by Diane Duane
“Sounds like magic to me,” said McCoy.
“But not to me, sirs and ladies,” said Master Engineer tr’Keirianh suddenly, and everyone turned to look, even Ael. “The mathematics of our physics would suggest that such could happen. But our physics also has an ethical mode which suggests that the Elements are one in Their nature, straight through the universality of being…and there is no way such ‘plenum shifts’ could not happen: ‘as at the heart of being, so at the fringes and out to the Void.’” He frowned a little, his look for the moment closely matching Scotty’s. “I will agree, the mathematics involved is thorny. Finding a way to describe accurately what we think might be happening…” He shrugged, a purely human gesture, and Jim looked at the graying hair and the lined face and suddenly, he couldn’t tell why, conceived a liking for this man. “It is challenging. And also disturbing.”
K’s’t’lk chimed soft agreement. “Yes,” she said. “It has been very controversial among my people’s physicists. There have been some unplanned reembodiments over the issue.”
Knowing what he knew about the Hamalki life cycle, Jim wasn’t sure whether this translated exactly as “suicides.” He hoped it didn’t. “K’s’t’lk,” he said, getting up and walking around the table to where she sat, “how do you mean ‘controversial’ exactly? Your people have been rewriting physics cheerfully for centuries, on the local scale anyway…something that other physicists find distressing, but that doesn’t seem to bother you people in the slightest. But this is ‘controversial’?” He shook his head. “After all, you could just do it if you wanted to.”
“If,” K’s’t’lk said, looking up at him. “Of course we could. But our physics, like that of the Rihannsu, includes an ethical mode as well as a strictly mathematical one. The math tells you how…and the ethics tell you whether you should. In this case…” She jangled a little, an uneasy sound. “If equivalences on this scale are indeed possible, they might break the unwritten ‘first law of space.’”
“You mean there are written ones?” McCoy said, with his eyebrows up.
“In the form of the clearly expressed physical behavior of the universe, of course there are,” K’s’t’lk said. “‘Don’t let go of a hammer above your feet while standing over a gravity well. Don’t breathe vacuum.’ How large does the print have to be?” She chimed laughter. “But Doctor, this is something else. The inferred, inherent right of being to be otherwise.”
“That I understand,” McCoy said emphatically.
“You may,” Jim said, “but now I’m lost.”
Scotty folded his arms and leaned on them. “Captain,” he said, “have you ever heard the saying ‘Time is God’s way of keeping everything from happening at once’?” Jim nodded. “Well then,” Scotty said, “there’s a corollary to that law: Space is God’s way of keeping everything from happening in the same place. God or not, space seems to violently resist physical objects coinciding—say by sharing the same volume, like someone beaming into a wall—”
“Doctor,” Ael said, concerned, “are you cold?”
“No, Commander,” McCoy said. “Not yet, anyway. But thank you.”
Jim smiled. “—or by being forced into synchronization in other ways. Some have called it a reaction against the oneness of all matter and energy or the ‘ylem’ of pre-time, before the Big Bang. Whatever, the general tendency of the universe is presently away from order, toward chaos. That’s just entropy. But it can also be expressed in another way. Things don’t want to be the same, or stay the same; they want to be different, and get more so.”
“No ‘Plus ça change, plus c’est la même chose’…?”
“In life, yes. In this area of physics, no….”
The communicator went. “Bridge to Captain Kirk,” said Mr. Mahasë’s voice from the bridge.
Jim stepped over to the table, hit the comm button. “Kirk here.”
“Sempach has just dropped out of warp, Captain, and is closing. ETA five minutes.”
“Hold that thought,” Jim said. “Not the one about Plus ça change: the other one. I know you’re still feeling your way through this, but we need solutions fast.” He looked down the table at Ael. “Commander, would you walk with me briefly?”
