The Second Shift: Working Families and the Revolution at Home

Home > Other > The Second Shift: Working Families and the Revolution at Home > Page 33
The Second Shift: Working Families and the Revolution at Home Page 33

by Arlie Hochschild, Anne Machung


  Weitzman, Lenore. The Divorce Revolution. New York: Free Press, 1985.

  Welter, Barbara. “The Cult of True Womanhood.” American Quarterly 18 (1966): 151-74.

  “What Do Cal. Freshmen Feel, Believe, Think? Results of an Annual Survey.” Cal Report 5 (1988): 4.

  “When They Both Work, Who Cleans the Toilets?” San Francisco Chronicle, October 11, 1982.

  “When You Can’t Be Home, Teach Your Child What to Do.” Changing Times, August 1984.

  Wiseman, Paul. “Young, Single, Childless Women Out-earn Male Counterparts.” USA Today, September 2, 2010.

  Yogev, Sara. “Do Professional Women Have Egalitarian Marital Relationships?” Journal of Marriage and the Family 43 (1981): 865-71.

  Yogev, Sara, and J. M. Brett. “Patterns of Work and Family Involvement Among Single and Dual-Earner Couples.” Journal of Applied Psychology 70 (1985): 754-68.

  —–. “Restructuring Work for Family: How Dual-Earner Couples with Children Manage.” Unpublished paper, Center for Urban Affairs and Policy Research, Northwestern University, Evanston, Ill., 1987.

  Yogman, M. W. “Competence and Performance of Fathers and Infants.” In Progress in Child Health, edited by A. Macfarlane. London: Churchill Livingston, 1983.

  Nonprofit Organizations Engaged in Helping Working Families

  MomsRising

  Since 2006, this one-million-strong organization has pressed for such causes as fair pay, paid maternity and paternity leave, paid sick days, early care and education, and toxic-free bottles, toys, and home environments.

  The Labor Project for Working Families

  A national nonprofit founded in 1992, the LPWF partners with labor unions to advocate for family-friendly workplaces and the right of workers to care for themselves and their families.

  Take Back Your Time

  Since 2002, the organization has worked to raise awareness about “time poverty” in America. Vacations are not, they argue for example, an idle luxury, but crucial to a healthy, civically engaged, environmentally responsible, family-friendly society. They also raise awareness of child “nature-deficit disorder.”

  Every Child Matters Education Fund

  Founded in 2001, this organization works to create a lobby for struggling families that otherwise lack it, to press political candidates to address the urgent need for various child-friendly programs.

  National Organization of Women

  Funded in 1966, N.O.W. remains the largest organization in America pressing for women’s rights, including the economic rights of mothers and caregivers, and economic equity.

  National Partnership for Women and Families (formerly the Women’s Legal Defense Fund)

  The Family and Medical Leave Act was written by a member and the organization fought for nine years to enact it. Since 1971, it fought to end discrimination against pregnant workers, to litigate on-the-job sexual harassment, wage discrimination, and child-support enforcement.

