by David Wood
“So this was Kidd’s church, huh?” Bones asked.
“It was.” Avery quickly donned the mantle of lecturing professor. “Not this building, of course. This is actually the third Trinity Church. The original structure was built in 1698. During its construction, Kidd even lent the runner and tackle from his ship to help them move the stones.”
“That’s pretty old, for white Americans, that is.” Bones gave her an evil grin and Maddock chuckled. “The cemetery looks pretty cool. Maybe we’ll have time to check it out.”
“There are a lot of famous people buried here and in Trinity’s other two cemeteries. Alexander Hamilton, Horacio Gates, Robert Fulton, John Jacob Astor...”
“Wait, the Jingleheimer Schmidt guy is buried here?” Before Avery could reply, Bones laughed and gave her arm a squeeze.
“Good thing Angel isn’t here. She’d have punched you for that one.” Maddock felt a pang of regret and realized how quickly he’d grown accustomed to Angel’s presence. He missed her easy laugh, her self-confidence, and the way she rode herd on Bones.
“Yeah. Don’t you know she’s climbing the walls in that rinky dink jail?”
“You don’t seem too concerned that your sister is sitting in a jail cell,” Avery said. “Are you two not close?”
“She’s fine.” Bones waved her concern away like a wisp of smoke. “This isn’t Angel’s first rodeo. She wasn’t as bad as me when we were kids, but she had her moments. I just feel sorry for her jailer. You think I can get under someone’s skin, you ought to see her in action.”
Maddock smiled at the thought, but couldn’t escape a feeling of guilt that they hadn’t found a way to get her out of her predicament.
They spent a moment longer admiring the church and the grounds, soaking in the history.
“Doesn’t it seem like we go to a lot of these places?” Bones asked.
“Yeah, but no complaints here.” Maddock examined the architecture, its blend of sturdy lines and artistic trappings. He loved these pockets of history that stood against the disposable construction of recent generations “At least, not too many complaints.”
“You guys keep dropping these little comments about places you’ve gone and things you’ve done,” Avery said, “but you won’t dish. It’s starting to tick me off.” She gave them each the evil eye and stalked into the church.
Maddock grimaced and looked at Bones, who chuckled.
“She’s a spitfire.” He started to say something, then hesitated. It was a strange thing for Maddock to witness. Bones was never uncertain about anything. At least, he never let it show. “Say, Maddock, I’ve been meaning to ask you something.”
“All right. Shoot.” As eager as he was to go inside and begin the search, he was, at the moment, even more curious about what Bones wanted to talk about.
“It’s kind of weird for a guy to have a thing for his best friend’s sister, don’t you think?”
Maddock felt his face grow hot. All his conflicted feelings about Angel rose anew. Had he been that obvious? How long had Bones known?
“Bones, I don’t know what to say.”
“Look, if you want me to stay away from her, I will. She’s your sister and I don’t want to mess up our friendship, but I wouldn’t mind hanging out with her. She’s cool.” He looked at Maddock then looked away.
It took Maddock a moment to realize what Bones was talking about, and then he laughed.
“Oh! You mean Avery.” Relief flooded through him.
“Yeah. Wait, who did you think I meant?” Bones cocked his head and looked quizzically at him.
“Nobody.” He quickened his pace and didn’t meet Bones’ eye. “Yeah, that’s cool. I could tell you have a thing for her, and she’s only been my sister for a couple of days.”
“Dude, you suck at math. She’s been your sister all her life.”
“You know what I mean. It might be different if we’d grown up together.”
“Yeah, that might be a little different.” Bones sounded thoughtful.
“We’d better get going.” He strode through the gate, headed toward the entrance, relieved Bones didn’t press the issue.
By the time they caught up with Avery, she had used her credentials and charm to gain a look at the journal. She sat at at table under the close scrutiny of an archivist, a stocky man with light brown hair, blue eyes, and a youthful face. He gave Bones a funny look before returning his attention to Avery, who was carefully turning the pages with gloved fingers. Maddock and Bones sat down on either side of her and watched her work.
