by Tom Keneally
‘You see,’ said Darragh, ‘I was at the capture with him.’
‘Yeah. I can’t see why that Fratelli guy didn’t ask one of us. Made my feelings known to him, too.’
So Father Tuomey’s was not the only territory which had been violated.
‘Look,’ said the American priest, ‘you can’t pretend they won’t be a bit hard on him. Not with all that’s going on. He shouldn’t have fornicated with a white woman either. That gets us in bad with the Australians. You guys don’t like that any more than we do.’
‘He has a genuine taste for the sacraments and a strong doctrinal sense.’
‘I’ll do what I can. I’ve got the compound, the hospital, the dental corps and the signals personnel to attend to. We’re over-stretched. I’ve got nothing against the man, but he doesn’t stand for more than the others do. The truth is, the others do their duty better than he’s done.’
‘Would I be able to visit him?’ asked Darragh. Let me know if you’ve got some extraordinary intention, the monsignor had told him. Was visiting Gervaise an extraordinary intention?
O’Rourke sighed yet again. ‘Look, we can do the job with him. Guys like him love to get on the good side of a civilian.’
Darragh weighed this monsignor-like advice, and considered whether he needed to see Gervaise more than Gervaise needed to see him. ‘He seemed concerned about his safety,’ said Darragh.
‘He’d say that.’
Darragh paused again, to think of more pretexts. ‘I’d consider it a great favour. And I think he’d feel safer …’
To Darragh’s surprise, O’Rourke relented. ‘I’ll have to check it out with the MPs, and then get back to you.’
As Darragh waited for O’Rourke to contact him again, Monsignor Carolan pursued his career as a student of battles. He still conned the battle maps reproduced on the front page of the Sydney Morning Herald and matched them against the maps of his Times Atlas to give them an added dimension.
In the third week after Easter, the monsignor sat for periods by his cabinet radio, with the Herald and the atlas in his hands, studying maps which represented the great island-dotted blankness of the Southwest Pacific. Through this and other overheard news, Darragh became aware that a crucial confrontation was brewing in that theatre of lethal blue called the Coral Sea. This wing of the Pacific was hemmed in on three sides by the Solomons, Papua, and Australia’s north coast. It was believed that the Japanese Admiral Inouye was on his way across the huge arena of the Coral Sea to capture Port Moresby in New Guinea. And as the monsignor told Frank at breakfast on May 7, if Moresby went, then Australia would in short order be invaded.
Over the next days, the monsignor kept track of the events in the Coral Sea with a military fervour rather than that of a potential martyr of the one true Church. He seemed bravely undisturbed about the possible impact of the battle upon his plans for paying off the church and expanding the school. He was passionately intrigued by the fact that this was the first battle in the history of humankind in which the sailors of both sides did not see each other’s ships, but only each other’s lethal planes. Japanese carrier planes tried to sink the American and the Australian flotillas in this new and fantastical warfare. The destiny of the Western and Christian world was to be decided in these bright, equatorial waters, and Darragh was surprised he felt so little urgency, alarmed at his wooden sense of separation from the God of history and of the immanent world. By the time he emerged from the confessional on Saturday evening, the flagship Australia had valiantly saved itself from persistent attack. Two more American aircraft carriers had been damaged, but the Japanese flotillas were broken and Japanese aircraft carriers had been sent to the bottom. By the time Darragh met the monsignor in the sacristy, at the end of saying the eight o’clock Mass on Sunday, Darragh heard that it was official. The Japanese had been turned back for the moment. They would no doubt try again, but they need not succeed any better than they had this time.
‘I intend to declare this a Mass of thanksgiving,’ said the monsignor, robing for his nine o’clock, his face translucent with happiness.
The next day’s tennis was in large part a farewell to a classmate of Darragh’s who had had experience as a youth in the militia and who had been appointed a chaplain to units in northern New South Wales. There were rumours that these battalions were about to go to New Guinea, so the after-match beer was drunk to jokes about rank—the classmate would begin as a one-pip lieutenant, a ‘second loo–ie’ as Australian jargon had it—and about the comic likelihood that the young priest might need or be tempted to take up arms, and thus become a warrior priest, like Father Murphy of the Irish 1798 uprising, or the Irish monk who had won the Military Cross for killing Prussians in the Great War. Darragh kept the story of his sharing the siege with Gervaise to himself. He was pleased no rumour of it had reached his friends.
