by Zoey Parker
But I’d exhausted every possibility. Going to the club had been my big last-ditch effort, and now I knew how far that had gotten me. I’d had my heart broken for all my efforts, and I was no closer to finding my sister.
There had to be another way. That couldn’t have been the end of the road. She had to know someone, somehow, who had ties to this.
I looked up the stairs from where I stood by the front door. There was one more option still open to me. I hadn’t gone in there yet, not since I loaded her belongings into her old room. I’d promised myself I wouldn’t unlock the door until she came home. But there was no choice now. I was desperate. This wasn’t an invasion of her privacy. It was a last-ditch effort.
I was holding the key in my hand, having taken my keyring off the hook to return the keys to my car. It was a small, gold key which fit into the old doorknob, an original fixture of the house. I had to do this. She would want me to.
I climbed the stairs slowly, bracing myself for what I would find. It wasn’t that I was afraid to find a clue. It was more fear of the emotions I’d run into while going through her things. There was no way around it.
The key slid smoothly into the lock, then turned. And there I was, facing boxes filled with my sister’s life. A life I hoped wasn’t over yet.
I didn’t know where to start. She wasn’t a packrat, but there were still an overwhelming number of boxes and bags. I decided to take the box closest to me, sitting on the floor with it and pulling off the lid.
It was so “Sabrina,” I nearly cried. Her clothes. I pulled out the sweater which laid on the top of the pile and held it to my nose. It was her. I breathed deeply, rubbing the soft wool over my face. It was Sabrina’s scent. Her favorite perfume, Tommy Girl. I’d come to associate that scent with her over the years, ever since she first discovered it in a department store. Since she’d been missing, I’d smelled it once or twice on random women and had been overcome by memories.
I closed my eyes, feeling like she was still with me. She had to be out there somewhere.
The rest of the box was also full of clothing, which I went through with a loving gaze. It all reminded me so much of her. I could remember her wearing every single thing. Her good jeans. The skirt she sometimes wore to my gigs. The blouse she wore to a barbecue and spilled ketchup all over—she’d managed to get the stain out after soaking it, I saw. Her favorite sweatshirt, worn so many times it had started to fray at the collar and cuffs. I used to joke that she would wear it until it fell off her.
The next box wasn’t so memory-filled, but it was just as much a sight into my sister’s mind as the first box had been. This one was full of books. Classics, mostly. She was so smart. Tolstoy, Austen, Forster, Hemingway, and many others. When girls her age didn’t read much more than their social media feed or the occasional blog post, my sister was reading literature.
It wasn’t all highbrow, though. There were popular novels in there, recent titles I remembered talking over with her. A few of them had come from me, I realized. I’d passed them on to her once I finished reading them. I ran my fingers over the pages, remembering how we sat with our tea and chatted about our favorite lines and scenes. We were a book club of two, she used to say. I wouldn’t have wanted it any other way. She was the smartest person I knew, always full of insight. She was also wickedly funny. I could have sat and talked with her for hours on end and never gotten bored. She was always refreshingly bright and honest.
The next box was full of pictures and mementos. This was one of her few odd little habits, but even this was understandable. She saved literally everything that could ever have a meaning somewhere down the line. Ticket stubs from even the most terrible movies and concerts. Programs from every play she’d ever seen, or been part of in school. Birthday cards, Christmas cards, graduation cards. I saw a few cards I’d given her. She always wrote the date on the back, in the bottom right corner.
It was the same with her photos. She had millions of them, it seemed. Middle school, high school. Friends, teachers, neighbors. Me. Lots of me. At the amusement park, at the mini-golf course, at the beach. I remembered the dream I had and flinched, putting those photos to the side, where I wouldn’t have to see them again.
There were some random, loose photos, too. I remembered gathering them all up from a pile on her desk and throwing them into the box before closing it up. They were the only ones which hadn’t been in an envelope. I laughed softly to myself. Who had photos printed nowadays? She was like a relic from the past, but I was glad. Otherwise, I would have so little from her, if it was all on a memory card somewhere far from me.
I flipped through the loose photos quickly at first, then more slowly. The redhead in the one picture. Wasn’t she the one who hadn’t wanted to speak to me? And the brunette with the big rack. I recognized her, too. She’d been more sympathetic, hadn’t she? But she’d still been afraid to talk.
They were photos of the club. I went back to the beginning, going through more slowly this time. She must have taken a bunch of random shots with her camera phone and had them printed at the pharmacy or something. They weren’t great quality—some of them were too blurry to make much out—but they told me a lot about her life in the last few months before she disappeared.
One guy kept showing up in many of the photos. He would routinely turn his face from the camera, but his auburn hair gave him away. I knew who he was. I remembered him all too well. I could still smell him, the sick bastard.
Sure enough, she’d managed to get a good shot of him at one point. He was smiling at the camera for once. He looked pretty drunk, so she must have caught him when he wasn’t feeling so unphotogenic. She was in the picture, too. Kissing him on the cheek.
