A sweating hulk with acne scars and bulging arms sprouting from a sleeveless sweatshirt dropped his sneaky gaze. “Yeah, man.”
“I love this show!” Dee gushed. “Paul Fiori is a walking, breathing piece of perfection!”
“He’s good as Salvatore,” Ted agreed without her panting enthusiasm.
“Yeah?” Salvatore demanded. “Yeah? Is that what you’re tellin’ me, Ice Pick?” More shifting of eyes and sweating from Ice Pick. “ ’Cause I’m gonna tell you somethin’.” Salvatore sprang from his seat and grabbed the giant around the throat, rushing him across the room and slamming him against a wall. “I’m gonna tell you about how a little girl got found in the street, a little girl in a sweet blue dress pulled up around her waist from where some animal raped her over and over before he wrung her sweet little neck until her face turned as blue as her dress and her mother had to see that little girl, had to look in that little girl’s face and say, ‘Yes, that’s my baby,’ and for the rest of her life every time that mother tries to sleep she’ll see that little girl’s sweet face all blue and the eyes bulgin’ out—”
Salavatore’s well-meaning but vastly inferior partner stood back reverently, gazing at the law enforcement god that was Eddie Salvatore. “You gonna tell me that, Ice Pick?” He pounded the man’s huge head against the wall. “ ’Cause I got a hunch, Ice Pick. I got a hunch you didn’t have nothin’ to do with hurtin’, rapin’, stranglin’ that little girl, but you gotta give up the truth, you hear what I’m sayin’? ’Cause you don’t give up the truth I’m gonna beat you till I turn that head of yours into a big, soft melon with brains drippin’ outta your ears—”
“It was Snipe, man!” Ice Pick screamed, spraying saliva, overwhelmed by the blazing rage of Salvatore. “It was Snipe, I swear!”
“Hot damn, that was great!” Dee took a slug of beer from a can, now willing to talk because the scene had swung away from Salvatore. “You get confessions that way, Ted?”
Terror of the interrogation room, that’s me, Ted thought dismally. “Sometimes it gets pretty rough.”
“Like when?”
“It’s hard to remember all the times.” Ted gulped beer, thinking furiously. “You remember that old man found floating in the lake a couple of years ago, bullet in his heart? We got the guy what was seen with him last . . .”
“Yeah?” Dee asked eagerly.
And Sheriff Purdue had conducted the interrogation, half-drunk and belligerently ignoring the guy’s plea for a lawyer, bullying him into a confession that a judge rightly labeled fruit of the poisonous tree. The guy had walked away a free man with a smirk at Ted he’d never forget. “It was pretty bad,” he said lamely. “I’m not supposed to go into details, though.”
“Oh, hell.” Dee sounded as if she knew he was trying to snow her. “Tell me about Warren Hunt and Charlotte Bishop.”
He had to make up for her disappointment in his previous murder tale. “Got their throats slashed.” He paused for effect. “Somebody nearly took off Charlotte’s head.”
“Wish I’d have seen them! Given me a real thrill to see those two mutilated like a couple of pigs.”
Ted blinked at her. “Jeez, Dee.”
She threw back her head and laughed. “I was joking. You should see the look on your face!”
“Shut up down there!” The voice of Dee’s mother shrilled down the dingy stairway and bounced around the living room. “And turn off that damned TV. You’re runnin’ up the electric bill.”
“Why don’t you turn off your heating pad and your dehumidifier and your air conditioner, too?” Dee muttered savagely.
“Is she cranky tonight?”
“Cranky? That one of your mother’s words? She’s a bitch all the time now, not that she was ever a bed of roses to live with. Being deserted by two husbands didn’t improve her disposition, but my brothers and I couldn’t help it.”
“They don’t come around much anymore, do they?”
Dee flushed. “Not anymore.”
