Don't Explain: An Artie Deemer Mystery

Home > Nonfiction > Don't Explain: An Artie Deemer Mystery > Page 14
Don't Explain: An Artie Deemer Mystery Page 14

by Dallas Murphy


  I suddenly felt like an intruder, but it wasn’t our fault. This rude intimacy had been forced on us. We didn’t want it. Dogs will be dogs. I felt like apologizing to the poor soul for seeing him that ultimately naked. But at the same time something else was bothering me—

  Why now? If this person had been dead long enough to decompose this thoroughly, why only now were the dogs finding his bones? Or could it be that they had dug him out of his wildcat crypt generations ago, and they took visitors to see their bones like the siblings in To Kill a Mockingbird take the new boy to see Boo Radley’s house? That was probably it. Dogs dug the poor bastard up ages ago…If so, wouldn’t some person have found them by now?

  “Artie, do you think it’s Kempshall?”

  I envisioned calling Clayton: “We sure enjoy your place, met your dad.”

  “Artie—?”

  “Hmmm?”

  “I think I’d like to get out of here right now.”

  “Sounds good to me.”

  “I feel like we’re being watched.”

  “You do? You mean figuratively?”

  “No, I mean literally.”

  I circled in place. I didn’t see anything except trees and sky. And bones.

  “It’s probably just a feeling, though,” she said stiffly. “I’m sure we’re not really being watched.”

  “Naa, who’d be watching us?”

  I slapped my thigh. Hard. Jellyroll appeared at it. I looked down at him, he up at me. He was looking a little edgy himself. His ears were flat against his skull. His upper lip stuck to a canine. The three of us started backing toward the trail down the hill.

  “I still feel it—” said Crystal.

  We went slowly at first, but with quickening pace. Soon we were hotfooting it down that path. We didn’t exactly run, but we didn’t slow down until the trail leveled out along the shore. It felt better to have the water nearby. Without trying, I could smell myself, the stink of mortal fear. Jellyroll walked at my ankles, peering up into my face. He doesn’t have much feeling for human remains, but he knows when I’m shook. It undermines his faith in the order of things. Sometimes I find the responsibility burdensome.

  “I’m sorry,” said Crystal.

  “What? Why?”

  “For scaring us. I just felt creepy.”

  “Understandable.”

  “Does anybody ever swim here?”

  “Walrus, maybe.”

  Unseen birds twittered sweetly. They didn’t give a shit about human business.

  “I want to.”

  “I think people die of exposure in that water, Crystal.”

  “I want that feeling off of me.” She stripped off her shirt. Leaning against a white pine tree trunk, she removed her jeans. In a pair of powder-blue panties alone, she padded down to the rocks. I looked both ways. There were no boats except ours at anchor in the bay. She covered her breasts with her forearms as if that would protect them from the searing cold, and in she went. It took her breath away. Watching her it took mine, too.

  She gasped and hissed and screamed all at once. I wanted her suddenly, deeply, but I wasn’t willing to enter that water. She swam a few strokes out into the cove. Then she turned and raced ashore. I met her on the rocks with her shirt. I rubbed her body with it as she gasped in my arms. I wanted to make love, and further, I thought it was important that we do so. Even before we called the police.

  I mentioned that to Crystal as we hustled toward the house.

  It sounded good to her, she said.

  SEVENTEEN

  The skull was gone. The spine was gone, and so were the ribs. There was no pelvis, no arm or leg bones. Even the dog tracks were gone. There was no sign that bones or dogs—or Crystal and I—had ever been anywhere near this particular location.

  Sweaty and dirty, Cabot County Sheriff Theodore Kelso climbed out of the ex-crypt. Almost three hours had passed since our last trip up here. It had taken that long to get the message to Kelso and for him to come to Kempshall Island. Crystal, who had made the call, did not mention the bones on the telephone. We didn’t say a word about bones until Kelso arrived in person. But now the bones were gone without a trace. Someone had obviously been here in the last three hours. The killer? And whose bones were they? And did Kelso think we were bullshitting him?

