by Nancy Thayer
“Everyone’s working outdoors today,” Madaket remarked. They turned into the landfill drive and stopped by the booth. The supervisor directed them to the great hill of refuse where giant backloaders scooped dirt over the trash and seagulls swooped screaming by the hundreds, looking for food. Madaket got out and dragged and tossed their load into the pile, then slammed shut the Jeep and drove back toward the main road.
“What’s that?” Joanna asked, pointing to a cement island between the entrance and exit lanes.
“That’s where you sort your recyclable bottles.”
“And that?” Joanna pointed to an odd area where used furniture and damaged appliances stood forlorn under the sun.
“That’s the take-it-or-leave-it pile. If you’ve got something that’s not good enough to sell but not bad enough to destroy, something someone might be able to use, you leave it there. Anyone can leave stuff, anyone can take it.”
“What happens if no one takes a piece?”
“I guess it gets tossed in the trash heap.”
“Slow down. Stop. I want to get out and look.”
Joanna dropped from the Jeep and walked over to the fenced-in lot. She’d never seen anything quite like it before, but then never before in her life had she seen this side of home ownership. It seemed such a melancholy, heartbreaking thing: all these objects, solid and once valuable, abandoned under the sun. A three-legged table leaned on a perfectly sturdy wooden chair with the cane torn in the seat. An open box overflowed with pink-and-white-checked curtains which once had billowed starchily at someone’s kitchen window. Joanna was filled with a sudden pity.
“Joanna?” Madaket came up behind her.
“Look at that!” Joanna exclaimed. Stepping over a crooked push lawn mower and a stained rolled rug, she picked up a picture frame. “This is a perfectly good frame!”
“Joanna, it’s come apart at two corners, and the glass is cracked.”
“Well, we can replace the glass and glue the corners together and clean it up and repaint it and it will be as good as new. It’s beveled wood, Madaket.”
“Joanna, you can buy a much nicer frame in town.”
“Of course I can. That’s not the point. Why should this be destroyed? Just because the original owner doesn’t want it doesn’t mean it should just be tossed away!”
“Well, of course if you want it, if you think you’ll use it, take it,” Madaket told her.
So they put the frame in the back of the Jeep and took it home. Later that week during the long evenings when Joanna was alone, she worked on the frame in the kitchen, washing it, scrubbing out the crevice in the beveling with a toothbrush, gluing it together, and finally painting it a shining, clean, navy blue. She was so pleased with it when she was finished that she hung it on the kitchen wall even though she hadn’t yet found a picture to put inside. After that day, she made an outing at least once a week with Madaket to sort through the take-it-or-leave-it pile to see if anything else needed rescuing. She liked having projects which didn’t involve sitting at the computer in the evening.
Tory often asked Joanna to join her at movies or lectures or art exhibits in town or shopping for clothes. But their lives ran on different rhythms. Tory had houseguests almost all the time, and her children had houseguests. With so many people in her house to feed and wash and entertain, Tory had brought up from New York her maid, a tiny, shy, older Vietnamese woman named Lei, who crept noiselessly around the house doing her chores. Lei did not enjoy conversation, and hated the beach and the sun; but Joanna had been present when Tory said, “Lei, how would you like a nice big color television in your bedroom?” Lei had smiled beatifically, and after that Tory kept the maid supplied with soap opera tabloids and boxes of soft-centered chocolate candies, and in return Lei adored Tory.
“Perhaps Madaket would like to meet Lei,” Tory suggested one day.
“I can’t imagine why,” Joanna responded. “They have nothing in common.”
“Darling, they have everything in common. They’re both maids. You know, like Upstairs, Downstairs.”
“This isn’t Victorian England, and we don’t have a Victorian class system, or at least those of us who are enlightened don’t!” Joanna snapped.
“I’m not trying to insult your little housekeeper,” Tory said in a soothing voice.
“God forbid. I just thought they might enjoy each other’s company.”
“Why? Lei must be twenty years older than Madaket, at least!”
