Twins Make Four: A Mistaken Identity Secret Baby Romance

by Nicole Elliot

  “Cole!” She shuddered and arched her back. “Yes. Right there.”

  I fucked her roughly and her pussy clenched around my fingers, bringing her close to her climax. I licked her nipple fast and hit her G-spot each time I thrust my fingers into her, and with each passing second she was more fidgety and louder.

  “Please, don’t stop.”

  I smirked. “And what if I do?” I took my fingers out.

  “Cole!” she protested.

  “You’re one naughty girl and I have to punish you.” I lowered myself and pressed my mouth on her swollen clit.

  “Oh Cole...” She grabbed my head and pressed me against her. “That’s amazing...”

  She was completely soaking my face, her perfect scent making me undone. She smelled and tasted perfect, and I loved how easily she responded to me. I pushed my tongue into her hole and fucked her with my tongue, at the same time rubbing her clit with my thumb. I could feel she was so close, her whole body shuddering and muscles clenching, and I increased my speed, ravaging her pussy.

  Several moments later she came, holding me tight as I waited for her orgasm to pass. There was nothing hotter than Addison coming on my face and I wanted it again and again. “You are so beautiful, baby. So hot.” I licked her juices off her before I brought her down to the floor and pushed her to the kitchen table.

  I turned her around and bent her over the table, her back facing me. Her sexy ass came high in the air, and it was a great view. I loved fucking her from behind. I spanked her once.

  She whimpered. “Oh! What was that for?”

  “Your punishment. Don’t think that I’m done with you.” I spanked her again, getting more turned on by redness that spread on her soft skin. Her pussy contracted in pleasure, and I spanked her several more times, making her moan. She started begging me to fuck her.

  “Please, Cole... please, fuck me.”

  Damn. I pressed my cock between her ass cheeks and grinded against her. I was so hard and desperate to have her, but I loved teasing her like this and making her wait.

  Finally, I thrust into her hard and wrapped her hair around my hand to keep her in place. “I will fuck you rough, baby.” I got out and rammed into her again. I could already feel her juices overflowing from her hole. “You’re only mine. You better remember that.” I pulled almost completely out and then I went in again in a swift move. She was so wet now that it was dripping, allowing me to enter smoothly.

  “Only yours,” she replied and squeezed my cock with her insides.

  I smacked her ass again and groaned when her pussy clenched around me. I was fucking her rough and fast, bringing her to another orgasm, and her pussy squeezed my cock.

  “Cole!” she screamed.

  “Addison, baby,” I hissed as she wiggled in ecstasy. I couldn’t hold myself much longer and as I increased my tempo, I was already cumming several seconds later, spurting my seed into her warm hole. I held her hips tightly until my last drop of sperm was out, and even then I felt this wasn’t enough.

  Now I was definitely late for work, but I didn’t care. “Look what you did to me. Now I have to take a shower and be really late for work.”

  She giggled and looked at me over her shoulder. She was so gorgeous and my heart beat faster just looking at her. “Don’t I deserve another punishment then?”

  I returned her smile. “No more punishments. I just need to feel you again. Right now.” That was enough to give me a hard-on again, and I rushed through the apartment as I pulled her with me, planning to take her in the shower.

  Fourteen

  Cole

  We were kissing as we entered the bathroom, unable to stop while she undressed me. She took off all my clothes and moved her hands over my naked chest and stomach. A second later she wrapped her hand around my dick and stroked it slowly. I groaned and kissed her again. “You are driving me crazy,” I muttered.

  “I could say the same.”

  I pushed her backward and into the shower. I turned on the warm water and bent to kiss her breasts. She pushed me against her, already ready for me, and this time I wanted to fuck her slow and long. I grabbed her hips and brought her up. She wrapped her legs around me as I pushed her back against the wall. My rigid cock easily slid into her warmth, and I got inside inch my inch, enjoying the way her pussy embraced me.

