Louis insisted that she use a tape recorder he’d brought rather than the jail’s installed system. In fact, throughout the interview, he’d controlled what was actually recorded. If not satisfied with an answer given by Villalobos, he’d stopped the machine, discussed the matter with the ugly little man, and then rewound the tape. Then on his signal, Breman had repeated her question, and Villalobos answered in a “more appropriate” manner.
After the interview was over Breman had announced to the press that there was “reasonable cause” to order DNA testing. She’d felt somewhat better when the DNA results came back positive. At least that part of Villalobos’s story was accurate.
By arrangement, she’d leaked the results first to Harriman, who seemed to have made his own deal with Louis, so that the New York Times —quoting “an anonymous source in the Kings County District Attorney’s Office”—had the story a day before the rest of the media. Shortly afterward, Breman had held a press conference on the steps of the Brooklyn courthouse with Louis at her side, announcing that “in the interests of justice” her office would be joining Louis’s motion to have the convictions overturned. “It is my opinion that the so-called Coney Island Four have been exonerated by these developments, and this office will not seek further action.”
In the days that followed, Breman was even able to convince herself that she had done the right thing. It helped that she got a lot of encouragement from others. Activists in the African-American and civil rights communities lauded her “courage in the fight against institutionalized racism”; the Kings County defense bar issued a statement that read in part, “finally a district attorney who recognizes that justice, not conviction statistics, is the duty of the state when prosecuting crimes”; and the Times even wrote an editorial. The editorial noted that based on the “exclusive” reporting of award-winning writer Harriman, the newspaper’s hierarchy agreed with Breman’s decision and that “perhaps other local district attorneys should take note of the evenhanded administration of justice by the Kings County District Attorney and seek to emulate her to bring credibility and honor back into their own dealings.”
The only downside had been putting up with the tirades of the assistant DAs Repass and Russell, who’d insisted that they’d presented evidence in the original trial that there was a sixth perpetrator but that did not mean that the teenage defendants had not “initiated and participated” in the crime. “The jury understood this to be the case and convicted Sykes, Davis, Wilson, and Jones in less than two hours of deliberations,” Repass argued.
Breman was proud of how she stood up to the know-it-alls. She pointed out that there were no eyewitnesses to place the five black teens at the scene—not even the victim could substantiate that allegation—“but we have irrefutable scientific evidence that Villalobos committed the crime, as well as his confession.”
“An uncorroborated confession. There’s a legal precedent for this—hold a hearing, put him under oath, at worst retry the case,” Russell countered.
“A waste of time in my opinion, which is the opinion that counts here,” Breman said. “Villalobos’s confession is corroborated by the DNA evidence. There was no physical evidence or eyewitness testimony tying the defendants to the attack on Liz Tyler.”
“We had a witness testify that five black teenagers were seen leaving the general area,” Russell countered.
“No one who could say it was these boys,” Breman countered.
“These ‘boys’ were also convicted of several other assaults that night,” Repass pointed out, “including nearly killing an elderly man with a piece of steel bar like the one found beneath the pier.”
“We try people for one crime at a time here,” Breman said. “As you point out, they were convicted of those other crimes and served their time for them. It is this crime for which there are very large questions of guilt—questions that in my opinion raise a serious ethical question of how we were ever in a position to, in good faith, ask a jury to find these young men guilty beyond a reasonable doubt…. And, I might add, there was no physical evidence—blood or hair—on the steel bar suggesting that it was the same one used that night in the other crimes.”
“By the time it was found, the tide had washed it off,” Russell said.
“It’s nonsense anyway,” Repass added. “These ‘large questions’ were looked at by the jury, and they found that we’d answered them beyond a reasonable doubt. And what about the confessions? Those animals corroborated the evidence—hell, they boasted about what they did.”
