by Ben Bova
“Really?”
Grechko nodded, his ever-present smile temporarily replaced by something close to a scowl.
DiNardo mused, “I wonder how the Americans feel about it?”
“There is Brownstein, we can ask him.”
Murray Brownstein was taller than the Italian priest and the Russian physicist by several inches, yet his back was so stooped that he looked almost small, slight, in his gray jacket and off-white chino slacks. His face was California tan, his once-golden hair now graying and so thin that he combed it forward to cover as much of his high forehead as possible. Where DiNardo looked like a swarthy overaged wrestler and Grechko resembled a pleasantly puzzled old man, Brownstein had an air of intense dissatisfaction about him, as if the world never quite managed to please him.
He saw Grechko and DiNardo coming toward him and immediately flicked his eyes toward an empty corner down the corridor. Without a word the three men fell into step and walked away from the crowd at the refreshment table: Grechko with a glass of tea in his hand, Brownstein holding a can of diet cola, DiNardo empty-handed.
“What do you think of all this?” Brownstein spoke first as they reached the corner. His voice was low, tight, like a conspirator who was afraid of being overheard.
DiNardo made an Italian gesture. “Brumado has given our colleagues a chance to vent their anger, but now even he is growing short-tempered.”
Brownstein said bitterly, “It’s all a frigging waste of time. Our government’s already made its decision.”
“You are not pleased?” asked Grechko.
“I don’t like scientific decisions being made in Washington and then rammed down my throat.”
DiNardo said, “But perhaps the decision is a good one. After all, the canyon is an extremely interesting environment. If I had been allowed my own way, the teams would have been landed on the canyon floor.”
“Much too risky for the first mission,” Grechko said flatly.
“I disagreed then, and I disagree now,” DiNardo said, without a trace of rancor.
“The science may be okay,” Brownstein said. “It’s the politics that rankles me. If we allow the politicians to override our decisions …”
DiNardo interrupted, “But that is why this meeting was called. So that we scientists could make our decision and then inform the politicians of it.”
“Doesn’t matter what we decide. That damned Indian is going to Tithonium whether we like it or not.”
“You mean Dr. Waterman, not Dr. Patel.”
“Yeah, right. Waterman.”
“But if the sense of this meeting is opposed to changing the mission plan,” Grechko said, “that will force the politicians to reconsider.”
“No it won’t. The Japs are going along with the new plan.”
“They are?”
Brownstein nodded grimly. “Tanaka was in the same plane with me. He happened to be at CalTech when this meeting was called. He told me Tokyo has agreed with Washington to okay the Tithonium diversion.”
“Without consulting their own scientists or mission directors?” Grechko seemed shocked.
“It’s a done deal,” Brownstein said. “All we’re doing here is jerking off.”
DiNardo raised his eyebrows slightly.
“Unless,” Brownstein added, “we decide to make a fight of it.”
“No,” said the priest.
The two other men stared at him. Brownstein almost snarled, “You’re willing to let some ignorant bunch of politicians tell us what to do?”
“In this case, yes.”
Brownstein shook his head, more in anger than in sorrow. Grechko tasked, “Why?”
“There are at least two very powerful reasons not to oppose this decision.”
“Damned if I see even one,” Brownstein said. “If we let the politicians win this one, next thing you know they’ll be telling us how to tie our fucking shoes!”
“As a geologist,” DiNardo said, with hardly a wince at the American’s language, “I agree with Waterman. The canyon is the best place to go, considering the limitations of time, equipment, and supplies of this mission.”
“And skip the volcanoes entirely?” Grechko asked. His little smile seemed to irritate Brownstein.
“If we are forced to make an either-or choice, I would say, yes, skip the volcanoes altogether. However, I believe we can at least make a preliminary reconnaissance of Pavonis Mons. A few days, at least.”
“That’s your professional opinion, is it?” Brownstein asked.
“Yes. As a geologist I agree with the politicians.”
“You said there were two reasons,” Grechko prodded.