She rose and accompanied him out the door. When it closed behind them, Jim said, “Ael, the commodore in command of Sempach is likely to have mixed feelings about your crew at large spending any more time aboard Enterprise, even as controlled as the circumstances have been. You, and your senior officers, under supervision, I can now justify…but no one else for the time being. And things may change without warning. I hope you’ll understand.”
“Captain,” Ael said, “I understand better than you think. And I thank you for trusting us so far…when I have sometimes misstepped in that regard.”
Jim nodded; then said, “I should go see the commodore. Spock will assist you with anything you need in the meantime; I’ll see you later.”
“We will be moving out for the rendezvous point,” Ael said, “after the rest of the task force arrives?”
“That’s the plan as I know it. If the commodore gives me different news, I’ll see that you know about it as soon as possible.”
“Very well,” Ael said. “I shall be on Bloodwing for the time being. With another Federation ship in view, and more coming, my place is with her. Until matters stabilize.”
They stepped into the lift together. “Until they do…”
“Till then, luck and the Elements attend you,” Ael said.
“Thanks,” Jim said, thinking, as the lift doors shut, I hope I don’t need it, or them….
Chapter Six
Sempach was one of a newer, experimental class of cruisers, the Constellation class, named in memory of Matt Decker’s old ship that had been lost against the planet killer in the L-374 system. The class-name ship and Sempach had been the first out of the shipyards, with Speedwell close behind, and all of them were already busy performing their basic function—trying out a new four-nacelle design that was supposed to provide starships with a more streamlined and reliable warp field, capable of higher speeds. The technology, referred to as “pre-transwarp” in some of the literature Jim had seen, was extremely interesting but technically somewhat difficult to understand, and Scotty had passed it on to his captain with a single comment: “Rubbish.” Nonetheless, the technology seemed so far to be working all right, and the design crews had plainly been busy elsewhere too: the ship was very handsome from the outside, with a lean and rakish look to her. As the transporter effect wore off, Jim looked around Sempach’s transporter room, surprised at its size and its somewhat nonutilitarian look; there was even a small lounge area off to one side, with comfortable seating. Kind of overdone, Jim thought as he greeted the transporter technician at the console and then raised an eyebrow at himself. She’s affecting me. Still, it’d be nice not having to stand around waiting for visiting dignitaries to arrive.
The transporter room doors opened, and Commodore Danilov came in, looking much as he had when Jim had last seen him in San Francisco: a brawny man of medium height, dark with a combination of Polynesian and eastern European blood, the dark hair going silver-shot now above a broad, round face, surprisingly unlined for someone of his age.
“Sir,” Jim said, “you hardly had to come down here to meet me…”
The commodore gave him a wry look out of his sharp dark eyes as they shook hands. “Captain,” Danilov said, “I’m still learning to find my way around this ship. I know I could have sent a lieutenant for you, but they get lost too. Come on.”
They went off down the corridors together, the commodore making his way quickly enough despite his disclaimer. Jim’s feelings about his superior officers ranged from the respectful to the occasionally scandalous, but here was one man in whose case he came down hard on the respectful side: twenty-five years in Starfleet, the kind of officer who flew a ship or a desk with equal skill—though he fought them more often than he simply flew them. Danilov’s
experience and effectiveness in battle had become legendary; in particular, he had probably scored more points during the last big war with the Klingons than any other commander except Captain Suvuk of Intrepid, until the Organians blew the whistle and stopped play. Jono Danilov had that invaluable commodity for a commander, a reputation for luck. He always seemed to come out only slightly scorched from any trouble he got into, no matter how the trouble seemed to seek him out—and it did.
“She’s a fine ship,” he said to Jim as they turned a corner, “a little fidgety at first, but she’s settled in nicely now. Fleet’s pleased; they’re already flying the keels for the two new ones—Stargazer and Hathaway.”
Jim nodded. “She’s a real lady, Commodore. And she still has that new-ship smell.”
“I want to keep it that way for a while,” Danilov said, shooting Jim a look, “and avoid getting things all scorched and smoky. The question is, will I be able to.”
