by Charles Todd
8
Walking back through Duncarrick’s main square, Rutledge stopped and considered the shops and houses lining either side of the road. These townspeople were prosperous enough, as Hamish had pointed out, but without obvious signs of wealth. Surely a small inn on the outskirts of town would offer neither problem nor competition. If The Reivers provided extra rooms to people on market day, so much the better. As for competing with the only hotel, Rutledge doubted if it could hold a candle to the amenities offered there. It would have served a simpler class of person who couldn’t afford the grandness of The Ballantyne. And any success it had enjoyed would have been modest in comparison to this part of the town. A good living for the owners, yes, but hardly extravagant.
He moved on, watching people going about their daily lives. Women entering and leaving the shops, a nursemaid with a pram carefully maneuvering it through the door of a house, a woman sweeping her front step, a small boy playing with a top, men in dark suits coming out of offices, others in work clothes, carrying the tools of a trade, a crocodile of schoolgirls marching in the wake of a schoolmistress wearing a thick coat and unbecoming hat.
Ordinary people, their eyes avoiding those of the stranger passing them. No curiosity about his presence or his business. As if once burned, twice shy…
Hamish said, “McKinstry was right. They’re a dour lot!”
There was one other common feature among them. Un-smiling faces and thin, tight mouths. As if life was a burden, and they were used to enduring it.
A woman stepped out of a shop close to where he was standing and cast a surreptitious glance in his direction.
Hamish saw her before he did, commenting that she could have studied him just as clearly from the front window. A tall woman, pretty in a severe way, with her hair in a tightly confined bun, her sweater and skirt a very prim gray with only a touch of color in the silk shirtwaist, a paisley of peach and gray and white.
She made a fuss over the potted plants that stood on either side of the shop door. They were pretty, a mixture of rose geraniums and something lavender and white, like pansies. Satisfied, she turned and went quickly back inside. He looked at the neatly painted sign above the door. A. TAIT MILLINERY. He filed it away for future reference. If she had been interested enough to inspect a stranger, she might also be a gossip…
Rutledge retrieved his car from The Ballantyne’s yard and drove out past the church. He found The Reivers again and stopped across the road to look at it. Yes, he’d been right. Comfortable, decent-hardly a blot on the conscience of Duncarrick. Neither a wild tavern nor a seedy lodging.
Small and long, no more than two stories with an attic above, the inn was one of those old buildings that survived because they were in nobody’s way-no one wanted to build a square here, or shops, or a large house.
Duncarrick’s main square, on the other hand, had probably seen the demise of a whole street of houses to widen the space to suit nineteenth-century builders with Progress on their minds.
The houses on either side here and down the lane by the inn’s stables were neither picturesque nor ugly, more a reflection of the straightforwardness of the people who lived in them. Only the house to one’s left facing the inn was by any measure grand, boasting three stories and an extension toward the rear, as if it had grown over the years with the family living there. The windows had been set with some eye to symmetry and style, lending a faint touch of grace.
The inn looked rooted in its earth, tidy, freshly whitewashed in the past year, the door to the bar hidden behind a climbing rose that had spread with age to cover the porch it had been intended to adorn. It was a hardy rose to survive in this climate, and the small garden at its feet showed some care for the impression the inn made on passersby. The bar parlor, on the side facing the narrow lane into the inn yard at the rear, had a green door, and crisp white curtains showed behind the windows next to it.
Time could have turned this into a rowdy pub on the outskirts of town, but the inn had managed, somehow, to retain a certain dignity. Because two women had had the care of it?
“I canna’ think why they’d persecute a lass with such a dowry as the inn,” Hamish was saying. “They’d be more likely to want their sons to wed her.”
And that, too, was a question worth considering. It all kept coming back to that: Why had the town united so easily against this woman?
On impulse, Rutledge shut off the engine and got out, crossing the road and walking down into the inn yard, where the stables and outbuildings stood.
