by Nele Neuhaus
“Nothing,” Connors said, shrugging his shoulders. “What can we do? Given the current evidence, we can’t prove anything. Until this woman reappears, I won’t even think about preparing indictments that would just be thrown out due to a lack of evidence.”
It was silent in the large office.
“Oh well.” Jenkins cleared his throat and then smiled. “It appears I’m no longer needed in New York. However, I want you to update me regularly about the progress in this case.”
“Of course.” Connors nodded. “I’ll keep you posted.”
Nick Kostidis stood at the frosted door of the private internal medicine ward on Goldwater Memorial Hospital’s third floor. He stared out the window. Ever since he’d found Alex in that sleazy dive, something had changed inside of him. The sight of her battered face, the fear and horror in her eyes, made him forget his own sorrow. Now, he felt a hot, raging fury, a wild thirst for revenge. His time of paralyzing numbness was over, and Nick knew with certainty that he wouldn’t allow Vitali to get away unscathed this time.
The sun pushed through the thick cloud cover and shone on the skyscrapers behind the United Nations. Somewhere over there, Vitali was sleeping calmly, thinking that Alex was dead. Just as dead as Mary and Christopher, Britney Edwards, David Zuckerman, Clarence Whitewater, and Zachary St. John. But he was mistaken. Alex was alive and would soon overcome her shock. And he—Nick Kostidis—would do everything in his power to support her in her testimony.
Nick’s eyes burned from exhaustion, but there was no time to sleep. Lloyd Connors and Gordon Engels had come to the hospital the very same night. They agreed to keep Alex’s reappearance hidden for the time being. Nick and Connors managed to convince Gordon Engels that Jenkins was no longer on their team, and Engels had called the president’s chief of staff and the attorney general—both of whom gave a green light to a strategy excluding the FBI from the investigation.
A few days earlier, Connors had hired a private detective to find the eyewitness to the murder Vitali had committed in 1963—at least according to van Mieren’s testimony.
“I don’t just want to throw Vitali into prison,” Connors had said. “I want him in the electric chair.” He was deeply shocked to see how brutally Vitali had treated Alex.
The frosted glass door opened, and Dr. Virginia Summer, senior physician of the internal medicine ward, stepped out. She balanced two paper cups of hot coffee. Nick had known Ginnie Summer for a long time. She’d been a friend of Mary’s, and her husband was a senior partner at a much-respected law firm. Nick had studied with him back in the day at NYU. “Hello, Ginnie,” Nick said. “How’s Alex?”
“As good as can be expected under the circumstances,” Dr. Summer said as she handed him one of the coffees. “She has broken ribs and severe contusions, but fortunately no life-threatening internal injuries. With a few days of rest and good medical attention, she’ll be over the physical part of this very soon.”
The doctor gave him a scrutinizing glance.
“And you?” she asked. “How are you?”
Nick looked at her; he shrugged his shoulders and stared out the window. The city that he had always loved, that he’d always fought and lived for, felt hostile all of a sudden. A sip of the hot, strong liquid revived his spirits.
“I’m doing pretty well,” he replied. “I’m slowly getting used to Mary not being there when I come home.”
He swallowed hard. Was it unfair to Mary that he had fallen in love with Alex? Would it have happened if she hadn’t lost her life?
“You look very tired,” Ginnie determined. “Go home and get some sleep. Ms. Sontheim is in good hands with us.”
“I know.” Nick smiled tiredly. “That’s why I brought her here.”
The doctor nodded.
“You seem to truly care for her,” she said. “Is it true what they say about her on TV?”
“No,” Nick said, shaking his head, “none of that is true.”
He sat down awkwardly on an orange plastic chair, and the doctor sat next to him.
“I’ve never before seen you so worried,” Ginnie said, “and so compassionate.”
Nick turned his head and looked at her in astonishment.
“You’ve changed,” the doctor said.
“Have I?”
“Yes,” she said. “Since I’ve known you—almost thirty-five years now—you’ve always been self-involved. Many ambitious men are selfish, but it was more than that in your case. I never envied Mary being married to you.”