He came to a door without a label and waved it open. Danilov’s quarters were considerably bigger than Jim’s on Enterprise, and the office was also a lot more spacious. “Palatial,” Jim said. “Rank hath its privileges.”
“Hardly. This is the standard captain’s cabin for this model. Sit down, Jim, please. Can I offer you a brandy?”
“Thank you, Dan, yes.”
He went over to a glass-doored cupboard and got it, and Jim sat looking around him for the moment at the furnishings, as spare as most field personnel’s, but still individual: on the desk, a sleek, round old Inuit soapstone sculpture of a bear; a good amateur watercolor of the Ten-Thousand-Step Stair in misty weather, hanging on the wall behind the desk along with a brace of latoun-inlaid “snapdragon” flintlocks from Altair VI; a shaggy blue tree-pelt from Castaneda draped over the back and seat of the high-backed chair behind the desk.
Danilov handed Jim the drink in a heavy-bottomed crystal glass and seated himself. “Viva,” he said, lifting his glass.
“Cheers,” Jim said, and sipped.
They sat appreciating the drinks for a few seconds, but no more. “So,” Danilov said, “tell me about this little engagement you had here.”
“Little!” Jim gave him a look. “Seven ships against two, sir; not my kind of odds. And circumstances were less than ideal.”
“It would have been seven against one,” Danilov said, “had things gone strictly by the book.”
“They didn’t,” Jim said, “because I used some latitude in construing the orders that Fleet had specifically given me.”
“Might I inquire about the reasons, Jim?” Danilov asked. “Or was it just on general principle?”
“I had a hunch.”
Danilov let out a long breath. “No arguing with those,” he said after a moment. “They’ve saved both our lives often enough before now.”
“And it turns out to have been a good thing, in retrospect. It proves I was correct to be concerned about leaks of information from—” Even now Jim could hardly bring himself to say “Starfleet.” “From Earth.”
Dan sat back and looked at him. “No one but Fleet should have known where Bloodwing was going to be, or when,” Jim said, “and regardless, there were seven Romulan vessels waiting for us there, cloaked. If Ael had been on site when originally scheduled, she would be dead now.”
“Not a captive?”
“I doubt it. No one offered us the opportunity to surrender her. They just attacked.”
“Your presence there might have affected their plans.”
“That’s occurred to me. But it doesn’t matter, Dan. Bloodwing’s commander wouldn’t have allowed herself to be taken alive. She would have fought until her ship was destroyed to prevent the Sword, or herself, falling into their hands.”
“You’re sure of that?”
“Yes.”
“You’re sure,” Danilov said, looking steadily at Jim, “that your thinking on this particular subject is clear?”
“Dan,” Jim said, nettled, “‘this particular subject’ is a non-subject. My ‘thinking’ as regards Commander t’Rllaillieu is clear enough for my first officer, who is something of an expert on the clarity of thought, and my CMO, who is something of an expert on humans in general, and me in particular.” Danilov’s gaze dropped. “The commander is a courageous and sometimes brilliant officer who, at the cost of her own career, sought us out and gave us valuable information which kept the balance of power from being irreparably destroyed. If the effectiveness of that intervention has been rendered short-lived by subsequent events, well, such things happen. If one of us had done the things she’s done, he or she would have been loaded down with enough decorations to make the wearer fall face forward on trying to stand. But because she’s from an unfriendly power, no one seems willing to take what she’s done at face value.”
There was a short silence. “The point is,” Danilov said, “she’s a Romulan. And Romulans plot.”
Jim got up and started to pace. “Dan, with all due respect, you know as well as I do why you were so glad to get away from that desk in San Francisco. Politics! Romulans have politics just as we do, though possibly in a more complex mode. But this time, politics is failing, as it sometimes does, to keep this culture’s internal conflicts from erupting into a war that affects others outside it. Including us. And we still have a problem at our end, because somehow very detailed information about our reactions to this situation is leaking out of Starfleet and getting to the Romulans—going straight to where it can do the most harm.” Jim paused and gripped the back of his chair, leaning on it. “Something has to be done, and fast. Otherwise, when hostilities do break out, we’re going to be in serious trouble.”