They were in a fair state of repair. With little work done during the war and no money after it to tackle major improvements, upkeep spoke well for the management.
He was poking about in the stable, looking for the cabinet where Inspector Oliver had discovered the first set of bones, when a loud voice said, “Here! What do you think you’re doing!”
He turned to find a tall, heavy-shouldered man of middle age standing in the doorway, arms akimbo, staring at him with harsh dislike. Shadowed by the doorway, his face was dark and ugly but had a strength to it as well.
Rutledge, well aware that he was trespassing, replied peaceably, “I’d heard that the inn might be for sale.”
“There’s no decision been made to sell or not sell,” the man said.
“I see.” Rutledge turned, having found what he was looking for, the part of the wall pulled down to bring a skeleton to light. The cupboard, deep enough to start with, had been made shallower to conceal the grave behind it. A careful bit of work-a hundred years ago trouble had been taken to make the spot seem ordinary, unsuspicious. It must have been quite a shock for Inspector Oliver to discover that his “corpse” was nearly as old as the inn.
Rutledge began to walk toward the man blocking the exit. It made him uneasy to have his way closed-even in the relative spaciousness of the stable, he could feel the claustrophobia it invoked. The air seemed thick, suffocating “Tell me about the owner-” He broke off. After being buried alive in the impenetrable mud of a shell crater, weighed down by Hamish’s body, Rutledge had come to hate being shut in-confined in any fashion. Traveling on trains, sleeping in a small room, seeing himself cut off from escape through a door or down a stair-the need for space was so urgent that it ignited a rising panic. Even here he could feel the sudden dampness of sweat on his face, the difficulty breathing, the awareness of hideous danger “You’ll be wanting to speak to the police, then,” the man told him bluntly but didn’t elaborate. His stance was intentionally threatening now, belligerent, as if he sensed Rutledge’s sudden uneasiness. Rutledge felt his own muscles tensing.
Rutledge replied, “A woman, I understand. What has she done to find herself of interest to the police?”
“None of your affair, is it?” At last the man moved out into the sunlight, and Rutledge followed, his breathing still uneven.
Damn this, he swore, fighting the claustrophobia. Keep your mind on what you’re doing, can’t you?
But Hamish, too, was responding to the man’s aggressive stance, asking if he had believed the innuendoes and the letters-or was incensed by them. Rutledge thought, It was difficult to tell. He was a man who showed little in his face; he would not be easy to interrogate.
“Does she have any family? Heirs?”
“None.” Uncompromising. Cold. Then, grudgingly, “None that I know of.”
No mention of the boy. But he would inherit nothing… would he?
“Then I’ll be on my way.” Walking back toward the inn, Rutledge could sense the man’s stare boring into his back between his shoulder blades.
If this was any example of how the townspeople felt about the woman who owned this property, it was evident that she had somehow made abiding enemies.
Which didn’t fit into the picture of her that McKinstry had so glowingly painted.
Who was the woman in the eye of a controversy that might well end with a hanging?
Rutledge realized suddenly that he didn’t even know her full name.
Not that it mattered, he thought, but it was an indication that whatever crime she had committed-from lying to murder-she had somehow lost her identity because of it. As if, by refusing to call her by name, Duncarrick could finish what they had begun back in June-shunning her until she was without reality and finally disappeared.
What had this woman done to stir up such dark passions?
It was odd, he thought, crossing the quiet street to his car. First the venomous letters and then the one to the minister-Elliot? The finding of one body that didn’t match the crime, and another that did. Persistence, patience-and what else? Luck? Or persecution?
It smacked of the latter. Hamish, in the back of his mind, agreed.
Rutledge stopped before turning the crank and looked back at The Reivers. The accused owned this inn. Did someone covet it? She had a small child to provide for, never mind whether it was rightfully hers or not. Did someone covet the child? Or want it taken away to punish the accused, a twisted revenge for a real or imagined grudge? And these were the more obvious reasons for wanting the woman in prison and out of the way. What others might there be? Was there something in the inn that no one knew about, which mattered to another person? Or was it something in the past of the accused that put another person in jeopardy? Hanging was a certain way of silencing her.