Breman bristled at Repass. “I’ll thank you not to refer to these young men as ‘animals.’ It merely serves to underline the accusations that this office has a problem with racist attitudes. As for the confessions, they were boys at that time—coerced, badgered, and intimidated by grown, gun-toting men who threatened them with every sort of punishment under the sun, including the possibility of the death penalty if Liz Tyler had died.”
“Oh, Christ!” Repass exclaimed, “They were laughing about it in front of the cops. One of them talked about how much fun it was—that’s not exactly the response of a frightened ‘boy.’”
“Nerves,” Breman shrugged. “Trying to put on a brave face.”
“What about the defendant who took me to the scene and said he didn’t realize there’d been so much blood?” Russell asked.
“That was Kevin Little, who, if I remember correctly, was given a pretty sweet deal for turning on his childhood friends,” Breman said. “Hardly an unbiased witness.”
Repass started to say something, but Breman sat up in the manner bosses do when they’ve given recalcitrant subordinates a “fair” hearing but are ready to move on. “This conversation is over,” she said. At last, she thought, I can get rid of these two, and I’ll even look like the hero as far as the public’s concerned.
“I think it would go a long way toward reestablishing this office’s credibility with the public if you two took it upon yourselves to sign off on the motion in support of vacating the convictions, as well as demanding that these four men be released immediately from custody.”
Seeing the shocked looks on the other women’s faces, Breman barely contained a giggle before adding, “It might mitigate some of the damages should they prevail in a lawsuit against this office.”
“Fuck you,” Repass said.
Smiling, Breman shook her head as if she didn’t quite know what to do with such an unruly child. She cocked an eyebrow and looked at Russell, who nodded her head toward her colleague. “What she said.”
“Well then,” Breman said, clasping her hands as if they’d all reached some mutually satisfying agreement, “that leaves me no choice but to place the two of you on administrative leave.” She leaned forward and pressed the button on her intercom, “Teddy, could you come in here, please.”
A moment later, Theodore “Teddy” Chalk entered the room and glared at Repass and Russell. His boss had already told him what was up and that the women, especially the hotheaded Repass, might get violent.
Teddy wasn’t the sharpest tool in the shed, but he was one good-looking, square-jawed, dark-eyed, dark-haired, olive-skinned, bodybuilding hunk of former-cop-turned-bodyguard. He was also madly in love with Breman, and she’d occasionally allowed him to service her sexual needs, although that was more to ensure his absolute devotion than out of any genuine desire for him.
“Teddy, would you please escort Ms. Repass and Ms. Russell to their offices, where they are allowed to remove a single box containing their personal belongings. However, they are not to take any legal paperwork or files. Can you do that for me?” She gave him her most beguiling smile, which made him blush and then straighten as if he’d been given an order by a superior officer. He’d been a marine for a couple of years out of high school, and once in a moment of passion she’d told him that it turned her on every time he snapped to attention when she spoke, so he’d stepped it up ever since. “Yes, ma’am.”
Teddy stepped forward as if
to physically remove the women but stopped when Repass snarled, “Touch me and I’ll kick your balls up around your shoulders.” He looked confused, then glanced over at Breman, who rolled her eyes and nodded her head toward the door.
The bodyguard and two angry women were gone from her office for only a minute when Hugh Louis stepped from the small antechamber where he’d remained out of sight during the discussion. “Well done, Krissy, well done,” he said. “You go, girl. Good to hear that someone in government still believes in the Constitution and the concept of reasonable doubt.” He shook a fat finger and looked at the ceiling as he recited, “…‘better that a hundred guilty men’—not that my clients are guilty of these crimes—‘than a single innocent man lose his freedom.’…I believe it was Jefferson or someone like him who said that.”
That had been that past summer. Now, as Teddy stood back from the car door and extended a hand to help her out into the frigid December air, Breman recalled how Louis’s praise that day had made her skin crawl. Again the little voice was asking her to leave so that she had to remind herself that she was doing this because Louis could practically guarantee her the black vote. This is just a little thing, she thought, we’re accomplishing a lot in the office getting bums off the streets and arresting graffiti taggers to make cleaner, nicer neighborhoods. And you can’t do that sort of good if you’re not in office, can you.
