What was I thinking, though? Most of my makeup disappeared along with my tears on the car ride over to New York. My curls are starting to frizz after my hair dryer debacle this morning. The only thing I had going for me was my clothes until that guy had to bump into me at Gray’s Papaya. That was just my luck. Lately, I have had plenty of bad vibes sent my way.
I’m hoping my luck is about to change because I can use some good news. Keeping my fingers crossed that Carter will hear my planned speech, I get out of my car and lock the door behind me. I practiced it several times on the way over here. But I’m nervous, so I hope I don’t choke on my words.
My body shakes as I walk toward Carter’s front door, the uncontrollable urge to run away almost too much to pass up. What if he laughs in my face? What if he never wants to speak to me again? That is my biggest fear and not because of the book. As much as I loved our little game, I want my big guy back. I miss Carter so much I can’t sleep or eat. My mind always wanders back to him.
Carter lives in a giant house, much like the one my parents live in off the Mainline of Philadelphia. Except Carter resides in South Jersey, like most of the professional athletes who play for Philadelphia teams. And he lives in an expensive neighborhood.
Most of the houses on the block are so far apart you couldn’t throw a rock at you neighbor’s window if you tried. Now, that’s what I call privacy. Living in the city, after all those years of growing up in suburban hell, I had eventually begun to love the noise that filled the otherwise silent void I had become accustomed to back home. This neighborhood has that same eerie quiet, with nothing more than birds chirping to keep me from focusing too much on the sound of myself breathing.
My heart pounds out of my chest as if I am on death row and about to face the executioner. Groveling is not something I have ever done before. Everything with Carter is a new experience for me. I hate that he makes me so on edge. If he were someone else, I would march right up to his door and tell him to fuck off after leaving me hanging. But I want him back, regardless of how stupid I feel coming here.
The wood hurts my knuckles when I knock on his larger than life front door. Carter is a big guy, so it’s no surprise the door reaches up so high I couldn’t touch the doorframe even if I jumped. I bet even Carter has a hard time reaching it. Holding my breath, I wait as the door swings open. I expect Carter, but instead, I get…a woman. A gorgeous woman. And she’s holding a baby. His baby?
Oh, my God. This must be why he was so closed off with me. He has a girlfriend or a wife and a baby. This wouldn’t be the first time I dated a guy, only to find out he was married or had a secret life I hadn’t known about.
The blonde woman smiles at me, a smile that travels up to her big, blue eyes as she adjusts the child in her arms. Her baby is adorable, maybe only a few months old, but he looks nothing like Carter. He looks like her with his soft features, pale skin, and bright eyes. Carter is the complete opposite of them—dark hair, borderline long enough to put in a hair tie, deep brown eyes that hold so much sadness they mirror mine, and that perfectly toned and tatted body I want to climb like a mountain.
“Can I help you?” the woman asks, giving me a pointed look. She kisses the top of the baby’s head to sooth him. He still has tears in his eyes, even though he seems happy with the toy in his hand.
Throwing my hands on my hips, I stare her down, wondering who the hell she is and why Carter never told me about her or the child. “I’m looking for Carter. Does he live here?”
“Yes,” she says, offering nothing of use to me. “What can I help you with?”
This conversation is so awkward my body is screaming for me to retreat. If Carter has a secret wife or girlfriend, then who am I to break up their family? I don’t want to be a home wrecker. A few times, I have unintentionally been that girl, and I hate the feeling. I hate not knowing what you have gotten yourself into ahead of time because the man was too much of a pig and a coward to own up to the truth. But this child and woman do not deserve this.
“Um…nothing, I guess.” For once, I sound so unsure of myself that even I don’t recognize my own voice. “Have a nice day,” I mumble under my breath as I spin around.
The few seconds it takes to get back to my car and slip inside are the longest few seconds of my life. I held my breath the entire way, practically running out of air by the time I grip the steering wheel and finally breathe again. After I glance up from the steering wheel and see the front door closed over, the first tear streams down my cheek, followed by the waterworks.