He found himself thinking of the child again. Torn away from its mother, from the only home it had known, put to live with strangers. There was a cruelty in that.
Then why hadn’t she lied to protect the boy? “I don’t have my marriage lines-my husband took them, to show the Army…”
Why hadn’t she left the town as soon as the shunning had begun? But he thought he had the answer to that-the shunning had reduced custom at the inn to the point that she might not have had the money to go away. Had that been the intent of it-?
The woman’s voice behind him startled him. “Are you looking for someone?”
Rutledge turned and removed his hat. Hamish, responding to his surprise, was suddenly alert, watchful. She was tall and plump, dressed in black but young, perhaps twenty-four or -five. A little girl of six or seven held her hand.
“I was admiring the inn. I’d heard it might be for sale.”
The woman shook her head. “Early days to know that!” She turned to the door of the house in front of which he’d left his car. A neighbor, then…
“I understand the owner is to stand trial on some charges.”
Her face hardened. “She is.”
He found himself asking, “Do you know the name of her barrister? I might speak with him.”
“Armstrong’s his name, but he doesn’t live in Duncarrick. Jedburgh, I think I was told.”
Rutledge smiled down at the little girl. She smiled shyly back. He wondered if she’d played with the child living in the inn but couldn’t ask in front of the mother. And as if the thought had sprung from his mind to hers, the girl said in a soft, sweet voice, “I used to play with him. The little boy at The Reivers. But he’s gone away. I miss him.”
“Hush! You were told never to speak of that again!” the woman commanded, and the child turned her face into her mother’s skirts, flushing with shame, as if she had transgressed horribly.
The woman opened the house door and went inside, shutting it firmly behind her. Shutting out Rutledge and his questions. Unwilling to gossip-to speculate-or to defend.
9
Rutledge drove back to Trevor’s house rather than take a room at The Ballantyne, unwilling to move himself into Duncarrick until he’d spoken with Oliver. It was a courtesy, but often small courtesies lubricated the wheels of change. The long drive gave him time to think. That evening over dinner, he told David Trevor how he had spent his day.
Trevor smiled. “Once a policeman, always a policeman.”
Rutledge grinned in return. “Blame human nature. Curiosity is man’s besetting sin.”
“The Garden of Eden,” Trevor agreed. “Eve is always blamed for offering Adam the apple, but it’s my view that he had been looking for an excuse to see how it tasted. He would have bitten into it on his own in a day or two.
“What I find interesting about the situation you described,” Trevor went on, “is that I know the Chief Constable in that district. Robson. A good man. So is the fiscal, by reputation. I can’t quite see Robson railroading a young woman if there was no real evidence against her. You know that Scotland is different from England in that we don’t have a coroner’s inquest. The procurator-fiscal and the Chief Constable, together with the officers involved, discuss the evidence and come to a decision as to whether or not there should be a trial. It isn’t based on a coroner’s jury that might be prejudiced for or against the suspect. And it’s often decided on several levels-whether, for instance, the woman would be better off having a jury establish her innocence for all to see. Have you considered that aspect of a trial, Ian?”
Rutledge finished his soup and set down his spoon. “I have, but it seems to me that bringing her to trial-assuming of course that she’s innocent of the charges-has hardened feelings against her. In the upshot, the jury might prefer to hang her.”
Trevor nodded to Morag to take away his empty soup plate and said, “They’ll work it out, Ian, but I’d watch my back if I were you. I’ve never met this Inspector Oliver, but he’s certain to resent your interference-that is, if he’s still smarting from his encounter with Lady Maude. And she could be trouble, come to that. There’s a very complex relationship between parent and child, and I have a feeling you’ll be damned if you do-and damned if you don’t- prove conclusively that Eleanor Gray has nothing whatsoever to do with this business.”