Darragh returned to St Margaret’s about dusk, his mind flickering with daydreams about a martial career. If the Japanese succeeded in the end, how much preferable would it be for a man to be among fellow soldiers, to be a military prisoner if necessary rather than part of the great mass of hostages. His nature was not a rancorously envious one, however. The daydream was more pleasant than bitter. Yet it was in its way intense again, as it had been on the day four years earlier, when the exorcist had urged him to be a merciful confessor.
As he came in through the front door of the presbytery, he saw Mrs Flannery seated on the edge of the chair which stood beneath a print of Our Lady of Perpetual Succour. She looked like a woman in a doctor’s waiting room, and stood upright as Frank appeared. She had an officious and chastising whisper, and that was what emerged from her lips now. ‘The monsignor’s been waiting for you. He’s in his office with that policeman.’
Which policeman? Surely the Lidcombe affair was not a matter for the civil police.
‘Go in, Father,’ said Mrs Flannery, gesturing with one hand. ‘Go in!’
Darragh did so. Monsignor Carolan and Detective Inspector Kearney were drinking whisky together, seated either side of the monsignor’s desk.
‘The man of the hour,’ said Inspector Kearney, putting down his glass. His double-breasted coat was unbuttoned and the monsignor was in his customary autumn cardigan. They had an air of being at easy understanding with each other and with the whisky they shared. But the monsignor seemed embarrassed as he stood up.
‘Well,’ he said, and shook his head. ‘Frank …’
The detective rose too, and began to button his suit coat. He said, ‘We presume you don’t know, Father Frank. Mrs Catherine Heggarty is dead.’
Darragh became instantly giddy and was jolted sideways a step. The world had become too fast in its malice. He leaned against the wall and was gratified in some minor key of his senses to assure himself that it, at least, was still solid. Somehow the detective inspector produced a third glass from the table and sloshed some whisky and soda into it. Looking keenly at Darragh, he said, ‘You should have this, son.’
Rather than believe what had been said, he was willing to accept the monsignor and inspector had devised this chastising lie to save him from folly. But Monsignor Carolan still seemed more tremulous than Darragh might ever have imagined him to be. He said, ‘Because you had your Monday off, I had to give the poor thing her last rites. Rigor hadn’t set in. I hope her soul was still there. Because the circumstances … they weren’t promising.’
It was good priestly practice to absolve bodies not utterly claimed by death’s iciness, in the hope that a repentant soul lingered, awaiting the blessed word.
Breath returned to Darragh. ‘She can’t be … She was at Mrs Flood’s burial. Just ten days or so ago.’
‘Ten days is a long time, Father Frank.’
‘Tell me,’ said Darragh. ‘Was she in an accident?’
His soul at a distance from the room, he observed Inspector Kearney inform the Monday tennis-playing dolt who had wandered into the monsignor’s study. ‘Misadventure,’ said Ke
arney. She had been strangled early that morning. Did they, Darragh and the monsignor, really know what strangulation was? asked Kearney. It was harder than in the films to strangle any healthy soul; it took either great strength or great accidental bad luck on the part of the victim, and sometimes of the killer. This hadn’t been bad luck. This had been strength. And it had not been done by someone who had forced his way in. There were no signs of that. Quite the contrary, Kearney asserted.
Darragh, in misery, returned to his body and heard the inspector’s words as a distinct series of bricks, or stones, laid in place. ‘It takes strength,’ Kearney explained in a lowered voice, ‘to close off the oesophagus of someone healthy, to crush the larynx. Then at the same time, this strangler of Mrs Heggarty’s constricted the arteries carrying blood to the brain. That takes double strength. Neighbours haven’t told the son yet, he’s been staying with them overnight. They got him ready for school and he’s over with the nuns now.’