Nick sighed.
“I admired you, regardless,” Ginnie continued. “You had a vision that you fought for with all your might. You always succeeded in inspiring people with your ideas. But sometimes you were downright self-righteous and inconsiderate.”
“I’ve realized that,” Nick admitted. “I was too uncompromising and made many mistakes.”
He turned the coffee cup in his hands.
“And now? Has something changed?” the doctor asked.
“Oh yes,” he said. “I’ve been punished severely for my arrogance, and I’ll have to live the rest of my life with the guilt of knowing that Mary and Chris died because of me.”
He was silent for a moment.
“Alex came to me at a time when I was seriously contemplating suicide. She came and listened to me like no one else did. She wasn’t afraid to talk to me. All I heard from our friends were empty phrases. All of a sudden, everyone seemed afraid of me. Only this woman, whom I hardly knew, came to me and she helped me to survive. I’m deeply indebted to Alex. She saved my life in two ways.”
“I get it,” the doctor said quietly.
“Do you?” Nick looked up, and Dr. Summer saw the agony in his eyes. She grabbed his hand. This revelation that he had true emotions, was capable of acting without expediency, suddenly made him likable in the doctor’s eyes.
“Mary was a friend of mine,” she said quietly. “I liked her so much. But she’s dead, and you must live on. No one expects you to mourn forever and be lonely.”
Nick stared at her. Then he frowned, as if he were about to burst into tears. He watched Ginny Summer leave behind the frosted glass door, and then he turned toward the window and leaned his forehead against the cold glass. Self-righteous and inconsiderate. An egoist. Yes, that’s what he was. Filled with conviction about the righteousness of his actions, he’d never even considered the feelings of all the people he indicted and prosecuted. He’d been too enamored by his own success and reputation to even evaluate himself. Now, he’d received a painful lesson in humility. Fate had punished him severely for his mistakes, but it had also given him a second chance.
The posh St. Regis Hotel had become a major construction site ten days before Christmas. An army of interior decorators and craftspeople worked at full speed to transform the foyer, the ballroom, and the adjoining conference rooms into a magical winter wonderland. Truckloads of fir trees, fake snow, and countless lights hinted at how the finished space would look on Saturday evening.
The chief designer—a young interior architect with a serious face, who chain-smoked and wore her dark hair in a ponytail—walked around the hotel with a clipboard under her arm. She had the chaos totally under control, directing the electricians, the painters, the carpenters, and the decorators.
Sergio smiled happily as he saw what a work of art was being created solely for his charity ball. “Hello, Sharon. You’re doing wonders.”
“Oh, Mr. Vitali,” Sharon Capriati replied with a mixture of impatience and awe. “Do you like it so far? Just wait until everything’s finished.”
Sergio gave her a look that, in his experience, no woman could resist. The young woman threw him a cutting look and then laughed. Her austere face was pretty. Sergio wondered what she was like in bed. He examined her firm, small breasts beneath her gray T-shirt and her well-shaped behind in her skintight jeans.
“Stop!” Sharon Capriati suddenly turned around and waved at two men transporting large wall pieces on a li
fting cart. “The pavilion goes over there! Next to the fir forest!”
She turned toward Sergio again, smiled apologetically, and made a note on her clipboard.
“Maybe you should have invited your guests to the Caribbean,” she said. “This is going to be quite an expensive affair.”
“That doesn’t matter,” Sergio said, shrugging his shoulders. “I want everyone to still be talking about this next year. I booked the best bands, and the food will leave everyone speechless. What about the champagne fountain?”
“It’s going to be right at the center of the ballroom,” she answered, absentmindedly sticking a pencil behind her ear. Sergio examined her closely.
“You’re doing a great job,” he remarked. “Would you like to join me for lunch today?”
“That’s very nice of you.” Sharon Capriati smiled the same impersonal smile that Alex had mastered so perfectly. “But I’m very busy. After all, you want to have a party here in twenty-four hours.”