  Index

  advertising, 25

  advice books, 26-29, 32

  agrarian society, 186-87, 238n

  Alcorn, Katrina, 263-64

  Alston, Beverly, 144, 146, 149

  Alston, Carol

  and baby-sitters, 197

  and career strategies, 194-95

  and child care, 148-52, 156

  and cultural pressures, 240

  and education, 152-53

  family life described, 143-48

  and gender strategies, 147, 153-59, 192

  and household strategies, 195

  Alston, Daryl, 143-47, 148-53, 155-56, 261

  Alston, Greg

  and child care, 148-52, 261

  family life described, 143-48

  and fatherhood, 185

  and gender strategies, 147, 153-59, 192

  and housework sharing, 148-49, 195, 213

  and wife’s career sacrifice, 152-53

  American Council of Education, 255

  Arendell, Terry, 244-45

  au pairs, 66. See also baby-sitters and day-care workers

  baby-sitters and day-care workers

  and capitalism, 269

  and class issues, 161, 241

  and cultural changes, 158, 227-28, 239

  interviews of, 5, 25

  and the Livingstons, 160-61, 164-72, 227, 228

  and men’s gender strategies, 228-30

  and the Myersons, 104

  and the new man, 178

  as second income, 65-66, 72

  and the Steins, 121-23

  Baranskaya, Natalya, 24-25

  Barnett, R. C., 3

  Baruch, Grace, 3

  Beaumont, Bill, 51-52, 54

  Berg, Barbara, 243

  Bernard, Jessie, 107

  Bianchi, Suzanne, 265-66

  blacks, 6, 12n, 14, 23-25, 184, 186, 251. See also specific individuals

  Blades, Joan, 268

  blue-collar families, 62, 250. See also class, social

  Bonds of Womankind (Cott), 237

  Bourdieu, Pierre, 223

  Brown, Helen Gurley, 26

  Bureau of the Census, 244

  Canada, 259-60

  Catholicism, 106-7, 108, 162

  Changing Times, 227

  Charles, Maria, 289n5

  Chicana women, 242-43

  children and child care

  and the Alstons, 148-52

  and child welfare, 266-67

  and divorce, 211-12

  and fatherhood, 231-34

  and gender ideology, 14, 15, 78

  and gender roles, 27, 58, 104, 116-17, 158, 181-82, 205-7, 223, 228-31

  and gender strategies, 195-96

  and housework sharing, 177

  latch-key children, 227

  and marital tensions, 164-72

  and the Myersons, 102, 104, 156, 227

  and parenting roles, 225-28

  research on, 271-87

  shared responsibility for, 20

  and the Steins, 117, 123-24

  time spent on, 9

  and the Winfields, 156-57, 181-85

  and women’s careers, 81-88, 90-91, 92, 94, 97-99, 113, 114-15, 136

  and workplace pressures, 169-70

  Chodorow, Nancy, 155-57

  class, social

  and baby-sitters, 161, 241

  and changes in the workforce, 12n

  and corporate hierarchies, 287n4

  and the Delacortes, 62-63, 241, 242

  and divorce, 88

  and economic logic of gender roles, 222-23

  and family myths, 19

  and fatherhood, 232

  and gender ideologies, 188-89

  and job types, 136-37

  and the Judsons, 130

  and marriage trends, 257-58

  and men, 62-63

  and sleep patterns, 279n2

  and traditionalism, 204-5

  and women in the workforce, 241-42

  and working-mother image, 23

  Clinton, Bill, 259

  Collins, Dennis, 52

  comparison groups, 5, 51-57, 253

  corporate hierarchies, 287n4

  Cosell, Hilary, 30

  Cott, Nancy, 237

  Courtney, Olive, 26

  Cowen, Carolyn, 233

  Cowen, Paul, 125

  Cowen, Phil, 233

  Cowen, Rachel, 125

  cultural pressures

  and child care, 158, 227-28, 239

  and the Delacortes, 64, 106-7

  and divorce, 134

  and domestic heritage, 242-43

  and education, 107, 114, 152-53

  and family myths, 45

  and fatherhood, 231

  and gender ideologies, 42, 106-7, 250, 252

  and the Holts, 52, 57, 64, 240

  and homes, 101

  and housework sharing, 213-14

  and incompetence strategy, 74

  and the Judsons, 130

  and the Steins, 115-16, 125

  and supermom strategy, 22-33
r />   and traditionalism, 65-71

  and women’s careers, 23-34, 85-86, 106-10, 180-81, 200, 202-3, 205-7, 239-41, 255-56, 264 (see also supermom(s))

  Dale, Barbara, 29

  Dale, Jim, 29

  Delacorte, Carmen

  and class issues, 62-63, 241, 242

  and cultural pressures, 64, 106-7

  and economic pressures, 62-64, 189

  and gender ideology, 190

  and generational changes, 257

  and incompetence strategy, 73-76, 193, 199

  and marital tensions, 201, 207

  as “new peasantry,” 242

  and primary parenting role, 156

  and traditionalism, 61-71, 71-73, 204-5

  Delacorte, Delia, 66

  Delacorte, Frank

  and child care, 81

  and cultural pressures, 64, 106-7

  and economic pressures, 62-64, 189

  and incompetence strategy, 73-76, 193, 199

  and marital tensions, 201, 207

  and second-shift work, 188

  and traditionalism, 61-71, 71-73, 204-5

  Denmark, 268

  divorce, 201-12

  and the Alstons, 146

  and housework, 207-12

  impact on daughters, 257

  and interview subjects, 5

  and the Judsons, 130, 133-34, 141-42

  and the leisure gap, 4

  and marriage standards, 168-69

  and national priorities, 259

  and the Tanagawas, 88-90, 203

  and wage inequality, 244-45

  and women’s’ entrance into workforce, 12

  Divorce: Women and Children Last (Arendell) 244

  domestic help. See baby-sitters and day-care workers; housekeepers “Doonesbury” (Trudeau), 200