Not now that she’d been fired from the hospital where she occasionally lifted drugs for her brothers to sell, Ted thought. He always told other people the charges against her were false. They weren’t and he had mixed feelings about the drug theft. What she’d done was against the law, but the brothers were losers with kids who were going hungry. She’d denied the allegations Andrew St. John had brought against her, even to Ted. She had only told him the truth one night when she was particularly drunk after a call from one of her nieces who’d run away from home. The girl was sixteen and Dee was afraid she would become a prostitute. There was no mistaking the sincerity of her love for the kids, but she’d done what she’d done and she was just lucky the hospital was more concerned about bad public relations than pressing charges or she would have landed in jail.
After losing her job, Dee would have left town if her mother hadn’t been diagnosed with lung cancer. She now lived in her mother’s house rent-free in return for nursing care. She earned enough to exist by typing. She also did other people’s laundry, although Ted wasn’t supposed to know this. He did know, though, and often anonymously threw business her way.
Dee hoped he would marry her. She’d never said so, but her desire was obvious. She was attractive in a strong-boned, earthy way. She lived life with a vengeance, though, and when she was forty, she’d probably look hard. That’s what his mother kept telling him. Of course at fifty-seven Rhonda Hysell looked twenty years older with her long, shapeless, dark clothes and equally long shapeless hair that had never been touched by a beautician. Then there was her constant church work, her obsessive collection of Hummel figures she couldn’t afford, her fervent attacks on dust and mildew, her unending war on grubs and mealy bugs and other garden pests. And for him she wanted a woman just like herself. Instead her son seemed to prefer Dee Fisher, a hard-drinking, raucous atheist. However, in Rhonda Hysell’s mind Dee’s worst sin seemed to be the blatant sporting of a tattoo.
Ted snickered at the thought. “What?” Dee demanded.
“Show me your tattoo.”
“What? Why?”
“I just want to see it.”
“You’re in a weird mood,” she said good-naturedly and pulled up her sleeve. A red rose in full bloom sprawled three inches up her bicep. “You hate it, don’t you?”
“No. I’ve decided I like it.”
“You do?” Dee looked surprised and pleased. “Maybe I’ll get another one.”
“Let me guess. A big heart with ‘Mom’ written inside.”
“Not in this lifetime. I was thinking of a butterfly.” She paused. “On my right cheek.”
“Your right cheek!” Ted shook his head violently. “Oh, no, Dee. That would look awful. Why would you want to spoil your face that way?”
She whooped with laughter. “My right buttock. My ass, you big dope!”
Ted stared at her a moment. Then his laughter joined hers. Mrs. Fisher thundered for quiet, displaying astonishing volume and shocking vocabulary, which set off Dee and Ted in a fresh fit of hilarity. They collapsed against each other, tears streaming from their eyes.
“Damn, I have a good time with you,” Dee gasped.
“As good a time as you had with Eugene?” Ted asked and immediately regretted the question. The ghostly hand of Eugene Farley seemed to pass over her face, wiping away all happiness. “Eugene was different.” Her voice always became eerie and flat when she spoke of her former lover.
At times like these, when Ted felt jealousy rising in him, he was tempted to tell Dee the truth about Farley. But he couldn’t hurt her that way. He couldn’t tell her about one day during the trial when he’d found himself sitting next to the elegant young Farley during a recess. He’d never spoken a word to Farley and was surprised when he’d suddenly asked, “Have you seen that young brunette who sits in the courtroom every day? The one who always wears the navy blue suit?”
“Yeah,” Ted had answered. He’d noticed her great legs the first day.
“I
used to date her. She has a good heart.”
Ted didn’t know what to say. He didn’t know about her heart. He only knew about her legs.
“She was the first single woman I met when I came to Port Ariel,” Farley went on. “She was in love with me. I enjoyed her company for a while, but she was too rough around the edges. I’m afraid I treated her shamefully, but there she is, every day, with her heart in her eyes when she looks at me.”
“If it bothers you, maybe she meant more to you than you thought,” Ted speculated uncomfortably.
Eugene Farley’s perfect profile had remained calm as he considered this. Then he shook his head. “No. She meant nearly nothing to me. I’m just sorry I wasn’t kinder to her.” He’d looked at Ted. “There is a balance in the great scheme of things, you know. Maybe I’m in so much trouble because I’m being paid back for my indifference to that young woman.”
