by C. P. Snow
34: Obligations of Love
Although I had had only a few hours’ sleep, I was lying wakeful when Bidwell called me. He drew the blind and let in the grey half-light of the December morning: I turned away, longing for sleep again, I wanted to shirk the day.
Bidwell had not lit the fire in my sitting-room early enough; there were only spurts of flame among the great lumps of coal. Smoke blew out of the grate, and it struck cold and raw in the lofty room. I sat down heavy-heartedly to my breakfast. With an effort, I roused myself to call down the stairs for Bidwell. He entered with his usual smile, intimate, deferential, and sly. I sent him to find whether Pilbrow was up yet, and he returned with news that Pilbrow had pinned a note on his door saying he proposed to sleep until midday and was not to be disturbed.
I knew that, as soon as he was about, he would be punctilious in warning his former side of his change of vote. His views were eccentric for an old man, but his manners had stayed gentle and nineteenth century; the only grumble I had ever heard him make about his young friends of the left was that, though he was sure there was some good reason for it, he could not for the life of him understand why they found it necessary to be so rude.
It was certain that Jago, Brown, and Chrystal would receive his note of apology by the end of the day. I did not want to break more bad news to Brown; over breakfast, I decided to leave it, he would find out from Pilbrow’s note soon enough. Then I thought I had better face the trouble, and sent out Bidwell with another message, asking Brown to visit me as soon as he came into college.
He was busy with the scholarship examination, and it was not until eleven o’clock that he arrived.
‘Is it anything serious? Have you heard about a meeting?’ he asked at once.
I told him of Pilbrow’s visit. His face flushed an angry purple, and he cursed with a virulence I had never heard before. He ended up: ‘It’s all his confounded politics. I always thought that he’d never grow up. It’s bad enough having people with cranky opinions in the college, saving your presence, Eliot, but it’s a damned scandal when they interfere with serious things. It’s a damned scandal. I shall never think the same of Pilbrow.’
It was the first time in the whole year that he had lost his balance. At last he said, with regretful bitterness: ‘I suppose we may as well tell Chrystal. I should have hoped at one time that he would take it as much amiss as I do.’
Chrystal listened to the news with attention, and received it quite differently from Brown.
‘Well. That’s that,’ he said. ‘I can’t say I’m much surprised.’
His response was mixed from the first moment – mixed, with his soft-hearted concern for his friend’s misery, his guilt at his friend’s anger, his delight at a hidden plan, his strong but obscure gratification.
‘It’s just as well I established contact yesterday,’ he said triumphantly. ‘We hadn’t told you, Eliot. Brown was not happy about going on. But some people on the other side would welcome a meeting. Of everyone who wants to come. Throwing everything into the melting pot. I told Brown yesterday it was our best way out. Now I’m sure of it.’
‘The position was different yesterday.’
‘I took it for granted there were floating votes.’
‘I don’t want a way out from Jago, and I never should,’ said Brown.
I asked if the meeting had been decided on.
‘I don’t think they’ll back out,’ Chrystal replied. ‘I’m not sure if they want to.’
‘Not even,’ I said, ‘now that they can see a majority for Crawford? When they hear about Pilbrow, they’ll feel they’re winning for the first time. Why should they want a meeting?’
‘They would be very foolish to contemplate such a thing,’ said Brown heavily to Chrystal. ‘Yesterday was a different situation. They stood to gain by saying yes to any approach you made. It was only decent common sense for them to draw you on. I shouldn’t think much of their judgement if they hadn’t welcomed any discussion you liked to suggest. They knew that we were showing our weakness.’
‘It’s turned out right. It may save us,’ said Chrystal.
‘I’ll believe that when I see the slightest sign that they’re willing to compromise – now they’re sitting with the majority.’
‘I’ll see there’s a meeting,’ said Chrystal. ‘It can be done. They’ll be willing to compromise.’
