by AC Oswald
Table of Contents
Chapter 1
Chapter 2
Chapter 3
Chapter 4
Chapter 5
Chapter 6
Chapter 7
Chapter 8
Chapter 9
Chapter 10
Chapter 11
Chapter 12
Chapter 13
Chapter 14
About AC Oswald
Other Books from Ylva Publishing
Coming from Ylva Publishing
Sign up for our newsletter to hear
about new and upcoming releases.
www.ylva-publishing.com
Chapter 1
Savannah turned the key in the lock to her front door. Her hand shook. She straightened her jacket and carefully stepped inside, trying not to make any noise.
She tiptoed to the kitchen and switched on the light.
“Who is she?”
“Jesus, Bethany, you scared the shit out of me!”
Bethany leaned against the kitchen counter, her eyes red rimmed and puffy. She looked as tired as fuck.
Savannah knew that her next words would seal the fate of their relationship. Truth or lie? Either way, Bethany was going to get hurt.
“Seriously, Savy. Tell me her name. I want to know.” Bethany sounded so powerless, as if she had already given up the fight.
A fist in her jacket pocket just barely kept her hand from shaking. She swallowed back a lump in her throat. “Lory,” she said. “Her name’s Lory. Loredana, actually. She’s Italian.”
Hurt simmered in Bethany’s eyes. She looked like she’d been punched in the stomach.
“Isn’t that what you expected to hear?” Savannah asked.
For a while, no one said anything, and the silence became suffocating.
“Do you want me to leave?” Savannah tried to keep her gaze steady. She had just thrown away five years, five long, happy years together.
Bethany picked up her shoes and put on her jacket over her old Mickey Mouse sweatshirt and pajama pants.
“Where are you going, Beth?” Savannah’s gaze followed Beth’s every movement.
“I’ll go to my mom’s place for now, I guess,” Bethany whispered. She removed the hair tie from her ponytail, and the strands cascaded onto her face.
Savannah knew this was so she wouldn’t see her tears. She saw them anyway.
“I’m sorry, Beth. I really am.” She sighed. “You deserve better.”
Bethany’s head snapped up. “I deserve better?” She let out a sarcastic laugh. “Just tell me why. I want a reason, okay? Then I’m out.”
What to tell her? There was no way she could give her the real reason. She had made her decision, and there was no turning back.
“It’s not you, it’s me.” Wow. What a cliché.
Bethany shook her head. “You can’t even give me a real reason. Don’t you think I deserve that much?”
She did deserve that much. She deserved all the good things in the world. Bethany was the most kind-hearted, funny, beautiful, loving person Savannah had ever met. Which was why all this was for the best.
“You’re right,” Savannah said. “It’s just that I realized…” Her throat closed over. “I realized I moved on, okay? This is not what I want. I don’t want to spend the rest of my life with you in this apartment.” It was hard to keep her voice even. “I don’t want to have kids. I need space.” She felt evil speaking those words when she saw the effect they had on the one person who meant the world to her.
“Space to spend time with your Italian chick?” Bethany mopped her tears with her sleeve. “I’m sorry my pizza sucked.”
Savannah couldn’t bear it any longer. She leaned against the fridge, her eyes shut. “Maybe it’s best if you leave now.”
She tried to focus on her breathing. This would soon be over. She’d let Bethany leave, and then she’d move on; she’d somehow make it. She’d somehow manage alone. It was for the best—at least the best for Bethany—and Savannah needed to remember that.
The door clicked closed. First the kitchen door, then the front door. Then the apartment fell silent.
In the silence, she finally could let loose. Tears streamed down her face, and she sank to the floor, punching the linoleum next to her.
This was what she had wanted, what she had planned. It was the only way to get out of their relationship. It had to be this way.
“Stay strong,” she told herself and fumbled through her bag. She pulled out a small bottle of pills and poured two into her palm.
“Fuck this shit,” she said aloud and swallowed the pills, blinking away tears that refused to stop. “Fuck this shit.”
A year later and Bethany still asked herself what she had done wrong.
Sometimes it didn’t feel like a year. Sometimes it felt as if they had kissed only yesterday.
They had not spoken since that night Savannah broke up with her. Bethany had picked up her stuff while Savannah was at work. She left her key on the kitchen table. She had wanted to leave a note but hadn’t known what to say:
Please change your mind.
Whatever I did, I’m sorry.
You’re mean, Savannah. Mean. Here’s your stupid key.
I hope you’ll be happy with her.
I could have learned how to make better pizza. You should have told me.
Call me, please.
In the end, she had ripped up the would-be note and stuffed it into her jeans pocket. What was there to say on such a small piece of paper? What could she say after such a long relationship?
Bethany knew she wasn’t the smartest person in the world, but she was an expert on Savannah Cortez. She knew how to analyze Savy’s emotions, her actions, her words. But for a while before their breakup, Savannah had become distant and cool, and Bethany had become confused.
Leaving early and coming home late had become routine with Savannah. She never said where she was going, and she seemed to have lost all of her happiness. Bethany had known something was wrong, but whenever she tried to talk it out, Savannah closed up.
