Entering the Vancouver branch thirty years ago, Rowena wore an ankle-length coat, black wool. Richard walked behind, royal consort. She was tall, pale; the fashionable coat gave her still more height and presence. This twenty-something pair were fresh to the Coast, had just driven his old beater cross-country from the movement’s Centre in Toronto. Who forked over for that garment? Not Ms. Radical, who never had a nickel for the collection bucket. Her man was taller, paler, with a curly smile, and bent to Rowena like a folding measuring-stick. They wore Beatles glasses. His long hair was carroty red, hers a stream of black.
Sally, the assistant organizer, stood no chance. Her stocky build would have made that coat grotesque, and her face—after years of poverty, fluorescent light, cheap food, the stress of political crises—was sallow mud. Organizer Pete’s skin was as coarse. Unimportant, for an important man. Nor did his hands matter, stained by Gestetner, silk-screen, spirit ditto, Remington and Underwood. He and Sally exuded the twinnish affect of the long-coupled. Pals.
Cordially they brought the new comrades to the hall’s kitchen for the Friday supper, and sat by them: Sally, Richard, Rowena, Pete. I was there, only a contact, not seated by the leaders, but I too saw Pete draw on the paper table-cover a map of downtown. As Rowena watched, his ballpoint showed the route for the anti-war march coming up in April 1971.
“See?”
“You’re the chief marshal?” Admiring gaze. Wide eyes. The works.
Pete blushed.
Richard’s death thirty years later, a week ago: sad. Not tragic, like those of others once in the movement, Josie, Bruce.
In today’s newspaper, tomorrow’s, Richard wouldn’t rate a line of print, but last week the Sun did note yet another drunk driver’s kill: male, 55, credit union manager. No family mentioned. Local TV showed a rainy crosswalk. Diagonally across the white stripes, a reflective yellow jacket. Long legs scissoring. A crushed bike.
Right after Richard and Rowena’s arrival on the Coast, anti-war worked hard to build the protest against America’s war in Vietnam. What hard means, people unfamiliar with radical politics have no idea. Friends of mine do time in the standard parties, but even if angry, worn out, tricked of victory, they’re safe. Secure. The left that I knew felt itself alone on a shattering rim.
That march was a huge success, Vancouver’s biggest to date, the cops nearly brutal. Seventeen seconds on The National.
At the movement’s social that night (the hall antic with exhausted revelry), the assistant organizer located me in the crowded half-dark. The Age of Aquarius reverberated so that Sally had to repeat her question.
“Cathy, could you find space for a comrade?”
“Catherine. I don’t understand?”
She explained. How humiliating.
My apartment then had an odd ell off the hallway where I stored camping gear.
“Of course!”
Sally obviously wanted to leave at once. I had no one to stay for. Silent, she walked by me down the hill towards the West End, where freighters’ lights glinted on English Bay’s blackness. The mountains, invisible.
At my place, as we cleared away tent and paddles to roll out foam and sleeping bag, I accidentally touched her arm. Tense. Almost rigid.
The next week, two small cartons and a suitcase appeared. The revolutionary stored her food in a corner of the fridge and washed her few dishes right away.
“I’ll be gone by month’s end,” paying her share of the rent to the penny.
Why did Sally ask a contact for refuge? Not a comrade. Not even a former comrade who’d dropped to sympathizer. Among the latter, old Duncan had heroic status, having gone to Spain with the Mac-Pap brigade. Others had cachet if they’d continued radical work in unions or the NDP, but most were judged as simply having failed to cut the mustard.
In Vancouver as elsewhere, thousands came around the far-left in the 1960s, 70s. Some were just here on a visit, as the comrades said, but others lasted over a decade, into the death years. I did. Rowena was soon history, off to write her dirty work—aka gossip columns—for any paying rag, but Richard, another relict, kept on through turn and fusion, faction and split, all the while studying accountancy.
Those two trees on that greeting card—why alone? Logging? Fire?
Ten decades ago, where I live was little more than tracks hacked out of ancient forest. A paddler by the shore, once past the False Creek sawmills, would have seen little through the trees but wisps of wood-stove smoke. Now it’s all towers and traffic.
