by Lexi Archer
There was never any question about the role I was going to play in this forbidden encounter. I was the ringmaster. Besides, this obsession meant I was more than content to sit back and watch. My cock throbbed at the sight of the three women together, and the idea of putting the men at either end and watching them fuck my girls, because that's how I was thinking of Michelle and Jennifer now, placed deliberately at either end of the fun where Jeff and Alan could reach them easily, was turning me on more than that the idea of jumping into the mix.
No, I was all about the watching. And more than anything I wanted to watch Jennifer and Michelle getting taken. And the answer to who was going to take whom was pretty fucking obvious.
"Alan, I need you to get behind Michelle," I said.
There was a moment where Samantha looked up with jealousy plain on her face, but then Michelle found a sweet spot and she closed her eyes and let out a groan. And she seemed to surrender to the logic of the moment. It's not like she could get particularly upset considering we were having something of a sexual free-for-all anyways. Her head went back down between Jennifer's legs and there was no more protest from her.
Michelle didn't stop at all. I figured that was an endorsement of the plan. If she wanted me to stop she would've said something.
Alan looked at me, unsure.
"You really want me to do this?" he asked. "That's crossing a line. Michelle is your girl!"
"And I know how much you've been turned on thinking about her all summer long," I said. "Now go in there and get her!"
The enthusiasm Alan displayed as he moved behind Michelle let me know he was more than happy to get back there and have a little bit of fun himself. That the protest he'd just made was nothing more than a thing he thought he had to do because he saw Michelle as my girl no matter how much he wanted to fuck her.
I could appreciate where his hesitation was coming from, but I didn’t need it. What I needed was to see another guy fucking my girl!
In a moment he was positioned behind her, and then I had the pleasure of watching yet another man's dick sliding inside my girlfriend. Michelle responded by moaning and pressing back against him. Apparently she was enjoying this as much as she'd enjoyed her fun with Jeff.
Fuck that was hot! And then there were four people in the line. Jennifer, Samantha, and Michelle all connected at the mouth and pussy, and Alan who was staring down at Michelle's back as he plowed into her from behind with a look of disbelief as though he was having trouble coming to terms with the fact that he was actually getting to fuck her.
I wondered how many times he'd fantasized about precisely this scenario over the summer. How many times he'd jerked off listening to her moaning when we were in bed together and he was left alone. The thought was hot, but not as watching him actually getting to consummate some of those fantasies!
And now it was time for me to complete this picture. I looked to the front of the line. To where Jennifer's head was thrown back almost over the edge of the lounge. Perfectly positioned for someone who wanted to fuck her mouth.
I was getting just as hot from the idea of Jennifer stepping out with another guy as I did at the idea of Michelle having fun with another guy. My mind had taken on the same possessive feeling towards Jennifer as it did towards Michelle. I saw her as mine, considering everything we'd just done and the obsession she'd been displaying towards me over the summer, and sharing her with another man was almost as hot as the idea of sharing Michelle with another man.
Not quite as hot, but almost.
Jeff stared at Alan with more than a touch of jealousy, though it seemed odd that he would feel jealous of another man banging Michelle considering he wasn't even with Michelle. I suppose there were probably all sorts of fucked up dynamics going on, but I figured the consolation prize I was about to give him would make him forget all about any jealousy he might feel about Michelle getting with another guy. It was something he was going to have to get over if he wanted to continue being part of the fun past tonight.
"Jeff?"
He looked over at me and there was some irritation on his face, but he quickly schooled it to a smile. Oh yeah. He was irritated that he wasn't getting to enjoy Michelle's treasures, but he also didn't want to make it too obvious that he was irritated. That might mean get him cut off from the fun for the rest of the summer. I didn’t even have to say anything and I knew he got it.
Maybe there was some telepathy going on between us as well. It was good to know he knew how to play ball, even if he was annoyed.
"What's up?" he asked.
"I think Jennifer would like a chance to have some fun with you," I said.
I looked down at Jennifer. Her eyes flew open and she locked eyes with me. She licked her lips. Yeah, she knew exactly what I was getting at. And the lust fueled gaze that passed across her face told me she more than welcomed the opportunity. I thought back to her talking about how hot Jeff was when she was trying to pull a fast one with her break room talk with Samantha. I figured she hadn't been exaggerating her attraction too terribly much.
And that look confirmed it. She wanted Jeff. Wanted to have some fun. Wanted to feel his cock inside her. And I desperately wanted to see that happen.
"Does that sound fun to you Jennifer?"
She bit her lip and nodded. I looked Jeff and cocked an eyebrow as though to ask him what the hell he was waiting for. Not that he waited too long after that invitation.
He moved forward and pressed his cock down against Jennifer's lips. She moved her head back, and a moment later he was face fucking her with surprising vigor. He'd positioned his arms on either side of her on the lounge and was pounding in and out of her mouth. And for a surprise she was taking it like a champ.
