Twisted Christmas

by Sara Cate

  “Yes, yes, please. I’ve fantasized about you eating me out for years.”

  I chuckle hearing her confession and lower my mouth, while keeping my eyes on hers. I drag my tongue through her folds one time, staring at her as she stares at me. Goosebumps erupt all over her flesh and the heels of her feet apply pressure to my back. She shakes slightly and I briefly wonder if she’s about to come already.

  “Wow.” She lets out a breathy sigh. “That feels…incredible.” She lets her head fall back. “Even better because it’s you.”

  And she’s probably right. My cock turned harder than steel the second my tongue tasted her tangy sweet flavor. I’ve never been this hard just eating pussy, making me think that the fact that it’s Gabrielle is making me more turned on.

  I continue eating her, alternating between licking and sucking her sweet clit before moving down and beginning to fuck her with my tongue. “I’m going to eat your ass later,” I tell her.

  She lets out a gasp and then a whine and her hands find my hair. She pushes my head down and raises her pelvis, grinding her cunt against my mouth. That’s so fucking hot. “I think I’m going to come.”

  “That’s right, baby. Come for me. Show me who this pussy belongs to.”

  Her eyes find mine. “Yours.”

  “That’s fucking right. That’s why you saved it for me, right? You saved this pussy for me because you knew no one could please you like I can.”

  “No one loves me like you do, J. I’ve always known that.”

  “No fucking one.” I growl. “Fucking remember that.” I grip her hips, dragging my tongue along her center again and again and again. “I’ll worship you, Gabrielle. You know that. I’ll love you harder and better than anyone.”

  She cries out, her body bowing off the bed as I feel her orgasm brewing. She digs her nails into my scalp as she humps my face, chasing the euphoric feeling. “I’m there.”

  “Come for me, Gab. Make that sexy cunt of yours come all over my face.”

  She cries out. “Yes! Right there, James! YES YES YES!” She screams as she grinds her pussy against my mouth. She spasms and jerks against me and I do my best to hold her down but her erratic movements are all over the place making me smile that she’s completely let go of her body. Her pussy quivers around my tongue and it’s the sexiest thing I’ve ever experienced while doing this.

  “Too much.” She gasps as she tries to pull away from my mouth. She twitches and I grip her tighter not wanting her away from me. I continue to tongue her pussy, alternating between sweet kisses and nips at her clit. “Fuuuuuck.” Her hands move away from my head and up her body to her hair. She finally lets her eyes flutter open and her eyes find mine. They’re bright and shining with lust and love for me. She bites down on her bottom lip just as a smile begins to play at her lips.

  I’m a fucking goner.

  Chapter 5

  James

  She sits up and rests on her elbows. Her skin is glowing even more than usual and her eyes are bright. My cock is harder than it’s ever been as I drink her in.

  “Wow.” Her breathing slows and she averts her gaze from the ceiling to find mine and a huge smile finds her face. “You’re really good at that.”

  Hearing her praise fall from her lips, makes me feel prouder than I’ve ever been to give a woman an orgasm. And then somehow, my dick hardens even more remembering that this was her first orgasm from a man.

  She pushes herself off her elbows and leans up to press her lips to mine. “Will you show me?”

  I move up her body slowly, dragging my tongue up her torso, circling her nipple before I’m hovering over her. “Show you what, angel?”

  “What do you like?”

  I start to tell her that I’ll like anything she does. That just the mere thought of her mouth on my dick has me ready to come inside my briefs which is something I haven’t done in probably a fucking decade. But then my darker, more sinister side takes over. Whispering thoughts that I should teach her what I want. Teach her what she likes so that she’ll be conditioned to only want it—no, need it from me. It’s selfish, but I’m selfish when it comes to Gabrielle. I want her. All of her. And I know for a fact, I’m never going to be ready to give her up now that I’ve had her.

  “I want to suck your dick,” she whispers and my carnal thoughts are interrupted by one of most men’s favorite sentences.

