Friday seemed busier than usual at the diner, but I was okay with that; it kept my mind off of JT and what was going to happen tonight. We sent a few texts back and forth throughout the day, but neither of us mentioned what was about to happen.
I finally closed up the diner and made it back to the cottage around four in the afternoon. JT had sent me a text earlier, warning me he might be late again because they had a big job come in. I was disappointed, but totally understood. His dad only had JT, and he had to be there for him.
I took an extra long shower, trying to loosen up my tense muscles. I shaved my legs carefully and laughed at myself. I was as bad as a sixteen-year-old girl who was about to lose her virginity. I didn’t have a ton of past partners, but I wasn’t lacking experience when it came to sex. Why was I so nervous about sleeping with JT?
Because I loved him. There. I admitted it. I loved JT. Should I tell him tonight? What if he didn’t say it back? I didn’t want him to think I was confusing sex and love.
I got dressed in shorts and a tank top after my shower, throwing my hair up into a messy bun on top of my head. I poured myself a glass of wine to help me relax and went out on the dock to wait for him.
I was almost done with my wine when I heard his truck pull up to the cottage. I swore the butterflies went into overdrive when they heard the rumbling sounds of his truck. I waited on the dock for him and could hear his footsteps getting closer.
“Hey you, sorry I’m late.” He sat down next to me on the bench and leaned over for a kiss. He was wearing a faded grey t-shirt and his camo shorts. His hair was damp from a shower, and he had decided to forgo the baseball cap tonight.
“That’s okay.” I smiled up at him.
“Got started without me?” He nodded to the empty glass of wine.
“Yep, I needed to relax.”
He put an arm around me and pulled me into him. “Why did you need to relax?”
“It’s crazy, but I’m nervous about tonight,” I admitted in a small voice.
“Me too.”
“We should go with the flow and let things happen naturally, right? That’s why we’re so good.”
“True.” He rubbed my shoulder. “That’s one of the reasons I love you; you’re so easy to be with. I can be me and don’t have to pretend or play any games.”
I sat forward and looked at him. “Did you say you love me?”
His cheeks got red and he started stammering. “Yeah, I guess I did. It’s true, though.”
“I love you too.”
He smiled, and all of my nerves and tension melted away. I stood up and lifted my tank top over my head. I wasn’t wearing a bra, and the look on his face was priceless when he saw my naked breasts.
“What are you doing?”
I unbuttoned my jeans and slid them off of my hips. They pooled at my feet, revealing my black lacey thong. I stepped out of them and stood in front of him. “Let’s go skinny dipping.”
He groaned and slid a hand up my thigh. “God, you have the sexiest panties,” he murmured and hooked his thumbs in the waistband. He pulled them from me painfully slowly. When I was totally naked in front of him, he stood up and kissed my lips softly. “You’re so beautiful, Kara.”
“Thanks.” I smiled and turned around, diving into the water head first. I came up for air to find him still standing on the dock.
“What are you doing?” I called out to him. “Get your clothes off and get your naked ass in here!”
“Yes, ma’am,” he laughed and began to strip. Soon he jumped in and swam to me, pulling me against him. The water was shallow enough for us to stand up, but deep enough to hide our naked bodies from any curious onlookers at the nearby cottages. His erection was pressed against my stomach, and I ached for him to be inside me.
We kissed and I wrapped my legs around him, the head of his cock probing my entrance. “JT,” I whispered. “I want you.”
“Are you on birth control?” he asked, breathing hard. We’d had weeks of foreplay between us and were both more than ready to consummate this relationship. We could be slow later; right now, I wanted him buried deep.
“Yes. And I’m clean.”
“Me too,” he groaned, as my hand encircled his cock and slowly guided it inside me. My head fell back with a moan, and he leaned forward to nibble on my neck as my body adjusted to his invasion. Fuck, he felt even better than I had imagined all of those nights alone in my bed.