Damn. I was going to have to get a blowjob from her at some point. She looked like she was as good as Michelle. Maybe better!
I crossed my arms in front of me and surveyed my handiwork. Five people coming together. Two girls that I considered to be mine on some level fucking other guys. Allowing other men to press their cocks inside them. And it was so hot. My cock throbbed as I looked at what I'd done.
I couldn't resist. I reached down and stroked my cock as I watched and listened to what was playing out before me. The girls licking one another's pussies. Apparently finding hidden depths that only women could considering the experience they had with female anatomy. Their moans grew louder and louder.
Then there was Alan who was ending his dry spell in one hell of a way. First by fucking Samantha and now by pounding into Michelle. By filling her with his cock. There was Jennifer on the other end getting face fucked like a champion. And Jeff who was taking exactly what he wanted as he stared over at Alan and Michelle.
I wondered if he was enjoying some of the same fucked up emotional turmoil that I felt when I was seized by the obsession. That would be interesting. The guy who tried to take my girl from me feeling the same desire I felt at the idea of having my girl taken by another.
Sure she wasn't actually his girl, but he'd probably been obsessed with her for most of the summer and he finally got that taste tonight. Maybe that taste was enough for him to feel some of the same possessiveness that I did. I could see why he’d get off on the idea of watching her with another guy.
The world before me was the sound of everyone fucking. The wet noises of skin slapping together. The forbidden nature of watching Michelle fucking another man, watching Jennifer taking another guy, watching the women fucking one another.
I started jerking my cock, but I figured I could have a little more fun. I moved forward. Positioned myself over Samantha. And I thought about how irritated I’d been when I discovered she was the one orchestrating everything. At least I assumed she was orchestrating everything. The plan they'd come up with seemed too devious for Jeff, and I had a feeling Jennifer liked me a little too much to try and pull something like that.
Samantha seemed to feel my presence over her. She pulled away from Jennifer for a moment and looked up at me. Smi
led as she saw me jerking my cock. But she didn't stop me. No, she went right back to Jennifer's pussy. Enjoyed the taste of her friend and the taste of my come buried inside her friend.
Well, she was about to get a hell of a lot more than just my come on her tongue.
The frenzied sexual energy seemed to be reaching a crescendo. The girls moans were getting louder. Loud enough that they could probably be heard throughout the park. Talk about a fucking good thing that we'd closed the place out before we started having our fun, otherwise it would've been pretty fucking obvious what was going on here. Jeff was grunting in the same way that he had when he came inside Michelle, and Alan seemed on the edge himself.
I stroked my cock and pointed it down at Samantha. And with a final groan I let go. I exploded and my come landed on her back. Jeff grunted one final time and buried himself in Jennifer's mouth, filling her with his come. Pumping her stomach full of his load. Pumping my Jennifer full of his load.
Meanwhile Alan continued fulfilling his fantasy of getting with Michelle. He let out a roar as he held onto her hips and buried himself. And a second man was depositing his load inside my girlfriend in one evening. Fuck!
That moment hung for an eternity, and then it was over. All too soon. It was a damn shame, but considering everything we'd been up to I figured this was the last time we’d have this sort of fun.
Everyone seemed to come back to reality, but it was a friendly reality. It was a reality that was filled with smiles and looks of disbelief passed back and forth. No one could really believe we'd actually just done this, but fuck had been hot.
"So," Michelle said. "Who’s for raiding one of the snack stands?"
Everyone looked at her and this time the disbelief had nothing to do with the fun we'd just had. She looked at each of us in turn and grinned.
"What? After all that I could use a snack! Keep up the electrolytes after vigorous exercise and all that."
Everyone devolved into a fit of giggles. What else was there to do?
16: Big Question
I was on break and so of course the first place I went was back to Michelle’s shack. I was sure Michelle would be there. It was early enough that she was probably working on a schedule or something.
I patted my pocket. There was a small bulge there. I took a deep breath and asked myself again if this was really something I wanted to do, but then again considering everything that had happened recently there was no way I couldn’t do this.
As crazy as it was.
As I walked back there I passed Samantha. She could've been in the break room, but something about the way she looked at me and smiled told me that wasn't the case. That and the way her hair was messed up ever so slightly.
"Have fun," Samantha said. "I got her good and ready for you!"
My head swam as I continued on towards the shack. That was just a small example of the kind of crazy fun that had become the norm ever since that crazy night a couple of weeks back. All of us had decided to take the crazy permission granted by that evening of fun and run with it.
The next couple of weeks had been a nonstop free-for-all with Jeff, Alan, Jennifer, Samantha, Michelle, and me. There wasn't a single night that went by without some combination of all six of us heading over to the apartment for some fun. The nights when we all got together were the most fun.
I guess in a sense I'd been wrong that night. I hadn't peaked sexually with that one night. It certainly seemed I'd peaked sexually when it came to this summer, though. I couldn't possibly see how this was going to get any better, though from the way things were getting more serious between Michelle and me even as we fucked more and more people it seemed like there were all sorts of possibilities that could happen once we were back at school.
