by Madison Faye
His eyes looked at me wolfishly then, and I could feel his cock actually throb deep inside of me. “You are just full of damn surprises, you know,” He smirked at me and I blushed. His cock throbbed inside of me again, and I bit my lip again, our eyes saying everything as I turned back.
“Anna, come out; please?"
Slowly, the closet door opened, and she stepped out.
My friend’s face was bright red, and her eyes wider than I'd ever seen. She was clutching her discarded dress to herself as her eyes darted from my eyes to to Tyler’s and then back to me, looking almost teary-eyed; “Oh my God, Chris! I’m- I’m- ohmygod I’m so embarass-”
“Anna.”
Tyler’s deep voice was both commanding and soothing at the same time, and just as my friend was about to start crying, she stopped and gasped at the sound of it.
“It’s okay, we’re not mad.” His hand trailed up and down my side, teasing my skin and making my nipples stand out rock hard on my chest under the sheet. I felt so fucking naughty just siting there on his cock while Anna stood right in front of us with only a sheet covering us.
“Aurally,” I took a deep breath and met her eyes - my best friend in the whole world - with mine. “Actually I want you to stay,” I swallowed heavily, my heart racing. “I want you to watch us,” I said quietly.
Anna’s eyes went wide, her mouth opening in shock. “Chris?” She looked at me pleadingly, almost like she was looking for a reason not to break down.
I felt my cheeks burn bright red and my pulse skip a beat as I locked eyes with my best friend. “I- I really do,” I breathed it out, feeling my whole body clench up in excitement as I did; “If you- I mean, if you want to.”
I watched her eyes get even wider as a blush crept into her face. “Are you sure? Christina, you’re my best friend, I’d never want to-”
“I’m sure.” And I’d never been more sure of anything in my life.
She swallowed heavily and looked at Tyler. “Mr Wea-” she blushed and shook her head. “I mean, Tyler? You’re okay with, um, me being here?”
He chuckled, and I made a small noise as I felt the reverberations rumble through me through his cock still balls deep in my pussy. “Like I said, the cat’s already out of the bag, isn’t it?”
Slowly, I watched a sly grin creep across her face and a twinkle shine in her eye. Now there was the mischievous, daring Anna I knew and loved.
“She wants you to be a part of this, Anna,” he said, his voice dark and so damn sexy.
Anna took a deep breath and nodded, as if transfixed by his voice - something I could definitely sympathize with. She bit her lip and slowly took a few steps towards the edge of her bed and sat down on it, facing us.
We had our audience.
“Okay,” she said quietly, her face red. “I’m ready.”
Tyler chuckled behind me and I drew a long, shaky breath as I turned to look at him. “Is this crazy?” I asked, raising my brow at him.
He grinned and kissed me. “No crazier than anything else you and I have managed to get ourselves into.”
I nodded, and before I could do any more debating, he smirked at me and let the sheet covering us fall to the side.
I turned back at Anna’s gasp, seeing her eyes wide as saucers as she stared at us, now totally and completely bare for her. Her eyes dropped immediately down and her jaw dropped as she stared right towards were Tyler and I met; to my tight little pussy stretched around his big, thick cock.
We all sat there frozen for a minute, everyone’s heart beating a million miles an hour and unsure of what to say, until Tyler decided to take matters into his own hands. He held me tight, his firm hands cupping my ass, and slowly, he began to slide me wetly up his cock.
It was my moan that broke the silence; my soft, mewling moan as I felt him slide me up his thick girth.
Anna gasped again and brought a hand to her mouth in shock as more and more of my older lover’s huge dick slid out of my tight slit, glistening in the dim light and making her jaw drop.
“Oh my God,” She whispered almost to her self, biting her lip and staring bug-eyed at Tyler’s thick cock.
Slowly, he pulled me back down, and I groaned softly as I felt him push into me, filling me up to the brim as she watched us. We began to move again then, as the nervousness dripped away and the incredible feeling of being one with each other took over. I started to rock up and down on him, losing myself in the utter decadence of fucking him while my best friend watched.
Anna’s hand slipped under the dress draped across her, and she blushed as my eyes caught her’s. My brow furrowed and a sensual moan escaped my lips, making her breath catch as we locked eyes. She smirked at me, and then gently, lifted her dress and dropped it to the side.
Okay, at this point, I’d seen my friend naked before, and even with what had happened the other day when we’d come together, it’s not like I was suddenly switching teams here. But as she let her cover drop and bared her body to us, I gasped at how beautiful she was. Her soft white skin glowed, and her breasts were full and round, her nipples so softly pink and puffy that I couldn’t tear my eyes away from them. My eyes followed the curve of her ribcage down to her hips, and I moaned as I watched her hand slide back into her white cotton panties.