“If women sat on the jury, there would be no doubt that this young woman would be convicted-and the question is, will they bring such pressure to bear on their menfolk that the results are the same?” In his own cases, Rutledge made it a point to be absolutely certain that his evidence, clearly presented, left no room for doubt. In his mind or the jury’s. But jurors were often contrary-convicting where there was only circumstantial evidence and acquitting where proof seemed indisputable.
“Burns-the fiscal-is too good a man to allow a prejudiced jury.”
But was he? The woman was already set for trial on purely circumstantial evidence. What if, Rutledge thought, he himself proved that the bones on the mountainside were Eleanor Gray’s and that she had borne a child before she died? The assumption would be that it was the child the accused was raising. A natural assumption-but not necessarily a true one. Would there be justice-or a miscarriage of justice? And for the child’s sake, it was imperative that Rutledge got it right. He could feel tiredness seeping into his shoulders and into the muscles of his neck.
“Are ye up to it, then?” Hamish asked.
Rutledge let the subject drop. At the end of the meal, David Trevor studied him for a moment, then said, “It’s still on your mind, isn’t it? That problem in Duncarrick. You’ll be leaving for good in the morning, I take it.” There was a note of regret, barely concealed, in the pleasant voice. “I’m glad you came. You don’t know how much it has meant to me to have you here.”
Rutledge looked down at his plate. “I wasn’t sure I could face coming back to Scotland. It seemed insurmountable, just thinking about it.”
Trevor said, “Yes, it’s different, isn’t it?” With a sigh, he added, “I suppose a time will come when I don’t listen for him in the late afternoon, just before tea. Or lie awake at night, thinking I’ve heard his key in the lock. Or look for him at breakfast in the morning.”
But Rutledge hadn’t been thinking of Ross Trevor. His mind had turned to the dead Scots soldiers who had not come back at all.
On the brink of sleep that night, the nagging doubts began.
Hamish, listening to the questions that Rutledge was mentally cataloging, said, “You canna’ know the whole of it. You havena’ interviewed the prisoner nor looked at where they found the victim. You havena’ spoken to the neighbors nor even seen the ch
ild. You’ve heard only yon constable’s view of the matter, and he’s prejudiced in the woman’s favor.”
Rutledge said in defense of his doubts, “I’ve investigated too many murders, I know something about the way evidence comes to light. The facts here don’t fit awkwardly, as they should do. Who could have known that the skeleton was in the back of the cabinet in that stable? Someone did, I’ll wager! Because Oliver came back a second time to search. If he didn’t know, who did?”
He turned over, feeling sleep slipping away from him.
“The inn is closed, the child is taken away, and the woman is sent to prison to stand for her trial,” he went on to himself, unable to stop his mind from working. “With no impediment.”
Hamish countered, “Aye, but there was no way of knowing the Yard would be brought into the case.”
“Why did Lady Maude change her mind? I was nearly certain when I left there that her daughter was alive and well. Why did she change her mind? ”
Hamish said, “She didna’ strike me as frivolous or foolish.”
And that, Rutledge thought, finally on the verge of sleep, was an extremely insightful analysis of Lady Maude.
The next morning in the rain Trevor helped Rutledge carry his luggage out to the car, then shook his hand warmly. Morag, a shawl over her head, came to embrace him, shamelessly reaching up to him. Rutledge found himself wishing that he needn’t leave after all. He had found ghosts here-and affection. The ghosts he was accustomed to. Affection he was not.
The rain fell in a heavy downpour that seemed to presage winter, a coldness in the air that touched the skin as he drove back to Duncarrick.
Inspector Oliver wasn’t at the police station. The constable on duty, MacNab by name, stood up warily as Rutledge introduced himself, and offered to send for Oliver. “For he’s out at a farm west of town. There’s been a rash of small fires that were probably set on purpose.”