After lunch, Roy and I were sitting in my rooms. We intended to walk out to Gay’s house in time for tea; it was no use leaving the college until three, for the old man took his afternoon sleep according to the timetable which regulated all his actions and which had not varied for forty years.
I had deliberately kept back from Brown and Chrystal that we were making an attempt on Gay. Chrystal was now set on a compromise, and I did not think it safe to tell him. Unless Jago’s chances were revived, there was nothing Chrystal would do to help: he was more likely to hinder.
‘Just so,’ said Roy. ‘He’s an interesting man. If he’d been as single-minded over poor Jago as he was about making Sir Timberlake unbelt, we should have raced home.’
We talked about personal politics, of which in different places we had now seen a good deal. One point had struck us both: will, sheer stubborn will, was more effective than cunning or finesse or subtlety. Those could be a help; but the more one saw, the more one was forced to the banal conclusion that the man you wanted on your side was the man who believed without a shade of doubt that you were right. Arthur Brown was cunning and resourceful; but he had been the mainstay of Jago’s cause because, more powerfully than any of us, without any qualifications at all, he was determined to get Jago in. And Crawford’s side, which had so long been numerically weaker, began with Despard-Smith, Winslow, and Getliffe, not one of whom ever felt a doubt between Crawford and Jago. In that they were luckier than we had been; for Chrystal, whose will could be as strong as any of theirs, had had it split throughout the entire struggle.
As we were talking, there was a tap on the door and Mrs Jago came in. She said: ‘I’ve been up to Roy’s rooms. I had to find someone–’ and burst out crying. I led her to a chair by the fireplace, tears streaming down her face: there she cried aloud, noisily, with abject and abandoned misery: she laid her head on the arm of the chair, but did not try to hide her face: her heavy body shook with tearing sobs.
Roy and I met each other’s glance. Without speaking, we agreed to leave her alone. When the weeping became quieter, when the convulsions no longer tore her, it was I who stroked her hand.
‘Tell us,’ I said.
She tried to summon up her dignity. ‘Mr Eliot, I must apologize for this exhibition,’ she began, with her imitation of Lady Muriel – then she began to cry again.
‘What is the matter?’ I said.
She tried again to be grand, and then broke down.
‘They’re all saying – they’re all saying that I’m not fit to go into the Lodge.’
‘Alice, what do you mean?’ said Roy.
‘They all hate me. Everyone here hates me. Even you’ – she straightened herself in the chair, her cheeks glistening with tears, and looked at Roy – ‘hate me sometimes.’
‘Don’t be foolish.’
‘I’m not always as foolish as you think.’ She put a hand to the breast of her frock, and drew out a note. I looked at it and so did Roy over my shoulder. It was Nightingale’s flysheet.
‘What else does it mean?’ she cried. ‘I know I’m an ugly hysterical woman. I know I’m no use to anyone. But I’m not as foolish as you think. Tell me the truth. If you don’t hate me tell me the truth.’
‘We don’t hate you,’ said Roy. ‘We’re very fond of you. So will you stop hurting yourself? Then I’ll tell you the truth.’
His tone was affectionate, scolding, intimate. She dried her eyes and sat quiet.
‘That paper means what you think,’ said Roy. ‘One or two men mean to keep Paul out at any cost. They’re aiming at him through you. They’ve done the same thro
ugh me.’
She stared at him, and he added gently: ‘You’re not to worry.’
‘How can I help worrying?’ she said. The cry was full of pain, but there was nothing hysterical in it.
‘I should like to know how you saw this paper,’ I said. ‘Did Paul leave it about?’
‘He’d never be careless about anything that might upset me – don’t you realize he’s always taken too much care of me?’ she said. ‘No, this one was sent so that I could see it for myself.’
‘Poor thing,’ said Roy.
‘That must be Nightingale himself,’ I said. ‘What in God’s name does he hope for?’
‘He hopes,’ said Alice Jago, with a flash of shrewdness, ‘that it will make me do something silly.’
‘It might be just malice,’ said Roy.
