I put my car in gear and drove over and parked sideways behind both their cars and got out. I took hold of Garner by the back of his coat collar and pulled him away from Beth Ann.
“You are causing an embarrassing scene,” I said.
He twisted and tried to hit me. I slapped his fist away. Beth Ann tried to run past us. I caught hold of her arm with my free hand and pulled her back.
“Why can’t we all just get along,” I said to them.
They both said variations of “Let go of me.” He tried to hit me again. I let go of Beth Ann, and punched him in the solar plexus. He gasped and bent over and when I let him go, stumbled back against his car, trying to get his breath. Beth Ann had started off again. She was wearing three-inch heels and ran badly in them. I caught her in two steps and brought her back.
“You have no place to run, anyway,” I said.
“He threatened me,” she said, her breath heaving. “The bastard threatened to kill me.”
“Did not,” Garner gasped.
There was a picnic table on a small patch of grass at the corner of the parking lot.
“Let us sit over there,” I said, “and talk.”
“No . . .” Beth Ann said.
Garner had straightened. Still leaning against the car, he shook his head no.
“I wasn’t asking,” I said. “Someone has probably called the cops, and you might want to get calmed down and have a story ready when they get here.”
Both of them looked horrified. It was something they’d never considered. The three of us walked across the parking lot and sat at the table. In the distance, I could hear a siren.
“You had a little sort of lovers’ spat,” I said. “I, in a friendly way, intervened, and now we’ve talked it out and no one has any complaints to register.”
Both of them heard the siren, too. Neither of them said anything. Beth Ann was still flushed, but Garner was very pale.
58
A STATE POLICE CAR pulled up in front of the restaurant building, and a big trooper got out and went in. In a moment, he came back out with two people. They talked. He nodded. They pointed toward us. He nodded. As he walked across the lot toward the picnic table, a second cruiser pulled in and parked behind his.
The big trooper stopped at our table. I recognized him. It was one of the two Staties who, at DiBella’s request, had brought Animal to the state maintenance shed for me to reason with. He looked at me. I looked at him.
“DiBella’s friend,” the cop said.
“Sort of,” I said.
“I understand there was some trouble here,” the cop said, and looked at Garner and Beth Ann.
Garner gathered himself.
“I’m afraid it was just a lovers’ spat, officer.”
The cop looked at Beth Ann. “You agree with that?” he said.
She smiled at him, which was pretty impressive.
“Yes. I feel like a fool,” she said. “But Roy and I . . . we lost our tempers at the same time.”
“You?” the cop said to me.
“I happened upon them, and intervened and managed to reconcile them.”
The cop looked at me and shook his head. But he didn’t comment.
“Either of you wish to file any kind of complaint?” he said to the happy couple.
“No, sir,” Garner said.
“We’re fine,” Beth Ann said.
The trooper looked at me. “Everything’s fine,” I said.
“You people better learn to settle your differences another way,” he said. “I get another complaint and I won’t be so easy about it.”
He and I both knew that was a crock. He hadn’t even taken their names. But he and I both knew also that idle threats work sometimes.
“It won’t happen again, officer,” Garner said.
“Absolutely not,” Beth Ann said and smiled again at the cop.
The smile was effective. It managed to suggest somehow that she’d like to have sex with him. Which, of course, could have been true. The cop looked at me again.
“That your Mustang there?” he said.
“I’ll move it at once,” I said.
He nodded. “You all have a nice day,” he said.
He walked back across the parking lot and stopped next to the second cruiser. He spoke to the second cop for a few minutes, then got into his own car and both of them pulled away. The three of us at our picnic table were silent for a bit.
Then Beth Ann looked at Garner and said, “You cocksucker.”
“You keep your damned mouth shut,” he said to her. “Just remember what I told you, and keep your damn mouth shut.”
Garner stood then and stalked away toward his car, which he couldn’t drive away in because I had him blocked.
“Could you move your damned car?” he said.
59
BEFORE I MOVED MY CAR, I reached in and took the keys out of Beth’s. When Garner was gone, I walked back to the picnic table, sat across from her, and put the keys on the table.
She didn’t speak. Neither did I. We listened to the steady sound of traffic from the pike. A burly woman in pink shorts and a white T-shirt walked a very small fuzzy white dog near us. I smiled at the dog. The dog paid me no attention.
“What do you see in him?” I said after a while.
Beth Ann looked at the table and shook her head.
“He’s kind of soft and dumpy,” I said. “But he’s very annoying.”
