Cowboys Mine

by Stacey Espino

  Eva had hoped they’d take control once alone with her. Her body was a hormonal mess, her thoughts continually drifting to her basest desires. She didn’t want to spell out the fact that she wanted them to fuck her. How could they have forgotten their night in the city?

  “Why’d you bring us here, Eva?” asked Colton.

  “So we can be alone.”

  She couldn’t walk away once the roast was over, not after seeing them all evening. All her old perceptions had changed, and they were no longer just North and Colt, her best friends from the next ranch over. They were her everything, not to mention the perfect specimens of the male form—tall, strong, and muscular. She thought back to all the times she’d seen them working under the sun in just their blue jeans or the many nights they’d slept cuddled beside her in nothing but fitted boxer briefs. How had she managed to look past those devastatingly good looks for so long?

  “It’s getting late. What do you want to do?” asked North.

  “I want you both to make love to me.”

  “Here?”

  “Here.”

  Colt shifted to his side, cupping her cheek in his big hand. “I want a lot more than this night, Eva.”

  “I know. I’m giving you all of me—tonight and forever.”

  North squatted down next to her. “People will talk. You don’t even know if your own parents will approve.”

  “It’s better than the alternative.” Eva leaned close enough to steal a kiss from Colt. He didn’t push her away as she half expected, but he kissed her back. She moaned into his mouth, loving the feel of his lips and brush of his tongue.

  “God, I’ve missed you, baby girl.” He kissed her with passion, the length of his body pressed against her. She closed her eyes, absorbing how good it felt to be in Colton’s good graces again.

  When he attempted to unbutton her jeans, she immediately helped him, not wanting him to change his mind. Her body was hotwired, her pussy contracting in distracting waves. North tugged her pants clean off her body, her bare legs breaking out into gooseflesh from the cool evening air.

  She reached into the big pockets of her sweater coat and pulled out a small tube of lube, handing it to Colton.

  “Where’d you get that?”

  “You left it in the silver bullet.”

  North settled on her other side. He brushed her hair to the side and peppered kisses along the back of her neck. “Tell us what you want, Eva.” His voice was gruff, making her even needier. She could feel their feral desire all around her.

  “I want both of you,” she said. “Together.”

  “We’re both here.” Colt’s hand drifted south, his fingers slipping under the waist of her panties. She parted her legs, hoping to guide him to where she needed him. Her inner folds were already swollen and moist, preparing for what was to come.

  “That’s not what I mean.” Eva remembered how it felt when Colton had penetrated her asshole with a finger. It had created a wild burst of sensation that was incomparable. And she figured it was the only way for her to truly marry their ménage a trios. She wanted to feel both men claim her, binding them together in new, wondrous ways. Surely they’d been curious of the same thing. She’d heard other people talk about the pleasures of anal sex, so it couldn’t be too bad—even if Colton and North were hung like horses.

  “Tell me, sweet thing.” Colt bent two fingers into her pussy. She grabbed his shoulder, digging her nails in as he pushed harder. Eva couldn’t even answer, not with her inner walls pulsing around his invading fingers. She wanted to cry out for more, but managed to keep a measure of composure.

  “I want both of you to have sex with me.”

  “We can do that,” said North with a growl. He tugged off her bulky sweater, trailing kisses along her bare shoulder blades. Shivers skittered along her skin as his rough hands roamed along her exposed curves. She felt surrounded, warm, and sexually alive.

  “This time you’re mine first.” Colt rolled her clit between his fingers, making her gasp for air. He knew exactly how to touch her, as if he knew her body better than she knew herself. “I’ve been dreaming about you since Chester.”

  She shook her head, barely capable of speech. It felt so good to be wanted and desires. “No, I can take both of you at the same time.”

  “You can’t handle both of us, Eva. It’s best to take turns,” said Colt.

  “I really need both of you.”

  North pushed down her panties and smoothed his hand over the globe of her ass. “It’ll hurt too much.”

