by Darien Gee
Bettie is looking between the women, not quite sure about what’s happening. Ava can see that her eyes have gone slightly vacant, the confused look returning. “You’re leaving?” Bettie asks, perplexed.
“I am,” she tells Bettie. She turns to Isabel, who won’t look her in the eye. “I came by to give you the key, and to tell you we’re moving. We were evicted from our apartment, so Max and I have to be out by the end of the week. I came to say goodbye. And thanks. For everything.” When Isabel doesn’t say anything, Ava gives Bettie’s hand one last squeeze and leaves.
Chapter Twenty-one
Charlotte Snyder, head teller of Avalon State Bank, greets Isabel and Bettie in the lobby.
“So exciting!” she exclaims, leading them to the back of the bank. “When I got your call, I wasn’t sure what to think. Lost safe-deposit keys! It’s like something out of a movie.”
Isabel just feels weary. She’s had to take more time off from work, much to the chagrin of her kid boss who’s still managing to somehow keep KP Paper & Son afloat. She’d expected that he would complain, possibly even fire her, but instead he surprised her by saying she’d been given a raise. Apparently her sales numbers have been at an all-time high, something Isabel hadn’t been paying much attention to. She credits this to not really caring about her job, which makes handling rejection all the more easy. She keeps at it until she gets a yes, and then keeps at it some more.
But keeping at it is starting to take its toll on Isabel. She’s been running on caffeine and adrenaline since the fire, and it’s finally caught up to her. Even with Bettie now living at Abe and Imogene’s, Isabel still doesn’t seem to have enough time to tie up all the loose ends. There are too many to count.
And now, this. Bettie’s box, not to mention the surprise safe-deposit box that was held in Bill’s name. Isabel had to get a court order to get permission to open the box, and while it wasn’t all that difficult, it just makes everything feel more serious, more formal. Whatever Bill was hiding, Isabel is about to find out.
“Hey, sorry I’m late.” Yvonne comes up behind them and gives Isabel’s arm a squeeze. “Have you opened the boxes yet?”
Isabel shakes her head. “I’m thinking maybe we should leave Bill’s alone. There must have been a reason I didn’t know about it, right? And I’m not so sure I want to find out what’s inside.”
“I sure hope I stashed some goodies away,” Bettie tells Mrs. Snyder. “I could go for a nice surprise. Say, are you still serving free pastries?”
“Every day before ten,” Mrs. Snyder titters. “Though we’ve replaced the doughnuts with Amish Friendship Bread. So delicious!”
Bettie turns to Isabel, eager. “What time is it?”
Isabel looks at Yvonne. She doesn’t have the energy to even lift her wrist to look at her watch.
“It’s ten,” Yvonne confirms.
Bettie lets out a whoop. “Charlotte, I tell you, there is nothing sweeter than free Amish Friendship Bread.”
“I couldn’t agree more,” Mrs. Snyder says, nodding her head fervently. “Today was my baking day, so I brought in chocolate-dipped Amish Friendship Bread biscotti—it has a touch of coconut. Perfect with your morning coffee!”
“I can’t stand Amish Friendship Bread,” Isabel mutters, “but coffee?” Her tired eyes perk up.
“Try water,” Yvonne says. “You could fuel a rocket with the amount of caffeine in your system.” She turns to Mrs. Snyder. “So, what now?”
“Well, we have Bettie’s box ready. And if you have your key”—she nods in Isabel’s direction—“we can have yours brought out right after. Since you got that court order, the box is all yours. It’s a shame you didn’t know about it earlier.”
“I don’t think I could have handled it earlier,” Isabel says. She turns to Yvonne. “I’m not even sure I can handle it now. Bill probably meant to give someone else power of attorney after the divorce was final. Ava, maybe. She should be here, not me.”
“It doesn’t matter,” Yvonne tells her. “At this point you need to see what’s inside. It could even be empty, Isabel, and all your worrying will be for nothing.”
Empty? Isabel’s not sure what’s worse. Finding something she didn’t know about or wondering what Bill had been planning to put inside.