For a moment, I nervously looked back at Tyler, suddenly wondering if this had been a bad idea as every secret, buried insecurity I’d ever harbored came bubbling to the surface.
His eyes locked onto mine though, and he kissed my fiercely before pulling back. “I’m only looking at you, gorgeous; don’t forget that,” he whispered as he leaned forward and kissed me again.
Yeah, how did I get this guy again?
Tyler dropped back then onto his back, and I cooed and leaned forward towards his legs to ride him again. His hand’s guided my pert little ass as I rocked up and down on him, bouncing my hips as my tight little pussy milked every inch of his huge shaft.
Anna made a soft sound as her hand moved in slow circles beneath her panties, before she stopped as her cheeks burned bright red. With a deep breath, she grabbed them and skimmed them down her legs, kicking them off and openly spreading her legs in front of me.
Oh my God.
My friend was beautiful. Like, jaw-droppingly, adorably, beautiful. Her skin was like porcelain, her chest flushed pink like her nipples. I bit my lip and moaned as my eyes fell to her hand between her legs. I didn’t know she’d shaved the soft red hair she had there that matched her head into a small little strip above her pussy, and I groaned at how fucking sexy it was. I could see how wet she was as she moved her fingers around her clit, her legs spreading wide as she leaned back on her bed, her eyes locked on where Tyler and I joined.
The eroticism of the whole moment washed over me then, and I began to moan louder as Tyler rocked up into me, stuffing me full with every thrust. I watched, breathless, as Anna slid her fingers down into her folds, her moans joining mine as they sank into her pussy.
The three of us, though separated by a few feet of carpet, began to move almost as one then. Tyler’s strong hands on my ass lifted me up and down every inch of him, my clit dragging up and down his shaft with every thrust as he buried himself deep inside of my tight young pussy. And Anna was right there with us, her fingertip circling the hard little bud at the top of her glistening wet pink slit as her mouth hung open, watching us.
I was getting close already, probably pushed there even faster by the voyeuristic thrill of being watched, and I started to push back onto Tyler’s cock faster and faster as my cries and moans got louder and breathier. I could tell he was getting there too as his deep groans began to match mine and his cock began to swell inside of me.
“Oh, Mr. Weaver, fuck me with that big cock of yours! Pump my little pussy with that thick dick!”
Anna and Tyler both groaned at my little innocent voice, and I started to bounce up and down on him faster and faster as I squealed and moaned.
“God you feel so good stretchi
ng me like that, mister. Your big fat cock feels so good inside of me like that!”
Anna moaned, seeing this side of me for the first time as her fingers blurred over her wet, glistening slit. I could hear Tyler groan behind me as I bounced on him, milking every inch of his shaft.
He sat up then, rocking deep inside of me as one hand went to my nipples and the other down to my clit, which he began to rub in circles as he ground up deep inside of me. Anna moaned loudly, her fingers blurring across her slit as she locked her eyes on us moving as one, and Tyler’s fingers began to match hers evenly on my own clit.
He began to hungrily suck and kiss at my neck, sending shivers right down my spine. And as my eyes suddenly drew up to lock with Anna’s, and I knew I was about to come right in front of her.
Tyler’s fingers strummed my aching clit once more, just as his other hand rolled one of my nipples and his mouth sucked hard at my collarbone.
“I’m gonna come, baby,” he growled into my ear, making both me and Anna moan out loud.
“And I’m gonna pump you full of my thick, hot cum.” I teetered on the edge, feeling myself start to fall.
“Come for me, honey. Come for my big dick.”
Yeah, that did it, for all of us.
With a loud cry, I shuddered as I came, clenching tight around his big cock and moaning as my orgasm tore through me. There was a small cry across from us, and I looked up in time to see Anna gasping and crying out as her own climax pushed her over the edge. And right then, Tyler’s cock swelled up even bigger inside my pussy. With a roar, I felt him throb and twitch deep inside of me as the first thick squirt of his cum splashed up into me. Anna’s eyes went wide as she realized what was happening - that Mr. Weaver was shooting his cum deep inside of me.
Squirt after squirt of hit hot, thick cum erupted into my fertile young body, filling me to the absolute brim as he gasped and slowly kept pumping me. Slowly, gasping then, we all slowed to a stop until we were still in the semi-dark of the room, breathing heavily and trying to catch our breaths.
Okay, wow. Holy fucking SHIT wow.