No, you’re being paid back for embezzlement, you dumb shit, Ted had thought in disdain.
He had absolutely no sympathy for Eugene Farley. The guy had everything—looks, polish, an impressive education, a great job—everything Ted wanted desperately but could only imagine having. Farley could have had someone like Tamara Peyton. Maybe even Charlotte Bishop. And he’d thrown it all away to embezzle money from Max Bishop so he could win back Viveca Cosgrove, an older woman and a gold-digger. Ted didn’t even think she was pretty—she looked too styled, too stiff, too perfect, like a store mannequin. Max had brought in that high-powered outside accounting firm from Cleveland and they’d nailed Farley immediately. Oliver Peyton had done a piss-poor job of defending Farley—even Ted could see he wasn’t half-trying. He’d been convicted. Then, weakling that he was, he had committed suicide. And here was Dee still grieving herself to near distraction over him.
Stealing from Max Bishop. What a fool.
Max Bishop. Oliver Peyton. What was the name of that accounting firm from Cleveland that discovered Farley’s embezzlement? Martin, Goldstein, and Hunt. Richard Hunt, father of Warren Hunt.
“What’s wrong?” Dee asked suddenly. “You look like someone just zapped you with the heart paddles. I’d say about 350 joules.”
“I’ve got to call Meredith,” Ted said. “Now.”
11
I
WEDNESDAY MORNING
“Ruth Meadows certainly seems nice,” Natalie said casually. “Are you serious about her?”
Andrew St. John set down his coffee cup with a clatter. “Serious? Where do you get your nerve?”
“I think it’s a perfectly appropriate question.” Natalie took a small bite of toast and chewed calmly. “After all, if our positions were reversed, you would ask me the same.”
“That is different.”
“It isn’t.” Natalie grinned. “Besides, all this evasion answers my question.”
“No it doesn’t,” Andrew said sternly. “I barely know the woman.”
“Hear that, Blaine?” The dog looked up from a bowl of Alpo. “He barely knows the woman.”
“It’s true. Not that it is any of your business, but we have been out to dinner exactly three times and she cooked dinner for me once at her house.”
“That’s it?”
“Yes, nosy, that’s it.”
“I’m disappointed.”
“Forgive me.”
“No need. There’s still time.”
Andrew gave her a hard stare. “My darling girl, Ruth is a fine woman but I have no desire to change my life style.”
“So you say now. Who knows? In three or four months—”
“About you and Kenny,” Andrew interrupted. “What’s going on?”
“Nothing.”
“Balderdash.”
Natalie giggled. “Dad, only characters in novels say balderdash.”
“I’m the exception. Stop changing the subject. You and Kenny.”
Natalie spread more jelly on her toast. “We had a fight.”
“I guessed that much. About what?”
“I really don’t want to go into it.”
“Another woman. He was sleeping around.” He paused. “Well, don’t look so surprised. The first time I met him I knew he was the type.”
“The type? Isn’t that an unfair generalization?”
“Not when I saw him eyeing every woman who passed by when you weren’t looking. I never approved of him. I especially disapproved of you living with him, which is probably why you did it.”
“It is not!” Natalie flashed. “I loved him. Love him.”
“You were right the first time. You don’t love this man, Natalie. Don’t go back to him.”
“Don’t tell me what to do!”
Andrew held up his hands. “Sorry. You’re too old to take orders from your father. I’m at least entitled to give a little advice, though.” He laid his napkin on the table. “I’m off to the hospital.”
Natalie drew a deep breath, trying to calm herself. “Exciting day?”
“Appendectomy and gall bladder.”
“Sounds thrilling. Tamara’s visitation is from six to eight. You will be free by then, won’t you?”
“I can be there by seven.” He carried his plate to the sink, unobtrusively dropping a piece of bacon in Blaine’s bowl. “I hate visitations.”
