by Aaron Polson
“Why didn’t you go with Ben?” she asked.
“Ben? Sometimes I really hate that bastard. I didn’t want to punch him. I mean, how the hell can the guy fall asleep after hitting the ditch?”
“He was asleep before hitting the ditch,” Sarah said.
Johnny nodded. “True. Besides, I didn’t want to leave any of the women alone.”
Kelsey crossed her arms. Now wasn’t the time to show her hand. “How chivalrous.”
“Don’t go all feminista on me.” Johnny shrugged. “We don’t even know who lives here—hell, Farmer Bob could be asleep upstairs. Maybe he’s an ax murderer. This damn house must be at least four or five thousand square feet. Three stories and a basement by the looks of the foundation. Huge. Maybe he is asleep upstairs. Maybe he knows we’re here, and the old guy’s watching.”
Kelsey shivered. “Stop playing. You’re giving me the creepy-crawlies. Why do you call him an old guy, anyway?”
“Just a feeling.”
“Yeah. Me too. The feeling.” Kelsey rubbed her arms. The air had dropped a few degrees, but there wasn’t a draft. If anything the room was dead. “Maybe it’s the jitters after the accident, but I don’t like this place.”
“Definitely has a vibe.” Johnny moved closer to Kelsey. His blue eyes locked onto hers. He held out a hand. “We won’t be here long.”
She hesitated, her breath catching in her throat, and then took his hand. The skin was cool and ruff, not warm like she’d expected. Maybe it was the room. Maybe the chill was in the house itself. “We should look, too.”
Johnny turned toward the hallway. “The basement, wherever it is?”
“I don’t want to, but—”
The scream stopped Kelsey’s words before they left her mouth. Sarah’s scream. Kelsey didn’t think again until she was, following Johnny, halfway up the stairs. They rounded the landing, hurtled the final flight, spilling into the darkened second story hallway. Dim, yellowish light filtered from a window at one end. Down the other direction, a black figure waved.
“Down here!” Ben called.
Kelsey’s eyes adjusted to the darkened hallway, but she couldn’t see Sarah. Johnny trotted in front. He didn’t seem to be afraid—not like she was. Why was her heart rattling in her chest? Why did she feel like she couldn’t breathe? Ben moved back, further into the hallway. Johnny stepped through the doorway to which Ben had been pointing. He wheeled and tried to grab Kelsey, but too late.
She gasped. “Oh my God.” Her hands covered her mouth, but she couldn’t shut her eyes.
A man lay in a half-filled bathtub. His near-white hair clung close to his pinkish scalp, but was not wet. Although his hair showed old age’s silver-grey, the lack of lines on his face told a much younger story. His dead eyes stared at them, almost as though he’d been watching the door when he died. Almost as though he’d been waiting for them. In his left hand, draped as it was over the tub’s edge, he held a knife, the folding type which held utility blades used in construction. Thick gashes marred both wrists, a disordered criss-crossing of cuts. His right arm stretched along the far edge of the tub and wore a slash from the base of his hand to mid forearm. The cuts on the left were much smaller.
Sarah whimpered from the corner. Johnny stepped inside and pulled her to him, pressing her face against his chest. “There’s no blood,” she muttered.
“Bullshit,” Ben said. He’d closed in behind Kelsey, blocking the door.
Sarah pushed away from Johnny’s chest and glared at Ben. Her voice became firm, almost angry. “No blood. There’s no God-damned blood.”
Kelsey’s body turned to ice as she hunted—but didn’t find—a single drop. The few inches of bathwater in the tub were clear despite the old man being fully clothed. The linoleum floor reflected a small, sunny patch from the window but was otherwise unmarred.
“No blood at all.”
Part 1: The Cast
Chapter 1: Kelsey
Kelsey hated the club.
She hated the noise, the sweat-slicked men bumping and grabbing and oozing all over her. She hated the way the throbbing beat worked into her brain, and how she woke the morning after a dancing with the beat still pounding in her blood. She knew these were things a fit, attractive, twenty-seven-year-old woman was supposed to like.
But she didn’t.
