An Amish Paradox

Home > Other > An Amish Paradox > Page 42
An Amish Paradox Page 42

by Charles E. Hurst


  Stevick, Richard A. Growing Up Amish: The Teenage Years. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2007.

  Stoll, Elmo. “Views and Values: Daughters of Sarah.” Family Life, March 1977, 8–10.

  Stoltzfus, Louise. Traces of Wisdom: Amish Women and the Pursuit of Life’s Simple Pleasures. New York: Hyperion, 1998.

  Swander, Mary. Out of This World: A Woman’s Life among the Amish. New York: Viking, 1995.

  Szasz, Thomas S. The Myth of Mental Illness. New York: Harper and Row, 1974.

  Tambiah, Stanley. “Ethnic Conflict in the World Today.” American Ethnologist 16 (June 1989): 335–49.

  Thompson, James D. Organizations in Action. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1967.

  Turner, Victor. “Betwixt and Between: The Liminal Period in Rites de Passage.” In Symposium on New Approaches to the Study of Religion: Proceedings of the 1964 Annual Spring Meeting of the American Ethnological Society, edited by J. Helm, 4–20. Seattle: American Ethnological Society, 1964.

  Tyler, Tom. “The State of Trust Today,” 2006, www.forbes.com (accessed March 26, 2009).

  Umble, Diane Zimmerman. Holding the Line: The Telephone in Old Order Mennonite and Amish Life. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1996.

  _____. “Who Are You? The Identity of the Outsider Within.” In Strangers at Home: Amish and Mennonite Women in History, edited by Kimberley D. Schmidt, Diane Z. Umble, and Steven D. Reschly, 39–52. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2002.

  Van der Walt, Joelle M., William K. Scott, Susan Slifer, P. C. Gaskell, Eden R. Martin, Kathleen Welsh-Bohmer, Marilyn Creason, Amy Crunk, Denise Fuzzell, Lynne McFarland, Charles C. Kroner, C. E. Jackson, Jonathan L. Haines, and Margaret A. Pericak-Vance. “Maternal Lineages and Alzheimer Disease Risk in the Old Order Amish.” Human Genetics 118 (2005): 115–22.

  Von Gruenigen, V. E., A. L. Showalter, K. M. Gil, H. E. Frasure, M. P. Hopkins, and E. L. Jenison. “Complementary and Alternative Medicine Use in the Amish.” Complementary Therapies in Medicine 9 (2001): 232–33.

  Waldrep, G. C. “The New Order Amish and Para-Amish Groups: Spiritual Renewal within Tradition.” Mennonite Quarterly Review 82 (July 2008): 395–426.

  Wasao, Samson W. “Fertility Differentials among Three Amish Affiliations in Ohio.” Ph.D. diss., Ohio State University, 1995.

  Wasao, Samson, and Joseph F. Donnermeyer. “An Analysis of Factors Related to Parity among the Amish in Northeast Ohio.” Population Studies 50, no. 2 (1992): 235–46.

  Weaver, Eli I. My Grace Is Sufficient for Thee. Walnut Creek, OH: Carlisle, 2003.

  Weaver, Roy M. “Glimpses of the Amish Church in Holmes County, Ohio, 1917–1922.” Heritage Review 16 (January 2007): 9–11.

  Weaver-Zercher, David. The Amish in the American Imagination. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2005.

  Weber, Max. “Class, Status, Party.” In Social Theory: The Multicultural and Classic Readings, edited by Charles Lemert, 126–36. Oxford: Westview Press, 1993. A 1920 article reprinted.

  _____. The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism. Los Angeles: Roxbury, 2002.

  Wenger, Anna Frances Z. “The Phenomenon of Care in a High Context Culture: The Old Order Amish.” Ph.D. diss., Wayne State University, 1988.

  Wenger, Glenn. Depression. Ephrata, PA: Weaverland Mennonite Publications, 2002.

  Wiker, Benjamin. “Mennonite Midwife behind Bars.” National Review Online, December 3 2002, www.nationalreview.com/comment/comment-wiker120302.asp (accessed April 27, 2009).

  Wuthnow, Robert. After Heaven: Spirituality in America since the 1950s. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 1998.

  Zook, Lee. “Slow Moving Vehicles.” In The Amish and the State, edited by Donald B. Kraybill, 145–62. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2003.