The journal was thin, its pages yellow, and the script faded. Avery worked her way through the book at a steady pace, her blue eyes moving back and forth across the page as she devoured the text, putting Maddock to mind of a typewriter carriage. When she finally reached the end, she frowned.
“What is it?” Maddock asked.
Avery held up her hand, cutting off further questions, and slowly leafed back through the journal. After a few pages, she paused and leaned closer.
“Careful,” the archivist cautioned. “No sneezing or drooling allowed.” He smiled, but his comment was not entirely meant to be humorous.
“Pages have been torn out.” Avery slid the book across the table so the archivist could take a closer look. The ragged edges were just visible.
“Are you sure?” The man took a closer look. “Holy crap.” He dragged it out into a good four syllables, and Maddock thought he detected a trace of a southern accent, so out of place in the heart of New York City. “I’m sorry. I’m going to have to take this back.” He donned a pair of gloves and gingerly reclaimed the journal from Avery.
“Do you know if the page was there when it came into your collection?” Maddock asked.
“I assume so, but I haven’t read the entire thing. The donor is meticulous and I think she would have mentioned if it was incomplete.”
“Who else has looked at the journal since it came into your collection?” Avery sounded like a prosecuting attorney interrogating a witness, and her manner seemed to take the man aback.
“Only the...” He reddened and shook his head. “Only the donor.” He averted his eyes, but Maddock could see the lie there.
The guy was obviously protecting someone, but who, and for what reason? Instinct told Maddock that the archivist was not a bad sort. Maddock decided to take a chance.
“The part of the journal you read, was there any mention of Captain Kidd?”
“There was.” The man’s face brightened. “It was interesting and a little weird. Kidd was in trouble with the crown and he knew it, so he came to Vesey because he said he had a secret he wanted to confess. Vesey doesn’t go into detail, but Kidd says a secret was entrusted to him that he didn’t want to let die. He gave Vesey what he called a ‘treasured possession,’ but Vesey inspected it later and couldn’t see that it had any value.”
“Did he say what it was?” Avery had stripped off her gloves and now clutched the edge of the table.
The man shook his head.
“We’re interested in Vesey,” Maddock began. “Are any of his personal effects on display at the church, or anywhere else? Maybe a wooden chest?”
“There is an old chest that’s bounced around the church since Vesey’s time, though I don’t know if it belonged to him. It’s nothing fancy, and has been ill used, I’m afraid. It was passed around and used for storage until someone finally realized its age and thought it was worth preserving. At the moment it’s in St. Paul’s Chapel.”
Avery smiled and nodded at Maddock. The pieces were falling into place. They thanked the man and left the chapel in a hurry. When they reached the street, Avery didn’t pause, but turned left and took off down the sidewalk at a fast walk that bordered on a jog.
“So where is St. Paul’s?” Bones asked, his long legs allowing him to easily keep stride with her.
“Just a few blocks down the street,” she said. “It’s a part of Trinity Church. I know where it is, but I’ve ne
ver been there. It’s even at the corner of Broadway and Vesey Street. I’m so stupid.”
“You’re just like Maddock. Don’t be so hard on yourself,” Bones began, but clammed up at one look from Avery.
St. Paul’s was a Georgian-style church, boxy and surmounted by an octagonal tower on a square base. From the Broadway side, a portico sheltered a statue of Saint Paul, which was flanked by double doors on either side. To the left of the entrance, in a fenced, grassy area, stood an obelisk, on which was carved an eagle and a man’s profile. Maddock wondered if this Masonic symbol could have any connection to the Templars who built the church beneath Oak Island.
