The man her father had tried to kill.
“It’s about time you joined us down here, Dex.” Dillon Reese’s smoky drawl rose over the laughter and hum of voices in the bar. “You haven’t been in here since my wedding.”
Dex gave him a nod. “I don’t want to do too much socializing with the troops, you know. Bad for the image. Pretty soon they’ll start seeing me as human.”
“No one would make that mistake.” Dillon lowered one lid in a teasing wink.
Alyson was surprised by the camaraderie forged between the two men. They hadn’t seen eye-to-eye on anything before her father’s death. Of course, her father had nurtured the rift between them.
Dillon gave Dex one last grin before focusing on her. The smile fell from his lips. “Howdy, Alyson.”
Somewhere she found the strength to nod. “Dillon.”
A thousand beats of her heart passed before he spoke again. “The Hefe Weizen is wonderful. You should try it. Jacqueline really outdid herself on this one.” His lips stretched into a gentle smile. An accepting smile. “On the house.”
Alyson’s breath escaped in a tortured whoosh. Dillon Reese had a heart the size of his native state if he could welcome her after what her father had tried to do to him and the woman he had since married. “Thanks, Dillon.”
As if she’d heard Alyson’s thoughts, Jacqueline Schettler Reese rounded the corner into the bar, flashing her husband a wide smile. Even though she was dressed in a boxy apron, the round shape of her pregnant tummy was clearly visible.
Neil Fitzroy’s crimes against Jacqueline were the worst of all. He and his accomplice, Buck Swain, had tried to kill Jacqueline’s daughter to keep her quiet after she’d witnessed her own father’s murder. Alyson had never met Jacqueline. And even after Dillon’s reaction, she didn’t want to meet her now.
“Dillon, I have to go pick up Amanda from her gymnastics class. Can you hold down the fort until the night shift gets set up?”
“Sure thing, darlin’.”
Jacqueline’s gaze landed on Dex. She gave him a big smile and poked her husband in the shoulder. “Haven’t you gotten Dex a beer yet, Dillon? It isn’t often we have the district attorney himself here. How are you doing, Dex?”
Dex returned her smile. “Nice seeing you again, Jacqueline.”
Jacqueline’s gaze moved to Alyson. “Aren’t you going to introduce us?”
Alyson held her breath. She would give anything to crawl into a hole about now.
Dex didn’t even flinch. “This is Alyson Fitzroy.”
Jacqueline’s blue eyes widened. “Alyson—”
“Fitzroy.” Alyson pulled herself up, ready to take Jacqueline’s contempt square in the face. “I’m sorry for the hell my father put you through.”
Jacqueline took a deep breath. When she exhaled, a polite smile lifted the corners of her lips. “Thank you. I’m sorry for the hell he put you through, as well.”
Alyson’s throat closed. Since her father’s death she’d felt ostracized from her former life, her former friends. People who knew she was Neil Fitzroy’s daughter had cooled toward her as if her father’s sins had tainted her. She’d lost more than Dex and her father the day Neil Fitzroy died. She’d lost who she was—who she used to be.
Never had she expected to be welcomed by Dillon and Jacqueline. Never had she dreamed she’d be welcomed back into the fold by the two people her father had hurt most. “Thank you.”
Dex looked down at her.
A chill sank into her bones.
Jacqueline’s and Dillon’s acceptance was small comfort when faced with the hard line of Dex’s mouth and the judgmental glint in his eye. She’d lost so much. So much that she’d never get back. No matter how much kindness strangers showed her, she could never regain the relationship that had meant the most to her. She could never undo the choices she’d made.
“SO WHAT will it be? Dex? Alyson?” Dillon drawled. “Two pints of Hefe Weizen have your names on them.”
Dex held up a hand. He really should take Dillon up on the offer sometime, try to do more to smooth over the rift that had been between them. But now wasn’t the time. “We’ll have to take a rain check, Dillon. I need to talk to Cohen. Thought he might be down here. Have you seen him?”
Dillon nodded and pointed to a booth in the corner. Tall and thin, John Cohen hunched over a beer alone. Perfect. He nodded his thanks to Dillon and started across the pub.