But I can’t sit here and cry in Carter’s driveway. A Carroway holds their head high and keeps their composure even in moments of duress, my mother would say. Nothing ever bothers her. Everything rolls off her back. I wish I could call her and tell her what happened with Carter, but she doesn’t even know he exists. Even if she did, she would say that he’s an idiot and to move on.
Sam was right. I have no friends other than Kennedy. My mother is the equivalent of talking to one of the statues in her garden, and my father is most likely locked away in his office or overseas somewhere, closing another deal for his company. I’m sure Kennedy is with Tyler, off celebrating their new child. I have no one. Nothing. All that is left are my books and my not-so-secret porn stash.
Tonight might be one of those nights where I break out the wine bra and walk along the Delaware River for some clarity. I do that when I need to clear my head and think about my next move. With Carter on the brain, I may need more than one wine bra to get me through the night. I had better stop by the liquor store to buy every bottle of red they have left. Because I sure as hell will need it.
Carter has a child. And a girlfriend. Or whatever the fuck she is to him. I hate him so much my skin tingles from the anger coursing through my veins.
After a few minutes of sobbing in my car, I push the start button and pull off Carter’s property, leaving my pride behind in his driveway. I sucked it up to come here and confront him, only to find out I was the only one invested from the start. He never had any intention to let me into his closed off heart. All the games we played were just that.
So, why would he lead me on and continue to play with me if he had a life waiting for him?
My mother would tell me that men have urges and that talented guys like my father and Carter are no exception. Like my dad, Carter is on the road more than he’s home, and I guess they both will take what they can get wherever they can get it. The difference between my mother and me is that she doesn’t care. Where I want a man to commit to me and only me for the rest of my life. Is that too much to ask? I think not.
As if reading my mind and knowing I need to talk, a call from Kennedy blares through the speakers of my Mercedes.
I press the call button on my steering wheel, relief washing over me. “Hey, K. Perfect timing.”
“Are you okay?” Her voice sounds soft, almost as if she’s whispering. “Carter just called Tyler. You showed up at his house unannounced?”
“Yeah, what’s wrong with that?”
“I thought you were going to send him something not show up at his door.”
“What difference does it make?” I wipe back the tears running down my cheek with the back of my hand and sniff. “Either way, I found out about his lovechild and mystery woman. I can’t believe he did this to me.”
“You were the one playing with him, Syd.” Now, she sounds annoyed with me. “What did you think was going to happen? That he would wait around for you for the rest of his life? I told you he wouldn’t put up with that crap, and you didn’t listen to me.”
“I just…I can’t believe he has a kid. Don’t you think that’s something he would have thought to tell me in the time we spent together?”
Kennedy sighs into the receiver. “Some people keep their secrets locked up and throw away the key. Tyler did the same thing with me. Remember the day he threw me out of his house because I had asked him if the pictures of that boy on his mantle were of his son?”
> “Yes,” I mutter, knowing where she’s going with this.
“Well, it turned out that the boy was his son.”
This is an unexpected turn of events. “Wait. I thought you said he wasn’t Tyler’s son. I was sitting on the couch next to you when you did most of your research.”
“I didn’t find it until later that week. I had kept digging until I finally found the adoption papers. Blake is Tyler’s son, but the kid has no idea. I even met Blake and his adoptive parents.”
“How come you never told me about any of this? What else are you hiding?” I blow out a puff of air, annoyed. “Does no one trust me with their secrets? It’s not like I would have gone around and blabbed about Tyler and his son. Did you not trust me enough to tell me?”
“It has nothing to do with you, Syd. The world does not revolve around you. I had promised Tyler I wouldn’t tell anyone, including you. I’m sorry, but it was not my secret to share. Tyler doesn’t want anyone to know other than those who are close to him.”
“And I’m one of them?”