Not long after Sally came to my place, on returning from a late movie I heard moans in the ell. Walk by, brush teeth, bed. A strangled concluding gasp. The apartment door closed, the street door. Out my room’s window I saw a comrade walk away.
Next morning, Sally and I stapled some beach-towels into a curtain to shield the open end of her space.
Some of the almost nightly men were comrades, one a leading trade unionist and friend of Pete’s. This trophy pleased me. Where she got the others I don’t know. None stayed over. Sally then was thirty-five, I a decade older. Did she, wrongly, believe herself still young? At her age I failed to detach a man from his marriage. A pretty woman succeeded. No later chances at a long-term connection came my way. As for Rowena, she could have been my daughter.
What did we contacts do? What comrades did: cook Friday suppers, staff the bar at socials, distribute leaflets, paint banners, address envelopes, put up posters, sell newspapers, drive (few comrades had cars) to the demo, the printer, post office, bus depot, union hall, women’s centre, airport, ferry terminal, liquor store, hospital. We donated toilet and typing and carbon paper, paper towels, paper for silkscreening. We gave cash. What we couldn’t do: participate in the branch to decide the line.
My first act of witness occurred while on an errand at the Courthouse.
On its legal steps stood perhaps a dozen people, in chilly rain. Stop the War in Vietnam, their placards demanded. Alone they stood, held, were stared at. Thus I learned that my small hatred of America’s invasion wasn’t unique.
My notary’s office, my cubby, overlooked False Creek. Weeks later those same people, a twig of the Fourth International’s Canadian section, rented space downstairs. The storefront window advertised their forums, also meetings of a local anti-war group. I went. Again, again.
Having been in my thirties still imprisoned by hopes of marriage, I’d only seen on TV the huge Ban the Bomb marches surge over Burrard Bridge, Now I began to live in the vigour of anti-war. The slogans grew nuanced, transitional: End Canada’s Complicity, Bring the Troops Home, Don’t Do Uncle Sam’s Dirty Work. Clean bombs, dirty: that distinction featured in 50s war-talk too, then in the 80s, 90s.
The language of the 00s won’t differ. Today that’s beyond doubt. Dirty work. Someone’s got to do it.
Another, later discovery and distinction: I opposed all war. The comrades didn’t.
Professionally I did little for the branch. In British Columbia we’re scrivener notaries, with more powers than in many other jurisdictions, but revolutionaries don’t redeem stocks and bonds or purchase real estate overseas—not that I frequently oversaw such tasks. Often, notaries just witness. (That again.) This person is who she claims to be. This document does what it purports to do. Law school hadn’t been an option. I got over that; most people change shape to fit. I did review the branch’s lease with Pete, and gave advice after Maoists smashed the print-room window, but a lawyer was needed when two Youth got charged with resisting arrest.
Once I did assist children of the revolution. An anguished narrative of cross-border separation, separation, separation, divorce, illness, death, grief preceded these relicts. The extant parent needed a notary to satisfy US authorities that certain monies could be paid to the youths, or, in one case, to the parent in trust. All the real decisions long predated that amputated family’s arrival in my cubby.
The organizer a
nd assistant organizer, Pete and Sally, side by side for years before The Age of Aquarius dawned, though uprooted by Rowena still must confer. Avoiding their private office, they worked at a card table in the main hall. Low voices. Eyes on file-folders. Nearby, a work-party collated a pamphlet critiquing social democracy. Even we contacts knew that Sally’d asked the Centre for a transfer to Edmonton, Windsor, anywhere.
A chair banged to the floor, a high-speed hand met a face.
Sally rushed out.
We picked up page three, four. Pete didn’t touch his flaming cheek. The stapler bit sets of sheets. He folded the card table, went to the office, shut the door. Dialling. Soon, a honk in the back alley. He left. We finished our assignment.
Even with my bedroom door closed, I heard Sally and the man.