“But they’re both in domestic service, Joanna. I’m serious. Madaket might know things about the best way to cook fish or something. But if you don’t think it’s a good idea, let’s drop it. You really should watch yourself. Getting angry so easily can’t be good for your blood pressure.”
Had Tory always been so irritating, Joanna wondered privately, or was her pregnancy making her irrational? She listened with barely concealed boredom when Tory called to describe her endless rounds of fishing and sailing and golf and tennis, with cocktail parties every night and dinners for sixteen at pricey restaurants. When Joanna was invited along, she always politely refused. Tory’s group was too noisy and boisterous. Joanna needed peace and quiet. She was gestating like a primitive creature, needing only to be.
“I understand how you feel,” Tory said to Joanna one afternoon. They were on Joanna’s screened-in porch. Joanna was lying on her chaise with her feet up, and Tory was seated nearby in a wicker rocker. “Still, it’s not good for you to be cooped up all the time. You need exercise.”
“I do exercise. I walk on the beach every night. And just walking around this huge house, up and down the stairs—Doug said just the other day—”
“That’s another thing.” Tory rose, pulled her chair around to face Joanna, and leaned close to her, almost whispering. “You need to get out of the house more often. If you only could realize how many times you’ve said to me recently: Todd said. Or Doug said. Or Madaket said. Joanna, don’t you know that it’s really not, oh, I don’t know—appropriate—for your employees to become your society.”
Joanna laughed. “Oh, come on. I see other people all the time. I had dinner at the Latherns’ the other night. And I was at Pat Hoover’s gallery opening last week. Besides,” she continued, more seriously and defensively, “my main interest at the moment is in my house, and no one knows more about it now than the Snows and Madaket. I’d much rather talk to them than make small talk with people I don’t know at some superficial cocktail party.” Seeing Tory’s expression darken ominously, Joanna confessed frivolously, half joking, wanting to lighten the mood, “Furthermore, I haven’t seen a male anywhere else on the island as sexy as Doug Snow.”
“You think Doug Snow is sexy?”
“Yes. Don’t you think so? He’s got a sort of rough, tough, Rolling Stone, Marlboro Man look about him.”
“I guess I can see what you mean. But—”
It was so pleasurable, talking about Doug, it warmed Joanna all over. “When I told Madaket, she was shocked. She thinks he’s—”
“You told Madaket you think Doug Snow is sexy?” Tory nearly rose out of her chair. “What a stupid thing to do!” Now Tory was really angry.
“What on earth’s the matter?”
“Joanna, don’t be naive. These island people tell each other everything.”
“Tory—”
“Haven’t I told you? Hasn’t everyone told you? It really is them against us on this island. No matter how nice they appear on the surface, the island people hate us for being rich summer folk.”
“I think you’re wrong, Tory, at least about Madaket. She’s—”
“She’s your help, Joanna, and that’s all. Don’t make the mistake of treating her like a friend or a companion. And for God’s sake stop talking about Doug Snow being sexy! For one thing, he’s married.”
“Well, I know that, Tory. But a man can be married and still sexy.” Once again Joanna tried to lighten the atmosphere. “I mean, I can look, can’t I?”
> “Can you? I don’t know. Can you just look? You didn’t just look at Carter.”
Joanna felt her face flush as if she’d been slapped. “Tory, give me a break, will you?”
Tory’s mouth tightened to a thin line. For a few moments she sat in silence. When she spoke again, her voice was controlled. “I’m sorry, Joanna. It’s just that I worry about you so. You’re doing so many erratic things. Going to such extremes. Buying a house, not just a house, but such a big old house that needs so much work. Getting yourself so isolated out here on this island. Running around wearing a wig. Having babies all by yourself. I just don’t feel you’re behaving responsibly.”
Joanna responded heatedly. “Tory, not everyone can have the perfect family the perfect way. Not everyone can afford a house on Nantucket just for the summer. Not everyone gets to marry the person she loves. Not everyone would consider owning a house, writing two books, and having babies instead of aborting them irresponsible.”
“I never suggested you should have an abortion!” Tory snapped.
