I don’t know how long I was asleep when I was awakened by the sound of voices shouting and the doorbell ringing. A doorbell is an unnecessary addition when you have a large dog. Sam’s baritone bark almost drowned out the doorbell. I leapt out of bed and peered out the window. I saw car lights everywhere.
Sam and I approached the front door gingerly. “Who is it? What do you want?” I shouted.
“Mary, it’s Marco. Open up.”
I threw open the door. Marco and one of his Pit Bulls were holding a bloody Franklin Fieldstone. Another of the beefy Pit Bulls was standing behind them.
“We caught him in the act, Mary. The dumb bastard was trying to fit a key into your front door. We had to rough him up a little. He resisted our assistance in removing him from your front step,” Marco said winking at me.
Frank was dressed in black slacks and a black tee shirt. His nose was dropping bloody pools down the front of the shirt.
“Isn’t the hour a bit late for paying me a visit?” I said. “So it has been you that turned into a stalker.”
“You tell these bozos to get their hands off me or I’ll call the police,” Frank said.
“Oh, yeah, good idea. Then we can report Mary’s slashed tire, broken window, and vandalized house. They’ll enjoy charging a high-priced lawyer with burglary,” Marco said.
“Frank, why are you doing this? You know I could report you to the police and see that you’re charged with multiple felonies. Why would you risk your reputation?” I asked.
“Well, obviously, because I care about you,” Frank said.
“Some way to show you care,” Marco said as he gave Frank’s arm a good twist.
“I think what you really care about isn’t me. It’s that you couldn’t get your own way for once. A good lawyer left your firm and beat you in court and in the ethics proceeding. You just can’t stand to lose at anything, and to be beaten by a mere woman was just too much. Maybe calling the police is a good idea,” I said. “Marco, go ahead and call Coral Gables P.D.”
“Now wait a minute,” Frank said. For a minute, I thought he was going to cry.
“Look, buddy,” Marco said, “if you will cut out this crap and leave Mary alone, we’ll let these criminal acts slide for now. But if you so much as come near her again, Mary will file charges. My employees and I will be watching. Before you go to jail, you’ll need a trip to the hospital. Got it?”
“I can’t believe you’d hire a bunch of guys like this,” Frank said.
“Well, I can’t believe you’d turn into a common stalker,” I said. “Are you going to agree to leave me alone?”
“If that’s what you want, okay then,” Frank said.
Marco escorted Frank to his car, which was parked across the street. Sam continued to growl until the car pulled away. Then I invited Marco and the Pit Bulls in for a celebratory beer.
CHAPTER THIRTY-ONE
Monday morning arrived with the clock radio announcing that it was six a.m., and that a heavy fog covered all of Miami-Dade County. My head was certainly in tune with the weather. Fog covered my eyes and brain. I took Sam for a run to the Miracle Mile, ordered the strongest cup of caffeine at Starbucks, and grabbed the morning Herald.
The headline shouted SUSPECTED SPOUSE KILLER AWAITS HEARING. A picture of Lillian and me leaving the courthouse after the last hearing exploded under the headline. I looked like a self-satisfied cat with a mouse in tow, and Lillian looked like the mouse. I had her by the arm as she cowered from the photographers. No one viewing that photo would believe she was a killer. I hoped Judge Arnold read the paper before court. Most judges do, to see if their name is there or if their colleagues are getting more publicity than they are. This is a product of judges being elected every six years.
The article reviewed the murder and the background of the players: prominent family, CEO of local company, well-known charitable givers. Nothing harmful to Lillian, and no mention of Maddie. The good part of practicing law in Miami is that there are so many murders and corruption trials that the paper doesn’t have time to dig into each one.
I returned home to shower and do my hair. I decided on a white suit. White always denotes the good guys and it’s also the color choice of the Santerias, the Cuban religious group based on voodoo and magic. Not that I’m superstitious, but it’s best to cover all the bases.