  He leaned his ass against a fallen tree trunk, wiped his face with a white handkerchief, sighed. His uniform was informal. The khaki shirt had epaulets on the shoulders and flaps over the pockets. That was about it for uniform, except for the silver badge over his heart. He sighed again, looked skyward as if for guidance. Or patience.

  Crystal and I stood around waiting for him to decide something. I admit I have a problem with authority. Crystal has an open and trusting nature, so she has no problem with authority. I tend to assume those in authority are all Nazis.

  “I heard from your friend Detweiler,” said Kelso, neither here nor there. “He left me a professional courtesy message. He said he was working on a matter for you. ‘Matter,’ that’s what he called it. What would be the nature of that matter?”

  I told him that someone was stalking my dog, or more precisely that someone had claimed to be stalking my dog.

  He peered at me. “A nut?”

  “I guess so.”

  Then he peered at Crystal. She peered right back at him. “You mean to say you’re hiding out here?”

  “Sort of, yes.”

  He didn’t like that idea, you could tell. Maybe I wouldn’t like it either if I were him and some outlander brought psycho bait into my community. Besides, he had a vicious and very public human killing in Micmac to deal with. “Do you and Sid Detweiler know the stalker’s identity?”

  “No. We’ve been getting anonymous letters.”

  “Did you actually see the dogs spread the skeleton around?”

  We said no.

  Kelso pushed absently at a flat stone with his toe. “I wouldn’t like it if you and Sid Detweiler took measures against the stalker, should one show up here.”

  I said I understood.

  “I wouldn’t like it if you were luring him out here.”

  “What? Luring? Absolutely not. Is that what you think?”

  “I don’t know. You tell me what I should think.” He looked to Crystal.

  “We’re here for the solitude,” said Crystal. “Luring crazy people is the last thing we want to do.”

  “So then if you identify the stalker, what are you going to do?”

  “Call you,” I said right on cue.

  “I knew Sid Detweiler in New York. Well, by reputation. He solved the Ramirez case. Family of twelve shot to death execution style, including two infants. 1985. He solved it singlehanded.”

  I was sorry we didn’t remember the Ramirez case. Seemed families were being murdered execution style every couple of weeks back during the Reagan years.

  Kelso pushed himself away from the log and unpacked his Polaroid after rummaging for it in his nylon duffel bag. He asked us to point to the precise spots where we’d found the bones. We did, and he photographed each one. Then he labeled the photos on the back: “Arm and hand,” “leg w/ foot,” “pelvis w/ upper legs,” and so forth. I couldn’t see how the photographs would be of any use.

  We stood around waiting as he worked. I was ready to get out of that place before it tainted my view of the whole island. I liked the rest of the island. I wanted to stay a while and have nice sex without old corpses turning up.

  “Well, I guess you’ve heard about the night the Castle burned and Kempshall disappeared.”

  We said we had.

  “Yeah, you got to be in Cabot County at least fifteen minutes before you hear about that.” Kelso’s jowls hung, his trunk was thickening, but he was the same kind of urban hardass as his retired colleague Sid. “Tell me about the condition of the skull one more time.”

  Crystal told him this time.

  He took notes. “What sort of object would you say might cause a wound like that? Obviously,
you can’t make an informed judgment, and I’m not expecting one. I’d just like to hear your opinion. Like an ax?”

  We nodded, looked at each other. “Or a hatchet,” Crystal said. “Or a meat cleaver.”

  “Or a sword?”

  Crystal agreed. “A machete, maybe.”

  It was the same general kind of weapon as killed that woman in the rest room at the Cod End. I’ll bet that’s what he was thinking, but he didn’t say anything. “Are you close friends of Clayton Kempshall’s?” he asked instead.

  I said no, we were more casual friends, business friends.

  “Would you have a number where he can be reached?”

  I had numbers. “He’s in California.”

  “Are you going to tell him?” Crystal asked.

  “I’m not sure,” said the sheriff. “Depends on how this plays out. He closed his notebook, paused. “I guess you see my problem. There still ain’t any remains. It’s tough to investigate a murder without remains.” But it wasn’t that cut and dried for him. He was troubled by something.