“Enough chatter,” Bettie declares excitedly. “I want to see what’s in my box—I have no idea what’s in there!”
Mrs. Snyder’s face is washed in pity. “Because of your … condition?” She whispers the last word like it’s a secret.
Bettie gives her an exasperated look. “No, Charlotte. Short of having it deducted from my checking account once a year, I haven’t bothered to touch it in almost fifteen years. I forgot I even had it.”
Mrs. Snyder nods. “It’s funny how people tend to forget what they have. Okay, have a seat and I’ll be right back!”
Bettie and Yvonne sit down, but Isabel is pacing. Bettie is considering the possibilities, running through each one with Yvonne.
“What about gold bars? Wouldn’t that be something? Or a wad of cash!”
“Diamonds,” Yvonne adds. “Rubies from Madagascar.”
Isabel gives her friend a look. This is definitely not helping. “Bettie, whatever is in your box is something that you put in. Did you have gold bars or a wad of cash?”
“No,” Bettie says, her face falling for a moment. “But you never know, right? If my brain’s no longer reliable, who knows what I might have done over the years?” She turns to Yvonne, her face bright once again. “Stock certificates! Lottery tickets!”
Isabel resumes her pacing. Regardless of whatever is in Bill’s safe-deposit box, what’s troubling Isabel the most is that she can no longer trust what she knows. She’s starting to doubt her own memories about her life with Bill, because there is clearly so much that she didn’t know about.
Ava, obviously. She hadn’t seen that one coming but once it happened, she could see it for what it was—a series of chance and missteps, a fork in the road, his ultimate decision to choose one path over another. She knew her marriage had issues, and while she hadn’t expected he would ever leave her, she knows why he did.
But this is different. It’s deliberate, intentional, premeditated. Bill came to the bank, signed his name to the form, put money down for a box that neither she nor Ava knows anything about. He came here with the express intention of putting something into that box that he didn’t want to keep at home.
So what is it?
Mrs. Snyder reappears with a long metal box. She slides it onto the table. “Here you go, Bettie. Buzz me when you’re finished and then I can take you back to the vault, Isabel.”
Isabel and Yvonne flank Bettie as she stares at the box. “It’s bigger than I remember,” Bettie says, fingering the numbered plate on the front. She takes a deep breath and pushes back the metal lid.
It’s full of plastic bags, old magazines. Bettie pulls out a few Ziploc bags filled with documents folded in half. Isabel reaches for them, opens the first bag. The original deed to the house, the pink slip for her car, insurance papers, Bettie’s birth certificate, social security card, medical records. Isabel’s relieved to see them, because it makes a lot of things easier. She’ll make copies as soon as she can.
“Wow,” Yvonne breathes, and Isabel looks up to see her holding up a bundle of cash, mostly twenty- and hundred-dollar bills, also in a sealed Ziploc bag. “So you do have a wad of cash in there after all. It looks like there’s a few thousand here, Bettie. Is this yours?”
“Yes,” Bettie says, her voice hollow. She glances at it, uninterested. “Twenty thousand, I remember now. Proceeds from the first five years of my scrapbooking business.”
“Why didn’t you deposit it?” Isabel asks. She knows Bettie has both a savings and checking account at the bank, as well as an IRA.
“I did deposit some,” Bettie says absently. “I was saving the rest for …” Her voice trails off as she pulls out a Ziploc from beneath the magazines. Insid
e is something soft and rectangular wrapped in white tissue. Fabric? A sweater? Bettie’s face suddenly crumples.
Isabel slides into the chair next to her. Bettie’s hands are shaking. “Do you want me to help open it?” she asks.
Bettie’s eyes are wet. She shakes her head. “No. I’ll take it home with me.” She clutches it to her chest. “I want to go now.”
Isabel nods. She puts everything else into a bag and closes the lid of the empty safe-deposit box. They all stand up.
“Wait,” Yvonne says. “What about Bill’s box?”
Bettie’s face is drawn and pale, and Isabel wants to get her back to Imogene’s. “I’ll do it later,” she says, but Yvonne shakes her head.