  We were moaning together, holding each other tight as I rocked us slowly. Our sensual kiss made my mind blank, and I was already lost in her.

  “I need you, Addison,” I whispered, not able to take my eyes off hers. Her face was twisted in pure pleasure and her eyes were glazed with lust. So beautiful. She was definitely the most beautiful woman I’d ever met and I was so lucky to have her.

  “I need you too, Cole. I know what we’re doing here isn’t normal…”

  “Shhh...” I told her. Even though I wanted to fuck her slow, I couldn’t contain myself with her. Her pussy surrounded me and I needed more. I needed it to be faster and wild. I started moving more forcefully now, making her scream with pleasure.

  “Yes, Cole!”

  “I want you to come again. I want you to soak my cock.” The water rushed over our bodies, as I slammed into her.

  She cried out and dug her fingers into my shoulders. I could feel her pussy becoming tenser, and I knew she was about to come, so I sped up, fucking her so hard that I was sure her pussy would be sore after we finished.

  “Yes! Don’t stop! I’m coming!” She screamed and orgasmed, closing her eyes shut as she trembled in pleasure. I didn’t stop, continuing my hard rhythm through her orgasm. Her eyes grew wide. “Cole! What are you doing?!”

  “Showing you how good it can be.”

  She couldn’t stop screaming as if my cock brought her an immense pleasure that she couldn’t bear. “You see, baby? It can only get better. Now, come again for me.”

  I drilled her, fucking her wildly until her next orgasm erupted in her, and it was unbelievable how sexy she was as she thrashed against the wall, completely lost in pleasure. I couldn’t hold myself much longer, and this time I wanted us to come together.

  I pressed my lips against hers, pushing inside and finding her sweet tongue. I was pounding into her as I felt my pleasure finally reach its peak, at the same time as hers. I started coming, feeling her pussy clench around me so tight—squeezing every single drop out of me. I lowered her down and hugged her, needing her close to me.

  “You’re so good, Addison. You have no idea what you do to me.” I pulled her under the stream of water and took the soap, eager to wash her whole body.

  “I bet I do,” she giggled. “But now you’re really late for work.”

  “And that is supposed to be funny?” I raised my eyebrow, feigning anger.

  She bit her lip. “Maybe.” She was provoking me on purpose, acting like a naughty girl, and I was more than ready to respond to that. I pushed her against the wall again, trapping her hands above her head in mine.

  “Well, since you’re such a naughty girl, I really have to punish you again.” I grinded against her, my big cock already hard for her. “Brace yourself,” I warned her and pushed deep into her—where I belonged.

  Fifteen

  Addison

  “Yes, that’s fine. Roses on each table in the blush pink will be perfect. And don't forget about jewelry that goes with my gown. I want everything set up that morning so I don't have to think about anything.” I was scatterbrained on a normal day, hackers mind, but my wedding day? I didn't want to be responsible for anything. I knew I would forget something and ruin the whole damn thing. With Cole’s money, I had set up everything so nicely. Our lie was perfectly staged.

  I hung up the phone with the planner and turned back to Elizabeth who was sitting on the couch in Cole’s apartment rummaging through invitations.

  “I still think you're having a midlife crisis. Or quarter life I guess.”

  I rolled my eyes at her. “We have discussed this, this is what is best for Cole and me. So what if it's a
little rushed? It's not like I'm not getting everything that I ever wanted. I wish you could just be happy for me.”

  “I am happy for you, I'm just… concerned. I mean this guy shows up out of nowhere Addison! You are hiding him from me and then you decide to marry him? I mean what did Daddy say?”

  “That he would be wearing his uniform and he would be happy to walk me down the aisle. Mom was the same way. Just happy that I found someone and I'm settling down. I think you're just annoyed that I'm settling down before you.”

  I knew the last one stung, and that shouldn't have because I was just playing up this lie, but I knew that she had moved her boyfriend into her apartment since I had left and she was especially annoying since I had told her I was getting married.