“The second reason is political. Actually,” the priest said, making himself smile at Brownstein, “a mixture of science and politics.”
He hesitated until Brownstein asked impatiently, “Well, what is it?”
“I don’t believe it is wise, to try to fight the politicians when they have made a decision that is reasonably sound, scientifically.”
Before either of the other two could say a word, DiNardo went on, “Besides, the most likely place for our team to find traces of life is in the canyon. I am willing to take the chance that they will find something there. Something that will force the politicians to agree to further missions.”
Brownstein started to shake his head, but Grechko mused, “Certainly it would seem that the canyon is a better environment for life than the volcanoes. It’s like comparing the jungles of Brazil to the mountains of Tibet, isn’t it?”
“The Martian equivalent, yes,” DiNardo agreed.
“I still don’t like it,” Brownstein muttered. “If we give in to the politicians on this one, we’re opening a can of worms that’ll ruin everything in the long run.”
“Then we must not appear to be giving in to the politicians,” said DiNardo. “We must convince our colleagues to insist on the excursion to Tithonium—while keeping as much of the earlier mission plan as possible.”
Brownstein grimaced. “That’s a tall order.”
“It can be done,” DiNardo said quietly. “I am certain that Brumado will be in favor.”
Grechko’s smile widened perceptibly. “Then you can get up on your feet and try to convince the rest of them.”
DiNardo smiled back. “Oh no. I will convince Brumado. Then he will convince all the others.”
“Spoken like a true Jesuit,” said Grechko.
Brownstein snorted, but said nothing.
The crowd was beginning to stream back upstairs. The three men started back to the auditorium.
God grant me the strength to succeed, DiNardo said to himself. Then he thought, And God grant James Waterman good hunting on Mars.
SOL 22: AFTERNOON
Ravavishnu Patel stared at the broad, regal cone of Pavonis Mons. The volcano filled the horizon like a reclining Buddha, like a slumbering Shiva, destroyer of worlds—and their restorer.
“It’s a shame Toshima is not with us.” Abdul al-Naguib’s soft voice broke Patel’s nearly hypnotic spell.
The two men were leaning over the empty seats in the cockpit of the rover. Jamie and the cosmonaut Mironov were outside, placing geology/meteorology beacons on the rock-strewn ground.
“Toshima?” asked Patel, feeling slightly puzzled.
Naguib smiled. “It would remind him of Fujiyama, don’t you think?”
“Oh. Yes, perhaps. Although this volcano is very much larger. And there is no snow at its top. And the slope is quite different.”
“Different gravity field,” Naguib said, as if that explained everything.
“Yes. Of course.”
After a full day’s travel, a night’s stop out in the open plain, and a morning of jouncing over the roughening terrain, the rover was still more than a hundred kilometers from the base of Pavonis Mons. It was too big to be seen in its entirety close up. Only from this distance could they view the entire structure.
Like the volcanoes that formed the Hawaiian Island
s, the giants of the Tharsis region are shield volcanoes, lofty cones surrounded by wide bases of solidified lava. Pavonis Mons was the central of three such volcanoes, and the closest to the explorers’ domed base. The two others sat far over the curving horizon. Farther still beyond them was the most massive—and tallest—volcano in the entire solar system: Olympus Mons.
Pavonis Mons is a middleweight in comparison to mighty Mount Olympus. Pavonis’s base is scarcely four hundred kilometers across, about the width of Ohio. Its peak is hardly ten miles above the uplifted plain on which the rover sat. At its top is a crater, a caldera, barely wide enough to swallow Delhi or Calcutta.
For all its size, though, its slope looked deceptively gentle. Not like the steep rugged peaks of the Himalayas; Pavonis Mons’s flanks rose at a five-degree angle. Patel thought a man might walk to the summit easily, given a few days, and peer down into that yawning caldera. Was it truly dead? Or would he see fumaroles venting steam or wisps of other gases, preparing for the next eruption? The sky looked clear, cloudless. But what would he find if he could get to the top?