‘No, it’s their one chance to keep Paul out. I’m his only weakness, you know I am,’ she said. ‘I suppose they know Paul is bound to be elected unless they shout the place down.’ (Neither Roy nor I realized till then that she was still ignorant of the latest news.) ‘I’m their best chance, aren’t I? I’ve heard another whisper – I expect I was meant to hear it – that they’re not going to leave me alone. They think I’m a coward. They’re saying that this note is only a beginning. They believe that I shall want Paul to withdraw.’
‘You couldn’t help being frightened,’ said Roy.
‘I could hear them all talking about me,’ she cried. ‘I was hysterical. I didn’t know what to do. I ran out of the house, I don’t know why I came to you–’
I could not be certain what had happened. She had received the flysheet: but had it actually been sent by Nightingale? I could not think of any other explanation. Had there really been other rumours? Was she imagining it all? Now she was speaking, quietly, unhappily, and with simple feeling.
‘I’m so frightened, Roy. I’m terribly frightened still,’ she said. ‘I’ve not been a good wife to Paul. I’ve been a drag on him all these years. I’ve tried sometimes, but I’ve never been any good. I know I’m horrible, but I can’t prevent myself getting worse. But I’ve never done him so much harm as this. I never thought they’d use me to prevent him being Master. How can I stand it, how can I stay here if they do?’
‘Think of Paul,’ said Roy.
‘I can’t help thinking of myself too,’ she cried. ‘How can I stand seeing someone else moving into that drawing-room? And I know you think I oughtn’t to worry about myself, but how can I stand the things they’ll say about me?’
‘It may not happen,’ I said.
‘It will happen.’
‘If it does, you’ll have to harden yourself.’
‘Do you know what they’ll say?’ she asked me wildly. ‘They’ll say I wasn’t good enough for Paul. And instead of doing my best for him, I couldn’t resist making a fool of myself with other men. It’s perfectly true. Though none of them wanted anyone like me.’ She gave a smile, wan, innocent, and flirtatious. ‘Roy, you know that I could have made a fool of myself with you.’
‘You’ve always tried to make Paul love you more,’ said Roy. ‘You’ve never believed that he really loves you, have you? Yet he does.’
‘How can he?’
Roy smiled: ‘And you love him very much.’
‘I’ve never been good enough for him,’ she cried.
She was wretched beyond anything we could say to her: disappointment pierced her, then shame, then self-disgust. She had looked forward so naively, so snobbishly to the Lodge; she had boasted of it, she had planned her parties, she had written to her family. Could it still be taken away? We guessed that Jago had shielded her from all the doubts so far. Could it be taken away through her follies? She was sickened by shame; she had ‘made a fool of herself’ and now they might bring it against her. She did not feel guilty remorse, she was too deeply innocent at heart for that. She felt instead shame and self-hatred, because men spoke ill of her. She had never believed that she could be loved – that was the pain which twisted her nature. Now she felt persecuted, unloved, lost, alone. Had Paul always pretended to love her out of pity? She believed even that – despite the devotion, despite the proofs.
No one could love her, she knew ever since she was a girl, she never had the faintest confidence of being loved. If she could have had a little confidence, she thought, she might have given Paul some comfort; she would not have been driven to inflict on him the woes of a hypochondriac, the venom of a shrew, the faithlessness of one who had to find attention. He would never know how abjectly she worshipped him. All she had done was damage him (she saw the letter in her hand) so much that she could never make it up.
It was long past the time when Roy and I had planned to start for Gay’s, and we had to give up our project for that day. Nothing we said was any help, but it was unthinkable to leave her alone. At last she invited us back to her house for tea. She walked between us through the courts. On our way, we were confronted by Nightingale, walking out of college. His hand moved up to his hat, but she looked away, with a fixed stare. We heard his footsteps dying away. She said almost triumphantly: ‘They’ve cut me often enough.’
In their drawing-room Jago was standing, and the moment we entered he put his arm round her shoulders.