What had made Savannah do it? Why cheat with someone else?
Even after all this time, not knowing the answers drove Bethany nuts. And now, even with a new girlfriend in her life, she couldn’t stop thinking about Savannah.
She was happy with Amber, her new girl. Amber was nice, pretty, friendly. A sweetheart, really. But all these images, all these questions, all these unresolved feelings—they still hadn’t left her head.
She and Amber didn’t live together, and Bethany didn’t think she wanted to take that step anytime soon. Trusting someone new wasn’t easy, even though Bethany tended to see only the good in people. But then, where had trust gotten her? She’d had her heart broken. Badly. And as much as she tried to deny it, the break with Savannah had taken away her happiness. The world had felt gray. With one conversation, all her plans for the future had been erased.
Then, two months ago in July, Amber became a new client at the salon Bethany had started working at. They’d started chatting about miserable dates during one appointment, and Bethany had almost dropped her scissors when Amber started talking about dating a woman with a fetish for fake moustaches. They both started laughing uncontrollably. It had been a long time since Bethany had felt so lighthearted. One week later, she and Amber met for dinner, which led to sex, which led to more dates. It had been easy, especially since Amber and Savannah couldn’t have been more different.
Bethany tried to ignore how much she
missed snuggling with Savannah on the couch. Or linking pinkies when they went shopping for groceries. Or being pulled into a protective hug whenever they watched a silly horror movie.
She and Amber hadn’t even had a real fight yet. Sure, there had been small disagreements, but at some point, Amber would smile and tell her they should just forget about it and that it would be okay. With Savannah, there had been countless fights. Was it ridiculous to miss fighting, to miss the look Savannah would give her when she had done something wrong? She missed the way Savannah would carefully approach her from behind and position a shy kiss on her cheek as an apology.
Was it ridiculous to still think about the many times they had danced in the kitchen together, waiting for their pasta to cook? To smile when she thought about how dorky they must have looked, hopping around? Savannah would push her against the kitchen counter and kiss her until she felt dizzy. Those kisses were why they ate burnt pasta most nights.
Amber never burned the pasta. She worked in catering and knew how to prepare a perfect dinner. Their relationship was nice, nothing anyone could complain about.
Was Savannah still dating this Lory chick? At first, she had wanted to track down all the Loredanas in the city to see what the “other woman” was like but then had decided against it.
“You okay?” The question finally woke Bethany from her little trance.
“Sure.” She attempted a smile. “Why wouldn’t I be?”
Amber gave her a weird look and pointed at the cone in Bethany’s hand and the chocolate ice cream that was running down her fingers.
“Oh.”
She handed Bethany a napkin and helped her clean up the mess.
“You’re such a child sometimes.” She dabbed at a smear of ice cream on the tip of Bethany’s nose.
Bethany smiled, wiped her nose, and took Amber’s hand in hers. They continued their walk through the park. It was one of the last warm September days, and the leaves had started changing their color. It was a pretty afternoon with her pretty girlfriend. Bethany figured she should be happy.
The salon wasn’t exactly the hippest place in town, but Bethany loved seeing a lot of friendly faces there every day. The clientele were mostly housewives, some elderly ladies, and children.
Mrs. McClary’s hair was resting in the curling iron when the door jangled open and she heard the receptionist say, “Miss Cortez, it’s been a while. What can we do for you?”
Bethany froze. In the mirror, she saw Savannah talking to Anna at the reception desk.
“Ouch,” Mrs. McClary complained. Bethany had grazed her ear with the hot iron.
“Oh God, I’m so sorry,” she mumbled. Her hands were shaking. She risked another look into the mirror and made eye contact with Savannah, who looked equally as shocked.
Savannah’s gaze darted away and then fell back on Bethany again in less than a moment, as if she were trying to decide whether or not to turn and run.
“Miss Cortez?”
Savannah visibly startled. “Uh,” she stuttered, “you know what? Um, I’ll come back some other time. I…I’m sorry.”
She turned on her heel, gave Anna an apologetic look, and headed for the exit.
“Excuse me for a minute.” Bethany dropped the curling iron and ran after Savannah. There was no time to think about her actions. Pure instinct made her follow before it was too late. She didn’t know what she wanted to say, but she needed to look at her for a few seconds more. She needed to see an up close reaction to their meeting. She needed…anything but to see her turn her back and go.
“Savannah! Wait, please!”
The glass door closed behind her, and they stood in the street, staring at each other.
Savannah broke their gaze first. She looked down at the asphalt.
“Savy, it’s…it’s been a while.” Bethany tried to smile.
“Yeah,” Savannah replied. “How are you doing, Beth?”
This was beyond weird.
Bethany wasn’t sure what she was feeling, if it was excitement or sadness coursing through her body. She was surprised to feel no anger. Somehow the anger had vanished in the past year. Now all she saw was a person she used to love. She needed to be around her for a little while longer.