“Do it now,” she says firmly. “I’ll take Bettie to the Garzas’. Call me later.” Yvonne puts an arm around Bettie’s shoulders and leads her out.
Isabel watches them leave, tempted to run after them. She’d been counting on having some company when she opened the box and hates that she has to do it by herself.
“How are we doing?” Mrs. Snyder enters the room and looks around in confusion. “Oh, did Bettie leave already?”
“She wanted to go home.” Isabel holds out Bill’s key. “So do I give this to you?”
“Oh, no, dear. You hold on to that. Follow me.”
They walk into a small room filled from floor to ceiling with three walls of safe-deposit boxes. Mrs. Snyder lifts a ring of keys as she scans the wall. “Two-one-five, two-one-five … here it is.” She motions for Isabel to step forward. “You put your key in there. I’ll put the master here … and turn.”
Isabel does as she’s told and the small door swings open. Mrs. Snyder briskly removes the long metal box inside and hands it to Isabel. They walk back to the small table outside.
“Usually when a safe-deposit box is dormant we turn it over to the state treasurer’s office,” Mrs. Snyder tells her. “But Mr. Kidd paid for it in advance, twenty-five years! You still have nine years to go, isn’t that nice?”
Isabel counts back the years. That would have been right around the time they got married.
“Let me know when you’re finished,” Mrs. Snyder says, pointing to the small button on the wall. “Don’t you run off on me, too!” She gives Isabel a wink and disappears.
Isabel slides into the chair and stares at the box. It’s gunmetal gray, just like Bettie’s, but smaller. She looks for a clue as to what might be inside, but there’s nothing. It’s a standard-issue safe-deposit box.
Isabel puts her hand on the cover and hesitates. The last person to open this box would have been Bill, his fingers in the same spot as hers. She wonders what he was thinking, if he knew that someday she would be the next person to touch this box. She suddenly feels anxious, unsure if she should look inside. After all, there must have been a reason that he didn’t tell her about it.
She flips open the lid before she can give it a second thought.
At first she stares at the contents, blinking. Yvonne was right—it’s practically empty. There’s a thin manila envelope and a small white envelope with Isabel’s name written in Bill’s unmistakable style.
She slowly reaches for the envelope, her mind spinning. An apology, maybe, or a belated confession? Isabel, I want to explain what happened. Or maybe a favor from the grave? Isabel, I know you must be angry with me but there’s something I need you to do. Isabel turns over the possibilities in her mind, none of them quite convincing enough.
She finally turns the envelope over and breaks the seal. It’s a card. Isabel pulls it out, stares at the simple drawing of two red intertwined hearts. Below it are the words, MY BELOVED WIFE.
This can’t be right. Isabel feels almost light-headed as she opens the card. It’s dated March 17, the year after they got married. Their first anniversary.
Dear Isabel,
Today is our first anniversary. Hard to believe that a year ago we exchanged rings and a promise to be together forever. I am so happy to be sharing my life with you, and I look forward to all the years to come.
So much has happened lately—our first home, the dental practice, the news of our first child on its way. I don’t think there’s anyone happier than me in this moment. I don’t want to ever forget it. I’ll admit the idea is not my own—I borrowed it from an article in Reader’s Digest, about writing down the details of our first year together and putting it in a safe-deposit box to open on our 25th anniversary. It seems like a fitting way to make sure the small memories of the beginning of our life together don’t escape us.
So here it is. I can’t wait to see what the future holds. I love you.
Always,
Bill
Inside the manila envelope she finds a handful of pictures—waiting in line at the Ferris wheel at the county fair, large plates of spaghetti from the questionable Italian restaurant near Bill’s dental college, the night he proposed, their wedding, their disastrous honeymoon in the Bahamas where they both got food poisoning. Standing in front of the house the day they bought it, Bill’s hand resting proudly on the mailbox as Isabel stands next to him, laughing, tucked under his arm. A notarized copy of Bill and Randall’s partnership papers, his first business card. A long list written by hand of what was happening in that year, the beat-up Honda they were driving, places they visited, their favorite foods and movies. A bar napkin with a short list of baby names they’d come up with when they found out Isabel was pregnant, two weeks prior to their anniversary. The miscarriage would happen five weeks later.