  Just the feather light touch of North’s finger along the seam of her ass made her see stars. “Don’t stop,” she murmured. Colton’s fingers fucking her pussy, with the addition of North’s forbidden touch, stole all her inhibitions. She wanted to experience everything, and she wouldn’t take no for an answer.

  North trailed some of the natural juices trickling down her inner thighs back to her ass. He caressed her nether hole until she gasped for air. “If we do this, you’ll need to be prepared first.” As he pressed his finger all the way into her rear, she clamped down on him, loving the feel of the foreign object in her asshole. “Shit, you’re tight, baby.”

  “More,” she said.

  The men kissed her, crowded her, and continued to mimic the sex act with just their fingers.

  “I’ll whittle some of that ginger,” said North.

  “Good call,” said Colton.

  She had no clue what they were agreeing on, but North got up, tossed his shirt, and headed over to the burlap sacks in the corner. He went to work, carving one of the roots, rather than rejoining them.

  “What’s he doing?” she asked Colton. He rolled over her, positioning his body between her legs. Her panties slid back into place when she spread her legs, but it didn’t stop her from rubbing her pussy against his denim-clad cock.

  “He’s fashioning a plug to prepare you. The oil from the ginger will dull the pain.” He kissed all over her face, not solely from raw passion, but adoration. She could feel the mix of sexual love and the same unconditional McReed acceptance she’d known for a lifetime. It was beautiful and addicting.

  North returned, his chest bare and jeans low on his hips. His body was hard and lean-muscled, no extra fat. “You can still change your mind, Eva. I won’t care.”

  “I want to.”

  She knew the McReed brothers were unorthodox and had strong sexual appetites, if all the stories in town were true. But now they were hers, and hers alone, and she delighted in all their expertise.

  “Roll her to her belly,” said North.

  Colton did as asked, rising to his knees so he could turn her over. She rested on her forearms until a strong hand to her back forced her to lie flat on her stomach. Her panties were slid down her thighs until off her body, leaving her completely nude on the old patchwork quilt. One or both of the twins rubbed her bottom, patting it enough to make it jiggle. The friction travelled all the way around to her clit.

  “Get ready for his,” said North. “It’s gonna sting, but it’ll make things easier for later.”

  Colt kissed her forehead, rubbing circles on her back as North pressed a dollop of lube against her asshole. “It’s an old cowboy trick, baby girl.”

  “Do it,” she squeaked, not wanting her nerves to take over.

  The ginger root burned her delicate anal tissues as North slowly pressed it against her rear entrance. He moved in such tiny increments she questioned if he moved at all.

  “Relax, Eva, or it’ll feel worse. Bear down.”

  She did as asked, trusting both brothers completely. Eva pushed back against the invading phallus. Her breath picked up along with her rising nerves. She reminded herself that this was exactly what she wanted, and real cowgirls didn’t wimp out from a little pain.

  After a few minutes the homemade plug slipped past her unforgiving sphincter muscle, lodging into place. She gasped, then sighed, knowing the hardest part was over. The entire time Colton cooed in her ear, givi
ng her the strength she needed.

  “Perfect fit,” said North. “Now don’t clench down on it or it’ll burn. Just keep nice and limber.”

  “It gets better,” Colton whispered in her ear. “Promise.”

  She trusted Colt’s promises, and hoped he trusted hers. This was the beginning of something beautiful. Never in her life did she imagine getting hitched to the McReed twins. Now she realized they were her only possible future.

  They rolled her to her back. The butt plug shifted inside her, a mix of pleasure and pain.

  “Open your legs, Eva. I want to see your pretty little pussy.” Colt helped spread her legs open at the knees. “Fucking gorgeous. Look at that, North.”

  Both men knelt before her open legs, her most intimate parts on display for them. She wasn’t embarrassed like she knew she’d be with a boyfriend. Colton and North were so much more, a second protective skin.

  “She’s pink and swollen.” North petted her pussy, his fingers gently caressing her engorged folds.

  Eva felt dirty and wanton. She savored the twins’ attention, relieved they no longer pushed her away. Tonight she’d make them hers.