“Maybe another time?”
Sergio felt a prickling feeling of excitement rise inside of him. This woman was a completely different type, but somehow she reminded him of Alex, with her pronounced self-confidence and professionalism. Unexpectedly, the idea occurred to him to take her to the ball as his date. He stepped closer toward her.
“I’m terribly busy before Christmas,” she said, not even looking up from her clipboard and shrugging her shoulders, which annoyed him. What, was she a lesbian?
“Why don’t you accompany me tomorrow evening at the party?” he said.
But instead of excitement, he received polite testiness.
“Listen, Mr. Vitali.” Sharon Capriati sounded like a kindergarten teacher talking to a slow-witted child. “You hired me because I’m the city’s best interior architect. I’m doing my job. That’s what you pay me for. Let’s leave it at that.”
This clear-cut rejection left Sergio speechless.
He nodded and raised his eyebrows. “Whatever you say. I won’t bother you any longer.”
“Okay then.” She smiled briefly, but she had already turned away and walked over to a group of electricians installing spotlights for the stage.
“Dumb bitch,” Sergio muttered, offended. He walked up the stairs leading from the foyer to the ballroom and turned around on the last step. The view was just as grand as his first impression. Sergio could already tell that his party would be a success. It was the pinnacle of the holiday season in New York, and nearly a thousand guests would be arriving from all over the United States and even Europe. New York VIPs, politicians from Washington, Hollywood movie stars, famous athletes, and corporate bosses from all over were expected. But Sergio would be attending by himself, with no woman on his arm this year. Constanzia had vanished, and Alex—who had accompanied him last year—was dead. Sergio’s face darkened thinking about her, and he turned around so abruptly that he almost collided with Luca.
“What’s the matter?” Sergio asked him, still rankled by the interior designer’s rejection. He looked Luca up and down. The otherwise calm and cold-blooded man seemed agitated.
“I just got a phone call from Sandro Girardelli,” Luca said quietly. “He works in the administration of Goldwater Memorial.”
“And?” Sergio suddenly had a queasy feeling in his stomach; he was overcome by a sense of foreboding.
“A woman was admitted during the night three days ago,” Luca continued. “She was immediately brought to the private ward of a Dr. Virginia Summer, and the hospital administration doesn’t know who she is or why she was admitted. No one from the hospital’s staff is permitted to enter the room. It seems as if no one is supposed to know she’s even there.”
“Continue,” Sergio prompted him, looking suddenly petrified.
“Two US marshals guard the room around the clock,” Luca said, “but the woman has a visitor every night. It’s none other than Mayor Kostidis.”
“You told me that you dumped her in the river!”
Sergio struggled to keep his voice down. Alex was supposed to be dead! He’d seen with his own eyes that she had stopped breathing. There was no way she could still be alive.
“My men dumped her into the East River—at the Brooklyn docks where the current is the strongest,” Luca reaffirmed. “I swear to you that she was dead.”
“If this woman at Goldwater Memorial is Alex,” Sergio replied grimly, “then she certainly wasn’t.”
Sergio’s thoughts somersaulted in his head.
“I have to call Jenkins,” he said, biting his lower lip. He walked quickly through the foyer of the St. Regis. Then he stopped and turned around to Luca.
“A hospital is a wonderful place to make someone disappear,” he said. “You do it, Luca. You and Silvio. I don’t want this to go wrong again. Go over there and blow her away. And this time, I don’t want to hear any bad news, capito?”