Patel shook his head, almost in tears, and said to Naguib, “To think that we will have only three days to spend there. Three little days! It would take months merely to make a preliminary survey.”
This excursion to Pavonis Mons had been the first casualty of Jamie’s insistence on returning to the Grand Canyon. The original mission schedule had called for a week’s stay at Pavonis. That had been cut to three days.
Naguib gave him a fatherly pat on the back. “Even three years would not be enough. A man could spend his entire life studying this beast.”
“It isn’t fair!” Patel burst out, banging a fist on the back of the empty pilot’s seat. “The entire reason for my coming to Mars was to study the Tharsis shields and now this … this … upstart …”
“Calm yourself, my friend,” said Naguib. “Calm yourself. Accept what cannot be changed.”
Patel pulled away and walked down the rover module as far as the airlock hatch. Then he turned back toward the Egyptian. The two men stood silently, facing each other along the narrow length of the module: the slim, liquid-eyed Hindu, his dark face shining as if sheened in sweat; the older, stockier geophysicist, graying at the temples, lines etched at the corners of his eyes and mouth.
“The next thing you will tell me is that this is the will of Allah,” said Patel.
“I am an atheist,” Naguib replied, smiling gently. “But I realize that our Navaho friend has prevailed with the mission directors, and the Americans have seized control of the mission plan. There is nothing we can do about it.”
They heard the clumping of the two other men entering the airlock. Patel’s slim hands clenched into fists, and for a moment Naguib thought that he would gladly murder Waterman.
While the three geological scientists were off on their excursion, the three biological scientists spent their spare time planning the coming trip to Tithonium Chasma.
They sat at the galley table, strewn with maps and photographs taken from the orbiting spacecraft. They had all watched Jamie’s videotapes until they knew them by heart.
“Is it possible to believe that the formation could be a building of some kind?” Monique Bonnet asked.
Tony Reed, who had joined the three women when he saw them bringing their photos and papers to the galley, dismissed the idea. “It’s projection on Jamie’s part, a well-known psychological phenomenon,” he said. “We see what we want to see. We hear what we want to hear. That’s how palm readers make their money, telling their customers what they want to hear, no matter how outrageous it is. Something in Jamie’s subconscious wanted to see cliff dwellings and, voilà! he saw them.”
Ilona leaned back in her chair, reminding Reed of a tawny jaguar stretching on a tree branch.
“The formation truly exists. It is not imaginary. We will see for ourselves whether it is natural or artificial once we get there,” she said, her husky voice sounding almost bored with the subject. “For now, we must decide which of us goes on the excursion with Jamie.”
Joanna nodded agreement and turned to Monique.
“You go,” said the French geochemist. “The two of you. I will remain here and tend the plants.”
Ilona frowned at her.
“You don’t want to go?” Joanna asked.
Monique made a Gallic shrug. “You want to much more than I do. It makes more sense for our biologist and biochemist to go.”
“But you are a part of our biology team, too,” said Ilona, straightening up in her chair. “We will need your expertise to test the soil at the bottom of the canyon.”
“You can bring samples back here to me.”
“But what about fossils?” Joanna asked, looking worried. “You have the most training in paleontology. We might miss something.”
Monique laughed lightly. “If there are any bones or skulls out there I’m sure you can find them as easily as I.”
“Microfossils?” Reed asked.
She turned her dimpled smiling face to the Englishman. “Tony, I have scanned every soil sample that we have taken. I have cracked rocks open and put microtome-thin slices under the microscope. There are no fossils. No microbes, living or long dead.”
Reed fingered his slim moustache. “Well …”
“But, Monique,” said Joanna, “suppose we come across fossils at the bottom of the canyon but we don’t recognize them as such? Organisms native to Mars. How would we know that we are looking at fossils?”
“How would I know?” Monique shot back. “How would any of us?”
Joanna cast an uneasy glance at her colleagues around the table.
Reed broke into a wide grin. “A classic problem, isn’t it? How do you recognize something that you’ve never seen before?”
The three women had no answer.