“Then you can’t criticize me for ‘having them all by myself.’ In fact, Tory, I don’t think you have the right to criticize me at all!”
“I never approved of your affair with Carter.”
“I know you didn’t. And if it makes you feel better, I’m not having it with him anymore!” Joanna smiled at her own wit, but Tory only looked exasperated.
“I’ll say it again, Joanna. I’m just worried about you. I know you’re happy about these babies, and so I’ll try to be happy for you. And you know I’ll always be ready to help you at any time. But in the meantime, will you please try to be more—circumspect? Stop talking about carpenters being sexy. Stop confiding in your cleaning lady.”
“Madaket’s more than my cleaning lady.”
“Are you sure she should be?”
“Whyever shouldn’t she be? Are there rules about this sort of thing?”
“Don’t be so cavalier, Joanna. You really shouldn’t trust the natives. They certainly don’t trust you.”
“Look, Tory, I suppose I should be grateful for your concern. Obviously, you’ve been connected to this island longer than I have. And I will agree to stop talking about Doug being sexy. I suppose being so fat and pregnant makes me think I can say silly things and get away with them. I mean, it’s not like I intend to act on my feelings. But as far as Madaket goes—I really like her. I like her about as much as anyone I’ve ever met. I trust her. I enjoy being with her. And I’m not going to weaken that by any kind of suspicion. Besides, as I said, she doesn’t like Doug Snow. She wouldn’t tell him anything.”
“Yes, but she might tell someone else who would tell him.”
“From what I hear, she wouldn’t. She’s a loner.”
“Well, I’d find that worrisome if I were you. Why doesn’t she have any friends?”
“Oh, for heaven’s sake, Tory!” Joanna exploded. “If she has friends, you think she’s a gossip, and if she doesn’t, you think she’s odd.”
“I’ve had so many maids and nannies over the years, and so many difficult experiences. I’m just trying to protect you.”
“I don’t need your protection. I just want your friendship. Come on, Tory. At least trust me. I’m an intelligent person.”
Tory just glared at Joanna from her pale blue icy eyes. “Just say you’ll keep what I’ve said in mind.”
“All right. I will. Now, can we talk about something pleasant?”
Tory let out a loud, exasperated breath. “Okay. Truce. What shall we talk about?”
“How about the treasures I’ve been finding at the dump?” Joanna suggested mischievously.
“The dump.” Tory groaned and shook her head. “I don’t know what’s to become of you.”
Two days later Joanna woke to discover the temperature had fallen radically. The sky hung low and gray and the wind whipped the delicate bushes into a frantic dance. Far out, ocean waves surged and sank in great agitation, hurrying to dash themselves upon the shore.
Dressed in a sweater and thick socks for warmth, she worked on the porch all day. The Snows were painting the walls and woodwork in the large upstairs room, and she told them she had to avoid it because the smells of paint and turpentine could be dangerous to her pregnancy. And she was glad to keep away. Her conversation with Tory had left her feeling foolish every time she saw Doug.
At five the Snowmen left for the day, pounding down the stairs, bringing with them the scent of sawdust and turpentine. As they ran out to the truck, it was just beginning to sprinkle. Joanna found Madaket in the kitchen, tossing a huge salad with a garlic dressing. A pot of stew simmered on the stove and a pan of homemade corn bread cooled on a trivet.
“God, this smells good!” Joanna cried. “Madaket, you’re a genius! This is the perfect thing to eat on a day like today.”
“I made a fresh apple pie, too, and brought out vanilla Häagen-Dazs,” Madaket told her, smiling shyly.
Joanna leaned over the stove, greedily inhaling. “Look,” she said. “You’ve made far too much for one person. Stay and eat dinner with me.”
“Oh, I can’t,” Madaket began, but just then, with a tearing sound, the sky broke open, spilling its burden of rain out. It fell in torrents against the windows with an incessant pounding sound.
“Now you have to,” Joanna said. “You can’t possibly ride a bike in this weather.”
