There was some political dissent in Sverdlovsk in the Brezhnev years, by individuals and, rarely, by very small organizations. A memo sent to the Central Committee Secretariat by Yurii Andropov on June 12, 1970, detailed the arrests in Sverdlovsk of seven members of a Party of Free Russia, later renamed the Revolutionary Workers Party. In 1969 they had run off 700 anti-Soviet pamphlets, stuck some to walls, and pelted 200 of them, from a viaduct over Cosmonauts Prospect, onto the official parade during the November 7 festivities. Student A. V. Avakov was jailed in 1975 for distributing 300 leaflets at Urals State University and reading out a speech made by Leon Trotsky in the 1920s. Around the same time, a League for the Liberation of the Urals put out flyers calling for a popular referendum on “autonomy of the Urals.” No culprits were found. In February 1979, during the election campaign for the USSR Supreme Soviet, an unnamed Sverdlovsk group called on citizens to vote against the official nominees: “Comrades, let us cross out the names of the sellout candidates. They will forget about us right after the election. It doesn’t bother them that the party has put itself above the people and above the law, that prices are rising and the stores are empty.” This, too, went into the cold-case file.39
Yeltsin would have been within eyeshot of the 1969 protest and would have heard about some of these incidents through party channels. After November 1976, as first secretary, he was more fully informed and had to invest in the cultural domination and ideological hygiene that engross all authoritarian regimes. As came with the job description, his reports to CPSU meetings were now flecked with paeans to political conformity and harangues against Western imperialism. In September 1977 he carried out a Politburo directive to raze the building on Karl Liebknecht Street in whose cellar Tsar Nicholas II, his family, and four of their retainers were killed after the Bolshevik Revolution by a firing squad. Ipat’ev House was the two-story mansion of Nikolai Ipat’ev, a Urals merchant; the Romanovs lived in it as captives from April 1918, when they were brought there by horse and carriage from Tobol’sk, until the execution the night of July 17–18.40 It was in connection with this place that Yeltsin came to the attention of Andropov, the leading Kremlin hawk on demolition. An Andropov letter to the Politburo is dated July 26, 1975; the bureau’s resolution assigning the Sverdlovsk obkom to tear the house down, and present it as part of “the planned reconstruction of the city,” is dated August 4. Since 1918 the building had been variously an anti-religious museum, dormitory, and storehouse. Andropov noted that it had attracted unwanted curiosity from Soviets and foreigners. Other sources say there was fear it would become an anti-communist shrine or a cause célèbre abroad, and that there might be trouble in 1976, the eightieth anniversary of Nicholas’s coronation.41 Why the act waited two years, and waited until Yeltsin replaced Ryabov, is uncertain, but scholars of the city and region told me in 2004 that local conservationists prevailed upon Ryabov to temporize. Brezhnev, says Viktor Manyukhin, sent a note to Yeltsin in 1977 telling him to go ahead, as a United Nations committee was planning to discuss conservation of the home. Yeltsin was away on vacation when the destruction occurred.42 The foundation was filled with gravel and asphalted over.