“You’re going to be the godmother to our child, so I would say that makes you part of his inner circle now. Anyway, let’s not fight about this. The reason I was calling was to invite you over to our house for brunch on Sunday.”
“It’s weird to hear you say our house so soon,” I confess, a little jealous that Kennedy has found someone great to spend her life with and wishing I had that for myself.
“Well, Tyler might’ve bought this house, but it wasn’t a home until I moved in.”
“What time on Sunday?” I ask, crossing the bridge into Philadelphia.
“I was thinking around eleven or so. You know, brunch time.”
“Getting away from the city for a girl’s day is just what I need. I’ll bring the mimosas,” I announce, excited to see Kennedy this weekend.
We never get enough time together anymore, and I miss her like crazy. With my only friend living so far away, it leaves me with a lot of time to myself. It’s also more time for me to think about Carter and cry myself to sleep for being so stupid. At least now, I know why Carter wouldn’t be honest with me when I had asked him about his past. We all have one, and while some are darker than others, I was hoping Carter would let me in.
“You’ll be drinking them alone. I have a while before I can have another drink.”
“Don’t worry, babe,” I snort. “After the week I have had, I will have no problem polishing off a few bottles on my own. You can drink vicariously through me. I plan to drink like a frat boy during rush week.”
She laughs. “Well, don’t get too wild. I want Tyler to get to know the real you. You made quite the impression the first time.”
“Hey, I behaved myself that night.”
“Did you?” I know Kennedy so well I swear I can hear the condescending smirk forming on her lips. “You were upstairs in the guest bedroom, masturbating with Carter. I wouldn’t exactly call that making a good first impression. On either of them.” The way she emphasizes them makes me cringe.
Both Carter and Tyler must think I’m the same as one of their puck bunnies. And I’m not, which makes me frown at the thought. While I stopped myself from attacking Carter the night we met, I didn’t act like a lady. In fact, I acted like a whore who couldn’t keep her legs shut and needed a fix.
I was out of my mind that night. I still am. Carter does things to my mind and body that even I cannot fathom. I’m wild about him. And I want him to tame me, make me his. Too bad I lost him. Too bad he has another woman and a baby. Just when I think I couldn’t get any lower than I have in the past.
Hello, rock bottom, my new best friend.
“You made your point,” Kennedy, I groan. “I get it. I was an idiot for doing the things I did with Carter. We have chemistry together, and I don’t know…I couldn’t stop myself. He was too irresistible.”
“It’s a shame it didn’t work out for you. You guys looked cute together.”
“I had every intention of apologizing to him. But he has a baby. That’s the part I cannot get over.”
“Tyler has never mentioned anything to me about Carter having kids. As far as I know, Carter lives alone, doesn’t talk to anyone but Tyler and his sister, and keeps his head down and out of the papers. In all the years I have owned Sports Buzz, I have never heard a bad thing about his personal life. In fact, I’ve never heard anything about it at all except maybe a picture here or there with a model or puck bunny.”
“True, but couldn’t the same be said about Tyler? No one knew he had a son. He buried it so well you had to dig to find it. How many people would put that much time into searching through his past? I guess Carter is just as good at keeping secrets as Tyler. That must be why they are such good friends.”
“Yeah, I suppose so…” Her voice trails off but only for a few seconds. “I’ll mention it to Tyler and see if I can get him talking. I have a few tricks up my sleeve I can use.”
“I’m sure you do,” I deadpan, pulling into the parking lot at my apartment complex.
“Look, I have to run. I’m not feeling too hot. This pregnancy does not agree with my stomach. So, I have to go hang my head over the toilet for a few, but I’ll see you on Sunday, okay?”
“Sure thing.” I smile as I pull into a spot and turn off the engine. “Now, if you’ll excuse me, I have some drinking to fit in until then.”
She chuckles on the other end. “Have fun with that. See you soon. Kisses. Bye.”