Madaket stood still in the middle of the kitchen, looking out the window. She was wearing her usual outfit: work boots and a loose flowered cotton dress; today she’d pulled over it a fisherman’s knit sweater against the cold. Her heavy braid gleamed like carved ebony, lustrous against the creamy woven wool.
“Come on,” Joanna cajoled. “I’d really enjoy your company, Madaket. It makes me melancholy, eating alone night after night. Especially on a night like this.”
Madaket contemplated the night. Rain streamed down.
“All right,” she said softly. “I’ll stay.” She looked down at her hands, as if wondering where to put them.
“Great!” Joanna said. “I know what we’ll do. Let’s eat in the dining room, by candlelight! I haven’t eaten in there yet. It’s too big for one person.”
“The dining room is awfully—” Madaket hesitated, searching for the correct word.
“Formal? I know. But one thing I’ve learned doing my show is that there is no one way to use any room. Just because it’s furnished with expensive antiques doesn’t mean it should never be used. Just the opposite, I think. I mean, what is beauty for? I’ll set the table, you bring in the food.”
Keeping up a running line of chatter to put Madaket at her ease, Joanna went into the dining room and took a snowy white damask cloth and two napkins from the sideboard, the silver from the rosewood box, the china from the corner cupboard. She lit white tapers on either side of a vase of peonies and phlox, then the tall, dark green candles twisting up from the silver candlesticks on either side of the fireplace mantel. Between them stood an antique clock with the sun, moon, and stars smiling from its silvered face. It didn’t run—it was one of Joanna’s treasures from the dump—but it looked as if it belonged in the dining room, as if it had stood in this particular spot for decades. On the spur of the moment, Joanna turned off the electric light in the chandelier and wall sconces.
“Isn’t it romantic!” she said to Madaket as the girl came into the room. “My first meal in my own dining room! Isn’t my china beautiful?”
Madaket set the stew in its tureen on the table. “Yes,” she agreed wistfully. “I’ve never seen such a beautiful table.”
Joanna saw how hesitant the young woman was in her movements. She sat at the table almost paralyzed until Joanna put her napkin in her lap; then Makadet did the same. “Shall I?” Joanna said, gesturing to the stew, and she served everything, the salad on the salad plate, the stew in the bowl. “I’ve heard that in England when a group of adults meet each other for tea, the person who decides to pour asks, ‘Shall
I be Mother?’ I wonder if they really do that. I wonder if someone says that when the group is entirely male.” She spoke lightly, with a smile. Madaket smiled in return and waited until Joanna had taken the first bite until she lifted her fork to eat.
In her work, Joanna had learned to draw people out by asking about their strengths and their loves, and so as they ate, she asked Madaket about her cooking skills. Madaket talked about the island’s bounty—mussels on the jetties, berries on the moors, bluefish at Surfside—and by the time she cut into the warm apple pie, she spoke more easily about her grandmother, who’d taught her to cook.
“You’re lucky you had your grandmother to teach you things,” Joanna said. “I never knew my grandparents. God, I hardly knew my parents.” She felt Madaket’s eyes on her, waiting, reluctant to pry. “My parents were divorced very early in my life. I grew up sort of on the road with my mother. I was mostly an encumbrance when she was visiting her friends. Or I was shoved onto one of my father’s girlfriends, who as you can imagine were not prepared for a child in the house.”
“Really?” Madaket was fascinated right out of her shyness. She leaned forward. “That’s hard to believe.”
“Why?”
Madaket shrugged, drew back into herself, embarrassed to have made such a personal remark.
“No, really, Madaket, tell me. I’m curious. You can’t hurt my feelings. Lord, think about what I just said—it would take more than your remark to hurt my tough old feelings!”
Joanna felt the young woman’s eyes on her, judging.
“It’s just that you seem like one of the ones who … belong,” Madaket confessed.
Joanna nodded. “I know what you mean. But it’s an act. I’ve really led a rather makeshift life. Always envying those with a home and a family … which is undoubtedly why my show is called Fabulous Homes. To me, all homes are fabulous.”