Harvey Brandon Forrester was used to tracking down people who had disappeared. He had founded a private investigation practice twenty years ago, and he specialized in lost causes. His four partners preferred to limit themselves to easier cases, like following unfaithful spouses or finding defaulted debtors, but Forrester liked the more complicated cases. Strictly speaking, he was more of a bounty hunter than a private detective. Because of his excellent connections with the US Attorney’s Office and many renowned law firms in New York, he couldn’t complain about a lack of work. His search for the eyewitness in the 1963 murder of the gangster Stefano Barelli turned out to be more difficult than expected. Difficult because Forrester could hardly investigate in Little Italy. His client wanted to avoid anything becoming public about this investigation. Forrester had spent two long days searching the police files they’d provided him. He read the interrogation records and indictments, looked at pictures, reconstructed the sequence of events, and finally reached the conclusion that there had to be not just one eyewitness but at least six or seven. But the US Attorney’s Office was looking for one man in particular: the son-in-law of the owner of the small trattoria where Barelli was shot. His name was Vincente Molto, and he’d been missing since that day.
Forrester combed through documents and electronic records to find more information about the eyewitness. Vincente Molto was born on July 24, 1940. He married Lucretia Amato in May of 1962 and left New York with his wife on May 28, 1963, for an unknown destination. So the man had to be sixty years old. Forrester browsed the police computer and got lucky. Vincente Molto had been convicted of a crime in 1961—aggravated assault. There was a picture, fingerprints. And a note in the file stating that he was suspected to be a member of the Genovese family.
Harvey Forrester spent three sleepless nights; he tapped all available sources, spoke to reliable informants, and finally traveled to Florida where he actually made a find. In Tarpon Springs, a small town outside of Tampa, he found Valentine Mills living in a small house with a view of the Gulf. Forrester watched the man for a full day before was he sure that he’d found the right person. Although Vincente Molto had gained a hundred pounds since his mug shot had been taken, the unusually bushy eyebrows and the receding chin were the same. Forrester called Lloyd Connors on the phone.
“I found your man, boss,” he said. “He’s living under a false name in Florida, near Tampa.”
“Are you one hundred percent sure?” The deputy US attorney’s voice sounded tense.
“One thousand percent,” Forrester replied. “I’m never mistaken.”
“Okay,” Connors said, “I’ll send two US marshals. Don’t do anything that could give him advance warning.”
Lloyd Connors could hardly believe his luck. He hadn’t had particularly high hopes that Forrester would find the man that Nelson van Mieren had mentioned in his testimony. If this Molto—now Mills—was also willing to testify against Vitali, then everything would be clear-cut. The deputy US attorney smiled grimly. Maybe he could charge Vitali with the murder of Stefano Barelli. This murder, committed on March 17, 1963, was definitely a case f
or the electric chair. Van Mieren claimed that Barelli had tried to push Vitali out of the business. So Vitali killed him with a shot to his neck. The murder charge would be the icing on the cake when seeking a warrant for Vitali’s arrest. Connors picked up the telephone and called Nick Kostidis, but his secretary said he was out of the office taking care of private business. The deputy US attorney dialed Nick’s cell phone number.
“I’m on my way to the hospital right now,” Nick said after he heard about Forrester’s find. “I think we should move Alex to a different location.”
“Is she capable of answering some questions tomorrow? I want to arrest Vitali tomorrow evening at his grand ball, and I urgently need her testimony for that,” Connors replied.
“I think she’s ready,” Nick said.
“Good,” the deputy US attorney said as he leaned back, “she’s my best trump card against Vitali. Take good care of her.”
Two paramedics in scrubs entered Dr. Virginia Summer’s private ward at Goldwater Memorial Hospital. One of them pushed a stretcher, while the other held a clipboard under his arm.
A young doctor came out of the nurses’ station.
“Hello, can I help you?” he asked.
One of the paramedics, a stocky man in his midforties, smiled in a friendly way and looked down at his clipboard.
“We’re supposed to transfer one of the patients in your ward to another hospital,” he said. “Ms. Alexandra Sontheim.”
The doctor gave him a suspicious look.
“We don’t have a patient with that name. Can I see your papers?”
The paramedic standing behind the doctor reached into his jacket pocket and pulled out a revolver with a silencer. While the doctor stared at the papers, he raised his weapon and pulled the trigger. The stocky man caught the young doctor and placed him on the stretcher, while the other entered the empty nurses’ station to check out the ward’s patient listings.