Alyson walked close enough behind for him to catch the ghost of her scent, even over the aromas of cigarette smoke, fried food and beer. He’d tried to talk her out of coming to the Schettler Brew Pub. As angry as he was with her, he didn’t want to see her hurt. And he’d been sure coming here, digging into old wounds Fitz had left in his wake, would only hurt her.
He blew a relieved sigh through tense lips. Leave it to Dillon and Jacqueline to push aside their hatred for Fitz to embrace his daughter. Now if Dex could only push aside his concern for Alyson and focus on getting answers from Cohen, maybe they would get somewhere.
Reaching his destination, Dex folded himself into the booth, opposite Cohen. He moved over enough for Alyson to slide in next to him. “Hello, Cohen.”
Cohen looked up from his beer. A smile touched with the fine edge of cynicism spread over his lips. “Dex. Finally coming down from your ivory tower to join in the fun?”
Cynicism wasn’t uncommon in the district attorney’s office. God knew they dealt with enough nasty people doing nasty things to one another to get a bit jaded over the years. But John Cohen elevated cynicism to an art form. Dex gestured to the bar. “The fun looks like it’s going on over there, Cohen. Not here.”
“Are you saying I’m not fun?” Cohen shrugged. “What else is new?” Cohen’s gaze flicked to Alyson. He sized her up with deep brown eyes that had no doubt melted a few women’s hearts along the way. This time, the smile that spread over his lips was one of pure amusement. “I’ll be damned. I haven’t seen you in a long time, Alyson.”
Alyson smiled and nodded. “We have some questions for you, John.”
Cohen crooked a brow and glanced from Alyson to Dex. “So the two of you are a ‘we’ again?”
“No,” Dex said without looking at Alyson. He couldn’t bear to see the hurt look on her face. He leveled a pointed stare on Cohen. “We just came from the prison in Grantsville.” Dex paused, watching Cohen’s eyes.
If Cohen had any reaction, he hid it well.
Dex pushed on. “It seems you’ve been out there recently, as well.”
“And you want to know why?” Cohen’s gaze darted away from them and landed on a waitress walking toward him with a plate stacked with a burger and thick wedges of fried potatoes. “About time. I’m famished.”
The waitress served the food. “Would you like to order?”
“No. Thank you,” Dex said without taking his eyes from Cohen.
Next to him, he could feel Alyson shake her head. Satisfied everyone was taken care of, the waitress left.
“So why were you at the prison, Cohen?”
Cohen paused, seemingly sorting through his memory. “What prison was that?”
Dex balled his hands into fists beneath the table. If the A.D.A. didn’t start giving him some straight answers, he’d either have to charge him with conspiracy or beat him to a bloody pulp.
“The one near Grantsville. Grant County,” Alyson supplied.
“Oh, yeah. I went there to talk to Smythe, your rapist the governor just let loose.” He eyed Dex, one corner of his lips crooking into a cynical grin. “But of course, that’s why you’re asking, isn’t it?”
“What did you talk to him about?”
Cohen took a bite of burger. “Damn. I forgot to ask for ketchup. I can’t stand being without ketchup.” He set the burger on his plate and opened the briefcase set beside him on the table. Reaching inside, he pulled out a handful of foil packets containing ketchup. Ripping open a packet, he spread the condiment on his burger. He ripped open another
packet.
One more evasion and Dex would have to risk an assault charge. “Put down the damned ketchup, Cohen.”
John Cohen raised surprised eyes to his face.
“What did you talk to Smythe about?”
Sighing, Cohen set down the ketchup and shook his head. “Nothing earth-shattering. Same old, same old. Remember that assault case where one convict jumped another in the county lockup? Just about killed the guy?”
“I remember.”
“Smythe was a witness. It happened a while ago, back when he was still in jail, before he was transferred to Grantsville.”
Dex leaned forward in the booth. “The page you signed in on in the visitor’s log was missing. Do you know anything about that?”