  I move to my back and spread my legs so that she can kneel between them. She places her hands on her thighs, almost as if she’s nervous to touch me and waiting for instruction. “Take off my briefs.” I nod at her and lift my hips to give her easier access. She smiles and pulls my briefs agonizingly slowly down my hips. She grazes my cock with her pinky and a wicked smirk finds her face when she sees it twitch. She’s not looking at me which makes this moment even more intense. Her bottom lip is trapped between her teeth and one eyebrow is quirked in the most enticing way.

  She throws my underwear behind her off the bed and leans down, resting her weight on her hands as she stares at me, giving me a sheepish grin. “Use my mouth to make you come, James.”

  I ball my hands into fists to temper the ache in my cock. “Fuck. You can’t say things like that. It rattles the beast inside of me, and I’m not ready to introduce you to that side of me.”

  “Why?”

  “Because this is all new to you.”

  “But…” She lets out a breath. “You’re not new to me. Your darkness is my darkness. Especially…while we’re here. I want to explore this with you. All of this. And that means learning what you like and what you need. I want to be those things.”

  “You’re all I’ve ever fucking needed, Gab.”

  She tries to hide the smile, but I see it pulling at her lips and a painful ache spreads in my chest as that nagging thought of where this could possibly go long term sparks. She wants this as bad as I do and navigating this when it’s over is not something I’m prepared for.

  I push the thoughts away, knowing that tonight we don’t have to deal with it.

  Tonight, I get to fuck her in every way possible.

  “Lick the tip,” I instruct her. She wastes no time to lower her head and tease the head of my cock with the tip of her tongue. She licks it lightly once and my eyes slam shut as pleasure courses through my body. She does it again and again and circles the tip and I forget I’m supposed to be instructing her because she seems to know what I want. She moves from the tip and drags her tongue up my shaft before wrapping her lips around the tip and sucking hard. My hand finds her head and I tangle my hand in her tresses.

  “Is that okay?” I breathe out, but I’m not totally sure I spoke a coherent sentence.

  “Yes.” She mumbles around my cock as she lowers her mouth slowly. I look down and see she’s halfway down before she moves back up and I smile at the thought that she’s trying to deep throat me.

  “Don’t force it, angel.”

  She pulls back and a trail of spit connects her wet lips to my cock. It twitches at the visual. “I want it to feel good.”

  “Your lips are wrapped around my dick, trust me, baby, it feels good.”

  She wraps her lips around my dick and goes further this time. She gags and the vibrations send goosebumps all over my arms. She swallows and I think it opens up her throat because she moves even further down.

  “Fuuuuuuck me. Jesus Christ, baby.”

  She must be struggling with the spit control because I feel wetness all around the base of my cock. She finds her groove, moving up and down my shaft rhythmically. She grips the base and moves up and down with her mouth, fucking me better than anyone ever has. I’ve been exercising restraint up until now but the pending orgasm has my hips jerking and wishing that I could really fuck her mouth.

  “Lose control,” she whispers. “You’re holding back.”

  I stare at her curiously. “How do you know that?”

  “Your muscles are tight. Like you’re exercising restraint.”

  “You know
me so well, my God. Nothing is safe from you.” I chuckle.

  “Lose control, James. I can handle it. You don’t need to protect me from this. From you.”

  I grip her head. “Look at me.” Her eyes dart up to mine and I smile. “Tell me if it’s too much.”

  She nods and then she slides her mouth down me again. Only this time I meet her mouth, pushing my cock even further down her throat. Her nails dig into my thighs and a low groan rumbles in the back of my throat. No one has ever done that to me and I had no idea that it was so fucking sexy. I push further into her mouth. “Fuck. Baby, where…” I lose my train of thought because she does this thing with her tongue that renders me fucking speechless. She moves faster, up and down on me, making the sexiest sucking sounds as she pushes me closer to the edge.

  “Oh shit, angel, there.” I groan. “I’m going to come. Fuck, I’m going to come. I’m going to come.” My breathing becomes labored as my body jerks under her mouth and then my orgasm pulls me under. My grip tightens on her hair and I’m acutely aware of her fingers fondling my balls. “Right. Fucking. There,” I grit out.