The fifteen months Andropov was Soviet leader in 1982–84 were to bring out greater verbal rigor in Yeltsin. He huffed and puffed about imported films and pop music and about “duplicitous Januses” who debauched Urals youth with foreign culture and ideas. Yeltsin had subordinates detain in conversation party members who in the past wrote recommendations for Jewish acquaintances who later tried to emigrate to Israel. The hard-shell culture department of the obkom prevented one theater from staging a Russian play and banned six non-Soviet movies from local cinemas, while the department of propaganda and agitation stiffened controls over photocopiers. 43 In May 1983 a hue and cry in the Central Committee apparatus led Yeltsin to haul on the carpet the editor of Ural magazine, Valentin Luk’yanin, whose infraction had been to publish “Old Man’s Mountain,” a novella by Sverdlovsk writer Nikolai Nikonov about social decay in the Russian countryside. The work was already bowdlerized, having been worked over by the Sverdlovsk branch of Glavlit, the Soviet censorship agency, but even in that form it was too close to the bone for the apparat. Yeltsin forced Luk’yanin to own up to wrongdoing before the obkom bureau but left him in the editorship. At the July 1983 plenum of the oblast party committee, Yeltsin also denounced Valerian Morozov, an engineer from Nizhnii Tagil committed to a psychiatric hospital in 1982 for writing political letters to officials (in one to the Soviet procurator general he called the CPSU “a careerist mafia that has usurped power”) and for trying to send a manifesto abroad. Morozov, Yeltsin pointed out sternly, composed “a plump revisionist manuscript” and went to the city of Gorky to try to meet with “the not unknown anti-Soviet element [antisovetchik] Sakharov.”44 Andrei Sakharov, the father of the USSR’s hydrogen bomb, human rights advocate, and 1975 winner of the Nobel Peace Prize, had been exiled to Gorky in 1980 for protesting the invasion of Afghanistan. Luk’yanin later painted Yeltsin’s doublespeak at conclaves such as these as typical of the man: “He always knew in advance what decision needed to be taken and moved toward it like a tractor or tank. . . . He spoke very authoritatively and unconditionally. . . . This was the essence of the party’s policy. He was a glorious executor of it.”45
A quarter-century after graduating from Urals Polytechnic, Yeltsin had achieved levels of status and prosperity in excess of what he could have envisaged. And he had experienced the personal passages, sweet and sour, that midlife brings. Vasilii Starygin passed away in Butka in 1968. Yeltsin’s last surviving grandparent, Afanasiya Starygina, lost her bearings and tried several times to make her way back to her birthplace, Basmanovo. She died after wandering off in 1970; the body was never found.46 In 1973 Nikolai Yeltsin suffered a stroke. He and Klavdiya moved from the Butka house to Sverdlovsk to live with their divorced and childless son, Mikhail, in his apartment on Zhukov Street. Nikolai died in May 1977. Between Boris and Mikhail, a construction foreman, there were hard feelings about parental care and other family business, and Boris averted the appearance of favoritism. He is said to have commented to a colleague, “I earned everything in life on my own, so let him do the same.”47 Their sister completed her studies at UPI in the late 1960s, moved home to Berezniki, and, as Valentina Golovacheva, worked as an engineer and raised two children. She was to divorce her husband and migrate to Moscow in 1995 to work in a low-level Kremlin position, when Boris was president of Russia,48 but Mikhail took early retirement and did not leave Sverdlovsk. Naina Yeltsina’s widowed mother, Mariya Girina, was also in Sverdlovsk, having moved from Orenburg. After the deaths of her father, Iosif, and two of her five siblings in road accidents, Naina developed a claustrophobic fear of cars and airplanes.49
Yeltsin, as workaholics will do, suffered from health issues of his own. Only expert medical intervention, some sources say, was to help him overcome symptoms of rheumatic valvular heart disease and acute angina in the mid-1960s.50 Before Moscow he had fainting spells from hypertension and from labored breathing in airless rooms. He was deaf on the right side, the result of a middle-ear infection that grew out of an untreated head cold. The arches in his feet had fallen and he had lower back pain from volleyball and other insults. And he had been operated on for an intestinal ailment. In 1977 Yeltsin visited Hospital No. 2 for a bad infection of the second toe in his right foot. The swollen foot would not fit into his shoe—but Ivan Kapitonov of the Central Committee Secretariat was arriving at Kol’tsovo for an inspection tour. Yeltsin took a scalpel from the surgeon, made two slits in the leather, and limped off to his limousine.51 With his selection to the Central Committee in 1981, Yeltsin’s health was in the charge of the “Kremlin hospitals” of the Fourth Chief Directorate of the Ministry of Health. He told friends that a Gypsy fortune-teller predicted he would die at age fifty-three. In 1984, the year he was fifty-three, he lost weight and muscle tone; a medical exam in Moscow came up dry, and he put it out of his mind.52 He would
go to outlandish lengths, and not always successful ones, to cloak infirmities. One time, an otolaryngologist performed a small surgical procedure on him and he was groggy from the anesthetic. Rather than appear unsteady, Yeltsin had the orderlies roll him through the waiting room on a gurney, shrouded head to toe in a white sheet. The ruse backfired, and for days, it was rumored in Sverdlovsk that he had died.53
The vicissitudes of the younger generation ensured that Boris and Naina Yeltsin would rarely be alone in their spacious apartment. Their daughter Yelena enrolled in civil engineering at UPI after high school. Early in the course, and against her parents’ wishes, she married a school friend, Aleksei Fefelov. They parted and divorced shortly after the birth of daughter Yekaterina in 1979, and she and Yekaterina moved back in with Boris and Naina. Her father, nervous that Yelena’s problems might sully his reputation, sought the advice of Pavel Simonov, the subdepartment head for the Urals in the Central Committee Secretariat. Simonov calmed him down: For his CPSU superiors in Moscow, such things were personal, but, just in case, Simonov would brief them. “If Boris Nikolayevich had known at the time about the murky relationships within many other leadership families, he would not have worried. [He] never mentioned the topic again.”54 Several years later, Yelena married an Aeroflot pilot, Valerii Okulov; their daughter Mariya was born in 1983.