What did all that fucking mean? With Pete, had the basics of release, satisfaction, been rare? So easy to despise another thoughtless man whose cock makes his life-choices—yet Sally’s sex at my place did seem routinist, the movement’s term for one kind of political thought and action. A clinical assessment: nearly dead. They arrived about half-past eleven, she and someone, when the news was over and I’d finished in the bathroom. Soft footsteps. Flushes. Murmurs. Darkness, stillness, then the sounds.
After some nights of regret I’d been so accommodating, of wishing my guests would hurry up and be done with it so we could all get some sleep, I found my own breasts tingling. To touch myself with others nearby, unaware, was novel. Exciting. I stuffed the sheet’s hem in my mouth. My body became more eager, until when they entered my place I’d already be in bed, lights out, my hands moving. To keep myself from coming till at least one of them did was a painful pleasure.
I slept well. Sally’s morning face was porridge-grey, her shoulders curled as if to block further injury to her core.
Satisfaction. Is that what I felt last week, shoving Rowena’s envelope in the mailbox? Even at seventy-five, I don’t know.
Perhaps it’s me who wants condolences, sympathy for not being the relict of an old pair with dead roots still strong, romantic.
On Fridays before the forums, Sally with Pete still welcomed everyone to supper, she as ever a little shy, he affable. During his post-movement years with NGOs in Zimbabwe and Kenya, that trait surely served Pete well.
At the meal itself he sat by Rowena.
Sally, her back to them, chose another table.
Pale Richard ate anywhere. His eyelids had the rusty edges, sore-looking, that some redheads get, and he communed with his chili or hash as if in a room where no other steps sounded. I know that room. He didn’t converse. I and others tried, more than once.
During dessert, Pete rose to announce upcoming events. One night came great news: a French comrade, direct from the International, would expand his North American speaking itinerary to include our outpost.
Such a buzz over the canned pears!
Sally got up also, unusually, to remind us that North America’s struggle too was crucial for world revolution. As always, correct. Yet who’d choose to hear postal worker Helen on mechanization’s threat, again, when with Raoul we’d enter French anti-war? Helen was no Jeanne Moreau. In our heads 1968 still shimmered. Aznavour, Belmondo. We contacts, no matter our age and the pears’ tinny taste, just then felt part of us.
Those tragic deaths.
Josie. Only seventeen, she asked such urgent and politically naive questions that the Youth snickered. Older comrades winced, kept a kind eye. In a matter of weeks her speech fragmented. A brain tumour lopped off her life.
Saplings planted alongside city sidewalks often wear necklaces. Please water me. For all its rain, this climate may not provide enough. Some don’t survive. During winter, dead young trees look just like live ones. The surprise comes in April.
Near those trees on Rowena’s card was there a river, a wriggle of blue?
Comrade Bruce was forty-five but took the split hard, a child of bitter political divorce. Less than a year later he was running drugs across the Montana-Alberta border. A train killed him. His last joe-job for the International had been to remove the bright posters, banners, placards from the storefront.
The empty hall: unbearable.
A friend of mine, a commissioner of oaths, had found a spacious office in Gastown, above a typewriter shop, and suggested we share.
In 1990, a thousand affidavits later, Claudia and I retired from witnessing how rough human existence is, how knotty, contaminated.
Gladly, the computer store beneath expanded into our space. Such limited powers each of us has. Now Claudia and other friends and I sit around our dinner tables, shocked at how little time remains. Some men, lovers, husbands, are already gone. Fewer places are set. The past looks impenetrable, like islands as a kayak moves away; individual landforms coalesce into one dark shape, no visible channels in.
Why did so many contacts not turn into comrades?
Cowardice.
Fear of democratic centralism: Join that group, Carry this line.
Dues. Some people won’t spend even on what’s important to them.
Me? I couldn’t accept The end justifies the means and By any means necessary, i.e. violence. All the Romanovs needn’t have died. Nor the Kronstadt sailors. To give only two examples. No doubt the comrade assigned long ago to have a serious political talk with Cathy (repeatedly I had to claim my full name) made her report. Written off as a liberal, I thought as I pleased while newly alive in anti-war pickets, marches, vigils, tribunals organized by Trotskyists alone or with other groups on hard-won bases of unity sometimes narrow, sometimes broad.