Beth Ann shook her head again. It might have been disagreement. It might have been regret. The white dog accomplished its mission on the small plot of grass, and the burly woman took it away. She was wearing some sort of sandals with elevated soles, and she walked with a lumbering wobble. From my inside coat pocket I took a copy of the photograph I’d found in Beth Ann’s freezer and placed it on the table in front of her, next to her keys. She looked down at it without any reaction for a moment. Then she said, “It was you,” and turned the photo facedown on the table, and put her face into her hands and moaned. I didn’t say anything. No one was near us. I sat, quietly listening to the traffic and the wind and the occasional scraps of conversation that the wind brought us from people as they walked to their cars. The cooking smell from the restaurant was strong.
“You have it too,” she said finally.
“Too?” I said.
“He has a copy.”
“Garner?”
“Yes.”
I sat back. It wasn’t that I couldn’t think of questions. I thought of too many, and they were all jockeying for position.
With her face still pressed into her hands, Beth Ann said, “It’s not what you think.”
“I think it’s a picture of you naked with Jared Clark when he was even younger than he is now.”
She kept her face in her hands and shook her head again.
“Oh, God,” she said.
While she was contemplating whatever ruins she saw in the palms of her hands, I got my questions sequenced.
“Garner has a copy of this picture?”
Face in hands, she nodded.
“How did he get it?”
“He . . . he’s so weird,” she said. “At night, sometimes he goes through the school, searching lockers.”
“What lockers,” I said.
“Student lockers, faculty lockers. I don’t know why. He said he was making sure there were no drugs or guns or anything.”
“You believe that.”
She shook her head.
“What do you believe?” I said.
No hurry, plenty of time, ask all the questions, keep the strands straight, one strand at a time.
“He’s sick.”
“And it excites him to prowl?”
She nodded.
“Did he find this picture in your locker or Jared’s?” I said.
“Jared’s.”
“And what use has he put it to?” I said.
She kept her face in her hands.
“What use?”
“Is
that what you see in him?”
“He’s a disgusting little prick,” she said.
I nodded.
“He makes me . . .” She shook her head.
“If you have sex with him,” I said, “he won’t tell.”
She inhaled audibly. I waited. She exhaled even more audibly, as if she’d been running.
“Yes,” she said.
“How long has this been going on?”
“Two years.”
“Which makes the photograph more than two years old,” I said.
“Yes.”
“So Jared was how old when it was taken.”
She was silent.
“Fifteen?” I said.
She shook her head.
“How old?” I said.
“Fourteen.”
“So tell me about that,” I said.
She was silent again, framing her thoughts, no doubt.
“Take your time,” I said.
She did. But finally, she raised her face and looked at me. Her eyes were red, but she wasn’t crying. The bright sunlight penetrated her makeup, and underneath it she looked haggard and older than she was.
“It’s not what you think,” she said.
“It rarely is,” I said.
“Do you believe in love, Mr. Spenser?”
“I do.”
She had full eye contact with me, and she leaned a little toward me when she spoke.
“Jared and I love each other,” she said.
“How nice,” I said.
“Do you find that so hard to believe that someone like me would love a boy such as he?”
“I do,” I said.
She smiled sadly. She was regrouping swiftly.
“I do too,” she said. “And yet . . . and yet it’s true.”
“Are you aware that he is retarded?” I said.
“He absolutely is not,” she said. “You think I wouldn’t know?”
“Yes,” I said. “I think you wouldn’t know.”
“He’s reticent perhaps, a kind of dreamy poetic reticence.”
“The best kind,” I said.
“It began,” Beth Ann said, “when he was sent to me by one of his teachers. They felt he was withdrawn. He was so quiet in class.”
“To what did you attribute that?”
“Do you understand psychology, Mr. Spenser?”
“I’ve been in love for a long time with one of the great shrinks in America,” I said. “I’ve absorbed a little.”
“So you do believe in love.”
“Yes.”
“There’s a medical condition,” Beth Ann said, “called failure to flourish. Have you heard of that?”
“Yes.”
“Jared has the emotional and psychological equivalent of that disease,” she said.
“Caused by?” I said.
“A lack of mattering. A lack of centrality. No one thought he was important. He lacked self-esteem. He wasn’t loved sufficiently.”
I had been listening with my hands pressed together and my fingertips against my chin. I pointed at her with my pressed hands.
“And you had a cure,” I said.
“You . . . however you make it sound,” Beth Ann said. “Yes. I felt that if I could love him enough, I could bring him to a fully realized life.”
“Worked out good so far,” I said.
It was as if she hadn’t heard me. And maybe she hadn’t. She seemed deeply engaged in spinning her web.
“And in the process,” she said, “I came to love him, as I know he loved me.”
I nodded. “Who took the picture?” I said.
“Jared. He had one of those new digital cameras.”
“The kind you hook up to a computer?” I said.
“Yes. It had a timer attachment.”
“Did you have sex?”
“Then, when the picture was taken?”
“Then,” I said, “later. Anytime. Were you having sex with Jared.”