Then there was Tatyana Yeltsina, who was to be a political player after communism. As a girl, she was “a dreamer” who wanted to become a sea captain, and learned Morse code in preparation, but girls were not taken into the Nakhimov schools (for naval cadets). She then, like her father in the 1940s, longed to be a shipbuilder, and she figure skated and inherited his love for volleyball. Teachers and schoolmates have testified that she was weighed down by high expectations and illness. Graduating from School No. 9 in 1977, she announced to her parents that she planned to study in faroff Moscow. She did not want to repeat the experience of her sister, whose 5s at UPI, she said, were unjustly devalued as having been awarded po blatu—as part of the Soviet web of reciprocal favors: “I wanted to go away, to where no one knew my father.” He overruled Naina, and Tatyana went off to study computer science and cybernetics at Moscow State University. There she married fellow student Vilen Khairullin, an ethnic Tatar, in 1980 and had a son, Boris, in 1981. This union, too, failed, and she spent the year after the birth with her parents in Sverdlovsk before returning to Moscow to finish her diploma.55 Boris Nikolayevich at last had a male offspring. He was exhilarated that his grandson bore the legal name Boris Yeltsin.56
Professionally, Yeltsin was every inch the boss he had told his mother he would become. He savored the chief apparatchik’s role. His time as Sverdlovsk first secretary, he was to say in 1989, brought him “the best years of my life” up to then.57 Receipt of the Order of Lenin upon his fiftieth birthday in 1981, with a crimson flag, crimson star, and hammer-and-sickle surrounding a disc portrait of Lenin in platinum, rounded out his set of official awards. It came with an ode to “services rendered to the Communist Party and the Soviet state” and was presented in the Moscow Kremlin. Yeltsin’s personal records in the Sverdlovsk archive of the CPSU show him receiving one award while in the construction industry—his Badge of Honor in 1966—and nine as a party official. These included medals honoring the Lenin centenary in 1970, the thirtieth anniversary of victory over Germany in 1975, the centenary of Felix Dzerzhinsky (the founder of the Soviet secret police) in 1977, and the sixtieth anniversary of the Soviet Army in 1978; Orders of the Red Banner of Labor in 1971 and 1974; the Order of Lenin in 1981; a gold medal for his contribution to the Soviet economy in 1981; and a certificate of thanks from the obkom upon his departure in April 1985. Yeltsin held onto these medals after 1991, still proud of having earned them. They were stored in his home study and put on display at his wake in 2007.58
The boss Yeltsin of the second half of the 1970s and the first half of the 1980s must be evaluated in the context of the political and social order of the day. Roving far from the approved path was not in the choice set for the proconsul of the Soviet empire in a strategic province. The Ipat’ev House decision underlines the point. Yeltsin “could not imagine” balking at the Kremlin’s order. Had he, he “would have been fired” and whoever replaced him would have knocked down the building.59
A picture that incorporated nothing but orthodoxy, however, would overlook traits that differentiated Yeltsin from the typical CPSU secretary of his generation. There were signs of him holding back from the tedium of rites and routines. In television footage, he never wears his gold stars and medallions or busses dignitaries Brezhnev-style, although he does give out backslapping bear hugs. He seems more attentive than most to his wardrobe. His hair is suspiciously long for a member in good standing of the nomenklatura, and every few minutes he brushes a hank of it from his forehead. Ennui plays on his face as he drones on at conferences and sits through commemorations.
