by Jeff Koehler
* A wise decision. River water soon flowed freely over the original site, while the Jaypur garden still exists today.
* One of Bentinck’s most significant achievements was pushing for the development of a tea industry on Indian soil. Yet it is never mentioned among his accomplishments. Full biographies on the man, including Demetrius Boulger’s Lord William Bentinck (1892) and John Rosselli’s Lord William Bentinck: The Making of a Liberal Imperialist, 1774–1839 (1974), make not a single reference to his role in tea or the Tea Committee, even though the industry is one of the Raj’s most profitable and lasting legacies.
† The Assam Company still exists today as a large, publicly traded company that, along with producing tea, has expanded into oil and gas exploration and transportation.
CHAPTER 5
China Leaf
The East India Company’s agent was Robert Fortune, a curator at the Chelsea Physic Garden in London. Unlike many of his colleagues, Fortune was neither titled nor wealthy nor even well connected. He was born in Edrom, in rural, southeast Scotland, a few miles from the border with England, and on his birth entry his father’s occupation is listed as “hedger.”1 Having little formal education, Fortune began as an apprentice and then obtained a qualification in horticulture (though not medicine like most botanists). Skilled and ambitious, he worked in positions at the botanic garden at Edinburgh and then gardens of London’s Horticultural Society 2 (now the Royal Horticultural Society). He lacked the financial self-sufficiency generally expected for such gentlemanly expeditions, even those taken at the behest of others. But as a talented botanist, experienced in the delicate process of sending plants back to Europe, and, quite exceptionally, widely traveled in China, he was the perfect man for the job.
Fortune had not long returned from a lengthy trip in China. Six months to the day after the signing of the 1841 Treaty of Nanking, following the First Opium War, the Horticultural Society had dispatched the thirty–year-old on a flora-gathering mission. Surely, the parts in his subsequent book, Three Years’ Wanderings in the Northern Provinces of China, about traveling into prohibited areas of the Middle Kingdom in disguise particularly caught the attention of the Company’s board.
For this new mission, Fortune’s brief was different—and difficult: to gather tea plants, as well as production secrets, for both green and black tea. The consensus of British botanists was that green and black tea came from different plants rather than different ways of processing the leaves; Fortune suspected otherwise. While five ports were then open to foreigners, the great tea-producing regions of the interior remained off-limits. Fortune knew that he could not rely on agents but had to go himself to be certain of the plants’ sources, as well as to gather careful notes on soil and cultivation. Apart from a handful of Arab traders and Jesuit missionaries, few foreigners had ever penetrated so deeply into China or returned alive to tell of it.
Arriving in Hong Kong in August 1848, Fortune traveled immediately a thousand miles north to Shanghai and then inland to the picturesque, green-tea-producing areas around the Yellow Mountain region. A day out of Shanghai, he had his head shaved, donned Chinese robes, and had his servant sew on a braided hair tail that hung nearly to his heels.3 Like this, Fortune became his alter ego, Sing Wa, a respected businessman from some country “beyond the great wall” that justified his height and pale skin, heavy accent, and inability to speak the local dialects, and perhaps the reason he lacked a certain intrinsic fluency with chopsticks. Traveling by boat and on a sedan chair carried by teams of locally hired “coolies,” he reached his target and found tea growing luxuriantly on the hillside. He didn’t collect tea himself, but obtained plants and seeds from nurseries.
Back in Shanghai, Fortune readied his first shipment for the Calcutta Botanic Garden. At that time, a major problem for plant hunters was getting species back to sponsoring gardens in good shape. With stowage at a premium and freshwater always in short supply, ships were reluctant to transport them. Salty sea spray and merciless tropical sun were enemies of a plant’s survival, as were livestock on board, which would nibble on the tender shoots and flowers whenever possible.
To combat this, Fortune used Wardian cases, sealed glass boxes that had been recently developed by a physician in London’s East End named Nathaniel Ward. Acting like mini-greenhouses, they allowed the plants plenty of light and a fairly stable temperature. By recycling moisture, the plants could stay alive for years within the closed environment.