Danilov sat back. “Your concern,” he said, “is noted and logged.”
“Which reassures me. But what’s being done about it?”
Danilov just looked at him for a moment. “Jim, I can’t discuss it.”
Which meant he either knew something was being done, or knew that nothing was. “It’s going to impair our conduct of this operation,” Jim said, “if our personnel can’t be sure that details of where they’ll be aren’t being piped straight through to the people who’re going to be shooting at them.”
“You leave the conduct of the operation with me,” Danilov said, “since that’s where Starfleet has placed it.” The look he gave Jim implied that even enduring comradeship would not be allowed to interfere with some things.
Jim let the pause stretch out. “Yes, sir.”
Danilov let out a long breath and reached out to pick up the smooth gray soapstone bear, turning it over in his hands. “Aside from that for the moment, Jim, message traffic has become an issue. It’s way, way up on the Romulan side. We don’t even need to be able to read those messages to know that a massive mobilization is under way, and to understand perfectly well where it’s pointing.”
“Lieutenant Commander Uhura tells me that Starfleet message traffic has also been reaching unusual levels,” Jim said, sitting down again.
Danilov nodded. “Yes. With that in mind, we’re carrying some material for you that Starfleet didn’t want to send out through the ether. Strategy briefings, general intelligence from inside the Imperium…other information.”
“They are afraid that some of our codes have been broken.”
Danilov put the bear back down on his desk. “Yes. Some have been allowed to go ‘stale’ on purpose, for use when we want traffic to be intercepted. We’ve hand carried in two new encryption systems for you; all the rest of the ships in the task force have them already. You’re to have your science officer install them immediately. One of them is for use now, the other is to be held.”
“For when war breaks out…” Jim said.
Danilov looked at Jim with great unease. “No one in Fleet is saying that word out loud,” he said. “But you don’t have to be a telepath to hear people thinking it.”
“And another thing about message traffic,” Jim said. “Are you sure the monitoring stations are functioning properl
y? Those Romulan ships shouldn’t have been able to cross the Zone, cloaked or not, without being detected by the monitoring web. Are some of those satellites malfunctioning? Have they been sabotaged? Or have the Romulans come up with a cloaking device that not even the monitoring stations’ hardware can detect?”
Danilov frowned, shook his head. “It’s being looked into, Jim. We’re carrying a specialist communications team that will be performing advanced remote sensing and diagnostic routines to see what the story is when we get close enough to the Zone. For the moment, we’re treating the information as reliable once it’s been corroborated by other intelligence sources.”
Jim nodded. He took out the data solid he had brought with him and passed it across the desk to the commodore, who put it on the reading pad. A little holographic text window leaped into being, scrolling down some of the contents with a soft chirring sound.
“While we’re on the subject of things better not pumped into the ether at the moment,” Jim said, “on this solid is our most recent work on the Sunseed project, including a way to tune starships’ shields in order to screen out the worst of the artificial ion storm effect. I think this should be passed immediately to every other Starfleet vessel within range…and the preferred method of passing it should be by hand carry rather than broadcast.”
Danilov looked at the text a moment longer, then nodded and touched the reading plate. The “window” disappeared with a chirp. “We’ll pass it to them tomorrow,” he said, turning the solid over in his hands.
“More material should be forthcoming shortly,” Jim said. “But this kept our rear ends out of the sling at 15 Tri. Please make sure everyone takes it seriously.”
“All right.” Danilov looked up again. “There’s no doubt that your forethought pulled this one out of the fire, Jim. It was a nasty situation, elegantly handled. But I should warn you, there’ll still be some at Fleet who construe this kind of order juggling as an indication of someone trying to see how much he can get away with…”