undone.”
“And the rabbit game. Do you still remember it?”
“Clever rabbit, hide from my eyes, but I the cat shall thee surprise!” answered Maria Theresia breathlessly, recalling the nursery rhyme from before the shadow days.
After the memories, the hugging, the confidences, the tears, after having partaken of the snack that Anna had prepared for them, they went out for a walk.
Maria Theresia walked lazily, relieved to feel Nina’s arm firmly round her waist. She leaned against her like a fledgling who had flown too far away and at last rediscovered the security of the nest. She had confided in no one for months and was happy to be able to tell Nina of her liaison with Mesmer, her initial elation, and her present anxiety.
“My father hasn’t sent you, I hope?” she asked, worried that her greatest ally had switched sides.
“He doesn’t know that I am here. He thinks I’ve gone to see my family for a few days.”
“You have brothers and sisters and cousins! How lucky! I have only my parents. A mother who lives in the shadow of her husband and a tyrannical father who decides my every move.”
“It is thanks to your father that Herr Mesmer is treating you.”
“Yes, but between the prospect of losing my annuity if I am cured and ruining my reputation by staying here, he must have serious regrets!”
She spoke with an ironic smile that Nina had never before seen.
“Yes, Nina, here I have learned cynicism and bitterness, two feelings that were foreign to me. For a long time my blindness protected me from a reality that is not pretty to behold. What I have discovered scares me much more than the shadows that surrounded me. I have opened my eyes to a world that I knew nothing of, and it grows more and more disappointing every day. There is no room in it for simple, naïve souls who think that happiness is all about loving others. You can’t get by on love, or art. Ambition is the force that drives this world. People care more about clawing their way to fame and manipulating others than they do about what makes a concerto work.”
She took Nina’s hands in her own.
“I can admit it to you: I am having difficulty playing the piano because I have to learn to stop staring at the keyboard. But this is not the only reason. I have lost the faith I had in music. I used to think it would help me express emotions that an audience could share with me. During a concert the listeners and I would engage in a sort of conversation. There was an exchange between what I gave them and the way they received it. Their listening returned to me my emotion a hundredfold. Well, I no longer believe that. People listen and they are probably moved, but their attention is distracted by what’s running through their minds, and now I fear that they send back to me nothing other than their own vanity. They have no time to be affected by the music, even though music alone has the power to raise their hearts and ease their minds. They cannot be bothered. This is what preoccupies me now when I play. I analyze the world coldly. I no longer idealize it. As I’ve lost my conviction in my talent, I can’t convince anyone with my talent. This is what I’ve become, Nina. A girl without illusions. Music has ceased being my dream world. Now that I see the real world, I live with nightmares.”
Exhausted by having opened her heart to Nina, Maria Theresia suggested they head back to the house. They walked in silence, arm in arm, closer to each other than ever before.
As they entered through the French windows in the back of the house, they heard a commotion in the entrance hall. They rushed to see what was going on, only to discover Anna and the butler face-to-face with Monsieur and Madame von Paradis, the two of them screaming, demanding to see Herr Mesmer at once.
They saw their daughter and hurried toward her, not even noticing Nina at her side. Instead of taking her in her arms, her mother, in a state of extreme agitation, shook Maria Theresia violently.
“Hurry, gather some things. We’ll send someone later for the rest. You’re coming with us!”
Joseph Anton was still arguing with the butler. They could hear Mesmer in the garden, furious that her parents had entered his home unannounced.
He reached the front door and asked Anna to explain the situation.
Monsieur Paradis stormed toward him.
“I order you to return my daughter to me!”
Mesmer bowed, too ceremoniously to be paying his respects. As was his wont, he responded to excess with calm and to agitation with utter self-control.
“Mademoiselle Paradis is here because you have done me the honor of allowing me to cure her. You can take her back whenever you want.”
“I want her to leave with us immediately.”
Mesmer turned to Maria Theresia. She looked at him scathingly.
He gave her an imperceptible nod, then spoke to her father.
“You do agree with me that it is up to her to decide.”
“My daughter will do what I order her to do.”
“Never!”
The shout escaped her mouth to the stupefaction of everyone present—a shout so desperate that Joseph Anton stopped in his tracks, stunned to hear such a cry of distress coming from his daughter.
His wife, however, was so offended by this lack of respect that she took three steps toward her daughter and slapped her once on each cheek, shouting:
“We sacrificed everything for you. You shall do as you are told!”
She shook her, beat her. She was out of control, letting out years of bottled-up rage.
Maria Theresia protected her face, crying, while Mesmer and Nina tried to wrench her from her mother’s grip.
When she finally stood up, she shrieked:
“I don’t see anything any more!”
She put her hands to her eyes, took a few wavering steps toward Mesmer, and then lost consciousness.
Chapter 21
A FEW HOURS LATER, SHE WAS LYING FEVERISH IN HER bed, tossing her head in every direction, murmuring incomprehensibly. Her face was extremely pale, her body heaving as if waves of pain were coursing in spasms through her.
Nina tried to apply cool compresses to her forehead, while Mesmer massaged her temples with camphor oil.
Mesmer stood up, leaned over her bed, removed the cover, and placed his hands on her ankles. For a long moment he hovered over her without moving, before he drew closer without touching her further. Then, slowly, he worked his hands up the length of her body until he reached her head. Then he did so again and again, repeatedly increasing the tempo of his hands.
Suddenly, Maria Theresia stiffened. Her limbs tensed. She held her breath for several seconds. Mesmer removed his hands, and immediately her body relaxed. She started breathing normally again; her face slackened. Her sleep became peaceful.
Nina watched Mesmer admiringly. When they were sure that she’d fallen into a deep sleep, they walked to the window.
The full moon illuminated the garden. The night had washed away the trauma of the day.
“That was an epileptic fit, wasn’t it, Doctor?” Nina was overwrought, pa
nicking at having seen her dear mistress go from painful lucidity to sheer confusion.
“I’m afraid so. She will need time to recover, but I doubt we’ll be given any.”
Nina stared at him, shocked.
“Isn’t it the doctor who decides what is best for his patient?”
He placed his hands on her shoulders to reassure her.
“I can only suggest. I have no real authority. Between her father and the Court doctors, who knows what may happen?”
Nina insisted.
“But aren’t you going to protect her?”
Mesmer stared out the window, lost in his thoughts.
He took a moment to answer, and when he did he seemed far away, as if speaking to himself.
“I’d like to have devoted my life to treating her, to showing her the world. I’d have made of her an exceptional artist. I think I would have made her happy. But life has decided otherwise. My colleagues want my ruin. Monsieur Paradis wants his daughter. Their schemes will destroy her health, my career, and our future.”
He was overtaken by a wave of fatigue. He closed his eyes, then stood up straight and warmly clasped Nina’s hands in his own.
“I will try to keep her here as long as possible, but I am not optimistic. You are more than welcome to stay here as well.”
Maria Theresia was fast asleep. He stroked her cheek, then headed for the door.
“Good night, Nina. Thank you for watching over her. Later, when she has doubts about me, you will tell her that I loved her.”
The door closed silently behind him.
Chapter 22
THE NEWS MADE ITS WAY QUICKLY TO THE COURT. Joseph Anton von Paradis never tired of recounting his misfortunes. It became his mission to broadcast how Mesmer’s treatment had ruined his daughter’s constitution. He appeared not to see how such reports might confirm the rumor of the liaison between the two.
Pianist in the Dark Page 6