Catherine had more coffee ready at the office. “Brett called early to see if you were picking them up again,” she said. He sounded a little rattled. I didn’t know if you’d have time to go all the way over there, so I called Marco’s security office and asked them to provide a car and driver. The Yarmouths can certainly afford it. Lillian’s been paying your fees the instant she gets the bills. Was it okay that I arranged the car?”
“That was good thinking. It gives me more time to go over everything in my trial boxes. Let’s make sure that I have every folder for each witness. Do I have a time set to speak to each of them before the hearing?”
Catherine handed me the list. “I reserved the attorney interview room on the third floor like you asked, and all the witnesses know the room number.”
“Good. We’ll keep them away from the courtroom until I call them to testify. You’ll be in charge of moving them up to the sixth floor. This’ll be a real help.”
Catherine was excited about being on the scene. I noticed that she had tied her hair back and was wearing a pantsuit for the occasion instead of her usual jeans and sneakers outfit. But she still had the humongous backpack that went everywhere with her.
We loaded the boxes of notes and witness folders into the SUV along with the box of yellow pads, pens, paper clips, and an envelope with the photos of Maddie.
“What do you have in that backpack?” My curiosity took precedence over good manners.
“Oh, just a few things. Power bars, a water bottle, some pictures, cookies that I baked last night, some good-luck charms. Just the usual kind of stuff,” she said.
I smiled at this wonder woman. There was nothing usual about Catherine.
We arrived at the courthouse two hours before the hearing, well ahead of the press. Catherine and I loaded our boxes onto a wheely cart and got them into the attorney interview room. Then we went back down to the front entrance to meet Lillian and her kids.
Marco’s black SUV pulled up to the curb. I was surprised to see that Marco himself was the driver. He hopped out and helped the Yarmouths out. While I was shaking hands and kissing cheeks with Lillian and her kids, I realized that Marco was having a whispered chat with Catherine, who was blushing. Maybe the reason for Catherine’s attractive outfit wasn’t for her apearance in court, but for being courted by the head Pit Bull.
I led Lillian into the courthouse followed by Brett and Sherry. Catherine brought up the rear. We hurried them upstairs to a witness waiting room out of the reach of the press and public. It was almost time for the show to begin. I was running on nervous energy. I couldn’t imagine how Lillian could look so cool. She seemed totally calm. It could be a show for her children, or maybe she was used to stifling her emotions. Her appearance was completely different than it had been in the weeks right after Gary’s murder.
Promptly at one-thirty, Lillian and I took our seats at the defense table. All four prosecutors crowded around the State’s table. They huddled together whispering. They were shocked when Catherine and I wheeled our boxes and files into the courtroom and began assembling the witness folders on the table behind us. The State appeared to have only one small box of papers. I had to choke back the urge to laugh or high-five Catherine. They hadn’t done their homework.
Judge Arnold took his seat on the bench. “Good afternoon, State and Defense. Are all parties ready to proceed with the preliminary hearing?”
“Yes, Your Honor,” I said. “I would like to introduce my paralegal, Catherine Aynsworth. May I have the court’s permission for her to assist me this afternoon? She will be helping me with my files, and bringing my witnesses into the courtroom.”
>
The judge nodded his assent.
“Witnesses, Your Honor?” Karl Morris was on his feet, his voice rising to a high squeak. “The State was never informed of any witnesses.”
“Well, Your Honor, I revoked my demand for reciprocal discovery. The State dragged their feet so long in turning over any witnesses or documents that I decided to forego discovery, so I don’t know who their witnesses are either,” I paused to take a breath.
“Judge, we sent her the initial police report.”
“I could have gotten that on my own, Judge. That brief report was all I ever got.”
“Okay, Counsel, looks like we’ll all see the witnesses together in a few minutes,” Judge Arnold said. “State are you ready to proceed with your first witness?”