Then, the line goes silent, leaving me alone with my thoughts once more. Lately, that is not a good thing. At least I have this brunch to look forward to on Sunday. Maybe if I drink myself to sleep tonight, I can do the same tomorrow and wake up refreshed and new on Sunday. I need to binge drink and purge Carter from my system so I can move on with my life.
Chapter 12
Carter
“What do you mean Sydney will be here any minute?” I yell at Tyler without meaning to be so loud. But I have a right to be somewhat annoyed, maybe even a little pissed off. My voice carries throughout the living room of his house, the sound echoing off the vaulted ceilings.
“She’s Kennedy’s best friend, man.” Tyler sits back, sinking into the couch cushions as he kicks his feet up on the coffee table. He slides his hands behind his head, linking them together, and turns to face me. “You can’t avoid her for the rest of your life. At some point, you will have to grow a pair, deal with her face-to-face, and act like a man about it.”
“But you guys ambushed me.” My anger surges through my body, practically radiating off my skin. “What do you expect me to say? That I’m happy about it. Because I’m not. That woman is the devil. Sydney pushes until she gets what she wants, and then starts her games all over again. I had enough of it.”
He smirks at me, a real cocky one that makes me want to slap it off his face. “We both know you’re full of shit. You like Sydney. You’re just too afraid to tell her about your past. Hey, I get it believe me I do. I doubt I would have told Kennedy about Blake so soon if she hadn’t dug into my background on her own. But I’m glad that she did because look at us now. I’m finally getting the family I had always wanted. You could be happy, too, if you stop overthinking everything.”
I frown, shaking my head. “She finds too much joy in torturing me to make me happy. Not unless she changes her mind and wants to wrap her lips around my cock. That’s the only way she’s going to get me to reconsider. I’m sick of being fucked with, and I'm tired of the games. I had enough of it growing up to last a lifetime.”
He moves his hands back down at his sides and rolls onto his shoulder to lean closer to me. “From what Kennedy has told me, Sydney would do just about anything you want to get you back. Maybe you should listen to what she has to say.”
“Wait.” I hold up my hand in protest even more irritated than I was a few seconds ago. “This is a setup to get us back together. I’m out of here.” I attempt to get up from the couch when Tyler clamps his hand on my wrist, h
olding me in place.
“Well, yes and no. Just hear me out.” His expression changes along with his tone. This conversation is about to take a dangerous turn.
Having brunch with Sydney, stuck at a table where I’m sure she will grill me for more information, is not my idea of a fun Sunday afternoon.
“We wanted to get you and Sydney together so we could talk to you about the baby, but Kennedy also thought this would be a good place for you to speak to each other on common ground and without any commitments. Sydney is sorry for what she did and misses you. She’s on the phone with Kennedy every day, bitching about how she would do whatever it takes to get you back. Just eat this brunch crap Kennedy ordered and listen to what Sydney has to say and then you can leave after that if you want.”
Seeing Sydney in person will make it harder for me to leave. She’s smart and beautiful, enigmatic and crazy. But I like her, always have, which is why it was so hard for me to walk away. That’s why I acted like a coward and stopped calling her and ignored all of her messages.
I still think about her, wonder what she’s doing, but I cannot let myself get sucked into her vortex of insanity. My life is too complicated to allow myself to become part of her world. I cannot go back, not without Sydney making some serious changes.
Before I can decide whether I want to retreat or not, I hear Sydney’s voice echo throughout the house as she strolls down the long hallway with Kennedy. She takes my breath away. Literally. When she walks into the living room next to Kennedy, I am speechless and in awe of how gorgeous she looks today, even more so than normal. In a tight black dress that barely covers her thighs and hugs her in all the right places, I have an immediate response to her appearance.
Struggling to erase the dirty thoughts from my mind, I get up from the couch and think of how shitty I played yesterday at home just to keep myself from getting hard. I walk toward Sydney as if drawn to her energy, and forget what I was going to say by the time I’m standing in front of her.
Donovan (Face-Off Series Book 3) Page 11