When he was all the way in, he cupped my ass in his hands and held me still as he thrust in and out of me. I adjusted the angle of my hips slightly so his pubic bone was bumping my clit. I leaned back in the water far enough for him to capture a nipple in his mouth. When he sucked on it gently, I exploded around his cock, biting my lip so I didn’t cry out.
He pulled me back up so we were facing each other. “That’s it,” he urged me. “Come all over my cock.”
He started pumping harder, clutching me tight. He buried his face in my neck and thrust one more time before whispering my name and releasing deep inside me. We held each other tight until we came down from the high of our climaxes.
“That was definitely worth the wait,” he murmured and kissed my lips softly, staying inside me.
“For sure,” I agreed, wondering if he could hear how hard my heart was beating in my chest.
“Now that we got that out of the way, let’s go inside so I can make love to you properly.” He gave me a sly smile and moved towards the dock, holding onto me.
“Sounds good to me.” It was still fairly light out, and I wasn’t sure about making it to the cottage naked without someone seeing us. “How about you throw on some shorts and go inside to get some towels?”
“Sure.” He untangled himself from me and climbed up on the dock. I admired his tight ass the whole time, thinking how I would love to sink my teeth into it later. He pulled on his shorts and turned around, catching me watching him.
“I’ll be right back.” He winked at me and walked back up towards the cottage.
I sighed contentedly while I waited for him to return. While I hadn’t imagined our first time would be in the water, it seemed fitting and it certainly was hot. If that had been a small taste of the sparks between us, I couldn’t wait for more.
“Hurry up,” I called impatiently. I needed him again already, and I had a feeling I would never be able to get enough.
Chapter Eight
JT
“Night That You’ll Never Forget”
Holy shit.
I had to walk up to the cottage carefully so I didn’t fall over. My knees were still trembling from what had just happened–a few firsts for me: the first time I had sex in the water, the first time it ever felt like that, and the first time it happened with someone I loved.
I heard her call to me to hurry up, and I chuckled. Oh, I planned to get her back to the cottage and do all sorts of dirty things to her. I didn’t intend for our first time to go so quickly. I wanted to take my time, but I guess the past few weeks had been taking our time. We were so consumed with our need for each other we couldn’t wait anymore.
My cock stirred again, thinking about the way she responded to my touch. Underneath that cool exterior, she was a little sex kitten. I couldn’t wait to unleash more of it. I swelled with pride, knowing that no one else here knew this side of her and she reserved it only for me. I planned to take full advantage of it.
I found the towels and grabbed them before heading back out to her. When she saw me, she flashed me that smile that made my heart melt. “It’s about time,” she teased, and I shook my head with a grin. She was so sassy sometimes, but I loved that about her.
I held out a towel to conceal her while she climbed out of the water. I wrapped it tightly around her and leaned down to kiss her forehead. “Let’s go inside,” I said quietly and put my arm around her shoulder, leading her to the cottage. Neither of us said a word, but the desire was thick in the air.
I helped her inside and she turned around to fac
e me and dropped her towel. The moonlight shimmered in the window, revealing her gorgeous naked body. I didn’t get a very good look at it in the water, so I stopped to admire it for a minute. Her breasts were high and firm, a perfect handful, and her nipples were tight peaks of desire. Her legs were long and firm, and I remembered her mentioning a few times she was a runner, although she hadn’t had much time to run since she’d been here.
I leaned down and ran my tongue over one breast while my hand found and cupped the other one. She whimpered softly and put her arms around my neck. I sucked a nipple into my mouth, and she threaded her hands in my hair with a sigh. “JT, make love to me,” she pleaded. I reached between us and ran my finger along her folds, excited to find her already swollen from her need for me.
Those simple words ignited my already burning desire for her. Who was I to refuse her when she said my name and made a request like that? I stood up, and she whimpered in disappointment when my mouth left her body. Soon enough I would be kissing her all over. I didn’t plan to leave any inch of skin untouched.