Fortune packed the first batch of plants in the glazed cases. Tea seeds were particularly sensitive and, Fortune observed, only retained their vitality for a short period of time. Unsure as to the best approach, he tried several. “Some were packed in loose canvas bags,” he wrote, “others were mixed with dry earth and put into boxes, and others again were put up in very small packages, in order to be quickly forwarded by post.”4
Not until the following year (1849) did word reach him that the plants had arrived in Calcutta in good shape. The seeds, though, had failed to germinate. None of his methods, he wrote drily, “were attended with much success.”5 Although his travelogue, A Journey to the Tea Countries of China; Including Sung-Lo and the Bohea Hills; with a Short Notice of the East India Company’s Tea Plantations in the Himalaya Mountains, does not record it as such, the loss must have been a deep blow.
By then, Fortune had long since headed back into the interior. This time he traveled southwest to the famed black-tea-producing hills up the Min River and into the Bohea Hills of Fujian Province. Again, Fortune was successful in obtaining stock. With this load he tried new ways to send the seeds.
Having procured some fine mulberry-plants from the district where the best Chinese silk is produced, I planted them in a Ward’s case in the usual way, and watered them well. In two or three days, when the soil was sufficiently dry, a large quantity of tea-seeds were scattered over its surface, and covered with earth about half an inch deep. The whole was now sprinkled with water, and fastened down with a few crossbars to keep the earth in its place. The case was then screwed down in the usual way, and made as tight as possible.6
When the cases arrived in Calcutta, the mulberry plants were in good condition, and, encouragingly, the tea seeds had germinated. “The young tea-plants were sprouting around the mulberries as thick as they could come up,” wrote Dr. Hugh Falconer,7 who had recently taken over from Wallich as superintendent of the botanic garden, upon their receipt.
Fortune continued to hone his techniques as he filled and sent on more Wardian cases to Falconer. They arrived in good shape and were sent on to experimental tea gardens newly established in the western Himalayan foothills.
Now confident in his system of getting the plants and seeds to India in good shape, Fortune gathered his final, grand batch, the one that he would accompany himself to Calcutta. When this was accomplished, Fortune set out to fulfill what he deemed the most difficult part of his commission. He needed to convince experienced Chinese tea manufacturers from the best tea districts to go to India and teach their techniques to the fledging industry.
It proved easier than expected. Using a well-connected agent who offered the Chinese experts handsomely paid three-year contracts along with the promise of certain freedom in their tea planting and power over both Indians and British workers,8 Fortune engaged eight tea makers to emigrate illegally, even given the threat of torture and flogging not only to themselves but their families. He obtained a large assortment of tea-making implements.
Fortune filled fourteen Wardian cases with rows of young tea plants and sowed the tea seeds among them. He was left with a bushel of remaining seeds that he did not want to waste and layered them with earth under a collection of Chinese camellia plants for the botanic garden in two additional glass cases.
In mid-February 1851, Fortune, the Chinese recruits, the tools of their trade, and the tea-filled Wardian cases sailed from Shanghai to Hong Kong. There, the group boarded the Lady Mary Wood, a Peninsular & Oriental wooden steamship bui
lt ten years before and used on the Calcutta–Hong Kong service, for which the 160-foot steamer had carried a cargo of opium on its outbound run.9
The journey to Calcutta took a month. In mid-March, the Lady Mary Wood crossed the Bay of Bengal and entered the Hooghly River, the westernmost distributary of the Ganges. “Almost any pilot will tell you that his work is much more difficult than you imagine,” begins a Rudyard Kipling story, “but the Pilots of the Hugli know that they have one hundred miles of the most dangerous river on earth running through their hands—the Hugli between Calcutta and the Bay of Bengal.”10 In addition to shifting shoals, silt beds, mud banks, heavy currents, and a seven-foot tidal bore, at the time of year when Fortune and company were making their way to Calcutta, early monsoon winds were beginning to blow up through the funnel-shaped bay. Eventually the Lady Mary Wood neared the Second City of the Empire, the City of Palaces: Calcutta.