  “You're so lucky I'm not planning a bachelorette party for you because if I were, I would've taken pictures to show Cole just for that statement.”

  “Yeah thanks for not doing that, I don’t think I could handle anymore showing off then I'm already doing. And I'm really glad that you guys decided to just throw in the shower with the rehearsal dinner so people could bring gifts that if they wanted.” I was not the in the spotlight type, this was all a little much.

  “It's not like you need anything anyway,” Elizabeth said gesturing around Cole's apartment. She was right. I had everything here that I could ever want. I kept myself busy most of the day while Cole was at the hospital planning the wedding and keeping things tidy, not to mention thinking about him.

  Our chemistry over the past three weeks had become completely incredible. And while I had been better about not trying to seduce my new fiancé before he left for work in the morning that didn't mean I was sleeping in the guest room.

  Most nights I was cuddled up with Cole on the couch or getting rowdy in his bed. We were like the perfect new couple. Maybe getting married this fast wasn’t a bad idea, when you were still in that lusty stage and you couldn’t keep your hands off each other. Maybe Cole and I had figured it all out better than the rest of society. Or maybe in four months, we would never talk to each other again, and that was constantly nagging in the back of my mind.

  “How's the hospital for him? He said that this is the first time he's working in pediatrics.”

  Elizabeth was sincerely interested, which was refreshing because when I had first told about getting married her she had dropped a bottle of wine on the floor in my old apartment which shattered and was a total waste. Now she was at least asking about him like he was a real person and not someone I had made up. But she was still pressing for the four of us to go to dinner sometime, and after dinner with Cole's uncle, I wasn't too keen to repeat it. I still couldn't believe what he had done under the table if we had been caught! I couldn't even imagine.

  “It's fine. I don't think Pediatrics is really his thing, I mean he's used to a more military type of medicine but I don't think he hates it either. I mean he’s not there much longer anyway.”

  I noticed that Elizabeth raised an eyebrow at that. “And why not?”

  Shit. I hadn’t mentioned that Cole was only going to be working there for short period of time. I had to get better at the lie that was our lives.

  “Well he's on loan from another hospital, so I don't think he intends on staying there full-time or anything.”

  “What about you? Have you even been looking for a job? I just don’t want you to become this trophy wife Addison. Not to mention that's not really your style.”

  “And what’s my style? What's that supposed to mean?”

  “The little socialites, going to fundraising dinners and hosting cocktail parties. That might be what Cole is looking for, but that’s not you. That’s certainly not us.”

  “So what? Just because you and I were raised different than Cole, what’s that got to do with things? Elizabeth, that's kind of shitty thing to say.” Especially because she was right. Doubt pushed its way into my mind.

  She didn't make eye contact continuing to go through invitations. “I can't believe how many people got back to you, considering it was such short notice.”

  I could tell she was ignoring my comment but I couldn't really blame her. She was right, Cole’s world wasn’t my own. For God sakes, I was getting married to someone who was practically a stranger and that was all because he wanted me to. What was I doing? Who was I becoming? This was all completely insane! It didn't matter how good sex with Cole was, or all the things that I could get the money from the severance package.

  I was marrying him! I looked at Elizabeth as she continued to sort through invitations making the final no pile when I realized I needed to talk to Cole now!

  “Elizabeth, I'm actually going out for a bit. Can you lock up when you're done?”

  She looked at me, her face was concern and annoyance etched into it.

  “But I'm not even halfway done.”

  I grabbed my keys off of the counter and I muttered to her, “You might not need to finish.”

  Sixteen

  Addison

  I walked into the hospital already sweating and practically breathless. I felt like I was losing my mind. It was a smart girl, not the type that randomly got married because it gave them a lot of money. I was supposed to marry for love, not lust. How hadn't I seen this before?