“No, Your Honor. Ms. McIver, who is the case-law expert on our team, wishes to argue a motion, objecting to having a preliminary hearing in this case.” Lois McIver got to her feet and headed toward the lectern. She was carrying a stack of cases.
I was on my feet before she made it to the lectern. “Judge, this motion is too late. Today is the day of the hearing. The State has had over three weeks to file and argue such a motion. Additionally, I have several cases to pass up to the court showing that Mrs. Yarmouth has every right to this hearing, especially in light of the fact that no discovery will be exchanged.”
“Ms. McIver, have a seat. I have researched the law in this area myself. I am satisfied that I have made the right decision. You have had ample time to appeal my decision. You haven’t done so, so let’s get on with the hearing. How many witnesses will you be calling, Mr. Morris?”
“Probably two or three,” Morris answered.
“And you, Ms. Katz?”
“About the same number, Judge.”
“Then let’s get going. I like to have dinner before breakfast. State, call your first witness.”
“The State calls Detective Harry Fonseca.”
The bailiff went through the double doors into the hallway and bellowed for the detective. He entered behind the bailiff, walking with a slight swagger. He was dressed in his best courtroom apparel, dark pin-striped suit, white shirt, red tie, all of which covered his tattoos.
While the clerk was swearing in the detective, a young woman entered and motioned for one of the prosecutors to approach. I recognized her as one of the secretaries in the state attorney’s office. Charlene Montavo came to the bar that separates the public area from the well of the court. The secretary handed her a note. Charlene read it and dashed over to Karl, who was at the lectern ready to begin his questioning. Karl looked at the note, frowned, wrote something on it, and Charlene rushed back to the secretary who hurried out of the courtroom.
Catherine was seated beside me. “Go out and see if you can find out what’s up with the State,” I whispered. She moved out right behind the State’s secretary.
Karl looked confused. He shuffled his notes and began questioning the detective.
“State your name and occupation, sir.”
“Harry Fonseca, detective, Homicide Division, Miami Police Department.”
“And how long have you been so employed?”
“I’ve been with the department eight years. I was a patrol officer for two years, a general detective for one year, then I was assigned to robbery for three years, and two years ago I moved to homicide.”
“Have you received any special education for your position?”
“I graduated from the police academy eight years ago, and I took a fingerprint course three years ago.”
“Were you assigned to investigate the murder of Gary Yarmouth on February 8th?”
“Yes, I was assigned as the lead investigator.”
“And what duties does the lead investigator have?”
Judge Arnold interrupted. “There’s no jury here, Mr. Morris. I don’t need to hear an explanation of what work the police do or don’t do. Just get to the meat of this thing.”
“Yes, Your Honor. Detective, when did you arrive at the Yarmouth residence and what did you observe when you arrived?”
I got there around four fifteen or so. I talked briefly to the first officers on the scene. They had placed Mrs. Yarmouth, the defendant, in the living room. She was seated on a sofa, crying. Her clothes were bloody. There were no signs of a break-in. The front and back doors were unlocked and the alarm system was disengaged. I went upstairs and saw the deceased lying across a bed. One of the officers handed me an evidence bag containing a silver letter opener with a six-inch sharp blade.”
Karl picked up a plastic bag and brought it to our table.
“Any objection to the introduction of this letter opener?” Karl asked.
“It’s fine. No objection,” I said, standing up, hoping to shield Lillian’s eyes from the weapon.
“Okay, Counsel. It’s entered,” said Judge Arnold.
“State’s exhibit one in evidence,” the clerk said as she stamped the evidence bag.
“Was anyone else present in the house?” Karl continued his questioning.
“Just the officers. The emergency medical personnel had already left. The people from the medical examiner’s office arrived shortly after I did. They made some notes and removed the body.”
“Did you talk to the defendant?”