  “So what’ll happen, Sheriff?” Crystal asked.

  “Things are different here in Cabot County. In New York, there’d be supervisors and procedures. Things are different here in ways I couldn’t even imagine before I spent a couple winters. One of the ways things are different here is that what III think matters. By the way, Ms. Spivey, the wife and I are big fans of yours.”

  “You are?”

  “We installed a Brunswick Gold Crown in the basement a couple of years ago. Oh, we’re not good players or anything, but we enjoy the game. The wife just taped you on ESPN last month against Norma Jean Garth.”

  Crystal moaned. “I was awful.”

  “Well, you got a couple bad rolls. There’s of course nothing to say you found old Kempshall’s bones. Nothing to say he’s even dead. Now I could make a big thing of it, shake the trees, I might come up with something, but I’m not going to do that. This is on the assumption that we don’t ever see the bones again. A skeleton with its skull split open, you got to think homicide. I’d have to take steps, but not without the actual bones. However, there’s something you ought to know. Most of the people from around here already know about your find.”

  “They do? How?”

  “How could they?” said Crystal.

  “I don’t know how. But I know from experience it’s true. I’m from away. My wife grew up here, but not out here in the islands. It’s different in the islands. Maybe you hear the rocks talk if you were born here, the waves tell you everything, I don’t know.”

  “This just applies to people who live here?” asked Crystal.

  “Yeah.”

  “Then we’re talking abut the Selfs, aren’t we?” I asked.

  “Mainly, yes,” said Kelso.

  “How about a cup of coffee, Sheriff?” I offered, ready to get off that hill.

  “Sounds good,” Kelso said. “Incidently, I’m deputy sheriff. But I’m the law here.”

  The day was still exquisite, the air pure and undamaged. Birds sang. Small animals, much to Jellyroll’s delight, scurried and scratched in the brush as we passed. What did nature need with people?

  I brewed up a pot of Zabar’s extra good, and we sat at the picnic table drinking it. Kelso seemed distracted, even morose, and I thought he was thinking about the bones up on the hill, but he wasn’t. We sipped in silence for a while, then he said, “In New York when something really savage happened, well, like the Ramirez case, I began to think it changed people for the worse. Not just the people directly involved or the dead people, but everybody in the whole city. At first I thought it was just us cops it changed, because we’re the guys who pick up the shit. But I think everybody changed because of the killing. Now this killing in Micmac—it’s going to change people.”

  We sat in silence and watched the harmony of Dog Cove.

  Then Crystal said, “Why now?”

  “I beg your pardon.”

  “Why did the dogs only now find the bones?”

  His beeper went off.

  “Do you need a phone?” I asked.

  “You brought one?”

  “Yes. Come on in.” I showed him the phone, then went back out on the porch.

  Crystal nodded toward the shore trail.

  It was Dickie shambling along, pretending to be all loosey-goosey casual, looking around, as he headed our way. Jellyroll barked at him. Dickie walked to the foundation of the boathouse, stopped, looked up at us. Then like a Hollywood Indian he raised his right hand and said “How.” Jellyroll poked his nose through the railing. And Dickie said “How” to him.

  Crystal had that “asshole” look on her face.

  Dickie said, “Say, I was having a chat with my employee Hawley Self. Hawley says you enjoyed our product, and you seem like a man who appreciates plain speaking, so I wondered if you’d be interested in purchasing—”

  All along I’d been pointing to the boat plainly marked POLICE resting against the flat rock twenty feet over his right shoulder blade, but he didn’t catch on.

  Crystal could only shake her head.

  “Wow!” exclaimed Dickie as it finally caught his eye. “Here? Shhh! Kelso’s here? here? Now? What is this? Some kind of setup?” Dickie started backing away. He stumbled, spun, caught himself, and began to flee headlong.

  Kelso stepped out on the porch. He said, “Thanks for the phone. If you’ll excuse me, I’m going to shout at this fool. Dickie, halt!”

  Dickie halted.