She went to Tremors with Brit and Caitlin because she didn’t want to be alone, not after the dreams came back. Jared had haunted her dreams for the past week, Jared and the dead man with no blood. Even during waking hours, if Kelsey closed her eyes, the puckered-white flesh of the dead man’s gashes blinked in her memory. It haunted her more than the wreck, but Jared’s disappearance and the dull ached it caused weighed more than the dead man.
Nearly five years later, and the dreams were as bad as they’d ever been.
Even though she hated it, the club banished demons better than graduate studies ever had—much better than Human Lifespan Development or Principles of Testing and Measurement. A PhD in psychology seemed rather meaningless after what happened in the house. The world felt rather purposeless after Jared vanished without a trace.
“Hey, Kels? Where are you?” Brit asked. She’d been Kelsey’s friend since high school and still wore her dark hair past shoulder length. Kelsey had always thought of Brit—short for Brittany—as pretty, but in a vaguely Eastern European and mysterious way.
“Sorry,” Kelsey said. “Sorry… Just thinking.”
Brit flashed her news-desk-perfect teeth. “You need more booze, girlie.” She pushed a plastic cup filled with bright green liquid across the table. “This isn’t the time for thinking. It’s the time for drinking and getting stupid.”
Kelsey looked at the cup. The drink, whatever it was, glowed like radioactive Kool-Aid in a bad science fiction movie. Her eyebrows rose.
“Chill out. It’s a Midori Sour. Tastes like a Jolly Rancher but numbs the worry center.” Brit’s forefinger tapped her temple. “You’ve got way too much on your brain, sweetie. I don’t know why you’d want to stuff your pretty little head with all that psychobabble anyway.”
“It’s not that.”
Brit nodded. “Right.”
She shook her hair, and long black strands flopped over her shoulders. Her eyes—almost as dark as her hair—drilled through bone, mining Kelsey’s secret thoughts. At least Kelsey felt she was. They’d been friends for a long time, true, but Brit hadn’t gone on the ski trip. Brit hadn’t clutched the door handle in Johnny’s SUV while the vehicle spun out of control and landed in a ditch. She hadn’t felt the brutal, numbing cold from the snow, the endless white blanket which plagued them to the porch, which forced them inside. She wasn’t the one to find the dead man, wrists splayed open in his bathtub. She didn’t lose Jared.
“Earth to Kelsey. I’ve lost you again. Go on and take a drink.”
Kelsey touched the cold plastic cup. She brought it to her lips and took a drink. The alcohol was cool and sweet and sour as it washed over her tongue. It warmed her chest as it slid down her throat. Maybe she did need to loosen up and get, as Brit so eloquently said, stupid. Maybe she needed to bury the past and try and forget Jared, forget the house, and forget the dead man. Just dreams… Dreams and bad memories. She closed her eyes and took another sip. It did taste a bit like a Jolly Rancher.
“Watermelon,” Kelsey said.
“You like?”
Kelsey smiled. “I like. Let’s dance.”
Bodies shook and cavorted on the dance floor, all awash with flashing lights. Throbbing music—a pop tune with relentless, pounding beat—swayed arms and legs in unison. Kelsey followed Brit to an empty corner, and both joined the frenzy. Kelsey’s eyes roved the crowd. Even at twenty-seven, she was toward the upper age limit at Tremors. Some faces looked like children—a few might have been students from the abnormal psychology lecture for which she was the teaching assistant.
Three men—boys, Kelsey thought—in matching silver silk shirts made their way thr
ough the crowded dance floor. Each carried a plastic cup and faux-danced so as not to spill. Sweat slicked their faces so each sparkled under the bright, flickering lights. Kelsey watched them as she shuffled her feet. Some malaise and inhibition sloughed from her skin as she let the beat take her body. She hated the club, but Brit was right about one thing. She needed to let loose, get stupid. She hated the club, but dancing felt good.
She leaned close to Brit. “Those three are on the move. I think they’re looking for wounded members of the herd.”
Brit laughed. “The lead is cute. Kind of. But his nose.” She scowled and shook her head so her hair spun from side to side.
“It’s huge,” Kelsey said.
“You know what they say about boys with big noses.” Brit ran her hands down her body, rolling her eyes in mock ecstasy.