Isabel looks at the evidence of her early life with Bill, spread out in front of her like a show-and-tell project. She feels her eyes sting with tears and, at the same time, is shaking her head with a wry smile. Because this is exactly the kind of thing Bill would have done. A romantic gesture that would have been lost on Isabel because Isabel is the least romantic person in the world, but it would be just like Bill to do it anyway.
It’s been so long since she’s thought of him in this way. Her chest hurts, like the ache that comes with holding your breath for too long. To be able to think of him with fondness, with a smile on her face, to remember the good moments. When was the last time she could do this?
The pain catches her off guard, a sudden sting, a punch in the gut.
Bill, she thinks. He can hear her, she’s sure of it. She glances around, then settles back in her chair.
“Bill,” she says aloud. “If you’re up there somewhere, watching me look through all this, well, I can’t help but wonder if you forgot about this box. We were so young … I’m sure you didn’t think it’d end up like this. I sure didn’t.”
She hesitates, then takes a deep breath. “So things are going okay for me. I’ve been fixing up the house, as you probably know. Bettie’s house burned down, though, but she’s okay. We’ve become friends, actually. I know, I know. To think she used to drive me crazy all these years. Turns out she’s all right. More than all right. She’s kind of become like family to me. I’m glad you helped her out as much as you did when you were alive.
“You know how you were always telling me to go out and meet new people? Well, I have a new friend, Yvonne. She’s a plumber here in town. Really nice, very pretty, great teeth, gums to die for.” Isabel smiles. It was a standing joke between her and Bill—while most men judged women by their bodies, Isabel would tease him that the first thing he looked at was their teeth. “Work is going okay, too. I keep thinking I’m going to leave, but I just heard from my boss that I’m going to get a raise. Did you know I haven’t used a single vacation day since you died? I guess I should have taken one earlier—I seem to make more money that way.” She shakes her head, gives a small smile.
“So I guess if you hadn’t died you’d probably be married to Ava by now, maybe even have another kid.” Isabel is silent for a while. “Max is cute, Bill. He looks like you. I gave him some things of yours that I found in the attic. Well, gave them to Ava. She’s been hanging around a lot, but you probably knew that, too. It looks l
ike they’ll be moving. It’s probably a good thing—the place they lived in was a dump, and Randall was a jerk to her so she can’t get another job as a dental assistant. She does these bottle-cap things—necklaces and rings—they’re pretty good but it’s not enough. When you died all our money was tied up with the dental practice, and you know how that went. Randall bought out your share of the business, but it was such a paltry sum based on your partnership agreement. The lawyer explained it to me like you tried to a million times. Wish I’d listened better but I was too mad at the time.
“Ava’s all right. Not that you’re asking me for my approval or anything. I mean, I suppose if you’re going to leave me for someone, you could have done worse than her. Lately it seems like I’m the one who’s married to her. Did you see what she did when she put my name on her emergency call list? I had to go pick up Max from school! We had a fun time, though. I do wish he was at a better place. Ava and I kind of got into a fight about it. Not that it’s any of my business.”
Isabel picks up one of the pictures. Their first Thanksgiving as a married couple, gathered round the large oak dining table at Bill’s parents’ house. Everything was too big—the table, the turkey, the amount of food. Edward and Lillian had teased them, saying that they were waiting for grandchildren to fill the table.
“Anyway …” She gestures to the things on the table. “I’m not sure what I’ll do with it, but it’s nice to have it. I threw out a lot of things when you left, I was pretty angry. But I’m not angry anymore, and I’m glad to have them. So thanks.” She glances up at the ceiling, unsure if she should say anything else. “And um, take care.”
Isabel is gathering everything together when Mrs. Snyder pokes her head in. “Everything all right?” she asks, eyebrows knit in confusion. Her eyes look around the room. “I thought I heard you talking to someone in here.”
“It’s just me,” Isabel says. She stands up. “I’m finished here. Thanks for all of your help.” Her arms are full but she suddenly feels lighter.