  Eastern Europe, 3

  economic pressures. See also wages and income

  and changes in the workplace, 250-51

  and changes in women’s lives, 11-12

  and child care, 158, 181-82, 223

  and the Delacortes, 62-64, 188-89

  and divorce, 210

  economic logic of gender roles, 217-24

  and gender ideology, 130-31

  and gender strategies, 75-76

  and the Holts, 8, 38-44, 57, 188, 189, 223

  and housework sharing, 215-17

  and the Livingstons, 163, 217

  and marital tensions, 11, 169-70, 202

  marriage as redistribution mechanism, 245-46

  and the recession of 2008, 141, 265

  and traditionalism, 68-69, 71-72, 204-5

  and women’s financial dependence, 140-42

  and workplace pressures, 184

  Edder, Janet, 227

  education

  and cultural pressures, 107, 114, 152-53

  and economic logic of gender roles, 219-20

  and family histories, 57-58

  and gender ideology, 152-53

  and the Holts, 42-43, 57-58

  and Nina Tanagawa, 81

  education (cont.)

  and race issues, 23

  and the Shermans, 173, 174-75, 176

  and traditionalism, 67

  and women’s ambitions, 255

  and working mothers, 232

  egalitarian gender ideology

  and clashing couples, 201

  and class issues, 188

  and cutting back strategy, 195

  and depth of gender ideologies, 14, 15-17

  egalitarian essentialism, 289n5

  and female helplessness strategy, 73

  and housework sharing, 276

  and ideological contradictions, 190

  and incompetence strategy, 74

  and the Judsons, 140

  and marital mix of ideologies, 282-83n1

  and mismatch of gender ideologies, 58

  and second shift participation, 75

  and strength of relationships, 215

  Ehrenreich, Barbara, 13, 226, 240-41

  emotional and mental health

  and anxiety, 4, 27, 42, 115, 184

  and depression, 47-48, 83, 88-90

  emotional absenteeism, 122-23

  and fatigue, 50, 84

  and stress, 138-39, 167-68, 216, 263

  and support strategies, 78-81

  English, Deirdre, 226, 240-41

  Family and Medical Leave Act, 259

  family backgrounds

  and the Alstons, 157-58

  and the Delacortes, 69

  and fatherhood role, 224-25, 234

  and gender ideology, 14, 190-91

  and the Holts, 47-48, 50-51, 57-58

  and housework sharing, 213-15

  and the Judsons, 130-31, 132-33, 134

  and the Livingstons, 162, 163-64, 172

  and the Myersons, 101, 108

  and parenting patterns, 155-57

  and the Shermans, 173-74

  and the Steins, 115-16, 116-17, 125

  and the Tanagawas, 88

  and traditionalism, 61-62

  and the Winfields, 184-85

  and women in the workforce, 235

  family leave legislation, 259-60

  family myths

  and comparison groups, 54

  described, 18-21

  and division of labor, 94, 102

  and gender strategies, 19, 45, 127

  and incompetence strategy, 75

  and the Judsons, 140

  and marital tensions, 203-4

  strategies to sustain, 47-51

  and the Tanagawas, 81, 127-28

  upstairs-downstairs myth, 44-46, 48, 54-55, 58-59, 75, 102, 112, 203

  and workplace pressures, 180

  fatherhood

  and academic achievement of children, 285-86n7

  limiting idea of, 224-25

  research on, 231-34

  and the stalled gender revolution, 263

  third stage of, 185-87

  and the Winfields, 181-85

  feminism

  and the Alstons, 144

  and the Delacortes, 64, 65, 68, 75

  and the Holts, 47-48, 54, 58, 59, 75

  and sexual strategies, 43-44

  and the Shermans, 179

  Fernandez, Alicia, 230

  Fey, Tina, 264

  Finland, 268

  Finley, Shawn Dickinson, xxiii-xxiv

  Ford, Betty, 68

  For Her Own Good (Ehrenreich and English), 226, 240-41

  France, 208, 268

  Furstenberg, Frank, 244

  gay couples, 5, 52

  gender ideologies. See also egalitarian gender ideology; traditional gender ideology; transitional gender ideology