“I’m fine. Good. Great, actually,” Bethany babbled, laughing excitedly. “I have a job here. It’s nice.”
“I can see that,” Savannah said. “Much better than that cheap salon at the mall, eh?”
Bethany nodded. She had to resist the urge to reach for Savannah’s hand.
“You look great.” Savannah’s face had gone more serious, and Bethany knew she meant it.
“Thanks. You look…” Her gaze travelled up and down Savannah’s body, and she couldn’t help but frown.
“Hot?” Savannah asked, but Beth only frowned.
“I was going to say ‘thin,’ but…” Savannah had lost a lot of weight since she’d last seen her.
“Rice diet.” Savannah shrugged and pressed her bag close to her belly.
“How are things with…”
“Lory?” Savannah asked in a tone that Bethany couldn’t interpret.
“Yeah, Lory. So, how’s things with you?”
“Everything’s great. I mean… I don’t know. I guess it’s still awkward to talk about it, don’t you think?” Savannah mumbled. Her gaze didn’t meet Bethany’s.
“No, it’s fine. I mean, I’m glad to hear you’re happy. And I’m happy too. I found someone new, and she’s fun to be around, and…yeah. I have nothing to complain about.”
The smile was still frozen on Savannah’s lips, but her gaze softened. “I’m really glad to hear that, Beth,” she said through halting breaths. She sounded sincere. “You deserve to be happy.”
She reached out to cover Bethany’s hand with her own and squeezed it tightly. For a second, Bethany thought she could see a tear in Savannah’s eyes. Then Savannah’s hand was gone from hers.
“I’m on my way to see Lory right now.” Savannah fiddled with her long, dark curls. “But it was nice seeing you again.”
Bethany’s heart pounded faster as something like panic washed over her. She didn’t want to say good-bye to Savannah again without knowing if she’d ever see her again. It was silly to ask her to stay, to ask for her number. She didn’t even know what she wanted from her—friendship? All she knew was that she didn’t want Savannah to go.
“Can we hang out sometime?” She hated the desperate tone in her voice. “Maybe for a coffee? Or a hot chocolate?”
Why did she have to look so tortured? Savannah bit her lower lip and sighed. “I don’t know, Beth. I—”
“Only to talk about good old times, Savy. I know you’re in a relationship. I am too. I don’t want anything from you, okay? Just… I want to hear what you’ve been up to.” Bethany toyed with the zipper of her shirt. “I missed you. I mean… I miss being your friend. We’ve always been best friends,” she added in a whisper.
“Okay.” Savannah kicked at a nonexistent rock on the sidewalk. “I guess a coffee seems fine.”
A loud sigh coursed through Bethany. “My cell’s still the same.” She smiled. “If you still have the number.”
“I know it by heart,” Savannah admitted with a shy smile. “I mean, it’s an easy number. Many threes, not so hard.”
Bethany smiled and brushed her hand along Savannah’s arm. “I’ll be waiting for your call,” she said softly before she turned and ran back to poor Mrs. McClary.
When she went back inside, she glanced into the mirror. She was red, red as a tomato. Her head felt as if it were on fire, yet somehow she felt happy. And yet somehow she also had to fight back the tears. Even after all this time, Savannah hadn’t changed. She was still so damn confusing.
Savannah finally arrived at her destinat
ion. She had tried to remain calm, had tried not to let the unexpected encounter with Bethany drive her nuts. She had managed to avoid Bethany for such a long time and thought she was almost over her. After so long apart, she had hoped she could finally be strong without her. How could seeing her still hurt so much after all this time?
Why, oh why did Beth have to start working in that stupid salon? She certainly hadn’t been there the last time Savannah had dropped in.
It would be stupid to call her. It would be insane. What would they even talk about? There was nothing Savannah could say to her.
Her legs quivered as she walked up the few steps to the huge front door of the multistory brownstone and rang the bell next to the correct name tag: Dr. Loredana Valentini—Oncologist.
Chapter 2
Anna approached Bethany as soon as Mrs. McClary had left the salon. “What was that about earlier?”
“What do you mean?” Bethany asked, although she already had a pretty good idea what her colleague was referring to.
“You running after Miss Cortez.”
“I didn’t know that you knew her,” Bethany said slowly.
“She’s been here a few times. How do you know her?”
Bethany swallowed. “She’s my ex. We’ve dated for five years.”
“Oh.” Anna grimaced. “I didn’t know.” She gave Bethany a compassionate look. “I’m really sorry. You must be… You must feel terrible.”
“It’s okay.” Bethany shrugged.
Anna’s whole frame stiffened. “I know it’s often hard in relationships to deal with…well…such things,” she mumbled. “Uh…how is she doing? Miss Cortez, I mean.”
Bethany raised an eyebrow. She didn’t understand why their breakup seemed to be such a big deal to her coworker. She frowned.
“Um. I don’t know… She seems okay. She’s in a relationship with someone else.”
“Oh, I see.” Anna ran a hand through her hair. She seemed worried she was on dangerous ground. “Well…if you see her, tell her she can come in anytime, and send her my best wishes.”