As they both laughed, Caitlin, the shortest of the three, joined them. Kelsey felt Caitlin had the best body, busty but lithe with just enough ass to shake. Her blue eyes were monstrous, near Anime size, and hair in dirty blonde ropes offered a sweet, innocent disguise. Caitlin was always happy and Kelsey a little jealous.
“I thought I’d lost you two.”
The music shifted. The three silver-shirted boys danced toward them.
“I’m taking a break,” Kelsey said.
“Me too. I need another drink.” Brit grabbed Caitlin by the wrist.
“What?” Caitlin’s alcohol-slick eyes were on the boys in silver.
“We don’t want to lose you to the wolf pack.”
The three friends skirted to the crowded dance floor’s edge. Caitlin craned her neck to watch the boys in silver. Kelsey fell into her chair, suddenly feeling very tired.
“You two want anything? Another Midori Sour?”
Kelsey shook her head. “I’m good, thanks.”
“I could use another screwdriver.” Caitlin held out her half-empty glass. “Pretty please.”
Brit rolled her eyes and headed for the bar.
Caitlin pulled her glass to her lips. Kelsey grabbed her forearm before she took a drink.
“You don’t want to do that.”
“I don’t?” Caitlin pouted. “Why not?”
“You left it at the table. Anybody could have slipped something in there.”
“Oh my God.” Caitlin snorted. “You are such a mother, Kels. Lighten up.” Caitlin pulled her arm away, and a little liquid sloshed from the glass as the lights went out over the table.
“We hoped you ladies would have stayed on the dance floor.”
It was the nose, the leader of the silver-shirted wolf pack. His buddies grinned at either shoulder. Up close, his nose was big, ridiculously big, and Kelsey couldn’t stifle a giggle when she remembered what Brit suggested about boys with big noses. Big noses mean big…
“Some of us would have,” Caitlin said. She wrapped her tongue around the tiny black straw in her glass.
Kelsey rolled her eyes. She let her gaze stray across the room and fall on a tall man near the entrance. A flare burst in her memory. Johnny. She hadn’t seen him in almost five years, not since graduation, but it was him. His tall, cut features gave him away. Several years hadn’t changed anything about his face, his sleek, angular cheekbones and firm chin. Kelsey could almost feel his blue eyes, even across a dim club filled with people. He wasn’t dancing, just standing near the wall, almost like he was waiting for someone. Maybe looking for someone. Kelsey’s stomach knotted.
“…and our unit ships out at month’s end.”
Kelsey snapped back to her immediate vicinity. “What? Are you trying that old line? C’mon, boys. Really?”
Big nose blinked hard at the word boys.
Caitlin kicked Kelsey’s leg under the table.
“Whatever.” Big Nose frowned. “I can see you’re not interested. We were talking to your friend.”
Brit returned balancing three drinks in her hands. She read the look on Kelsey’s face. “Looks like I’m missing the party.”
Kelsey glanced at Johnny again. The dance floor lights flashed red and blue and white. “I was just leaving.” She climbed from her chair. Big Nose looked her up and down as she stood, and the two baboons at his shoulders did the same. She hated feeling dirty when a greasy boy eyed her like a cut of meat. She wanted a shower, to clean off the slime he’d heaped on her.
“Not bad,” he said.
Kelsey’s fingers curled into a fist at her side. “Fuck off.” She started to walk away.
He grabbed her wrist. “You wish, honey.”
Kelsey yanked her arm from his grasp. The flight across the club blurred in her head along with the music’s pound and her feet against the floor. She heard Brit’s voice bark her name twice, “Kels—Kels.” Shapes shifted and contorted, silhouettes of people, cardboard cutouts. Her head spun. By the time she worked her way across the room, Johnny was gone.
Chapter 2: Sarah
Sarah knitted her fingers together in her lap. She squeezed them until the knuckles turned white and let the blood flow back again. She’d had three previous sessions with Kim, her therapist, but never felt this uncomfortable. This nervous. She felt as though something lurked in the room, waiting for her. Watching.
“Something’s on your mind, Sarah?” Kim asked. Her face was round and kind with deep-set brown eyes. Kim’s face was friendly—the face of an aunt Sarah wished she had.