Founded as a trading post by merchant-adventurer Job Charnock and the East India Company in 1690, Calcutta grew quickly—it had 120,000 people by 1750—and became the capital of British India in 1772. By the time Robert Fortune sailed up the Hooghly with his Wardian cases of tea, Calcutta was the largest colonial trade center in Asia and a global city, the administrative and commercial center of India, and its cultural and intellectual hub.*
Spread along the eastern bank of the Hooghly, the city was safeguarded by the beefy, irregularly octagonal riverside Fort William and administered by an army of East India Company scribes in the Writers’ Building. Theaters and an opera house (1827) offered cultured entertainment, elite gentlemen’s clubs—the stoutly white Bengal Club (1827) with its dancing-cobra emblem,† even a number of Masonic lodges—provided social status, and the Auckland Hotel (1841) added luxury.‡ A handful of churches preached familiar themes in familiar settings: St. John’s Church (1787), modeled on London’s St. Martin-in-the-Fields; the brilliant white St. Andrew’s Kirk (1818), with its black weather vane topped by a crowing cock; and the newly consecrated St. Paul’s Cathedral (1847). The city even had a golf course; founded in 1829, the Royal Calcutta Golf Club was the oldest outside the British Isles. There were, to be sure, also less salubrious ways to pass time. In the 1750s, Robert Clive, the celebrated soldier and first governor of Bengal, called it “one of the most wicked places in the Universe … Rapacious and Luxurious beyond concepcion [sic].”11
Fortune’s exact destination, though, lay five miles downriver from the city itself: the Calcutta Botanic Garden.
He was met at the garden’s riverside ghat (steps down to the river) by Dr. Falconer, a heavy-set northern Scot from the coastal village of Forres, with whom Fortune had been corresponding. Anxious to see how the tea had fared, the Wardian cases were unloaded. As Fortune later wrote:
When the cases were opened in Calcutta the young tea-plants were found to be in good condition. The seeds which had been sown between the rows were also just beginning to germinate. These, of course, were left undisturbed, as there was room enough for them to grow; but it was necessary to take other measures with those in the camellia cases. On opening the latter, the whole mass of seeds, from the bottom to the top, was swelling, and germination had just commenced. The camellias, which had now arrived at their destination, were lifted gently out and potted, and appeared as if they had never left their native country. Fourteen new cases were got ready, filled with earth, and these germinating seeds were sown thickly over the surface, and covered with soil in the usual way. In a few days the young plants came sprouting through the soil; every seed seemed to have grown …12
Their journey far from over, the smuggled botanical jewels now had to be quickly taken from tropical Calcutta up to the Company’s gardens in the Himalayas. Within ten days the collection of plants, tools, and Chinese tea makers were ready to move on. Fortune had already been gone for nearly three years by then, but instead of returning home to England and his family, he accompanied the tea and its entourage.
As the monsoon rains were still a few months off, and the Hooghly River too shallow upstream to travel by boat, the group was obliged to take a ship back down to the Bay of Bengal to access the main branch of the Ganges where it flowed into the sea. Under the brutal late-March sun, the ship slid away from Calcutta in the ebb tide, down the Hooghly, and into the tangled tidal fringes and deltaic channels of the Sundarbans, the swampy, intermittently submerged archipelagic maze of mangrove forest that fingers into the sea. Narrow-snooted gharial crocodiles, soft-shelled turtles, and stocky freshwater sharks swam in abundance. From the shoreline or perched in tipsy wooden canoes, bare-chested fishermen cast nets for freshwater eel, catfish, and carp, including the golden mahseer, with its large, thick scales the size of tea saucers. The ship joined the main channel of the Ganges and traveled three hundred miles north to the Rajmahal Hills, then followed the river’s northwest arc to Allahabad, more than five hundred miles farther upstream. In the nineteenth century, thousands of “blind” Ganges River dolphins swam there, foraging in the muddy bed with their long, narrow beaks and large flippers, and Fortune would have seen schools of them rolling on the water and ducking and diving under the surface.