There was no denying it. That wasn’t a friendly kiss. You didn’t do that with these men—even I knew that, and I was hardly as close with them as she seemed to be. They weren’t just friends. He was her boyfriend, or, at least, the guy she was sleeping with.
He looked healthier in the photo than he had when I made his acquaintance. There weren’t any circles under his eyes, and his face was fuller. He’d lost weight and a lot of sleep since my sister went missing. I could only guess why.
“Are you Thorn?” I asked, staring down at his smiling face. “Did you hurt my sister? Did you kill her? Did you hold a knife to my throat, you bastard?”
I knew this had to mean something to the police. Hell, if I had to, I would tell them I’d seen the man who held the knife to me. I hadn’t, but they didn’t need to know that. I was willing to lie just to get them to pay attention to him. And even if it was a lie, I was ninety-nine percent positive it was him, so it wasn’t as though I was accusing an innocent man.
My phone rang, pulling me from my plan. Good thing, too, or else I would have collapsed into tears at the thought of staring at my sister’s possible killer. She looked so happy with him. She had no idea what he was capable of.
Another ring. I hoped it wasn’t Gabriel. He was the last person I wanted to hear from.
But it wasn’t. In fact, the number was blocked. I immediately assumed it was a solicitor, but some instinct told me to answer, anyway. There was no telling where a random phone call could lead.
“Hello?” At first, all I heard was static and faint background noise. I couldn’t make any of it out. Was it traffic? A TV? I wasn’t sure. “Hello? Who is this?”
“Kat?”
My heart skipped a beat. The voice was faint, but I thought I recognized it.
“Sabrina?” I shrieked, jumping to my feet. “Oh, my God! Sabrina! Is that you?”
“It’s me.” She was still so faint, so far away.
“Are you all right? What happened? Are you sick or hurt?”
“No, I’m okay.” How could she be so calm? I was blubbering like a fool, tears pouring down my face. I could barely speak for sobbing. But she acted like we’d only spoke yesterday. I hoped she didn’t have amnesia or some other sort of brain injury.
“Where are you,
honey? Oh, God, I’ve been looking for you like crazy! Where are you? I’ll come get you, anywhere. Just tell me!” Oh, thank God, thank God, thank God.
“There’s a motel, just off the highway. Maybe one hundred miles outside of town. An old Motel Six. Do you know where it is?”
“I think so. I’ve passed there before. You said it’s really old?”
“Yeah. Not many people stay here.”
I knew exactly where she meant. Even if I hadn’t, I would have gladly driven around for days looking for the place because my Sabrina was alive and safe. I couldn’t wait to bring her home.
“I’ll get you right away,” I said. “It should only take me a couple of hours.”
“I’ll be waiting for you,” she said, then hung up. I shivered at the way she ended the call. Something about her words teased at my memory of the dream I’d had just before waking up. I’ve been waiting for you. Wasn’t that what she’d said in the dream?
It didn’t matter now. All that mattered was she was alive. I could have danced for joy.
I threw on some random clothes and shoes, grabbed my keys and was out the door in an instant. It was all I could do to keep from breaking the speed limit as I raced down the highway toward my sister.
My phone buzzed several times as I drove, and I checked it every time in case it was Sabrina. Only it was Gabriel, texting me again and again. Don’t go anywhere, he said. Stay home. I’m coming for you. DO NOT LEAVE THE HOUSE.
I ignored him, tossing the phone to the passenger seat with a smirk. Let him try to keep me away from my sister. He would see who he was dealing with.
The phone buzzed on and on as I drove.
Chapter 18
Gabriel
When I left Kat’s house, I could still hear her voice ringing in my ears. Accusing me of being a liar, of using her. It tore at me, knowing what she thought of me. I hated knowing how hurt she felt, when there was nothing I could say to convince her of how wrong she was.
She wasn’t completely wrong, though, even though she was a little fast at jumping to conclusions. I did know something was wrong. I knew it had something to do with Thorn and her sister. I didn’t know the whole story, though. And I hadn’t been trying to keep it from her to use her…but to protect her, and Thorn.
That’s what it was all about. I wasn’t even concerned so much about the club anymore—I was still worried about losing power, about Thorn being arrested and causing chaos for me. It was my job to protect my men, and that’s what I was trying to do.
But I was trying to protect him, too, and that was more important. Not my VP. My best friend. He had done so much for me. Sometimes his friendship had been the only thing I had in my life that wasn’t shit. When I couldn’t depend on grown-ups or the other kids at the home, I could still depend on Thorn. And he could depend on me.
But was it fair to keep protecting him when I couldn’t depend on him anymore? He was a mess. He was falling apart. He had done something terrible. Could I keep covering up for him?
Now he wanted to talk to me. I wasn’t sure I wanted to hear it. I couldn’t deny it if I heard it coming from his mouth. I need to talk to you about Sabrina. Come to my house when you get this. That’s what his text had said. And it wasn’t something we could talk about over the phone. We had to talk about it in person. It couldn’t be good.