Sarah shrugged. “Just tired, I guess.”
“Tired?”
Sarah nibbled her lip and forced her fingers apart. The office air conditioning hummed to a stop. She pressed her hands against her knees to still them. “Tired, yeah. I’ve been working weird hours. Open one day, close the next. Just sort of throws me off.”
“I see.”
Without the air conditioning, the room was too quiet. Sarah was aware of her breath and Kim’s pencil scratching against the small, yellow notepad she always held. “It’s not that I dislike the job or anything.” Sarah shifted in her chair. “I mean I don’t see myself in retail forever, but who does?”
Kim nodded.
Sarah always felt like she had to make something up, conjure a safe story to fill the tiny office. She talked about work or television shows or music—anything to stay away from eating and how she’d starved herself into the hospital. She would talk about anything which would keep her away from the big hurt hidden behind her bulimia, the scar tissue left behind after she’d split with Johnny and stumbled into that awful house. Her gaze roved to a poster featuring Maya Angelou with a few lines of the poem “Phenomenal Woman”.
“It’s just been hard to sleep lately,” Sarah said.
“I see.”
“I’m not sleeping enough to dream, really.” Sarah said it—she said the word dream. Her heart swelled, choking off her breath.
“So you haven’t been dreaming?” Kim asked.
“No. Not really. I wake up two, maybe three times a night. I can’t seem to get a steady rhythm. Maybe it’s work, like I said. My schedule is all wonky.” Sarah pulled at her blouse’s hem and felt the stitch between fingertips. The air conditioning clicked on, followed by the airy hum from the vent.
Kim scribbled on her notepad.
“Not like I used to.” As soon as Sarah said the words, she knew it was a mistake. She’d let down her guard, dropped her armor.
Kim’s eyebrows rose. She leaned forward. “When did you stop remembering your dreams?”
“Years ago.”
“Before your eating struggles?”
Sarah felt “eating struggles” sounded so lame, so weak, like what she’d been through with bulimia was a spot of trouble, no big deal, nothing a stronger woman could have managed. She nibbled her lip.
“Sarah?”
“Yes. Before I started… You know.” She couldn’t say the word. She couldn’t bring herself to the truth of what she’d done, what she’d experienced. After the house, after the dead man and Jared and the questions and police—after everything, she hadn’t been able to look at
herself in the mirror properly. Her eyes had lied to her, told her ugly stories about her body. She couldn’t say the word bulimia. She couldn’t force her tongue to form the words binge and purge.
“I see,” Kim said.
Sarah shivered. “What’s to tell? I used to dream, just like anybody. Crazy stuff like lining up for a race but I was naked. Getting married but when I woke I realized the guy was my brother. Crazy stuff like that. But then Johnny and I—” She broke off, aware she’d crossed another line, a sizable leap too far. Kim didn’t know about Johnny. “I broke up with my boyfriend. Maybe that’s all.”
“I don’t think you’ve mentioned Johnny before.”
Sarah shook her head. “I haven’t. I thought I was over him.”
Kim’s eyes pointed toward the wall clock and shifted back to Sarah. “What can you tell me about him?”
“What do you want to know?” Sarah ran a finger along the chair’s upholstery.
Kim smiled.
“All right. Okay. We dated in college. He was an English lit major, handsome. Funny, too. I thought, well I guess I thought maybe we’d get married one day. I thought he was the one. But then things tanked. It’s funny because we never really argued. Maybe that was the problem. Maybe people need to disagree.”
“Disagreements can be healthy,” Kim said.
“Yeah. I suppose.” Sarah glanced toward Kim’s second story window. Clouds and blue sky, pale and flat and bright, filled the rectangular opening. “I suppose I needed to assert myself.” She was fishing, trawling for a response from Kim.
“The dreams stopped after the breakup?”
Sarah looked down at her hands. They rested on her pant legs, but her fingers bunched her slacks into pinched clumps. She let out a slow breath and relaxed her hands. “The dreams stopped after the breakup,” she said. Kim would spot the lie. Kim always saw through Sarah’s lies like they were made just for her, little tests which didn’t challenge the therapist’s skills. It wasn’t the breakup—not the breakup by itself.