  and changes in the workplace, 250-51

  and child care, 8, 78, 108, 148-49

  and comparison groups, 58

  contradictions in, 15-16

  and coping with feelings, 190-92

  and cultural pressures, 42, 106-7, 252

  and “deep ideologies,” 14

  and the Delacortes, 61-71, 71-73, 73-76, 193, 199, 205

  described, 15-17

  and disparities in second shift work, 14

  and economy of gratitude, 18

  and education, 152-53

  and family myths, 19, 45, 127

  and fatherhood, 224-25, 231-34

  and gender strategies, 17-18

  and the Holts, 16, 40-42, 45, 54, 58, 190

  and housework sharing, 183, 276

  and incompetence strategy, 74-76, 76

  and the Judsons, 132-42

  and marital tensions, 201-2

  and play styles, 151-52

  responsibility for home life, 8

  and the Tanagawas, 87

  and traditionalism, 65-71

  and women’s careers, 84-85, 99, 112-13

  gender strategies. See also superdad(s); supermom(s)

  and the Alstons, 147, 153-59, 192

  and careers, 126-27, 194-95

  cutting back on housework, 195-96

>   described, 17-18

  direct approaches, 192-93

  and domestic help, 196-97

  and Enlightenment ideas, 258

  and gender ideology, 192

  and incompetence, 72-73, 73-76, 193, 199, 205

  indirect approaches, 193

  and the Judsons, 132-42, 195, 198, 257

  men’s strategies, 197-200

  and national priorities, 259

  origin of term, 280n2

  and roles in marriage, 3

  and the Steins, 125-26

  and the Tanagawas, 78-81, 112, 125, 147, 194, 198-200, 252

  and women’s careers, 112-14

  General Social Survey, 289n5

  generational changes, 12, 21, 40-41, 172, 256, 264-65

  Germany, 208, 259-60, 268

  Goode, William, 207-8

  Good Morning, Merry Sunshine (Greene), 31

  government policy, 259-61

  gratitude

  an gender ideology, 18

  and comparison groups, 53-54

  and the Delacortes, 64

  gratitude (cont.)

  and gender strategies, 153, 157-59, 200

  and marital tensions, 202, 204

  and the Myersons, 118-19

  and the Shermans, 180

  and the Steins, 118-19, 128

  and the Tanagawas, 84-86, 118

  Great Recession of 2008, 141, 265

  Greene, Bob, 31-32

  Greene, Susan, 31

  Grusky, David, 289n5

  Hartmann, Heidi, 245

  Hatch, Diane, 210

  Having It All (Brown), 26, 28

  Hayden, Dolores, 12, 260

  The Hearts of Men (Ehrenreich), 13

  helplessness strategy, 72-73, 73-76, 193, 199, 205

  Hite, Shere, 13

  hobbies, 100-104, 105, 147, 197, 214-15

  Hochschild, Adam, xv

  Hochschild, David, xi-xii, xv

  Hochschild, Gabriel, xv

  Hoffman, Lois, 232

  Holt, Evan

  and changes in the workplace, 250

  and child care, 156, 254

  and comparison of responsibilities, 51-57

  daily routines, 34-38

  and economic logic of gender roles, 223

  and family myths, 19, 127

  and gender ideology, 16, 40-42, 45, 54, 58, 190

  and gender strategies, 125, 198, 199

  and housework sharing, 38-44, 44-51, 103, 173, 188, 189

  and leisure time, 38, 49-50, 55, 56, 197, 214-15

  and marital tensions, 11, 201, 207

  and repercussions of second shift, 8

  sacrifices of, 180

  and upstairs-downstairs myth, 44-46, 48, 54-55, 57-60, 75, 102, 112, 203

  Holt, Joey

  and family myths, 47-51

  and the Holt’s marriage dynamic, 34-39, 43, 46, 51, 55-57, 60, 75, 223, 235

 

‹ Prev