Jamie could feel the hostility building within the cramped confines of the rover with every kilometer they covered on their way to Pavonis Mons.
Dinner that evening was virtually silent. Even Mironov, whose normal expression was a pleasant smile, had nothing to say, no jokes to offer. Patel, perched like a nervous bird on the edge of the bench across the narrow table from Jamie, would not look at him.
Naguib tried to ease the tension.
“Tomorrow we reach the fracture zone, at last,” he said, mopping up the last bits of his meal with a thin piece of pita bread.
Feeling grateful, Jamie answered the older man, “Right. And we begin to get some absolute dates for the age of the lava flows.”
Patel put his fork down. “We have three little days to do the work that was originally scheduled for a full week.”
“I’m willing to work double shifts for those three days, Rava,” said Jamie. “I know you …”
“You know nothing!” the Hindu snapped. “Nothing except your mad desire to go to the canyon again and make yourself the hero of this expedition.”
“Hero?”
“Do you know how many years I have spent studying the Tharsis volcanoes? Not three. Not five. Not ten.” Patel was trembling with rage. “Fifteen years! Since I was an undergraduate in Delhi! For fifteen years I have pored over photographs of those shields, studied the remote measurements made by spacecraft. And now that I am finally here, you have cut down my time to three miserable days.”
Jamie felt no anger. He knew exactly what Patel was going through. He remembered how he had felt when Vosnesensky cut short his examination of the canyon and the cliff dwellings because of Konoye’s death.
“You’re right, Rava,” he said slowly, his voice deep and calm and implacable. “Only three days. I’ll do everything I can to help you learn as much as possible during our stay at Pavonis. But after three days we go back.”
“So you can ride out to the canyon.”
“Yes.”
“And look for your absurd cliff dwellings.”
“Look for life.”
“Bah! Nonsense! Absolute nonsense.”
“Rava, if I truly had my way we would stay here on Mars for a year or more. We would have new teams arriving. We would be exploring this planet on a rational scientific basis. But I don’t have my way. None of us does.”
“You have more of your way than I have of mine,” Patel grumbled.
Jamie acknowledged the point with a dip of his head. “Yes, that’s so. But if you want to come back to Mars someday and spend as much time as you like studying these volcanoes, then we’ve got to bring the politicians something that they can’t ignore. They can’t ignore evidence of life, Rava. And the most likely place to find life—even evidence of extinct life—is at the bottom of Tithonium Chasma.”
“There are other places,” Naguib said, “equally likely. Hellas, for example …”
“We can’t reach that far on this mission,” said Jamie. “It’s halfway around the planet. The canyon is as far as we can get this time, and even that’s stretching things.”
“You can be perfectly rational, can’t you, when you are getting what you want,” Patel said.
“I’m not going to argue with you, Rava,” Jamie replied. “I understand how you feel. I’d feel the same way if our positions were reversed.”
“Yes, of course.”
Jamie slid out from behind the narrow table and stood at his full height. Looking down at Patel he said, “If my jaunt out to the canyon had been scrubbed in favor of extending your stay at the volcanoes, I’d be sore as hell. But I’d accept it and try to do my best to make your excursion a success.”
Patel turned away from him.
Mironov, his usual smile long disappeared, said quietly, “I suggest that we drop this topic of conversation. The mission plan is firm. We spend the next three days at Pavonis Mons and then return to the base. No further arguments.”
Jamie nodded and headed up toward the cockpit. Naguib made a small shrug of acceptance. Patel grimaced and stared after Jamie, his dark eyes burning.
When Tony Reed tried to sleep he heard the night wind of Mars moaning outside the dome. The noise unsettled him. One little meteor hit, a bit of dust so small that they could find no trace of it afterward, had almost killed them all. Oh, it’s very well for Vosnesensky and the others to boast that all the safety systems worked and we were never in actual danger: My left foot! We could have all been asphyxiated. No, we wouldn’t have lasted that long. The blood and fluids in our bodies would have boiled. We would have popped like overcooked sausages, exploded like pricked balloons.