‘I must see to him,’ said Darragh.
The monsignor shook his head. ‘There’ll be time, and there’ll be others to do it too. Stand still for God’s sake, Frank.’
‘His father was taken prisoner,’ explained Darragh, to justify going over there, extracting Anthony … And then what?
‘It’s probably a case for the sisters at Killcare,’ the monsignor said. The Order of St Joseph ran an orphanage at Killcare, between surf and bush, north of Sydney.
Darragh still thought he could sidestep the evil rumour of strangulation, a phenomenon unknown among women in Homebush and Strathfield, suburbs which, whatever their ordinary and occasionally perverse sins, protected their citizens with the dome of their own blessed banality. It was a concept, too, which could not be fitted to what he knew of Mrs Heggarty. So for a time he concentrated his uncertain but awful grief on that orphanage some hours distant. Killcare, he knew by instinct, would be overcrowded because of war, and because of the Depression which only war had put pause to. It was not a homely institution. Anthony Heggarty, Darragh was sure, would prove an unsuitable orphan. He would prove short of the stoicism his situation asked of him.
‘I can’t accept what you’re telling me. She was far too strong to be strangled.’ The word itself invited incredulity.
‘You’d better accept it,’ said the monsignor, his face reddening. ‘Do you think we’d say a thing like that just for the joy of uttering it?’ The monsignor had a sourness in his mouth he would gladly have spat out, but could not do it here, in his orderly study.
‘You knew her, didn’t you?’ asked Inspector Kearney. ‘In your role as spiritual adviser.’
The mad idea came to Darragh that if Kearney had possessed the nobility to go off beer for Lent, Kate Heggarty would be alive. But she was not dead, he knew. It was still a tableau they’d devised to punish him for Lidcombe. And for having invited her into the presbytery. ‘See, we warned you about women …’ But the monsignor had talked about last rites and rigor mortis. He wouldn’t do that. He wouldn’t be such a ghoul.
‘I’m her spiritual adviser,’ said Darragh. ‘As far as I know. I haven’t made a lot of progress.’
The monsignor assured him, ‘I checked with the diocesan canon lawyer, Dr Field. He advised me that in these circumstances you are able to tell the inspector anything likely to help, unless of course it’s under the seal of the confessional. The poor thing will have few secrets anyhow, not now. Everything will become public property.’
‘Did she ask you about anything you can tell me?’ asked Kearney. He was not as on edge as the monsignor. His work had inured him. ‘You see,’ he said, ‘I’m asking you the same question as I asked you about that young runaway brother.’
Darragh could not frame words. He did not want to have her decisions, her rebellion and apostasy even, interpreted away in the stock terms of monsignors and policemen. ‘Well, I don’t know …’
‘But she came to the presbytery,’ stated the monsignor, flushed and insistent. ‘She had a conference with you as her spiritual director, didn’t she? It’s not as if Mr Kearney’s asking you to spill the beans from the heart of the confessional.’
‘Yes, but I don’t know that she sought advice on anything that would lead to this terrible … this terrible result. She is strangled?’
‘Yes,’ said the inspector.
The monsignor, more frankly annoyed than Darragh had ever seen him, began to do the inspector’s task. ‘Men are stranglers, Frank. You’ve never read in any newspaper of a strangling woman. And men worry soldiers’ wives. I’d say that she talked to you about men. Did she?’
Darragh felt that if he said as much they would nod like elders and write her off as a loose woman, a whore, asking for it. He believed more strongly in her honesty than he did in her murder, and felt a duty to protect it.
‘Please, Frank,’ said the inspector.
‘She told me that she had problems of faith. Her husband had been taken prisoner and it made her doubt the Church’s goodwill.’
‘We didn’t take her husband prisoner,’ the monsignor complained.
‘I’d like to see her body before I tell her confidences.’
‘What’s wrong with you?’ asked the monsignor. ‘She’s lost her right to confidences, poor thing.’
Inspector Kearney had lowered his eyes. ‘It’s not possible, Father Frank. The body’s been moved to the morgue. Awaiting the coroner’s inquest.’