“Of course. I asked her if she had been home all day. She said she had been out shopping. I asked her if she and her husband had been arguing. There was a chair overturned in the bedroom. She kept saying that she loved him. I asked her who owned the letter opener. She said it was hers, that it had been her grandmother’s. I asked her where she kept it. She said on her writing table in the bedroom.”
“Were you able to find any other witnesses to talk to?”
“One of the officers spoke to a neighbor, I believe. May I look at my report? I can’t remember who that was, but I do remember that it didn’t lead us anywhere.”
“You may refresh your recollection from the report.”
Detective Fonseca glanced through some papers. “Oh, yes, the next door neighbor claimed that she saw Mrs. Yarmouth drive into her garage that afternoon. She also saw a woman walking down the street, but she got in a car parked two doors away.”
“What else did you do that afternoon?”
“I arrested Lillian Yarmouth and charged her with the murder. It was a clear open-and-shut case. She was taken to the women’s detention center.”
“Now did you do any further investigation in the case?”
“Yes. I talked to people at the deceased’s place of business and I examined some credit card bills and phone records belonging to the deceased. There were hotel bills in New York and locally. There was also a telephone number called numerous times on his cell phone. We retrieved the name of the person whose number was called. It belonged to a woman named Maddie Rodriguez. We located her and my partner and I interviewed her. She admitted that—”
“Objection, Your Honor. This is hearsay,” I said.
“Well, it’s part of his investigation,” Karl replied.
“Judge, it doesn’t matter what it’s part of. It’s still hearsay. It’s what someone said outside of this courtroom.”
“It is hearsay, Mr. Morris. Does it fall under any exception to the hearsay rule?” Judge Arnold asked.
“May we come sidebar?” Karl asked. He looked agitated.
The judge nodded and gestured us forward. We gathered around the judge and the court reporter.
“I have a slight problem,” Karl whispered. He gestured for the other prosecutors to join him.
“It must be more than a slight problem, if Mr. Morris needs to call out this army,” I said.
The judge smiled. “What is the problem, sir?”
We were prepared to call Ms. Rodriguez as a witness today, but we have been unable to locate her. My co-counsel have been checking with our investigator to see if she has been located. That’s why I called them up here.”
Charlene Montavo stepped into our huddle. “Yo
ur Honor, we have been on the phone with the investigator. He has checked her work and her home and no one has seen her since yesterday. We are searching for her car and any other clues to her whereabouts, but at this time it seems she is unavailable, or has made herself unavailable.”
“So, Judge, her statements would fall under the exception of unavailability, and I could then inquire as to what she told the detective,” Karl said.
“I have no objection to this as long as I am afforded the same leeway in questioning my witnesses and cross-examining their witnesses,” I said.
“Okay, done,” said the judge. “Proceed, Counsel.”
“Detective Fonseca, what did you learn when you interviewed Maddie Rodriguez?”
“She admitted to having an affair with Gary Yarmouth over the preceding months. She further stated that she was sure that Lillian Yarmouth knew about the affair, and had been trying to get Gary to break it off, but Gary was committed to continuing the romance and divorcing his wife.”
“Did you do any other work in this case?”
“Other than writing some reports, no. We were sure that we correctly closed this case.”
“Thank you, Detective.” Karl took his seat.
I moved to the lectern, ready to cross-examine the detective, just as Catherine hurried back into the court room.
“May I have a moment with my paralegal, Judge?”
I moved back to the table where Catherine whispered to me, “Maddie Rodriguez has disappeared. The State is going nuts trying to find her. I overheard the secretary on her cell phone with someone, it must have been one of their investigators. It sounded like he went to Palm Beach to pick her up for court and she was gone.”
“I just found that out. She must have split before she got charged with the murder,” I said. Catherine and I looked at each other and smiled.
“Detective Fonseca, did you ever follow up with the neighbor who saw a woman running away from the Yarmouth house?” I began my cross-examination.
“Well, no, I read the patrol officer’s notes, and it didn’t seem important.”
Fatal February Page 13