  “You wait right there. I want a word with you.” He turned around to Crystal and me. “This could prove to be a case of police brutality, so you better look the other way, could get real ugly. It’s an interesting question you ask, Crystal. I’ve been asking myself that same question. It just doesn’t seem reasonable that human remains have been laying around in the open all these years.”

  “So what do you think?” she asked. She was getting interested. I wished she wouldn’t.

  “You brought it up,” said Kelso. “What do you think?”

  “The only thing I can think of is that somebody was interrupted in the middle of digging them up.”

  “Interrupted by what?”

  “Maybe by us coming up the trail, maybe by the dogs.”

  Kelso nodded thoughtfully. “These two idiots—Hawley and Dickie—think they can grow dope right under my eyes without me knowing about it. That’s always pissed me off, even back in New York. They think I’m stupid as they are.”

  Dickie had gotten tired of standing and had sat on a rock. He chucked pebbles into the water like a little boy waiting for punishment after school.

  “Crystal,” I said after Kelso had gone after Dickie, “remember I told you I met Hawley up the hill and he said he’d killed Compton Kempshall?”

  “Sure.”

  “Did I mention that the weapon he used for the job was a hatchet?”

  “No.”

  Late that night after Crystal had unpacked her things in the bedroom—I was in the living room listening to Mingus’s “No Private Income Blues,” the 1959 scorcher, not missing the irony— she appeared in the bedroom doorway and said, “Look what I found.”

  Crystal was naked beneath the soft flannel shirt she slept in, and it was breezing open as she approached, distracting me from what she’d found.

  “This was in the bottom drawer in a shoe box. The box was falling apart. Look how sad it is.”

  It was a tan teddy bear. The fur was ratty, bald in patches, faded in others. The sad thing about this teddy bear was that it had been ripped down the front, torn or cut from under its chin down to its crotch. Someone—a child?—had attempted to patch the wound by lacing it closed. But in places the shoelace had torn through the teddy bear’s skin, and time-browned cotton stuffing protruded from its thoracic region.

  “Aww,” said Crystal. “Do you think it was Clayton’s?”

  EIGHTEEN

  Artie—!” Crystal hissed. “Somebody’s out there!”
<
br />   I must have heard it in my sleep, before Crystal shook my shoulder, because I was dreaming about a screen door, white paint peeling, slap-slapping in a desiccating wind that blew across an arid, cactus landscape I’d never seen before. I snapped bolt upright, but the distinction between that dreamy desert and reality was still fuzzy.

  Jellyroll was barking his alarm bark—

  Was this a job for the shotgun? You didn’t even have to aim to change the world…

  There was enough light to see Crystal pulling a shirt over her breasts. I saw, also, that her eyes were flashing, and that argued for hauling out the firepower. Unarmed, I followed Crystal to the front door. She peeked out one corner, I peeked out the other.

  “It’s me! It’s Hawley!” He proved it by shining a powerful flashlight under his chin. His scarred face looked horror-movie hideous in that light. Rainwater puddled in the scar tissue. Rain? I didn’t know it was raining, but it was. And it was windy—

  I told Jellyroll to stop barking, and I opened the door. The wind yanked it out of my hands and slammed it against my bare toe. The pain paralyzed me. I waddled backward as Hawley entered.

  He was bundled in black rubber boots, stiff yellow foul weather gear, and one of those Captains Courageous hats. Water still sluiced off it. He had to lean against the door to get it closed. The wind howled.

  “The old man called on the radio. Comin’ back from Micmac in the slop, his engine quit on him. Old man’s needed a valve job since way last summer. I told him. Anyway, he got the hook down, but somehow got all twisted up in the rope and, pop, snapped his arm. So he had to cut the anchor away. He’s drift in’ for the Disappointments right now.”

  I didn’t quite grasp the message here. What did he want from us? “Ah, did you call the Coast Guard? Do you want to use my phone?”

  “I need to get a man aboard his boat to take a line.”

  “A man?” He couldn’t be proposing that we go out there and get him near the Disappointments in the dark on a night like this? Nah. “You mean me?” My voice cracked a little. My toe throbbed. I tried vainly to dampen the throbbing with the instep of my other foot.

 

‹ Prev