Cohen bit into his burger. When he finished chewing, he shrugged. “What is all this about, Dex? You think I helped Smythe stage that recent rape? Shades of Fitz?”
Dex tried not to notice Alyson squirm beside him. She raised her chin in that damned determined way of hers. “Did you?”
Cohen turned his smile on her. “Although I can almost understand Fitz using the system for his own profit, I do still have enough scruples left not to unleash a rapist scumbag like Smythe on the public. To answer your question, no, I didn’t help Smythe.”
Dex narrowed his eyes. He wanted to believe Cohen. But then what one wanted to believe and what was true often weren’t the same thing. God knew, he should have learned that lesson long ago. He’d had enough teachers.
He glanced at Alyson. Her forehead knotted with worry. Her lips tightened into a line.
Following Dex’s gaze, Cohen watched her, as well. “Sorry to disappoint you, Alyson. But I guess I’m not as bad a guy as you thought.”
She shook her head. “It’s not that, John. We just need to find out who did help him.”
“Hmm. Maybe I can help, after all.”
Dex tensed. He leaned over the table. “Spit it out, Cohen.”
“There was a hearing for the jail assault case a week ago, and I had to spring Smythe for a day to testify. He had a girlfriend in the gallery. At least, she seemed like a girlfriend, smiling at him, lots of eye contact when he was on the stand. Sick woman.”
“Who was she?”
“That’s the interesting part. I ran into her one other time this week. She testified in one of my cases. Her name is Jennifer Scott.”
Alyson gasped.
Dex turned to her. “Do you know Jennifer Scott?”
Alyson nodded and swallowed hard, as if trying to find the courage to face something she didn’t want to face. “She’s a forensic chemist. She works with me at the crime lab.”
“HAVEN’T YOU HEARD?” Valerie D’Fonse looked down her generous nose at Alyson, a conspiratorial grin on her face.
Alyson wasn’t in the mood for guessing games. Last night had been hell. She’d spent it in Dex’s guest room again after he’d refused to let her stay in her home until a security system was installed. She’d have rather stayed alone. He hadn’t said two words to her all night. He’d merely retreated into his library with the telephone. So much for his promise not to shut her out.
She bit the inside of her bottom lip. She didn’t know if she could stand one more night without Patrick safe in her arms. She needed answers. And fast. She’d come straight to Valerie for just that reason.
A brilliant but lonely forensic chemist, Valerie had made other people’s business her hobby. She spewed gossip the way Fourth of July fireworks spewed sparks. And that’s why Alyson was circulating in the crime lab’s break room to learn what she could learn. “I’m so out of the loop, Valerie. I haven’t heard anything. What happened?”
Valerie’s eyes sparkled as if all the gossip she packed into her mind was gunpowder and by asking the question, Alyson had just set flame to fuse. “Jennifer Scott doesn’t work here anymore.”
Alyson’s heart plummeted. “Why not?”
“She quit two days ago. Didn’t even give notice.”
“Two days ago?” How coincidental that Jennifer should quit the very day Smythe was released from prison. “No notice?”
“Not a peep. I didn’t even know she was going to quit. But that’s not the good part.” She lowered her voice and leaned toward Alyson over a table littered with candy wrappers and a paper bag lunch. “You’ll never guess where she got a job.”
Back to guessing games again. “Where?”
“Think big company, lots of bucks. And they don’t hand out jobs like candy at a parade. Let’s just say she must have an in.”
“Where, Valerie? Where did Jennifer get a job?”
Valerie grinned, her whole body tensed with the excitement of being the keeper of gossip in demand. “Smythe Pharmaceuticals.”
The name hit Alyson like a well-aimed fist. Now they were getting somewhere.
DEX COULD TELL Alyson had news the moment she poked her head into her lab where he was sitting in front of her computer, waiting for her. Her eyes sparkled like emeralds under a jeweler’s glass. Her cheeks flushed with color. The way she used to look, back when their biggest troubles were deciding which restaurant to choose among the dozens flanking State Street.
So different from the drawn look of fear she’d worn for the past few days.