Breman also had higher aspirations than the district attorney’s office, and Louis could get her there, too. He’d hinted as much when inviting her to this late-night meeting in Harlem. “A person with your ability and charm could do a lot of good for this community as a district court judge,” he said. “And I might be in a position to help a friend with those sorts of ambitions.”
Breman was certainly aware that Louis pulled a lot of strings behind the scenes when it came to political appointments. He was also known to have important contacts in the nation’s capital. A spot on the bench was a nice dream, one she felt she deserved, but on the ride over she also couldn’t get over the feeling that Louis had whistled and she’d obeyed like a well-trained dog.
“Maybe I should go in with you, Kri…I mean, ma’am,” Teddy said, glancing meaningfully at the big man standing on the sidewalk in front of the steps leading into the building. The skinny one had also come off the wall and moved onto the sidewalk.
Breman wished more than anything that she could say yes to Teddy’s request, but Louis had told her to come alone. He promised that she had nothing to worry about, even though he mentioned that Jayshon Sykes and perhaps another of the Coney Island Four would be present. Mustn’t show fear. “No. I’ll be all right, Teddy. I won’t be long.”
As she walked over to the steps, the fat man turned and proceeded up the steps ahead of her. After she passed, the skinny man parked himself at the bottom of the steps and stared insolently at Teddy, who stood looking after Breman like a retriever waiting for its master to come home.
At the top of the steps, Breman paused long enough to read the simple plaque on the outside of the building: Louis & Associates, Attorneys at Law. The inside of the office was nondescript, by all signs a no-frills, hardworking, underfunded legal firm.
Beyond the outer reception area was another spartan office with a desk on which rested the nameplate for Hugh Louis, Esq. The chair behind the desk was functional but nothing special, as were the two chairs in front. What art there was in the room consisted of cheap African knockoffs of Zulu masks and Swahili spears and a fake lion’s skin made of horsehide.
Breman figured that this office was probably where Louis met most of his clients. She was sure of it when she was led into the inner sanctum—a richly appointed den done in teak and leather. The walls were adorned with expensive-looking art pieces, including what she believed might have been an original Jackson Pollock. A black-and-white photograph of Louis with his arm around an uncomfortable-looking Joe Namath hung behind the desk, signed Best Wishes, Joe.
As she entered, Louis came out from around a bar where he’d been mixing “a root beer and rum…care to join me?”
Breman shook her head. “No, thank you. It’s been a long day and it would probably just make me sleepy.” She laughed, wondering if it sounded as false as it felt.
Louis mopped his forehead with the omnipresent handkerchief, which he then stuffed back into a pocket and held out his hand. “Good of you to make it, Krissy,” he said. “Sorry to make you—I mean, ask you—to make the drive from Brooklyn, but I thought it would be good for us to meet away from prying eyes. There ain’t many in this neighborhood, at least none who would say anything to anybody who might care.” He released her hand and pointed behind and to her side. “I believe you know my clients here, Mr. Jayshon Sykes and Mr. Desmond Davis.”
Breman fought to keep the smile on her face as she turned in the direction Louis was pointing. She had not seen the two men slouching on the black leather couch in front of the wall of books. She nodded. “Of course. Good to see you again.”
Neither of the young men acknowledged her greeting. They both appeared to have found something infinitely more interesting on the wall and on the floor respectively. Louis pretended not to notice the slight and waved her toward the chair in front of his desk while he went around behind it and sat down. Establishing who’s boss, Breman thought miserably as she noticed that her seat was several inches lower than Louis’s, who appeared to tower over her.
As a matter of fact, Louis was immensely pleased with himself. He’d filed a $250 million lawsuit against the City of New York and its police department, which he estimated might settle at one hundred million. He was contractually entitled to one-third of the settlement and by the time he added in expenses, including an apartment for his mistress, Tawnee, and the baubles she required to keep her happy, he’d get about half. And that didn’t include the book and film rights.