The interior of the chapel was elegant, but was not awe-inspiring like Trinity Church. Cut glass chandeliers cast slivers of light across the ceiling and the rows of white pews. All around them, banners memorializing the tragic events of the terrorist attack on the World Trade Center a decade before hung as stark reminders of the disaster that St. Paul’s had, according to Avery, miraculously avoided.
They fell in with the other tourists and made their way around the church. The history of the place was interesting. It had withstood not only the 2001 attack, but also the Great New York City Fire of 1776. Both George Washington and Lord Cornwallis had worshiped here at different times, as well as other figures of historical significance. Though he found it all interesting, Maddock was growing impatient. Where was the chest?
And then he saw it.
A simple, wooden chest sat atop a plain table in the back corner. It was afforded no special place. In fact, it was being used to hold brochures. Maddock took that as a good sign. No one who knew anything about the Kidd legend or the potential connection between this chest and the legendary pirate would ever put it to such a pedestrian use. If this was the chest they sought, there was a good chance its secret remained undiscovered.
He nudged Avery and inclined his head toward the chest. Her eyes lit up.
“That’s it. It’s identical to the one Dad found.” She took a hasty step in toward the back corner, but Bones grabbed her by the arm.
“Slowly,” he said. “Don’t draw undue attention to yourself.”
They moved casually in the direction of the chest, still looking around as if no single thing held their interest. When they reached the corner, Maddock turned to Bones.
“Turn around and look scary.”
“Can do, boss.” Bones pretended to answer his phone, twisted his face into an agitated scowl, and began speaking in a harsh whisper. Maddock had to admit Bones was a pretty good actor when he put his mind to it.
“Let’s see if it opens the same way as the other chest.” Avery pressed her finger against a raised wooden square and moved it side to side, then up and down in the shape of a cross. The square came free, revealing a hidden compartment.
Smiling, Avery reached in and removed a brass cylinder, uncapped the end, and plucked out a roll of aged paper, much like the Oak Island map. She handed the cylinder to Maddock and was about to unroll the paper when someone called out.
“What’s this now? Give me that.”
A big man with a shaved head approached them from near the doorway. If his British accent didn’t set off warning bells, his hand resting on the pistol at his hip did. The man took a step closer and held out his free hand.
“That’s right, hand it over now.”
Maddock tossed the cylinder at the man’s face and, as the fellow reached up to grab it, drove his fist into the man’s chin. The big man’s knees turned to rubber and he went down in a heap, his eyes glassy. Maddock grabbed Avery by the arm and steered her toward the door. All around them, people were talking and pointing. A few had taken out cell phones and were probably calling the police.
“He was a Red Sox fan,” Bones explained before following Maddock and Avery out the door.
Beneath the portico, Maddock looked out at the street and saw a dark-haired man leaning against the fence that ran along the sidewalk. Their eyes met and the man stood ramrod straight and reached behind his back.
“Gun!” Maddock shouted. Still holding Avery by the arm, he made a hard right and ran around the corner of the church and onto the churchyard. They sprinted past the obelisk just as a bullet deflected off its surface.
“Looks like it’s time to call in the cavalry!” Bones shouted, punching up a number on his phone while running at full speed. “Church Street at Fulton,” he barked, then tucked the phone back inside his leather jacket.
They dashed through the cemetery, navigating the tombs, hurdling low gravestones, and ducking in and out of the trees that shaded the yard. They reached the end of the church and veered to the right just as another muffled pop sounded and a bullet buzzed past Maddock’s ear. The streets were busy, but the guy didn’t seem to care who he might hit.
“Get Avery to the street.”
Bones nodded and pulled her along, ignoring her protests.
Maddock leaned against the wall and waited. He heard the sound of footfalls and someone breathing hard. As their pursuer came around the corner, eyes on the receding figures of Bones and Angel, and his pistol leveled, Maddock lashed out with a vicious roundhouse kick, catching the man across the shins and sweeping his legs out from under him. He landed face down on the stone path with a sickening thud, his breath leaving him in a rush.