She motioned him across the hall and into the vacant trace evidence lab and shut the door behind them, leaning back against the barrier.
“So?”
“Jennifer Scott quit two days ago. She has a new job.”
The news zinged along his nerves like an electric charge. “Don’t tell me. Her new job is with Smythe Pharmaceuticals.”
“Bingo.”
Dex reached into his pocket and pulled out his cell phone. “Do you have a number for them?”
Alyson nodded. She disappeared from the lab for a few moments then reappeared with the Madison phone book.
Dex paged through the thick book to locate the number and punched it into his phone.
“Smythe Pharmaceuticals,” a professional-sounding woman’s voice answered.
“I’d like to speak with Jennifer Scott, please.”
A pause stretched over the line. “I’m sorry, there’s no one here by that name.”
“Are you saying a chemist by the name of Jennifer Scott doesn’t work there?”
“That’s right, sir.”
“Thank you.” Dex punched the end button and slipped the phone back into his jacket pocket. “Damn. Is your gossip guru known for inventing stories?”
Alyson watched him, the sparkle gone from her eyes, a furrow between her delicate brows. “No. Usually she just sticks to repeating them. But why would Jennifer tell Valerie she had a job at Smythe Pharmaceuticals if she didn’t?” Alyson stuffed her hands into her pockets. “Unless Jennifer expected to be offered the job but the offer never came.”
“We won’t know until we find her.”
“So now we have two missing persons. Jennifer Scott and the alleged rape victim, Connie Rasula.”
He nodded. “That’s what it looks like.”
“I suppose we’d better get looking.” She turned and grasped the doorknob, but didn’t pull it open. “Wait.”
“What is it?”
She spun to face Dex, the sparkle back in her eyes. “Maybe we don’t have to find Jennifer to learn whether she stole that sample of Smythe’s blood from the crime lab.”
“I’m listening.”
“When we take a blood sample for DNA or serum testing, we have to add a preservative to it so the liquid blood doesn’t coagulate and start to decompose like blood normally would. The preservative is called E.D.T.A.”
The name of the chemical rang a bell in Dex’s memory. It had made the news during the O.J. Simpson case. “Isn’t E.D.T.A. present in blood naturally?”
“Only in trace amounts introduced by preserved food or other household products. But the blood sample taken from Smythe by the lab will have a very high E.D.T.A. content. If Jennifer stole blood from the lab sample, the blood
found under the recent rape victim’s fingernails will have an equally high E.D.T.A. content.”
Dex nodded. “And if the blood is the result of the victim clawing the rapist in self-defense as the victim claims, there should be only trace amounts of E.D.T.A. present.”
“Trace amounts at most.”
“How long will testing take?”
Alyson pursed her lips together like she always did when doing mental calculations. “If we get a specialist who’s used to doing the testing and you put a little clout behind the request, I’d say we could have results in about a day.”
He couldn’t stop a grin from spreading over his lips. “Set it up.”
“I’ll ready the sample myself. And I’ll label the samples anonymous.”
“Good thinking.”
Alyson shot him a triumphant smile that hit him like a punch to the gut. He used to burst with pride at the thought of having this brilliant woman in his life, in his bed. Whenever she made a contribution to a case, or found the answer to a tough problem as she had just now, he’d always felt like crowing.
He mentally shook his head. He no longer had a reason to be proud. Alyson wasn’t his anymore. If he hadn’t wanted to truly face that before, he had only to remind himself of the baby she’d hid from him.
He had to remember. He had to hold on to the anger, the hurt. He couldn’t let himself forget. He had learned that early in life.
He glanced at his watch. The day was trickling away.
Alyson opened the door to the evidence lab. “Hi, Valerie.” She smiled at a dark-haired woman and waited for her to walk past before stepping into the hall. She turned back to glance at Dex. “It’ll just take me a few minutes to get the testing under way.”
“So it should be complete by—” The bleat of Dex’s cell phone cut off his thought. He retrieved it from his pocket and punched the button. “Harrington.”
“Got some news.” Al Mylinski’s voice boomed over the phone.
Claiming His Family Page 4