  I just needed reassurance from Cole. I just needed him to tell me that we could continue dating as we were while we got married. That everything would turn out okay. But as I rounded the first floor of the Children's Hospital I saw my worst fears before my eyes. There was Cole laughing with one of the nurses, a petite blonde with full lips and even fuller breasts. She was touching his arm and giggling. He didn't even look up, totally focused on her. He never even noticed me as he turned around and she rubbed his shoulders laughing and giggling the whole time. She was giving him an impromptu massage.

  Jealousy raged through my body.

  Why was she touching him? What gave her that right? Not to mention what the hell was he doing? I suddenly realized I hadn't just come to the hospital for reassurance that our fake marriage wasn't totally fake but also for assurance the Cole actually liked me. That he cared. And here he was doing exactly what I should've expected him to be doing, acting like the total playboy that he was.

  At one point I had been smart, I didn't like men interfere with my career or what I thought about myself. But ever since I had been with Cole things had just fallen apart. And that was my fault, I had let that happen. I had somehow let my worth be entirely about what he thought of me. And as I stood there with my mouth gaping open I realized that I was done with all of that. He could say whatever he wanted to say to get me into bed, but clearly, our relationship was still strictly professional. We were both in it for the money. And at the end of the day I would walk away with that big ass check and I would never have to see him again. But as the tears pricked the backs of my eyes I realized I couldn't see him again tonight either.

  I turned on my heel and walked out of the hospital dialing the number of my best friends Kendall.

  “Hey, I need a place to crash for tonight. Don't ask questions, just have wine.”

  Seventeen

  Cole

  I dialed her number again but there was still no answer. So I left another fucking voicemail. “Addison. It's me. This is the sixth time I've called you. Where the hell are you? I need to know that you're okay. Call me back.”

  I paced back and forth this in front of the kitchen island again looking over the couch onto the coffee table where invitations had been sorted. Clearly, she had been home at some point during the day, but now she was gone. Missing. Part of me wanted to call John over at the station and see if he could put out a missing person’s report on her because I didn't know what else to do. I was frantic, I had never been like this about a girl. Sometimes they left, that was just the way was.

  But this time, it was different.

  I was practically falling apart without her.

  I needed her.

  I had to make sure she was
okay, wherever she was. But it was nearly midnight and I still hadn't heard from her. That meant something was wrong. Finally, the text came through.

  Don't worry I'm with a friend. I'll meet you at the wedding planner tomorrow as we discussed. Don't call me anymore.

  Don't call her? What the hell did that mean? She'd been living here for three weeks. Everything was perfect, I had even stopped on my way home at some premier coffeehouse in order to get her favorite type of blend. I was learning things about her, things that I liked. The whole thing was mindbending, to begin with, two complete strangers getting married. But here we were, falling for each other. She couldn't deny it any more than I could. I wasn’t that guy, I wasn't good at settling down, but she made me want to try.

  She made it so that I wanted this arrangement to last so much longer than four months.

  And now she was just letting it all fall apart? It didn't make any sense. I considered having a couple drinks or eating something, but I figured sleep was better.

  I tossed and turned most of the night hoping that at some point she would creep into my bed and we would snuggle up together and everything would be forgiven. Not that I had any damn clue what was wrong. But when the sun started shining through my blinds I realized she hadn't come home. I got ready for meeting with the wedding planner and checked my phone several times but nothing.

  What if she was pulling out of our deal?

  I couldn't tell which concerned me more, losing my shares in the company, or losing Addison.

  Eighteen

  Cole

  It had been nearly a week since Addison hadn’t come home, and now she was sleeping in the guest room. I had no idea what was going on with her. When I would come home from my shift she would have her door closed or be out on an errand. She was avoiding me.

  But today she couldn’t avoid me any longer, it was the rehearsal, no matter how annoyed she was with me, she’d have to put on a good face. Because there were about thirty people we’d have to lie in front of.