That was something to think about when we got back to school. For now I planned on enjoying myself thoroughly with what was on offer at the water park.
I patted my pocket again just to make sure it was still there. I wanted to lock this down.
I stepped into the shack and sure enough Michelle was there leaning back in her chair with a stunned look on her face. A stunned look and some slick juices on her mouth. I had no doubt that was from Samantha.
A look of panic cross her face as I stepped through the door, but it quickly turned to a knowing smile when she realized it was me.
"Did you pass Samantha on your way out?"
"You know I did," I said.
"That girl is insatiable! Who knew she'd be that into girls!"
"Yeah, it's definitely a big surprise," I said.
A big surprise, but one that had added another fun layer to the pleasures on offer. I sometimes wondered if Samantha was maybe more into the girls than she was into Alan, but he didn’t seem to mind. He’d been invited into our naughty sixsome, after all. That was all that really seemed to matter to him, so I didn’t press too much into Samantha’s surprisingly fluid sexuality. That was her business.
I fingered the bulge in my swim trunks. Thought about whether or not I really wanted to go through with this. It was one hell of a big step. It was moving fast, but at the same time given all the crazy experiences I'd had with Michelle it was something that I wanted. Almost more than I’d wanted to watch her with another man.
"Is something wrong?" Michelle asked.
"That depends," I said.
"On?"
"On how you react to a something I'm about to do…"
Michelle laughed. She got up from her chair and came over to give me a kiss. A kiss that was a combination of the familiar taste I'd gotten used to making out with her and another taste that I’d come to know and love in more recent weeks. The taste of Samantha.
"What could you possibly be worried about? You know what we've been doing lately! After getting me to fuck five other people I don’t think anything you say is going to surprise me!"
"Yeah? Well I'm going to give it a try," I said.
I grinned and she got a funny look on her face. Then I got down on one knee and pulled the box out of my pocket.
Michelle looked down and her eyes widened in surprise. Then her hand went to her mouth in a repeat of the same gesture that it seemed every woman did when this happened.
I'd come to a decision. Maybe it was too soon. Maybe I was moving fast, but I was in love with this woman. She was the girl for me. The way we’d transitioned so easily into this obsession was proof enough of that.
"Are you serious?" she asked, though she definitely seemed more intrigued than terrified. I figured that was a good sign. I grinned, opened the box.
With a little luck this would be the start of the rest of our life together.
Keep Reading!
Want more? Keep reading! There’s a FREE copy of the ENTIRE NOVEL Three Hearts, Two Nights, One Love waiting for you!
So read ahead, sign up for my mailing list, check out some of my other books, and enjoy the completely free bonus novel after you’ve done all that!
Thanks for reading!
More from Lexi Archer
Subscribe to my mailing list for all the latest updates and book news!
Sign up at: http://lexiarcher.com/subscribe/
Thanks for downloading this story and supporting me! Check out my catalog, all now available on Kindle Unlimited!
Also by Lexi Archer:
Novels
A whirlwind destination wedding leads to a bet with his brand new bride that will lead them into a forbidden world of watching and sharing!
A husband who wants to watch. A wife with a taste for dark meat. A friend willing to help the sexy couple. What could go wrong?
A faithful wife. A suspicious husband. An online game that lets temptation sneak right into their house even as it lets the husband watch every moment of that temptation…
A beautiful young wife. A husband obsessed with watching her with another man. A sexy new boss who desperately wants to lead her astray…
An island honeymoon. A blushing bride flirting with the sexy beach server. A h
usband who realizes he likes watching his wife with another man…
It’s a wild night as three couples become one at a crazy house party that spirals out of control!
A weekend away at a convention becomes so much more when his wife dons a sexy costume that makes her irresistible, and her husband finds he loves it!
Lisa strayed in college. Matt is obsessed with the idea of her straying. When their secrets are revealed it will change their marriage and sex lives forever!
A blushing bride-to-be. An indecent proposal from a “modeling agent” who has a lot more than casting on his mind. A naughty wedding night with another man!
Brandi is a good girl. The waiting for marriage type. Then she met Anthony, a chocolate god and her fiance's new roommate. Is she still the waiting for marriage type?
He doesn’t know who to believe as his girlfriend steps out and her sexy roommate swears she’s cheating! Who’s telling the truth?
An innocent wife never thought she’d stray until she met a sexy basketball player in one of her lab courses!
Jealousy over his wife’s old boyfriend becomes an obsession with seeing his wife get with her old flame as her ten year reunion approaches!
Dave wants to watch Laura with another man. Kristi, Laura's best friend, might be able to help. And the three of them might discover something incredible by the end of their vacation!
Check out a novel from my lesbian romance pen name! Night Terror is the greatest villainess in the world, and she has to find a way to defeat sexy new superhero Fialux. Oh, and she’s totally in love with her new archenemy. What could go wrong?