by Mia Alvar
I had been taught that senses were the doorway to skills. In the kitchen I held against Aroush’s tongue a pretzel-shaped teether that had spent the night in the refrigerator. She shivered. “Good girl!” I hugged and kissed her. An older, less impaired child I could have rewarded with raisins or candy; Aroush, who had never eaten solid food, I could only praise and love. I exchanged a cold teether for one that had steeped in a pan of warm water since morning. A furrow appeared between Aroush’s brows at the change in temperature, and I practically attacked her with cuddling.
By the time her mother arrived, Aroush was in her chair, and I was holding the flashlight two feet from her eyes. “Where is the light, Aroush?” I said, moving the flashlight slowly from side to side. “Do you see it? Aroush, follow the light with your eyes.” Again it was I who felt in the spotlight, with Mrs. Mansour there.
She applauded. “Now a flashlight; in time, a telescope. Isn’t that right, Teacher?”
“We have lots of work to do,” I said carefully, “before we start thinking about telescopes.”
Mrs. Mansour gave no indication that she heard me or understood. Lifting Aroush from her chair, she saw a plush rattle on the coffee table. “Toys, Teacher?” she said, with some concern. “Will my girl learn from baby toys?”
I picked up the rattle and shook it. “Auditory stimulation will develop her receptiveness to sound,” I said, “which is precedent to the acquisition of language.” In my earliest days of teaching I would sometimes hide behind jargon this way, learning quickly that a crowd of syllables could soothe the most anxious parent. It seemed to work on Mrs. Mansour, who smiled again and handed me a velvet pouch.
“Teacher, do you believe in miracles?” she asked.
Inside the pouch I found a choker: pearls as large and heavy as marbles, with a bluish silver tone to them. “In Libya they have built a river where there was no water. A pearl is only sand before it turns to precious stone. Then there is the flood, the burning bush, the tree in our desert that has lived four hundred years on nothing.” She took the choker from my hands and reached over to secure the clasp at the nape of my neck. “They say only children can believe such stories. Me? I believe. Like a child, I believe.” Her fingertips were cool, and some of their coolness seemed to linger in the pearls at my throat after she had gone.
—
Minnie came to visit me on her next day off, arriving as I lay Aroush prone on her rubber mat.
“Make yourself at home,” I said. “I’m just giving her some exercise before a nap.” I bent and straightened Aroush’s knees, then cycled them in the air. Her feet, unlike the rest of her, were normal, even perfect: smooth and plump as any little child’s, free of tumors or thumbprints. Her tiny toenails were painted a shade of pink darker than her dress.
Standing at a distance from us, Minnie swiped one of the shelves in my living room with her fingertip, reflexively checking for dust. Again she reminded me, in spite of her own childlessness, of my mother. “I don’t know how you do it,” she said, looking over at me while I massaged the backs of Aroush’s tumored palms, trying to coax her fingers to open and stretch. “My job’s no walk in the park, mind you. But at least when I polish the glass, it shines.”
I extended Aroush’s arms and turned her head from side to side. Minnie disappeared into the kitchen, and I could hear her opening the refrigerator and cupboards. “Please don’t bother, Minnie,” I called. “Relax and put your feet up.” It was her habit during daytime visits to prepare a dinner I could just reheat when Ed came home.
By the time I had put Aroush to sleep Minnie was wiping down my kitchen counters. “Pot’s in the fridge,” she said. “Afritada. Just put it on the stove when Ed’s ready to eat.”
“You didn’t have to do that.”
“Is she asleep?”
I nodded. We went into the den to watch television and ate the last of the sugar apples before they could rot. On screen, women with mink coats and feathered hair said evil things to one another.
“We’re going on strike,” Minnie announced.
“We?”
Some Filipinos had banded together, she explained, wanting the Ministry of Foreign Labor to raise both the minimum wage and the age ceiling for new incoming workers. “They’re even calling themselves a union,” she said, though the group was loose and informal and, like its members, had little real status in the world it hoped to change.
I thought of how she’d walked into my house and checked the curio shelves for dust. “Minnie, you just spent your day off cooking my husband’s dinner,” I said. “I can’t imagine you on strike.”