Substantively, Yeltsin nibbled at the edges of what was admissible in late Soviet conditions and presaged what he was to do in the reform era. He was a compliant activist—accepting of the system and ready to put body and soul into making it work, and yet able to make judicious intrasystemic innovations and accommodations.60
As the Soviet economy went downhill after 1975, Yeltsin repulsed calls to strangle what little Stalin had left of free markets in the USSR. When irate Sverdlovskers agitated in 1982 for caps on the prices of meat and fruit in the farmers’ bazaars, he branded them economic nonsense and lauded competition and self-sufficiency. “Prices in the marketplaces,” he said, “depend on supply and demand. In order to lower them, we mostly have to move more farm products to the bazaars and to develop the personal gardens of the province’s residents. Then . . . prices will fall.”61 In the state sector, Yeltsin adopted a device called the “complex brigade,” which decentralized some economic operations to small labor collectives and let them qualify for wage premiums. The formula, found here and there in the provinces since the 1960s, was “the closest approximation to entrepreneurial initiative the official Soviet economy ever tolerated.”62
Where he had wiggle room, Yeltsin made extensive use of the tool kit of the communist state to improve physical and social infrastructure and consumer welfare. He addressed these issues because of a desire to do the right thing, because he liked playing sugar daddy, and because, in a flip of his dictum in the construction industry (“Whoever worked better would live better”), he felt that employees who lived better would put out more in their work for the state. A partial list of Yeltsin’s projects would take in: a start on a subway for the city of Sverdlovsk; eradication of its squalid barracks housing; near-completion of a south-north road artery through Nizhnii Tagil to Serov (this project began under Nikolayev in the 1960s, and Ryabov had been unable to complete it); “youth housing complexes” which gave younger families first crack at apartments and down payments, on condition of putting in two years of labor on the construction; pressure on heavy and defense industry to manufacture scarce household goods;63 new theaters and a circus in Sverdlovsk and refurbishment of the 1912 opera house; a line for the province in the agricultural program for the Non–Black Soil Zone of European Russia (an acrobatic feat, since Sverdlovsk oblast is not in European Russia); and a City Day festival in Sverdlovsk, instituted in 1978, and neighborhood fairs to distribute food and consumer wares before winter. Yeltsin borrowed good ideas from others. The youth housing complexes had been pioneered in Moscow oblast; he tweaked the model by reserving spots for blue-collar workers, invalids, and army officers. The first City Day had been organized in Nizhnii Tagil in 1976 by Yurii Petrov. Compared to the world-shaking decisions Yeltsin was to be privy to after 1985, this may seem like small potatoes; to those affected, it was not.
Ventures like these would make headway only if clearances and means not written into the binding economic plan could be procured. For getting to the Soviet pork barrel, Yeltsin’s intensity and connections were irreplaceable. “For our industrial province
I hauled in from the center freight cars full of meat, butter, and other foods,” he says. “I telephoned, demanded, strongarmed.” He did the same for housing.64 His critics do not deny his deftness. Manyukhin pays homage to him for “beating out resources from the center” for local initiatives and extra goods and medicines. When push came to shove, “Boris Nikolayevich went all the way up to the general secretary.”65
Yeltsin’s worldview did evolve in the late Soviet period. To a degree, the evolution was intellectually based. He and Naina subscribed to five or six of the monthly “thick journals.” He had begun signing up for series of literary books while still a student at UPI, and the family continued this practice. The home library they kept on handmade shelves in his apartment study was to number some 6,000 volumes when they shipped it to Moscow in 1985. He often initiated discussions at the office about those social questions that could be debated in the Soviet media.66 Yeltsin even familiarized himself with a few dissident works. He told me that in the late 1970s he read The Gulag Archipelago, Alexander Solzhenitsyn’s unmasking of Stalinist cruelties (published in the West in 1973 but not in Russia until 1989), in a samizdat (underground) typescript that he got through his wife, who obtained it at work. When I asked him whether the KGB was aware of his reading, he replied, “Of course not. How would they know? They weren’t looking in my direction.”67 Yeltsin began to open up at reunions of old UPI classmates and with others about the misfortunes of his family in the Stalin period. The travel to foreign shores for which his position qualified him also helped widen his horizons. Andrei Goryun reports that as long ago as the late 1960s, having arrived back from his first Western trip, to France, Yeltsin told associates in the Sverdlovsk House-Building Combine about how the capitalist economy was humming along there, and that he was “very strictly warned” to watch his tongue.68 Naina Yeltsina’s opinions contained seeds of doubt similar to his. “We are all children of the system,” she said to an American television correspondent after her husband’s retirement. “But I was not a good one, to be honest. I was outraged by many things.”69
Yeltsin Page 13