“So do I, but it’s a tradition. Of course it will be a closed coffin.”
Andrew shook his head. “My God. That poor girl.” He looked at Natalie. “You were at the sheriff’s house until late last night.”
“The housekeeper had to leave so I stayed with Paige while he worked late. A double homicide makes for a busy day.”
“First Tamara, then Warren.”
“And don’t forget Charlotte.”
“I took her tonsils out when she was ten. She was a most dislikable little girl.”
“She was a most dislikable big girl. Except to Warren, apparently.”
“Does the sheriff have any idea who the killer is?”
“No,” she said, remembering that Nick had said perhaps Lily or Oliver killed Warren because they thought he had murdered Tamara. “Of course, I barely talked with him when he came in,” she added.
“Hmmm.”
“What does that mean?”
“Nothing. I simply thought it was very considerate of you to go out of your way to baby-sit last night.”
“I went over to see about Paige’s cat. Then this situation came up and she is a cute kid and—Dad, what are you smirking about?”
“Nothing except that Nick Meredith is single and goodlooking. I think he’s a fine sheriff. Probably an excellent young man—”
“Dad.”
“As you told me, dear, there’s always hope.”
II
Andrew had just left when the phone rang. “Good morning, Nat. Feeling better about things?”
Kenny Davis. With everything that had been going on, she had barely thought about him the last couple of days. Well, more than barely. Less than constantly.
“By ‘feeling better,’ I assume you’re asking if I’ve stopped being angry. I haven’t.”
“Come home. We can talk it out.”
“I don’t think we can talk this out, Kenny. You slept with another woman and it wasn’t the first time.”
“I’m not denying what I did. The reason why I did it is what we need to talk about.”
“We already have. You said you panicked at the thought of commitment.”
“But I’m over it.”
To her surprise, Natalie laughed. “It took less than a week for you to overcome this deep-seated fear? Kenny, I’m not a fool.”
“But I’ve done a lot of thinking since you left, Nat. I’ve missed you and I can’t imagine my life without you.”
“And after I’ve been back for a while and you’ve stopped missing me? What then?”
“You’re not giving me a chance.”
“Kenny, I told you I need time to think. Time doesn’t mean five days—”
“Six.”
&nbs
p; “Okay, six. Whatever. Besides, a lot has been going on around here.”
“I read in the newspaper about the murder of a Tamara Hunt in Port Ariel. Did you know her?”
“Did I know her?” Natalie burst out. “Kenny, she was Lily’s sister. You’ve met Lily.”
“Hey, don’t get so mad because I didn’t recognize the name of the married sister of someone I’ve met.”
“You make it all sound so casual.” Cold anger filled her. “Lily is my best friend. Tamara was her twin. I’ve known them since I was a child and I’ve talked about them so much since we’ve been together, but you don’t remember. You weren’t even listening to me.”
“Of course I was listening. I’m just not good with names.”
“Another lie.”
“Why are you so mad?”
She sighed. “I repeat that I asked for time. Considering what you did, I think you might have the decency to grant it. Instead, this is the second time in less than a week you’ve called. I am not ready to talk.”
“So I gather.” He paused. “You only have one more week of vacation time. You’ll come home then and we’ll talk.”
Home. Home was the condo she shared with Kenny. Could she possibly go back there and pick up where they left off?
I left off seeing Kenny in our bed with another woman, Natalie thought after hanging up the phone. Is that what he wants me to come home to?
A dull headache was forming at the back of her head. Tension. She could not take another round with Kenny. She turned on the answering machine to screen calls.
The doorbell rang. Natalie sighed. Now what? At least it couldn’t be Kenny.
She opened the door. Ruth Meadows stood smiling at her and holding a pie dish covered with aluminum foil. “I couldn’t sleep last night so I baked a few pies. Your father told me once that your favorite is cherry, so I brought one over.”
“How nice of you!” Natalie was genuinely pleased. “I haven’t had cherry pie for years.” She stepped back. “Come in. Dad isn’t here.”
Don’t Close Your Eyes Page 18