“You mean you can’t imagine me chanting or holding up a picket sign,” she said. “But not everybody does that.” The union had floated other, subtler strategies. Withholding smiles, for one. It had worked for a group of cashiers in Italy, omitting a personal gesture that appeared nowhere in their job descriptions but nonetheless brought management to its knees. “It’s time they felt it,” Minnie said—softly, like a timid child learning to speak. “How their lives would be without us. How this piece of sand would sink into the Arabian Gulf!” The rallies I attended in my youth had sounded a lot like that.
Aroush began to cry. I stood up, setting aside my glass and bowl. “I’ll just go see if I can get her back to sleep,” I said apologetically. “Be right back.”
In the living room, Aroush had soiled her diaper. I gathered her embroidered dress gingerly at her waist while changing her. A drop of soupy infant excrement leaked onto the carpet on my way to the trash. By the time I had washed my hands and scrubbed the stain, Minnie was at the doorway with her bag, putting on her shoes. “I just remembered something I promised to do for the church,” she said, which sounded like a lie. On most visits she lingered at my house as long as she could, sometimes through dinner. More than likely, I guessed, she hadn’t counted on hearing and smelling Aroush on her day off.
“I’m sorry I wasn’t a better hostess,” I said. It dawned on me that I would have driven Minnie home before, back when I wasn’t working for her boss myself.
“You’re busy,” Minnie said. “It’s all right. It’s a good woman who works when she doesn’t even have to.”
—
I was mesmerized by Minnie’s story of the Italian cashiers, their intimate but fierce rebellion. The quietest, most docile worker could, behind her apron or her uniform, be sharpening a blade. I began to imagine all the soft, subtle weapons a worker might employ. Avoiding all eye contact, perhaps, even while saying yes to an order; completing one’s duties very slowly, as if moving underwater. I paid closer attention: to the man wrapping my fish in brown paper at the Central Market; to the waiter who took my order and Ed’s at a restaurant near the Diplomat Hotel. It bothered me to think our life was built upon their backs, that even Ed’s crew at the pipeline must have wished for his downfall at some point or another. My instinct, my muscle memory, stood with and for the little guy, still. If the Minnies of the world felt wronged, I was on their side; I’d never owned a skin cream made of caviar in my life.
In college, with my fellow campus troublemakers, I lived by the gospel of solidarity. When the university’s expansion threatened to tear down the shacks and displace the residents of a slum outside the campus walls, we slept under tin scraps outside the chancellor’s office in protest. When yet another city newspaper was taken over by the government, its writers sacked and replaced by puppets, we tied black gags around our mouths. When former Senator Aquino was gunned down at the Manila airport, we wore shirts spattered with red paint and carried signs that said, WE ARE ALL NINOY. Now, with Minnie’s friends plotting revolt, however silent, I caught the fever again. After all, I’d thought of her when I took the job under false pretenses; I’d given Mrs. Mansour undue hope with Minnie’s grievances in mind. To act out on the job itself was just the natural next step. How far could I go, for the workers’ sake?
I stopped preparing lessons while Aroush napped or consulting my old textbooks. I
began to spend that time dusting the shelves, or chopping the vegetables for dinner, or catching up on other housework. When I ran out of chores I watched TV or read my paperbacks, legs stretched along the sofa. I left toys on the floor after Aroush and I had handled them, stopped structuring our afternoons. When housework, books, and even TV bored me, I napped beside her.
My lies grew. At the end of each day, when Mrs. Mansour came, I overstated Aroush’s every twitch and reflex, claiming successes that were unlikely. Mrs. Mansour rewarded these tales more handsomely every day. It was her custom to travel to London on weekends to shop for beautiful things; these trips now yielded loot for me and Ed as well. Her gifts fell into the category Mrs. Mansour called desireful: boxes of dark chocolate truffles; silk scarves; perfumes with such luxuriant names as Joy, Obsession, Poison; eye shadow kits with brushes the size of matchsticks. She herself had no use for the perfume, she said; she had been blending her own for years, a formula handed down from her mother and grandmother. She would hand it down to Aroush as well, when the time came.