  Chapter Fifteen

  North couldn’t tear his eyes away from Eva’s splayed legs. Her pussy was ripe and the bulbous end of the ginger root protruded from her asshole. It was erotic as hell.

  She wriggled, getting accustomed to the foreign invasion. Her skin was pale in the moonlight, her stomach smooth and nipples beaded tight. She was a vision, and his cock had never been harder. He’d have to keep a tight rein on himself tonight. Eva was still inexperienced and he wanted to introduce her to new things slowly. But his patience was already being tested when he wanted nothing more than to sink into her tight little cunt.

  “How does it feel now?” he asked.

  “Not so bad.” She reached her arms out for him. “Kiss me.”

  He lowered along the side of her, intertwining his fingers with hers. He kissed her on the mouth, losing himself in her sweet taste. North had never known what it felt like to really love a woman, and he never expected to. The entire idea of marriage and commitment turned him off after what he’d witnessed at home growing up. Although he’d had plenty of girlfriends and one-nighters over the years, the best of those experiences paled in comparison to one kiss from Eva Ford. He loved her so much it scared him.

  When Eva opened her mouth, her fingers tightening around his, he knew Colt had gone down on her. He saw his brother’s blond head buried between her legs. She kept her knees loose, her head tossed back and eyes closed.

  It was time to bring her to a higher level to prepare her for their dual invasion. He was still unsure if a true ménage a trios was a good idea for such a tight, young thing. But Eva wanted it to happen and, of course, there was nothing North wanted more.

  He collected both her thin wrists in one hand, bringing them above her head. He kept them locked in place as he descended on her exposed breasts. North suckled her tits, her mewling cries exciting him. She writhed and arched, the ginger root doing its job in preparing her.

  “I like it,” she chanted. “Oh God…”

  “You like it when Colt eats your pussy?”

  “Yes!”

  “I can’t wait to fuck you, baby girl.”

  She began to pant, an orgasm not far off. Colt pulled away before she could reach that peak. They needed her wound tight before attempting to double-fuck her.

  “Why’d you stop?” she asked.

  Colt hovered over her body. “You have to wait, little miss.”

  “I’m ready. I want you both. Please.”

  “It’ll be different with two men, Eva. There will be two cocks buried deep inside you.” He kissed between her breasts. “You’ll be filled to overflowing.”

  “Have you shared a woman before?” Eva asked.

  North didn’t expect her to ask about their sexual past. She knew they’d been around because they never hid it from her. But he’d never shared a woman with Colt. This was as new for them as it was for Eva.

  “You’re the first,” Colt said. “And the last.”

  The threesome came about so naturally that North never stopped to consider the public reaction. Colton wanted to talk about the consequences when they were in Chester, but North had brushed him off. Sharing felt right, a logical progression for North, his twin, and Eva. He only hoped Mr. Ford didn’t run them off. It would mean losing Eva and the family he’d grown to love.

  “Take that thing out,” said Eva. “I want the real thing.”

  North settled on the quilt beside Eva and kicked off his jeans. “Come straddle me,” he said. He knew Colt would want to take her virgin hole this time around, and it was only fair.

  She twisted to her hands and knees, crawling over his body, her long hair tickling his skin. “I love you,” she said, kissing his stomach and chest as she travelled higher.

  “Never leave me,” he said before kissing her lips. It would destroy him to lose her now.

  “Why would I?”

  He held her close, loving the warm skin to skin contact. Mentioning his worries and fears about Mr. Ford’s reaction to her news would only douse their rising passion.

  North held the base of his cock, guiding Eva lower. “Sit on me, sweetheart. Go nice and slow.”

  “Take the ginger out.”

  “Colt’ll take it out in a minute. Come on now.” He was getting anxious, his balls pulling tight to his body. All he could think about now was Eva’s pussy sinking down over his erection.

  She was sopping wet, easily slipping into position. She eased her weight down, her tight walls hugging him in a welcome embrace. He groaned, holding her hips as she lowered all the way to the hilt. It felt like heaven.