  Index

  accidents, 4

  and work, 193, 195, 232–33

  adolescents. See youth

  adoption, 101, 226

  advertising and Amish, 182, 185, 263, 286

  affiliations, 16, 18

  Andy Weaver, 2, 18, 22, 30, 36, 43–48

  attitudes toward other affiliations, 54–56

  Beachy, 32, 52, 64–65, 264–65, 308n63

  geographic distribution of, 25–26, 30

  and mission work, 58–67

  New Order, 18, 35–37, 48–52

  New New Order (New Order Christian Fellowship), 40, 51–52, 100

  Old Order, 18, 36, 52–55

  and rumspringa, 49, 67–68, 74, 76, 78–82, 226

  Stutzman-Troyer, 36, 40, 300–301, 310

  Swartzentruber, 2, 18, 35–43

  Tobe, 36, 40, 299, 301, 310

  and wealth, 211–13

  and work, 191–93, 197, 199–200, 215

  agriculture. See farmers, image of; farming; farms

  alcohol use, 69–70, 233, 274, 313

  and affiliation, 45, 50, 52, 62, 71, 75, 331

  after joining church, 275–77, 314n30

  Amish Country Furniture Association, 182

  Amish Education Committee, 324n6, 325n30

  Amish Helping Fund, 103, 320n18

  Amish insularity, 170, 221, 229, 288, 308n6. See also boundaries

  Amish-Mennonite Heritage Center, 10

  Amish Safety Committee, 194

  Ammann, Jakob, 15, 40, 49, 304n19, 309n12

  Anabaptist escalator, 34–35, 53–54, 63, 77, 310n17

  Anabaptists, 14, 32, 34, 270–71

  and Amish, 15, 34, 188

  and health, 231

  Andy Weaver Amish, 2, 18, 22, 30, 36, 43–48. See also affiliations

  appliances, household, 107–8, 118, 140

  ascetic Protestantism, 185, 188, 213, 328n27

  Association of Unmarried Amish Women, 130

  auctions. See Buckeye Dog Auction; produce auctions

  automobiles: and affiliation, 32

  as alternative to buggy, 60, 131–33

  ownership of, 18, 45, 47–48, 76, 84, 209, 264

  use of, 57, 132

  autonomy, 56, 123

  meaning of, 278

  ban. See excommunication

  Bargain Hunter, 136

  barn raisings, 96

  Beachy Amish, 32, 52, 64–65, 264–65, 308n63. See also affiliations

  beliefs of Amish, 18–19, 183, 186. See also affiliations; Bible

  Berlin (Ohio), 10, 30, 33, 40, 48, 64, 176, 201, 303

  Bible: as basis for general values, 18, 56, 64, 184, 223

  as basis for values in childrearing, 113, 115

  and gender roles, 113, 125

  and proselytizing, 58–59

  studies, 49–50, 86

  bicycles, 47, 106

  Bing Act, 28

  birding, 7, 134. See also hobbies

  birth control, 96, 100, 319n10

  birthing centers, 222–26, 266

  differences in, 223–25

  birth rate, 12, 99, 196, 199, 223

  out-of-wedlock, 226. See also conceptions, premarital; families: size of

  bishops. See church leaders, choosing

  blue-collar work. See employment; manual labor, value placed on

  border work, 20, 22, 259, 264, 266, 269–72

  Die Botschaft (The Message; weekly newspaper), 288

  boundaries, 179–87, 264–65

  among Amish, 81–82, 89, 264

  between Amish and English, 13, 22, 181, 191, 204, 218, 259, 265–69

  permeability of, 23, 264–65, 269, 275

  and purity, 306n37

  significance of, 24, 264

  strength of, 115, 264, 270

  types of, 264–65, 270

  Brethren church, 32, 60, 64, 305n20, 308n62

  Buckeye Dog Auction, 200

  The Budget (weekly newspaper), 101, 124, 185, 221, 238, 288, 298, 343

  buggies: and affiliation, 22, 43, 47–48, 55, 206, 262, 310n16

  as alternative to car, 60, 131–33

  options on, 10, 133

  and wealth, 133, 212r />
  and youth, 41, 76

  bundling (bed courtship), 38, 48, 73, 78–79, 274, 314n20

  Bush, George W., 31, 194, 267

  businesses, 2, 5, 6, 8–12

  advertising in, 182, 185, 286

  clustering of, 181

  cooperation among Amish, 182

  and exploitation of Amish name, 184–85

  global reach of, 182

  number of, 181–82

  partnerships with English, 184

  types of, 12, 76–77, 79–82. See also competition

  cell phones. See telephones

  cemeteries, Amish, 8

  change, general causes of, 20–22, 259–62