  I think I momentarily black out and I find myself struggling to breathe as my orgasm goes on and on.

  My eyes open and for the first second or two everything is blurry. I can see her still between my legs but I can’t quite make out her features yet. She giggles but I feel like I’m on sensory overload so I shut my eyes again.

  “I’ll take that as you enjoyed it.”

  I raise my hand and give her a thumbs up because words are still failing me. After a minute, I finally feel like I can speak. “You’ve never done that before?”

  “No, but I’ve watched porn. I know the basics, J.”

  “Watching and doing are different things. Fuck.” I rub a hand down my face and when I open my eyes I’m glad to know I’m not permanently blind because my sister sucked the fucking soul out of me.

  I know there’s going to be some kind of consequence for the taboo relationship we’ve entered but I’m not prepared to lose my sight.

  I let out a breath as she crawls up my body and rests her chin on my chest as she looks up at me. “That was fun.”

  “I’m glad you enjoyed it. I sure as fuck did.” I laugh.

  A sheen of sweat covers her body making her glisten. “I want to taste you again.” I pull her gently. “I want you to ride my face. I need to give you so many orgasms that your body is loose when I’m inside you for the first time. It’s going to kill me to hurt you.”

  “It’ll kill us both if we don’t find out what the other feels like…right now.” She smiles but she listens to my instruction and straddles my face. Her scent overwhelms my senses. She smells familiar and also like something new entirely. I grip her hips and submerge my face in her folds, kissing and nipping at her clit as she grinds her cunt on my face.

  “Your beard,” she whimpers.

  “Does it feel good? I’ll shave it if you hate it.”

  “Don’t. You. Dare.” She moans and when I look up she’s pinching her nipples as she continues to bounce up and down, rubbing her cunt lips against my lips.

  “You don’t want to know how many times I’ve had this fantasy.”

  I stop briefly. “Tell me.”

  “Too many. God, you’re better at it than you are in my dreams.” I spread her lips with my thumbs and push my tongue inside her, fucking her relentlessly as I press my fingers to her clit.

  “Baby, come again for me.”

  “And then you’ll fuck me?”

  “Fuck yes.”

  I grip her ass, pushing and pulling her harder against my mouth as she rides me. “I love you,” she cries. “I love you so fucking much.”

  My heart, mind, and cock all work in tandem hearing those words. They all seem to be in agreement that I won’t be letting go of Gabrielle Calloway anytime soon.

  If ever.

  I move my tongue back to her clit and suck it between my lips and she loses it. “Oh God!” She screams and her hands drop to stroke my head. “I love you, I love you, I love you,” she cries as she climaxes on my tongue. Her sweetness floods my mouth and I’m rather surprised I’m able to make her squirt the second time I’ve touched her but I plan to wear that fact like a badge of honor.

  “I love you too.” I tell her as she falls to the side next to me. She barely lets herself recover before she’s on top of me again, hovering over my dick. “I want to fuck,” she breathes out. Her eyes are wild and she looks almost feral. “I need to feel you inside me.” She grips my dick and rubs her pussy on it, smearing her wetness all over it. “Once I do this…” she starts, “once we do this, I’m yours.”

  “Make no mistake, Gab.” I reach up and grip her face before bringing her down so that her lips are hovering mere inches above mine. “You have always been mine.”

  And with that, I let her go and nod at my dick. “Ride me.”

  “You’re not worried about…condoms?” She cocks her head to the side.

  “Cute that you think I don’t know you’re on the pill. And I’d never put you in harm’s way. I’m clean.” I add, “I’ve never fucked a woman without a condom, Gabrielle, but I can’t not know what your pussy feels like wrapped around my dick.”

  She sinks down, gripping my shoulders so tightly as she moves slowly down my shaft. “Holy shit, I can feel myself stretching to accommodate you. You’re so big.” Her head drops to my shoulder and I can feel her breath coming out in little spurts against my skin.

  I grip her ass and hold her up from slamming herself the rest of the way down. “Slow.”

  “No,” she whines. “Let me.”

  “I don’t want you to get hurt.”