He had half hoped that if she had been laid out in her house in The Crescent, he might be permitted to visit her.
Darragh began to weep for her now. She was far gone into the hands of strangers.
To preserve her some small dignity, he said, ‘She told me nothing which explains this!’ The this he had not quite yet managed to believe in.
‘But you must want her killer found, Father?’ Kearney suggested.
Of course Darragh did, though he could barely believe in the man’s existence.
‘She said she could not remain a practising Catholic. I was very distressed to hear it. She told me that she felt very bitterly the injustice that her husband was a prisoner. His soldier’s pay was not enough for her and her son to live on in dignity, she said. I told her I’d contact St Vincent de Paul to see if they could help her, and she said she was too proud for that. She quoted Rerum Novarum.’
‘The social justice encyclical,’ the monsignor informed the inspector. ‘I’ve heard a lot of troublemakers quote that one in my day.’
The monsignor had anointed her extremities and her fine mute eyes, yet she had affronted him by being found so unfortunately treated.
‘Did she mention a man?’ asked the inspector. ‘Her neighbours mentioned a man.’
Darragh was awed by the potency of that question. ‘Was she interfered with?’ he asked without hesitation.
‘Not directly,’ said the inspector, getting this matter out of the way. ‘There was some stuff deposited on her, probably afterwards … a lot of stranglers are like that. They’re better with the dead than the living.’
Darragh was chastened by the image of this frightful man. His awful masturbation made all the schoolboys in the confessional seem like cherubim.
‘She mentioned a kindly man,’ said Darragh. He was willing to help even an imperfect agent like Kearney. ‘She knew it was a risk having him come to the house, but she said he wasn’t demanding, and he helped her maintain her dignity.’
‘How did he do that?’
Darragh knew how his answer would be interpreted. But there was no way of not saying it.
‘He brought her things which she felt contributed to her dignity.’
‘What sort of things?’
‘Extra food …’
‘Dignity,’ said the monsignor with a feverish air of knowingness to Inspector Kearney. ‘A woman making up her mind to adultery in return for a pair of stockings.’
Darragh thought he might punch him, which was a cause of automatic excommunication under canon law.
‘That’s an u
nfair view, Monsignor,’ he said. He could feel his own face blazing to match the monsignor’s. He and the monsignor were like two hot poles, with the cunning, cool terrain of the inspector connecting them. ‘She had a genuine desire that she and her son wouldn’t be degraded by want.’
‘Such a sentiment,’ said the monsignor, ‘doesn’t alter my first impression. Frank, if you don’t see as much, then you need to take a few more courses in moral theology.’
Frank said, ‘Monsignor, please stop pretending I’m stupid.’
‘And you, Frankie, you stop pretending we’re stupid. The inspector and I have in our different ways been round the block a few times. It isn’t bush week, you know, not with us. You’ll be treated as you treat us.’
Darragh found it hard to put in words, but it seemed to him that the monsignor was taking unnecessary and disloyal pains to do the policeman’s work, while Inspector Kearney sat by with a priestly serenity on his broad and normally combative face.
‘She told me she wasn’t going to be one of those hypocritical Catholics,’ said Darragh, ‘who risked sin and then crept back to the confessional. She said she wanted to be honest about it. She said her generous friend had not asked for anything, but she knew that he might, and told me that it was a moral risk she was willing to bear.’
‘And she told you nothing about who this fellow was?’ Kearney asked calmly.
‘No.’
‘An American soldier?’
‘I don’t know. She didn’t make a point of that. She seemed to want God and me to be under no illusions.’
‘A contract between unequal parties,’ said angry Monsignor Carolan.
‘I think you should have another drink, Vince,’ the inspector told him. ‘There are some things I haven’t managed to tell you or ask Frank yet.’
The monsignor sat down, panting. Darragh sensed the shock his parish priest had suffered, and felt a fraternal sympathy for him.
‘Did you ever visit her home?’ asked Kearney.
‘Yes,’ said Frank. His memory of going there recurred to him as an indefinably sweet instant, a daydream exalted and enhanced by duty.