“We made love,” Beth Ann said with great dignity.
“Did you get to spend time together aside from making love?” I said.
“It was difficult, as you might imagine. The prejudices of the middle class are fearful, as you may know. We took our time, and our passion, when we could.”
“And you saw no hint of functional retardation?” I said.
“No. Of course not. His grades were good. He may have seemed slow to some because he talked slowly. But he talked slowly because he thought so deeply.”
“As so many fourteen-year-olds do,” I said.
“He is unusual far beyond his chronological age,” Beth Ann said.
“Good point,” I said. “Most kids his age are not in jail for murder.”
“You can believe what you wish,” she said, and sat back so that her breasts pushed against her sweater.
Whoops.
“Unless your degrees are fraudulent,” I said, “you would be in a position better than mine to understand how unlikely it is that a woman like you would fall in love with a boy like Jared.”
She pointed her breasts at me. Both barrels.
“You think it’s impossible?” she said.
“Few things are impossible,” I said. “I think it is improbable.”
“So what would be your explanation?”
“I’d guess some sort of psychosexual pathology on your part,” I said.
“That’s disgusting.”
“So what happened?” I said.
“Happened?”
“To the relationship.”
“Garner made me break it off,” she said.
“He refused to share?”
“That, too, is disgusting,” she said.
“But true?”
“Yes. He said I had to stop seeing Jared or he’d destroy me professionally.”
“With the picture,” I said.
“Yes.”
“Did you tell Jared?”
“I tried to be as kind as I could be,” she said. “I told him the school knew of our relationship, and we would have to stop seeing each other for a while.”
“How’d he take it?”
“How do you think he would take it. He was devastated.”
“Do you suppose that made him go off on the school?”
“I don’t know what to think,” she said.
“You didn’t rush to his rescue when he did go off,” I said.
“What could I do?”
“You might have shared what you knew.”
“How could I help him by destroying myself?” she said.
Her whole bearing had intensified, as if she had been rehydrated. I had a private bet with myself where we were going.
“You might have avoided describing him to me in terms of a classic school shooter. Isolated. Bullied unmercifully. That kind of thing.”
“He’d already confessed and been arrested,” she said. She was starting to breathe more heavily, and her breasts moved as if rebelling against the sweater. “I didn’t see what good it would do to call attention to myself.”
“You know anything about Wendell Grant?” I said.
“Nothing,” she said. “I don’t believe I ever spoke with him.”
I picked the photograph up off the table and put it back in my inside pocket.
“What are you going to do?” she said.
“I don’t know,” I said.
“Do you suppose you could make Royce give me back my picture?”
“Probably,” I said.
“Would you give me back your copy?”
“No.”
“It’s all I have of Jared,” she said.
“You’ve probably had too much of Jared already,” I said.
Her eyes widened and her voice softened. I could hear her breathing.
“I need your help,” she said.
“You do,” I said.
“Can’t you help me,” she said.
“Probably not,” I said
“I don’t like my arrangement
with Royce,” she said. “But I do it because he makes me.”
“Uh-huh.”
“I want to escape from him,” she said.
“Uh-huh.”
“I would like an arrangement with you,” she said.
“I need time to work on my poetic depth,” I said and stood up. “I’ll get back to you.”
60
“SO SHE WAS fucking this guy to keep him from telling everyone that she was fucking this kid?” Cleary said.
“Well put,” I said.
“And the kid was underage when she was fucking him?”
“Almost certainly,” I said.
“And you can prove this?”
“Whoops,” I said.
“You can’t prove it,” Cleary said.
“I can probably prove it. I got the naked photo.”
“Evidence of a possible felony,” Cleary said. “I’ll have to examine it closely.”
“Yeah,” I said. “Take a number. DiBella’s already got first dibs.”
Cleary smiled.
“The photo’s pretty good leverage.”
“With her,” I said. “I have only her word with Garner.”
“But you know they were spending the night together.”
“Yes.”
“So why do you want to talk with the kid again?” Cleary said.
“I need to know where the love affair with Beth Ann fits in to what he did.”
“And I should help you with this?”
“In the interest of justice?” I said.
“Justice?” Cleary said. “This office wants convictions, not justice.”
“You’ll convict him,” I said. “But maybe the circumstances would mitigate the sentence.”
“His sentence gets mitigated and the fucking community will be in open rebellion,” Cleary said.
“Lot of heavy stuff happened to that kid,” I said.
“A lot of heavy stuff happened to other kids, in the school, when he killed them,” Cleary said.
“I need to know what happened,” I said.
“Spenser, get away from me,” Cleary said. “His lawyer’s already conceded. Nobody wants the sentence mitigated. His parents even want him long gone.”
School Days Page 17