I lifted her easily into my arms, and she rested her head against my chest. I carried her down the hallway, and she pointed to the first door. The door wasn’t shut tight, so I pushed it open slowly with my foot. Her room had a perfect view of the lake and, when I set her down gently on the bed, her body was bathed in the moonlight.
I stood at the edge of the bed, my eyes on hers while I removed my shorts. I knelt on the bed between her knees, and she propped herself up on one elbow. I pressed my forehead against hers. “I love you, Kara,” I said, my voice thick with desire.
She smiled and reached to touch my face. “I love you too, JT.”
I covered her mouth with mine, kissing her deeply. She tried to wrap herself around me so I could slip inside of her, but she was going to have to wait for that. My body was more than ready for her, but I wanted to touch and taste her more.
My lips moved down to her neck, nibbling and sucking until she was panting beneath me. Next I paid attention to each of her breasts, licking the nipples until they were so hard that she was whimpering and arching her back off the bed with need.
I almost lost my resolve; I wanted to sink deep inside her right then. Instead, I moved between her legs and put my hands on the inside of her thighs. I spread them wide for me, biting back a groan when I saw how wet and swollen she was for me.
Leaning forward, I ran my tongue along her. She cried out and clutched the bed sheets. I licked again, this time slower. My mouth continued its assault on her, my lips finally finding her clit and sucking it into my mouth. I slipped two fingers inside of her at the same time, and soon she was crying out my name and exploding with her climax.
When the last tremor left her, I kissed the inside of her thigh gently and moved back up her body. She took my face in both of her hands and kissed me hard. Damn, that was hot.
She tore her lips from mine. “JT, please. I need you inside me now.”
This time I didn’t refuse her. I took my cock in my hand and slowly guided it into her, closing my eyes and moaning as her wet heat surrounded me. I could get lost in her forever.
We moved as one, staring into each other’s eyes. I loved to watch her desire dance in those brown eyes of hers. I slipped a hand in between us, and my thumb pressed against her swollen nub. She moaned and nodded; from the way she was twitching and pulsing around me, I knew she was going to come soon.
I bent my head down and found a nipple. I bathed it with my tongue and, when I put the edge of my teeth on it, she tensed and called out my name. She shook under me from the force of her orgasm. Her pussy milked my cock with each wave of pleasure, and soon I was tumbling over the edge of my climax along with her. I called out her name, my voice a loud whisper.
I couldn’t believe it, but the second time was even better than the first. I bet each time I had sex with Kara it would get better and better. I had been with my fair share of women, even a couple of times with more than one, but nothing compared to the way it felt to be with her. I finally knew what the expression “making love” means.
I eventually rolled off of her, keeping an arm around her shoulder and holding her tight against me. She flung a leg over mine and put her arm across my waist. She snuggled into me, and I swore I heard her purr with satisfaction like a cat.
“That was amazing,” she said, finally breaking the silence.
“That doesn’t even describe it,” I replied, rubbing her arm with my hand. I didn’t want to ruin the moment, but I had been thinking about what might happen to us when she went back to Madison. “When do you go back to Madison?” I asked tentatively.
Her body tensed against me, and I knew she had been thinking about the same thing. “I don’t know. I will know more when Grandma and Grandpa get back tomorrow. The doctor is going to give them a time frame for when Grandpa can spend more time on his feet.”
“Oh.” I didn’t know what else to say. Would I be selfish to ask her to stay? She had a whole other life in Madison–one I was pretty sure didn’t have a place for me.
She sat up and swung a leg over me so she was straddling me. Her pussy was right over my cock, and it immediately came back to life. “Let’s not talk about that tonight. Tomorrow we can, but tonight let’s just enjoy each other.”
She circled her hips on me, and my eyes rolled back into my head with pleasure. “Baby, when you’re on top of me like that, you can do whatever you want,” I panted.