If he told me he killed Sabrina, what could I do? I tried to come up with some kind of plan as I rode. First, I stopped at my house to put on a shirt. While I was there, I decided to shower and get my act together. I wasn’t in any huge hurry. All he wanted to do was confess to me. The world didn’t hang in the balance.
I was putting it off, and I knew it in the back of my head. I didn’t wanna hear Thorn’s story. There was a picture of Thorn and me on a bookshelf. One of the only pictures I had in the house, and he was in it. We had gone fishing up at some lake whose name I couldn’t remember anymore. We were just kids in the picture. No more than thirteen, maybe fourteen. Both of us holding up our catches, which seemed so big at the time. Really, they were only a little bigger than guppies. But from the smiles on our faces, we were proud to have caught them.
I remembered that kid. That Thorn. He was brave and would always back me up in a fight. I had been alone in life until he came along. What had happened to him since then? I turned the picture face-down on the shelf. I couldn’t think about that kid anymore. The memories made it too difficult to do what had to be done in the present.
I couldn’t just accept what he had to say if he told me he killed Sabrina, and let it roll off my shoulders. Kat had nothing to do with it—I wouldn’t have been able to accept it if Sabrina wasn’t the sister of the woman I was sleeping with. A woman who hadn’t left my mind since the minute I met her. No, even without Kat, I wouldn’t have been okay with Thorn killing a woman, no matter how much I cared about him.
It would have been bad enough if she wasn’t involved. With her, it was a whole other story. I cared about her, too, and I knew how much she loved her sister. And from what Kat told me about Sabrina, she was a good person. She didn’t deserve whatever had happened to her.
I almost wished Kat had never told me about her. It only made what I had to do even harder.
I wasn’t sure what I had to do, actually.
I rode to his house, sick to my stomach. The entire ride, I had to remind myself that the past was the past. This was what mattered, right now. I had to do what was best for the club.
What about Kat? Didn’t she matter? Which mattered more? Now I remembered why I had stayed away from relationships for so long. They only made life more complicated. I had enough on my plate without the memory of her hazel eyes burning into me.
I let the wind push my thoughts away. Riding always cleared my head, and I tried to let it do that while I sped to Thorn’s house. I didn’t care about the speed. I sorta hoped the cops would pull me over. I was dreading the scene with Thorn that much.
For once, they were nowhere to be found. Of course. The one time I was hoping to see them.
I got to Thorn’s and saw his bike in the driveway. He’d gotten it from impound. At least he wasn’t out somewhere, raising hell. All he needed was to get busted for riding with a suspended license. There was no bailing him out from that. His ass would be in jail in no time.
I banged on the front door. No answer. I banged again, cupping my hands around my eyes to see inside through the window on the door. The place was a mess. Another one of Thorn’s bad habits was relying on his women to do his cleaning for him. His latest woman wasn’t doing it, obviously. It looked the way I would imagine a frat house looking. It had been a nice little house, once.
I banged again, leaning on the doorbell at the same time. Finally, I heard shouting from inside. “Shut up!” A woman’s voice. She sounded strung out or drunk. Or both.
She flung the door open and blinked against the sunlight. She covered her eyes with her hand. “Whaddya want?”
She was a mess. My eyes didn’t know where to go first. The frizzy, matted hair, the stained clothes, the sores on her arms. I sighed. “Thorn. I’m here to see Thorn.”
She uncovered her eyes, squinting at me. Her face wasn’t much prettier than the rest of her. “He ain’t here.”
I shook my head. “What? He told me to meet him here. He texted me earlier. He wouldn’t have left without calling to let me know.”
“Yeah, well, he’s gone now. Guess you don’t know him so good.” She tried to shut the door, but I held it open. I pushed my way into the house. It wasn’t just cluttered. It was dirty. It smelled like stale food and rotting garbage. When had Thorn become this person? This Tracee was obviously a junkie. Was she the only one doing drugs here, or was he doing them, too?
She pushed me, but I hardly felt it. “You can’t just come in here!” she shrieked. “You have to leave! He wouldn’t want you to walk in like this!”
I looked her up and down. “Who says?”
“I-I say,” she stammered. “I liv
e here, too. And you can’t be here.”
“Yeah, I can,” I said. “Tracee, right? Where did he go?”
“I don’t know. Now get out.” She shoved me again.
I advanced on her, backing her into the nearest wall. “How could he have gone anywhere without his license?” I cornered her. She tried to get past me, but I wouldn’t let her. Something didn’t add up, and I wasn’t going to leave until she was straight with me.
“Just because you don’t have your license doesn’t mean you can’t drive anymore, you know,” she spat.
“What did he drive?” She looked at the floor. “Your car? He took your car, didn’t he?”
“So what?” She was mumbling now, swaying. I was losing her. She must have just shot up or smoked up, or whatever it was she did. I shook her a little, not enough to hurt but enough to get her brain working. At least, I hoped so.