  child abuse. See domestic violence

  Child Labor Coalition, 194

  childrearing, 111–15

  differences in, 115–17

  children: disciplining, 111–12, 115–17

  ideal, 114, 172

  nature of, 111–12

  in schools, 144, 145, 147, 153–55, 160, 167–70

  and work, 122, 188, 193–94

  choice: meaning of, 280–81, 283

  and Ordnung, 68

  Christian Aid Ministries (CAM), 60, 64–66, 293

  church districts, 16–18

  conservative and liberal, 35, 48–52

  lower and higher, 35, 48–49, 77–80, 90

  number of, 29, 35–36

  size of, 16

  structure of, 16, 305n26. See also affiliations

  Church Funds 1 and 2, 250–51. See also health care costs; Hospital Aid Program

  church leaders, choosing, 305n26

  church services, 15–16, 46–47, 104

  church/state relations, 267, 276–77. See also government

  cigarettes. See smoking

  civic participation, 137. See also voting

  class consciousness, 21, 213. See also social classes

  Classic Word Processor, 208–9

  Clinic for Special Children, 230

  clothing, 18, 27, 52–53

  men’s, 37, 48

  women’s, 37, 43, 48

  Coblentz, Paul, 28

  cohesion, 275, 277, 281

  conversations and, 279

  dependence and, 280

  monitoring and, 279–80

  sanctions and, 280

  social structures and, 277–79, 283

  tradition and, 278

  trust and, 277, 279, 288

  values and, 277–78

  commonality among Amish, 14–20

  causes of, 275–84

  in education, 163–65

  in family, 98–99

  in health, 227–30, 232–36

  in rumspringa, 80–81; See also cohesion; differences among Amish

  communication, 83, 101–2, 110, 182, 221, 247, 288–89

  and work, 190–91. See also telephones

  Communion, 15–16, 45–47, 309n12, 315n30

  competition: in economics, 20, 181–83, 187, 202–3, 214–15, 261–62

  in sports, 134–35, 157

  computers: in education, 160, 165

  ownership of, 20, 32, 52

  at work, 199, 208–9

  conceptions, premarital, 74, 226, 314n23. See also birth rate

  congregations. See church districts

  conscientious objection, 28. See also nonresistance

  constancy, sources of, 205, 209, 260, 264–65

  consumerism, 131, 138–39

  Cooksey, Elizabeth, 74, 226, 314n23, 321n41

  cooperation and competition, 181–83, 214–15, 271–72

  cooperatives, 182, 214, 271

  copy machines, 208

  corporal punishment, 116–17, 147, 321n37. See also domestic violence

  Coshocton (Ohio), 8, 25–26, 178, 226

  counseling: bases of, 244

  facilities, 86, 127, 168, 244, 332n42

  training in, 243. See also mental distress

  courtship, 52, 54, 71, 73, 75, 78, 81–82, 131

  crucible, Amish culture as a, 260, 270, 272

  cultural capital, 164, 171

  “Dan” church. See affiliations: Andy Weaver

  Das Deutsch Center for Special Needs Children (DDC), 230–31

  dating, 73, 78, 81–82, 131. See also bundling; courtship

  dawdi haus, 96, 99, 104, 318n2

  death: and burial, 8–9, 254–55

  views of, 253–54, 257. See also funerals

  deer farming, 200–202

  defection, 51, 82–83

  reactions to, 91–93

  reasons for, 84–86, 161, 315n40, 316n45. See also retention

  demographic squeeze, 303n7

  Department of Labor, 194

  dependency rank, 177, 327n15

  deviance. See also drug use among Amish; Holmes County (Ohio): crime rate

  Devil’s Playground, 67

  diesel power, 107, 206–7. See also power, sources of

  diet, 135, 212, 233, 235

  differences among Amish, 22, 24, 34–37

  in family size, 99–100

  in handling youth, 68, 71–80

  in houses, 104

  interaffiliation views, 53–55

  in mission work, 60–63

  in shunning, 87–90. See also alcohol use: and affiliation; buggies: and affiliation; employment: and affiliation; farming: and affiliation; health care: and affiliation; schools, Amish: affiliation differences in; technology: and affiliation

  disaster relief, 60, 67. See also Christian Aid Ministries; Mennonite Central Committee