Ten years ago, as the US did its filthy work in Iraq and the ground war began, Vancouver’s February streets filled again, differently: Operation Desert Storm.
Amid thronging youth walked relicts like me, surviving from a previous age or in changed circumstances after the disappearance of related forms, species, structures. Bald Richard, wheeling his bicycle along the route from the Main Street train station to the once-Courthouse, told me of his volunteer work repairing bikes in the Downtown East Side. As the bullhorns assembled, I turned to say, “Shall we get out of here?” But he’d already taken a pass on the orations.
A puzzle, that 1991 meeting with Richard. He didn’t seem an apparition from a distant past. I already knew (how?) that he’d worked at a credit union. At some point after the far left imploded in the late 70s and before the Gulf invasion, he and I must have met. I don’t remember.
Later in the 90s he turned up at the local farmers’ market, smiling as he bent to show customers his loaves of rye and seedy bread. Occasionally I buy from Richard. Bought. We’d chat, as friendly relicts do. Homeward with organic this and that along the flowering streets, I’d speculate. Which causes most harm—cruelty, thoughtlessness, meaning well?
To accommodate Raoul, the French Trotskyist, an entire month of forums had been rescheduled. He—a short, plain man, the first disappointment—came to the hall with Pete and Sally the evening before his talk.
Just then comrades and contacts were doing a mailing about the Caravan to Ottawa planned by Vancouver’s women’s liberation: a cross-country drive to the capital, en route gathering supporters to demand changes in the abortion laws. A Great Trek, as in the 30s. Something big could happen. Everyone sensed that. Mass action, even. We folded leaflets, stuffed envelopes.
The task brought me as close to the sisterhood as I ever got. Yes, I’d attended some meetings of independent WL groups. The girls—no, young women—were friendly, but because of work I couldn’t stay up late on weeknights, nor could I sit on the floor as they did for hours, talking. Already it wasn’t easy to kneel for a full morning’s paddle in a canoe. Also my hair was permed. I wore heels and suits and a girdle and a sturdy bra. A living fossil. Now I’ll admit that their sexual exuberance intimidated me. Nothing to be done about that, then or now.
A
fter introducing Raoul, Pete and Sally left for an external meeting. She walked out first, looking back as if puzzled he wasn’t at her side. Only when she reached the street door did he follow.
The Frenchman helped us, efficiently, and in spite of his exoticism the atmosphere soon normalized. He learned some names (not mine), asked about local women’s politics and anti-war, but the conversation jolted. His English was far from fluent. We had to rephrase, oversimplify. I hoped he planned to read his speech.
Our work done, Raoul yawned, smiled. “I’d so much wish to ski while at Vancouver!“
Silence. Ski! How bourgeois! Not among French revolutionaries, evidently.
Pete and Sally never even headed out to camp, paddle, hike. Never drove to Seattle for a weekend. Rarely saw a movie. However, some of my friends skied. I went cross-country myself occasionally, though I’ve always loved liquid water best.
My voice sounded. “Rowena might drive you up to Cypress.”
By coincidence she arrived in the hall soon after, long coat swaying, hair shining. Now, in the photo heading Rowena’s theatre column and in her spreads on glamorous Down syndrome and lupus fundraisers, her hair’s still black. She’s only mid-fifties, though. Dye won’t yet cause that awful stiffness characteristic of hollow white hairs.
“Of course!” Lightly, smiling.
After this foray I was breathless.
The next night, Raoul stood before an overflow audience. He glanced at Rowena. To me she was in profile, eyes unseen, but I’d have bet a month’s income on the quality of her gaze. Sally introduced the speaker. His smiling thanks, so patronizing: handsome male to plain female. Anger ran me up and down. Already fired with joy at what I’d instigated, I sensed a sudden all-over heat and for a while heard nothing.
When sound began again, the atmosphere had gone wrong. Everyone lay open to the delights of political seduction, but that Frenchman, so expert and experienced, just hadn’t the tongue. We weren’t inside French anti-war. We were nowhere special. Fidgets, coughs. Flirtatiously, Raoul glanced at Sally for help. Once, twice, she supplied an English word or phrases. Then quit. Stared.
Red Girl Rat Boy Page 11