Over steaks and martinis at the Tribeca Grill, he’d cut a deal to do a book with the New York Times reporter Harriman, in exchange for half the royalties and favorable stories in the Times. So far, the reporter, who had never met a scene he couldn’t create out of thin air or a quote he couldn’t manufacture, had kept up his end of the bargain.
Louis and Harriman had a meeting set up the next week with three different publishing houses whose executive editors were already pissing all over themselves for the rights to The Coney Island Four: An American Tale of Racism and Injustice. As soon as they had a deal, Louis planned to fly to Hollywood and talk to a couple of producers he’d contacted about the film rights.
Life was good, but he thought it could get better yet. He’d called Breman and told her to meet him at the office for two reasons. The first was—as Breman had surmised—to make sure she understood who was in charge. He figured that if she was willing to drive to Harlem on a cold night in December to be given marching orders, she was his whore for the duration.
The second reason was that for all his meticulous planning, dangers remained dangers. The major difficulty was that for some inexplicable reason, Igor Kaminsky was still alive.
The idiot brute Lynd was supposed to have taken care of the problem but now he was worm meat. Then the brain-dead ghetto niggers sitting on his couch couldn’t count to two—the number of arms the man they’d shoved in front of the train had—and so the one-armed Kaminsky lived to rat on them another day.
Otherwise, there was only one other loose end that he had to worry about—and he didn’t think it was much of a concern. At the original trial, a teenage female named Hannah Little had testified that Kwasama Jones admitted to her over the telephone that Sykes and Davis had raped Liz Tyler. Hannah’s brother, Kevin, had been one of the five originally charged for the attack on Liz Tyler, but he’d agreed to a plea deal and testified against the other four.
Sykes had used his gang affiliations to find Kevin in California and have him killed in a staged drive-by shooting. He’d planned to have Hannah killed, too, but she’d disappeared from Bedford-Stuyvesant shortly after he
r brother’s death and hadn’t been heard from since. She could present a problem if the investigators working for the city found her, but given the long silence, Louis believed that she was too intimidated to come forward at this late date.
Which brought him back to Breman. He knew she’d talked herself into believing that she was “doing the right thing” in the cause of justice; he’d pounded that notion at her enough. But what if the letter from Kaminsky made her think again about Villalobos’s confession?
Louis knew his clients were guilty of the crime and that Villalobos was lying—he’d insisted on knowing and Sykes had filled him in with a smirk. But Louis didn’t care; some middle-class white bitch getting raped wasn’t worth the millions he stood to make by representing the Coney Island Four. But he was worried that Breman might grow a conscience because of the Kaminsky letter. Or, if the little shit came forward, that she would find it politically expedient to turn on him. Louis needed to make sure she was his.
Louis cleared his throat, took a sip of his drink, and asked, “Have you heard from that lying piece of shit Kaminsky fella who wrote you a while back?”
The question elicited a pang of guilt from Breman. She’d read the letter when it first arrived and sat on it for a couple of days. If what Kaminsky said was true, and it came out, she was going to have a lot of explaining to do. All sorts of questions might be raised about why she had capitulated so quickly and not followed procedures in dealing with Villalobos. So she took the letter to her mentor, District Judge Marci Klinger, who also happened to be presiding over the Coney Island Four lawsuit.
Klinger was another castoff from the New York District Attorney’s Office. She’d come aboard in the waning days of Garrahy’s reign, recommended by one of his colleagues who’d done it as a favor to a friend, her father. But the recommendation only went so far, and she’d proved to be a mediocre prosecutor at best. But, as she’d later taught her protégée Breman to emulate, Klinger had involved herself early and often in party politics and when a spot on the bench opened up as a result of the sudden and unexpected death of its owner, she’d inveigled the appointment with the help of her dad, a major contributor to the party.
Fury (The Butch Karp and Marlene Ciampi Series Book 17) Page 14