  diversity causes: external, 20–21, 261–63

  general, 260

  internal, 20–21, 260–61, 263

  divorce, 61, 87, 96, 98, 130

  dog raising, 200–202

  domestic violence: involving children, 97, 117

  involving spouses, 126–27

  Donnermeyer, Joseph, 74, 226, 314n23, 321n41

  Dordrecht Confession of Faith, 304n19, 315n39

  Doughty View Midwifery Center, 223

  dress. See clothing

  drug use among Amish, 67, 69–70, 74–75, 194, 313n12

  Durkheim, Emile, 23

  economic crisis, effects of, 262, 285

  education, 19, 119

  attitudes toward higher, 62, 163–65

  diversity in, 142, 170–73, 326n44

  public, 11, 153–59

  requirements, 141, 163

  special-needs, 167–70, 325n26. See also high school; homeschooling; schools, Amish

  elderly, image of, 99

  Elkhart-LaGrange (Ind.), 25, 57, 69, 103, 161, 175, 285

  employers, Amish: and Amish workers, 187–88, 193, 195–96, 204, 285

  employment: and affiliation, 191–92, 196–97, 199–200, 329n37

  in English businesses, 184–85, 192, 200

  and moral atmosphere, 184

  nonfarm, 176, 191, 197, 200–201, 285

  energy. See power, sources of

  environmental issues, 216, 287

  equality, meaning of, 129, 273–74

  evangelism, 32, 49, 59, 62, 71, 129, 312n42, 317n49

  ex-Amish. See defection

  excommunication, 38, 82–84

  and affiliation, 88–90, 93–94, 316n41, 317n51

  and baptism, 83

  families: and affiliations, 99–100

  extended, 99

  functions of, 102

  popular image of, 97–98

  and shift from farming, 97, 127–28, 140, 190

  size of, 99–100

  structure of, 98, 118–19, 123, 125, 129

  farm equipment. See horses, use of; milking machines; technology; tractors

  farmers, image of, 187–88

  farming: and accidents, 232

  and affiliation, 191–92, 197

  percentage of Amish in, 175, 197

  and personal character, 187–88

  regard for, 197–98

  shift away from, 12–13, 97, 140, 175, 187, 197

  as way of life,
13, 102, 128, 187–88

  farms: dairy, 7, 29, 191, 197, 208, 214–15

  organic, 197, 214–16, 286

  produce, 191, 199, 215

  productivity, 175

  size of, 2, 175, 190. See also farming; Holmes County (Ohio); land

  fax machines, 208, 217, 242

  fishing, 133–34, 136. See also hobbies

  Flat Ridge Elementary School, 8

  flying, 60

  Food Stamps, 178–79, 211

  foot-washing, 16

  Former Amish Reunion (FAR), 86–87

  founder effect, 229

  freedom, meaning of, 23–24, 273–74, 280–81, 283

  freindschaft. See families: extended

  funerals, 16, 102, 254, 305n25. See also death

  furniture making, 176–77, 179–83, 185, 191, 262. See also businesses

  future trends, 170, 216, 218, 284–89

  Geauga Settlement, 13, 25, 39, 117, 126, 230

  Gelassenheit, 18–19, 112, 189, 198, 272

  Gemeinde Register, 188, 251, 328n28

  gender roles, 32, 114, 118–19

  and farming, 128

  and shift from farming, 22, 127–28

  women’s views of, 121–26

  genetic diseases, 228–31, 240–41

  Gingerich, Ervin, 50

  Goffman, Erving, 270, 333n9

  government: aid from, 21, 169, 177–79, 195, 230, 234, 248, 252, 285

  regulations, 20, 187, 194, 265

  views of, 267, 276–77. See also Medicaid, participation in; Social Security

  Great Commission. See mission work

  Green Field Farms (GFF), 214–15

  greenhouses, 128, 202

  Haiti Relief Auction, 61

  health: and age, 233

  definition of, 231

  and diet, 233

  and lifestyle, 232–34

  and occupation, 242

  health care, 226–28, 230

  and affiliation, 221–22, 225–26, 228, 236, 247

  alternative medicine and, 234–38

  cost issues in, 234, 248–49

  criteria in choosing, 236, 238–39, 253

  and doctor-patient relations, 245–48

  and gender, 228, 232, 247–48, 331n12, 331n13

  and hospice, 253–54

  and immunization, 227–28

  traditional beliefs regarding, 236–38

  health care costs, 248

  and affiliation, 248–51

  paying for, 250–53

  reducing, 24

  high-context culture, 221

  higher education. See education, attitudes toward higher

  high school, 165–66

  General Equivalency Diploma (GED) certificate, 142, 166, 172

  history of Amish, 14–15

  in Ohio, 25–29

  hobbies, 133–34, 136, 322n69

  competitive sports, 135, 323n72

 

‹ Prev