  “It’s only the first time,” she tells me as she swats my hand away and leans down to press her lips to mine. “I know you probably can’t help it, and I love you for always trying to do right by me, but just relax and let me do this,” she whispers against my lips before she kisses me again. She slides her tongue between my lips and we kiss with an intensity that sets my skin on fire. She pushes herself further down and I feel her hymen and she must too because she whimpers against my lips. I run my hands up her back, stroking the skin just above the curve of her ass as she pushes through it and glides down the rest of dick as I swallow her muffled scream.

  “I’m sorry, angel.”

  “Don’t be sorry, just fuck me,” she breathes out. Her eyes are squeezed shut and when her eyes flutter open, there are tears.

  “Fuck. Baby.” I lean up, pressing my lips to her eyes and licking the tears beneath each of them. “I’m so proud of you. Taking my cock like the perfect girl you are.”

  She squeezes her eyes closed and all of her body must be in sync because she squeezes down on my cock just as hard and my eyes slam shut as I attempt to slow my orgasm. She raises herself up again and my eyes fly open to spy her looking down at where we’re joined. Her head snaps up to look at me and she winces. “There’s…blood.”

  “I assumed there would be.”

  “Sorry…” She frowns and I wonder why she’s embarrassed. She looks away from me and to the side and she begins to worry her bottom lip. “You probably haven’t had to deal with this in a while and—”

  “Stop.” I command her. “Look at me.” Her gaze snaps back to mine and I reach up to cup her cheek. “Do you think this is all a game to me? Some weird curiosity I was hoping to check off my list? I want you. All of you. And you bleeding all over my cock just means you’ve laid your claim over me in every way possible now.” I tighten my grip on her cheek and pull her down so that her lips are almost touching mine. “And it probably means, I’ll never know how to fully let you go when it’s time,” I tell her honestly.

  “I don’t want you to let me go.” She presses her face into my neck and I hear her whimper again. “Please don’t let me go.”

  I grip her shoulders and raise my hips, urging her to keep going. I’m still not ready to have this conversation yet. I don’t want to thin
k about a life that doesn’t include this. How am I supposed to play her older brother when and if she brings someone else home? How am I supposed to watch her give this part of herself to someone else? Would our relationship eventually be reduced to forbidden trysts behind closed doors or kisses in the shadows?

  Her lips find mine, silencing my thoughts. Her tongue intertwines with mine and I roll her so that I can be on top. “This okay?” I murmur against her lips. She nods and I begin to move faster and push harder into her. She’s staring up at me, her eyes wide and unblinking and I don’t even want to blink out of fear of missing a second of what’s happening between us. “Jesus Christ, Gab. You’re so beautiful.” I rest my forehead against hers as I bottom out completely and begin to fuck her with an urgency that I’ve never felt before.

  Her arms move around my neck and into my hair where she pulls at my strands. I lower myself closer to her and rest my lips at her ear. “Mine,” I tell her. “Fuck, you’re mine.”

  “Always,” she whines as she runs her fingernails down my back.

  With every thrust she is burrowing her way further into my heart and soul. My hand twitches and longs to be wrapped around her slender throat which is something I tend to do in bed, but I haven’t exactly broached the subject that this is one of my predilections.

  Next time.

  The thought that there will be a next time has my balls tingling with their pending release. “I’m going to come,” I tell her and she squeezes me in response.

  She lets out a low moan the last time I push further into her and my last thought before my cock empties inside of her is that I want her to come on my cock next time.

  “Fuck fuck fuck.” I slam my hand against my headboard and begin to fuck her harder through my orgasm.

  “Oh my God,” she cries. “It feels…really good now.” She’s raising her pelvis to meet mine and I feel the end nearing.

  “Gabrielle, goddammit.” I grit out as my entire body vibrates with the force of my climax. My eyes shut but I’m pretty sure they’ve completely rolled back or I’ve blacked out because when I open them, I’m lying on top of her. I realize I may be hurting her, so I lean up immediately, removing my weight from her. I look down at her and the smile across her face is almost too much after the orgasm I’ve had. “Was that…” I start and she nods vigorously.