She got up on her knees and grabbed my erection, impaling herself on it. “Good to know,” she replied breathlessly as she began to ride me. I let her use my body, moving any way she wanted to get her pleasure from me. I played with her nipples, twisting and pinching them slightly between my thumb and forefinger. She soon came hard, calling out my name. I wasn’t far behind, holding her down tight against me while my own orgasm ripped through me.
There wasn’t much sleep to be had the rest of the night. After waiting so long to have sex, we were both insatiable. Things got a little interesting, and we ended up doing it in the shower a couple of times and even on the kitchen counter. We laughed so hard when we cleaned it off, picturing her grandma’s face if she knew what we had done where she loved to cook.
Around four in the morning, Kara got up, wrapped in a blanket, and made us a pot of coffee. We took our mugs and went out onto the dock to watch the sunrise.
“I don’t want you to leave,” I finally admitted. “I love you and want to see where this is going. I know we weren’t going to talk about it, but I want you to know that.”
She nodded and took a sip of her coffee. “Thanks for telling me how you feel.”
She didn’t say anything else, and I was worried she didn’t feel the same. I wanted her to tell me she didn’t want to go, either, and would stay here so we could be together.
I set my mug down on the table next to us. I took hers and did the same. I pulled her onto my lap and positioned us so we were still wrapped in our blankets but with her straddling me. I touched her face with my fingertips. “I want to make love to you again out here as the sun comes up. This is where it all began.”
She bit her lip and nodded, moving so I slid inside of her easily. We held each other tight, and she buried her face in my neck. She was grinding her hips against me, and I could tell from her rapid breathing she was getting close to release.
“Come with me, baby,” I whispered, my lips on her ear and my hot breath against her skin.
She nodded again and let out a harsh breath when she released. I soon followed, thrusting hard up into her and holding onto her when I came deep inside her.
I heard a sniffle come from her and moved so I could look at her face. Tears were streaming down her cheeks. “What’s wrong?” I asked, concerned that I had hurt her.
“I don’t want to leave you,” she hiccupped. “I love you.”
“Baby, I love you too.” I reached up and wiped the tears away. “Don’t worry, we’ll figure it out. I’m not going to l
et you get away from me.”
She smiled and took a shaky breath. I gave her a confident smile, but on the inside I was worried. What future did this country boy have with a city girl?
Chapter Nine
Kara
“Fallin’ For You”
I was almost late opening the diner on Saturday morning, thanks to JT and his antics in the shower. He dropped me off, and we made plans for him to come get me later.
He kissed me softly before I got out of his truck. “Thanks for last night.” He kissed me again. “And this morning.” He grinned, and I couldn’t help but laugh.
“I feel like I should be thanking you. But I’m going to be so tired today with no sleep.” This time I kissed him. “Totally worth it, though.”
A few cars pulled into the parking lot, and I reluctantly pulled away from him. “I have to go before I have angry customers.”
“I’ll pick you up at three. Just call or text if you need me sooner.” He had to work at the shop today like he did every Saturday.
“I will.” I was reaching for the door handle when he put a hand on my arm to stop me.
“I love you, Kara.”
A shiver went up and down my spine. I think I would never get tired of hearing him say that. “I love you too, JT. But I have to go now.”
“I know,” he laughed. “See you later.”
I opened the door and jumped out of the truck, rushing to unlock the door of the diner. I turned on the lights and got a few things ready before turning the open sign on. The place was quickly filled with customers, and I had no time to even think about JT.
Around mid-morning, I took a break so I could send JT a text. I hadn’t looked at my phone since last night, and I wasn’t surprised to see a few texts from Brittany and a couple of voicemails from Grandma. I even had one from my parents.
I sent JT a quick text to let him know I missed him and then listened to my voicemails. I almost dropped the phone when I heard the one from my parents. It was my mother who mentioned they were coming to visit today. Shit! They wanted to talk to me about coming back home.
Play It Again Page 5