I passed these gifts along to Minnie. (I wanted her to use them, to dress up for karaoke night at the Gulf Hotel, or even go on a date with Mrs. Mansour’s Filipino chauffeur. But she too passed them on, to her sisters and nieces in Manila, or to raffles that the church held for charity.) These fancy things, I told myself, were like the riches Robin Hood would redirect to those who worked harder or had less than he. I didn’t deserve them, but someone did.
Aloud, Ed mocked the gifts that Mrs. Mansour left for him. “Just what I always needed,” he said, smirking at a diamond-encrusted tie clip; or “Time and money sold separately,” in response to a box of golf tees made of eighteen-karat gold. But later, through a halfway-open bathroom door, I would see him model the watch or the shirt studs, changing the angle of his arm and chest in the mirror. One morning, when he thought I was asleep, he quietly transferred the contents of his cracked vinyl wallet to a monogrammed money clip, and his keys to a brushed-platinum key ring, both from Mrs. Mansour.
—
One day Aroush made a small, unprecedented sound, distinct from her usual grunts and moans. I was watering an ivy plant near the living room window and polishing its leaves with a soft cloth.
“Haa,” it sounded like, but gentler than a laugh. A sigh.
“Aroush?” I said. I knelt beside her and looked into her eyes. Perhaps I had misheard the sound of one leaf brushing against another, or the spray of the bottle in my hand, or my own breath, as a whisper out of her.
The furrow in her brow smoothed over when I bent down. Her eyes thinned to crescents, with delicate folds around them. I could see each of her widely spaced teeth.
A smile. It went away, but I had seen it.
I felt as shocked as if she’d spoken a full sentence or stood and walked around the room. It was the closest thing to a miracle I had ever witnessed, and I’d done nothing to cause or earn it. Quickly I placed a chair on either side of her head, tying a length of string between them. With more string I hung a rattle, a soft block, and a squeaky toy from the line. I took her wrist and batted the block with her hand. Its inner chimes jingled as it swung and then slowed to a stop.
“Haa,” Aroush sighed again, looking—it seemed, for a moment—directly at the block, and smiling again.
I lay down beside her and looked up. I shook the string and took in the swinging toys, their jangling sounds, all the colors and textures, at her level. “Good girl,” I said. I kissed the soft, downy zone where her temple became her hairline.
The breakthrough energized me. When I fed Aroush her formula and puréed pears, I became determined to teach her to suck. Instead of placing spoonfuls near her throat, as Mrs. Mansour did for easy swallowing, I left them on the middle of her tongue or on the corners of her mouth. Aroush furrowed her brow, made a gagging noise. I dipped a pacifier into the mush and held it to her lower lip. Her mouth stayed open, her tongue slack. Eventually she cried, smelling the food but lacking the skill to obtain it. I relented, feeding her the rest of the meal as she was used to.
For once I didn’t feel I was completely lying when Mrs. Mansour arrived. “We had a grand day,” I told her. I threw words like developmental and affective into my report. But Aroush’s sigh and smile I kept to myself. To hear Mrs. Mansour say, “Today smiling, tomorrow Shakespeare,” or something like that, would have diminished our private milestone in a way I couldn’t bear.
That night I dreamed that Aroush was my child. Under a great black cloak I carried her against my body, clutching her henna-patterned hands in mine, and when she sighed or smiled only I knew it. I woke up suddenly and shook my husband’s shoulder. “Ed,” I whispered, “wake up.”
His head sprang from the pillow.
“What if I wanted a child?” I said. A ridiculous thing to ask a sleeping man in the middle of the night, and I knew it.
Naturally, he was disoriented. “Child?”
“Yes. A child.”
“But you don’t.”
“What if I do? What if I changed my mind?” It was an impulse, a cheat, a conversation I could later disown. In the morning I could easily convince him I had been talking in my sleep or that he had been dreaming.