  “I love how that feels,” she said. “You’re so big. You take away my ache.”

  “Good girl,” he said. “You’re just perfect.”

  Eva rose up and came down slowly. It was exquisite torture. “Am I doing it right?”

  “Yes, baby. Keep going.”

  His eyes lolled back in his head as she worked his erection. She was a beautiful sight, her perk breasts bouncing slightly each time she came down. He could see Colton standing behind her, carefully lubing up his cock. North was worried they’d hurt Eva, but he also trusted his brother to have her best interest in mind.

  After a few minutes of teasingly slow sex, Colton joined them.

  “Lean forward, Eva. I’m taking the ginger out now.” His twin pressed her down so she was chest to chest with North, his cock bending inside of her.

  North could feel the pressure ease when Colton plucked the plug out of her ass.

  “Better?” he asked.

  She was quiet at first, not answering. “I feel empty now. Empty and tingly, Colt.”

  “I’m going to put my cock inside your ass now. You sure you want to try this?”

  “I have to get used to it now, because I plan to have a lot of it.”

  Her grip on North’s shoulders tightened when Colton knelt behind her, getting himself in the right place.

  ****

  Colton had allowed his twin to take Eva’s virginity. Now he planned to take her ass for the first time, and he practically came just thinking about it. Her little asshole was open for him, thanks to the ginger plug. With his cock thoroughly lubed up, the introduction should be as painless as possible for Eva.

  He pressed the broad head of his cock between her cheeks, only pushing in about an inch before giving her a break. She was tighter than fuck with North’s big dick already waiting inside her. When Eva had first suggested they double-team her, his cock instantly sprang to life. It was a fantasy of every man. Add the fact he loved Eva more than he did himself, and he was raring to go.

  “You okay?” he asked, after pushing in another long inch.

  “Stop babying me, Colt. I’m hot all over, and you’re killing me going so slow.”

  His twin lifted a brow, just as surprised by Eva’s eagerness as him. He
kept going until the full length of his cock was inside her, along with North. The fit was incredibly tight around him.

  “How’s that?” he asked.

  Eva made a strangled sound, a mix of a gasp and a moan. “I’m so full. I think I’m going to come.”

  “Shit, not yet, darlin’,” said North. “Let us have a bit of fun first.”

  They began to work her body. It was awkward at first getting used to the logistics, but once they’d decided on a position the developed a steady rhythm. They fucked her good, pistoning in and out of her pussy and ass like a well-oiled machine. It was true they’d never shared a woman in bed, but it all proceeded naturally, like they were meant to have Eva sandwiched between them. Colton felt like the luckiest man in the world.

  The pressure in his balls grew to intolerable levels. Although his body was ready for release, he wanted to go on all night long. He was enjoying her too much to stop now.

  “More,” she cried. He could feel her ass spasming around him, warning of her imminent orgasm. Colton couldn’t wait to feel her milk their cocks simultaneously. They moved faster, thrusting vigorously in Eva’s willing body. All three of them were a mass of limbs and overheated flesh. It was perfect.

  He nipped the back of her shoulder, reaching around to knead her breast. The further they got into the sex act, the rougher and more animalistic they all became. Little Eva could take a hard fucking and still demanded more.

  “I love your ass. Do you like me fucking your ass, baby girl?”

  “Yes,” she gasped.

  “You’re all ours now. Every inch of you.” He wanted to own her, love her, protect her, and keep her as theirs. Never had one human meant so much to him.

  “It’s happening!” she shouted as if afraid of the intensity of her impending release.

  “Don’t fight it,” Colton said. “Relax and let your body guide you through it.”

  She came hard, her body suddenly bucking to a sharp halt, her ass clamping down on his dick without mercy. Then she exploded. Eva screamed with every contraction, the feminine sound turning him on like never before. As her inner walls kneaded both of them, Colton finally came, his hot cum spraying on and on into Eva’s ass. The relief was instantaneous. He groaned as every last seed spilled inside her, along with every ounce of his energy.