Anna giggled softly as she curled her legs up under her in the bed. “Okay, you guys are fuckin’ hot.”
I grinned at my friend, feeling bashful again, but also still incredibly turned on by the fact that she’d just watched us make love and come like that.
She stood, grinning at us and shaking her head as she reached for the bathrobe hanging off the end of her bed. “Chris, I love you, and you better not get all weird on me just cause of this.” She winked at me; “And Mr. W- uh, sorry, Tyler?” She bit her lip and grinned shyly at him. Only this time, there wasn’t a single bit of jealousy in me at the look. “You are- wow; just, wow.” She bit her lip and shook her head again, grinning impishly at us as Tyler chuckled and wrapped his arms around me as he pulled me into his chest.
“So- I’m gonna go, and give you two some space.” Anna paused as she walked to the door and turned back. “Thank you,” she whispered at me, her cheeks glowing. “Really, thanks. I’ll see you tomorrow.”
Yep, that was the Anna I knew and loved.
Chapter 16
Christina
Later on, I did end up going back to the hotel room with Tyler that he’d booked for the night. I mean hey, it certainly beat cramming into a single-sized dorm room bed. We collapsed into the bed together - both of us clearly still glowing about the night as I snuggled back into his arms. I forced myself to just enjoy the moment, and not think that tomorrow morning he’d be leaving again and this whole fantasy would end.
“It’s not for forever, you know,” he murmured into my neck, as if reading my thoughts. His arms held me tighter, and we fell asleep as I pushed tomorrow from my mind.
*****
“I’ve got a surprise for you.”
We were standing on the platform at South Station again, with arms around each other and looking to all the world like a couple saying a sad goodbye. I looked up at him, still doing me best not to cry like a dope in our last moments together. I mean I knew it wasn’t like this was the last time we’d ever see each other, but I also knew he wouldn’t be here the next day, or later that night when I knew I’d want him in my bed again. And besides that, when we did see each other again, it might be at home, with family and people who knew us around.
“So, uh, I’ve got some more business in a few weeks back up here in Boston.”
My mouth split into a huge grin as I looked up at him. Tyler definitely didn’t have any business here, it’d just been his pretense to come see me.
“Oh, business, hmm?” I grinned at him.
He winked. “I’ll figure something out.”
I melted into his arms just the same as he kissed me, never wanting to let him go.
*****
A few days after Tyler left to go back home, I got my first hint of something being different, but I told myself it was nothing; these things happened all the time, right? And even a few days after that, I still told myself it was nothing to dwell on and nothing to worry about; it would come soon, definitely.
But a week after I was due for my period without one, I knew something was up.
The test was easy enough, once I’d cabbed to the other side of the city to buy one and then secreted it back to my dorm room. The hard part though, was going to be opening my eyes and looking at it now, and seeing what was going to come next.
Slowly, I cracked my eyes open and stared at the little stick in my hand. I could feel my heart start to beat faster, and a flush come into my cheeks as I gasped.
Ok, now things where going to get really interesting.
Chapter 17
Christina
Just like that, with one little stick with a pink dot on it in my hand, my life suddenly got very, very complicated.
I remember spending the rest of that first day of knowing just in shock. I skipped classes, which was unheard of for me, and spent most of the day huddled in bed trying to lose myself in mindless Friends reruns.
The real scary thing was how alone I felt. I knew Tyler cared about me, but I wasn’t sure how he’d react if I just called him up with “surprise, I think I’m pregnant.” Besides, it wasn’t that long ago that he’d gotten out of a big commitment - namely marriage. Did Tyler Weaver even want kids?
Jesus Christ, what was I saying? Did I?
Te only other person who knew about us was Anna, which was, well, complicated. It wasn't like I'd been ignoring her since Tyler’s visit, when she'd openly watched us make love, it was really more that I was worried that things had gotten a little out of control that night. I'd been so caught up in the eroticism of realizing we were being watched, and I guess part of me was more of an exhibitionist than I'd ever really thought about.
Fucking Tyler and riding his cock while my roommate and best friend played with herself as she watched us had been insanely hot, but I was worried that we'd crossed a line. Anna was my best friend after all, and while it wasn't like we'd had some kind of a threesome or anything, it'd been a really intimate thing that I'd shared with her. She was a total free spirit, I got that, but I was still worried that what had happened was going to change us somehow.
Ok, so, maybe I had been avoiding her; just a little bit I guess.
She cornered me a few days later coming out the side entrance of the library, with frozen coffee concoctions in her hands.
“Christina”
I whirled towards my friend, faltering awkwardly for words; "Oh, uh, hey, I was just about to call y-“