His travelogue, though, mentions none of this, nor of the opium growing along the river valley. While he passed through the main opium-producing belt of British India during the harvesting season and surely saw peasants lancing the plump, pale-green poppy capsules and scraping off the tarry sap with curved knives, the only references to opium in his book were to ruffian addicts he encountered in China—never of the drug’s source. “All the towns on its banks have already been frequently described in accounts of India,” he wrote instead. “I may, therefore, simply state that we passed in succession the large towns of Patna, Dinapoor, Ghazepoor, Benares, and Mirzapoor, and reached Allahabad on the 14th of April.”13
Beyond Allahabad, the Ganges is strewn with shoals and rapids and not navigable by boat, so the entourage had to continue its journey by land. The twenty-eight Wardian cases plus the tea-processing implements filled nine bullock-pulled wagons. Throughout the 450-mile journey, fraught with danger, hardship, and, for the Scot, deep exoticism, he kept to his austere style. “In due time all arrived at their destination in perfect safety,”14 he wrote, with impressive restraint, of the weeks plodding northwest toward the Himalayas as the heat of the plains grew fierce.
The destination was Saharanpur, a former Mughal garden laid out in the mid-eighteenth century in the lower foothills. “When the cases were opened, the tea-plants were found to be in a very healthy state,” Fortune wrote. “No fewer than 12,838 plants were counted in the cases, and many more were germinating. Notwithstanding their long voyage from the north of China, and the frequent transshipment and changes by the way, they seemed as green and vigorous as if they had been all the while growing on the Chinese hills.”15
Between these and the earlier batches, Fortune added, by his own estimation, nearly twenty thousand new tea plants from China into India.16
Having safely delivered his charges—both plants and tea makers—to their new homes, Fortune spent the remainder of the spring and summer touring the government’s infant Himalayan tea plantations. At last, he began his long journey home. The first stage from the mountains to Calcutta took a month, visiting en route “the well-known cities of Delhi and Agra.”17 Fortune arrived in Calcutta at the end of August and stayed with Dr. Falconer at the botanic garden until a mail steamer was ready to depart for England.
“On the 5th of September I had the pleasure of seeing the Victoria regia flower for the first time in India,” he wrote, referring to the giant water lily with leaves that can measure nearly six feet across and bear the weight of a young teenager. “It was growing luxuriantly in one of the ponds in the botanic garden, and no doubt will soon be a great ornament to Indian gardens. It will soon reign as the queen of flowers in every land, and, like our beloved sovereign whose name it bears, the sun will never set on its dominions.”18
Those are the final lines of Fortune
’s book. It ends not on tea, the purpose of his journey, the obsession that drove the three-and-a-half-year undertaking, but rather an ornamental water lily gathered in the South American Amazon.
Fortune returned to the Far East thrice more—once in the service of the U.S. government to find tea that could grow in the southern states—and traveled to China as well as Japan, Indonesia, Taiwan, and the Philippines in search of plants. He is credited with introducing some 120 new species into Western gardens.
But little is known about Fortune himself outside the adventure- and plant-filled travelogues. As fascinating as these are to read, they are, for the most part, impersonal. Given his restraint in writing nothing of Agra or its sumptuous Taj Mahal to a society hungry for the exotic, it is no surprise that he was equally reticent of himself.
When Fortune died in 1880, his family—who are absent from his works—burned his diaries, letters, and personal effects. The few photos that remain show a stern-looking man with a high forehead and heavy lamb-chop whiskers. He looks remarkably similar throughout the years. In the final portrait, his forehead is higher and the whiskers friskier and fringed in white.
But the tea plants he smuggled from China carry on. From Saharanpur, they spread to various Himalayan plantations. And some of that exceptional stock eventually made its way to Darjeeling, where it would eventually produce the world’s finest and most expensive teas.
* * *
* In 2001 Calcutta changed its name to its Bengali equivalent, Kolkata, losing the longer, languid u to something sharper. The shift to its precolonial moniker was an effort to help preserve its Bengali identity.