Maddock hastily relieved him of his weapon, as well as a radio and cell phone. He rolled the man over. His nose was broken, his forehead split, and his face thick with blood and mucous. He gasped for breath, staring up at Maddock with hate-filled eyes.
“I know you’re Locke’s man,” Maddock snarled. “You tell him to back off. I might not be so nice to the next man who takes a shot at me. Got it?”
“You...” the man panted... “don’t give orders... to Locke. He has... something you want.”
“What do you mean?” Had Locke found the other chest?
The man clammed up.
“Maddock! Get over here!” Bones called from the street.
Maddock left the man lying there and ran toward the sound of his friend’s voice, dashing through the gate and arriving on the sidewalk by the entrance to the Church Street Subway station just as a motorcycle screeched to a halt in front of them, scattering pedestrians who shouted and cursed. Willis raised the face shield and smiled broadly at them. He loved bikes.
“Matt and Corey are on the way.” He said.
“Get Avery out of here,” Maddock told him.
This time, Avery didn’t argue, but leapt onto the back of the bike, pulled on the spare helmet, and wrapped her arms around Willis as he rocketed out into traffic.
“Look out!” Bones shouted, pushing Maddock to the ground as a bullet whistled over their heads and the few people who hadn’t been driven away by Willis’s bike ran for the subway or the churchyard. The big man from inside the church had recovered his wits, circled around the outside of the churchyard, and was now coming at them head-on.
Maddock reached for his Walther but, before he could draw it, a beat-up van flashed past them, and bounded up onto the sidewalk. As it drew even with the approaching man, the passenger stuck out his arm, encased in a hard cast, and clotheslined their attacker under the chin, linebacker style. The surprised man flew backward and tumbled down the stairs to the subway.
“Holy crap, that hurt!” Matt groaned as Maddock and Bones clambered into the van and Corey hit the gas. Sirens sounded in the distance but Maddock wasn’t worried. They’d be long gone before the police arrived. Besides, it had been the other guys shooting at them, and in front of witnesses at that, and neither was in any condition to get up and run.
“Why did you hit him with your cast?” Maddock asked as Corey wove the van through traffic.
“I don’t know, it seemed like something Bones would do,” Matt groaned, holding his arm to his chest.
“Amen to that, my brother.” Bones high-fived Matt’s good hand. “Nice rescue, by the way.”
“Did you find it?” Corey asked, eyes l
ocked on the street. “Because if I get points on my license, I want it to be for a good cause.”
“We did, and as soon as we catch up with Willis and Avery, we’ll see where it leads.”
Chapter 22
“Let’s see what we’ve got here.” Avery took out the paper they’d recovered from the chest and laid it on the table in their hotel room. She carefully unrolled it, revealing another map. Unlike the Oak Island map, however, there was no code to break. Instead, someone had added on to the original map. The older, more faded ink, showed a river and a stretch of shoreline. A dotted line led inland to a spot marked with a cross. Distances were lined out to specific landmarks: a tree, a boulder, and a bend in a stream. In the bottom right corner, the creator of the map had drawn three of the cross-in-circle symbols they’d seen on Oak Island arranged in a triangle around another familiar symbol- two Knights on a horse. Over the top of this map, someone had inked in a street, a building, and an “x.”
“That’s the cross symbol we saw at Oak Island,” Maddock said, pointing to the corner of the map.
“I don’t believe it,” Avery said. “This is Trinity Church.”
Maddock hadn’t even noticed the labels. Sure enough, the street was labeled “Wall” and the building “Trinity.”
“Kidd, or one of his contemporaries, must have added these details,” he said. “The land had probably changed so much that the landmarks on the original map were useless.”
“So, once more into the breach?” Bones asked, drawing an amused look from Avery. Maddock had long ago grown accustomed to Bones’ occasional lapses in which he let his intelligence show, but people who didn’t know him well were sometimes taken unaware.