“Sally, whatever you want,” he slurred, “you’ve got.” I wondered: was that a yes, his drowsy answer, or a no? Did he mean that I could have anything I wanted, or that I already had it? With a grunt, he turned his face back to the pillow and embraced me so tightly as to bury my face in his armpit and squash my mouth under his shoulder, ending the questions and conversation altogether. Where do you think you’re going? he used to demand, playfully, in those early days of our courtship, every time I rose from the bed or left his side. Then he would reel me back into his arms. And so it seemed now: as though he’d sensed me moving away from him, and knew even in sleep to grip me closer.
—
I formed a warm animal attachment to Aroush: to her smooth, square feet, to the clean smell of her scalp when I held her in my lap. As I had predicted, Mrs. Mansour, when she did notice them eventually, took the smile and “Haa” as evidence that in due time her daughter would map the stars or choreograph a ballet. But we were both happy. I had a renewed hope that one day I could bring Aroush to respond to her own name, to hold a ball with both hands, to point to objects when I named them. I felt like a teacher again: not necessarily heroic, but useful.
My textbooks and store-bought toys gave way to the elements. I took Aroush outside into the garden, touching her plump feet to the dry, rough patches of grass. I gave her flowers to smell. We lay down and gazed together at the shapes the clouds made. One day I filled a bowl with ice and another bowl with warm water. I cleaned out an old medicine dropper and found the spray bottle that I used to water the plants. I bathed her hands in the ice water and then in the warm, cheering as she reacted to the change in temperature. I squeezed the medicine dropper onto her palms and wrists. She was mildly ticklish, as I learned from her squint and sigh whenever something brushed her face, and so, playfully, I raised the spray bottle and misted her cheek with it.
Aroush began to scream: a guttural sound, higher-pitched than the moan that told me she was merely upset. She stiffened at the knees and elbows and squeezed her eyes shut. I felt the resistance in her body, the sudden rigid terror. “It’s all right, Aroush,” I said. “It’s just water.” Stupidly, I misted her palm. Her screams turned into violent choking noises; her face grew purple. I dropped the bottle and picked her up, rocking her until my knees hurt.
In the afternoon I watched Mrs. Mansour hoist Aroush onto her hip and drape her with the veil as usual. Accustomed by then to keeping secrets from her, I said nothing about the spray bottle. Parents at the special-needs school in Manila would take offense the moment we asked about a bruise or scratch, hearing only accusation. Are you a parent? I’d been asked, more than once. Then you’ve got no right. No right! She might ask why I’d sprayed Aroush in the first place—question my new curriculum, based as it now w
as not on science but on my own instincts. Why I had inflicted things on Aroush that would have tormented even a regular person.
That night Ed came home angry, having suffered some humiliation at work. “If a Bumbai screws up, it’s my fault,” he said. “Always my fault. None of the credit, all of the blame.” Sand sludge had accumulated in one section of the desert pipeline, and acids had eaten away part of the pipe wall. Sections would have to be replaced, at great cost to the company. “No good! This no good!” Ed shouted, imitating his Arab bosses.
“Aroush is terrified of spray bottles,” I said. “Today I spritzed her with the one I use on the plants, and she started screaming. As if I was torturing her.”
“They’ve got no right,” Ed continued. “Dressing me down like a schoolboy. That oil has got my blood in it!”
“A spray bottle. Can you imagine? Is there anything less threatening than that? I can’t wrap my head around it.”
“I can,” he said. I looked up—surprised, though I should not have been, that Ed had listened to me through his own complaints. “What did you expect?” he said. “She comes from a race that cuts off people’s body parts for petty crimes.”
His face was flushed. I touched his forehead, which was hot with fever. Upset as he seemed, I envied Ed his clarity. I had always been fascinated with kinks in the natural order, with anomalies, but my husband was a man who dealt in diagrams and blueprints. At work Ed drew up flowcharts and predicted outcomes, checking that the pipeline did in real life what he’d said it would on paper. His view of Arabs and Indians, and our place among them, was no different. Could he be right? Was there some brutal form of discipline I didn’t know about, involving spray bottles, and why would Aroush need it?
“I’m calling in tomorrow,” he said. “Screw them. Let’s see how their precious pipe does without me.” For the first time that evening I noticed that his voice was hoarse, as if hours of defending himself had worn it out. His nose was congested. A better wife surely would have noticed earlier.