‘I’ve been looking everywhere for you,’ he said. ‘Why didn’t you leave word where you’d gone? You mustn’t disappear without trace What is the trouble?’
‘What is the trouble with you?’ she cried. He had been standing in the twilight, but she had switched on the light as we went in. His face was haggard, his eyes sunken: even his lips were pallid.
‘You two know by now?’ said Jago. We nodded. He turned to his wife, his arm resting on her.
‘Dearest, I’m afraid that I’m going to make you unhappy. It seems that I shall be rejected by the college.’
‘Is this my fault?’
‘How could it be your fault?’ Jago replied, but her question, which pierced one like a scream, was not addressed to him. I answered: ‘It’s nothing to do with anyone we’ve been talking about. It’s quite different. Old Eustace Pilbrow has crossed over – for political reasons. He can’t even have read the flysheet when he decided, and he’d be the last to take any notice–’
‘Thank God,’ she said, laying her head on Jago’s shoulder. ‘If they don’t give it to you after all, Paul, I couldn’t bear it to be because of me.’
‘Does it concern us,’ asked Jago bitterly, ‘the precise reason why I may be thrown aside?’
‘Yes! Yes!’ she said. She rounded on me. ‘Why didn’t you tell me?’
I said: ‘I couldn’t – until I was sure Paul knew.’
‘Do you realize what it means? Do you realize that they’re hoping to humiliate me now?’ Jago cried.
‘They couldn’t,’ she said. ‘Nothing could. Nothing could touch you. You’re big enough to laugh at anything they do. They know you’re bigger than they are. That’s why they fear you so.’
Jago smiled – was it to relieve her, as a parent pretends to an anxious child? Or had she brought him comfort?
He kissed her, and then said to Roy and me: ‘I am sorry to receive you like this. But the news has knocked me out more than I expected.’
‘We’re not giving up,’ I said.
‘I’m not sure,’ said Jago, ‘that I shouldn’t ask you to.’
He seemed suddenly tired, passive, and resigned. He sat down in his armchair as though the suffering had lost its edge but had worn him out. He enquired after tea, and Alice rang for it. Suddenly he said to her: ‘Why did you ask whether it was your fault? What do you know about the flysheet?’
She began to speak, then said: ‘No, Paul, I can’t–’ and turned to us for aid. I told Jago that someone, presumably Nightingale, had made sure that she should see the flysheet: she was afraid there might be more attacks upon her: she thought they wanted her to persuade Jago to withdraw; she had been in anguish for Jago’s sake.
Very softly, Jago exclaimed.
&n
bsp; Then he spoke to her in a quiet, familiar tone.
‘I expect to be rejected now. Would you like me to withdraw?’
Tears had come to her eyes, but she did not cry. She could hardly speak. At last she managed to say: ‘No. You must go on.’
‘You knew what you had to say.’ Jago gave her a smile of love.
When that smile faded, his expression was still sad and exhausted: but in his eyes, as he spoke again, this time to Roy and me, there was a flash of energy, a glitter of satanic pride.
‘I’ve cursed the day that I ever exposed myself to these humiliations,’ he said. ‘I knew you and my other friends meant well, but you were not doing me a kindness when you persuaded me to stand. Whether the college rejects me or takes me, I am certain that I will not stand for another office so long as I live.’ He paused. ‘But I am equally certain that if those people hope to get me to withdraw through doing harm to my wife, I will stay in this election while I’ve got one single man to vote for me.’
He added: ‘And I shall leave nothing to chance. I shall tell my rival so.’
35: Crawford Behaves Sensibly
After Jago cried out that he ‘would tell his rival so,’ he asked Roy to find from the kitchens whether Crawford was dining that night. The answer was yes. ‘That is convenient,’ said Jago.
Crawford arrived in the combination room at the same time as I did, and several of his party were already there. They were drinking their sherry in front of the fire, and there was an air of well-being, of triumph, of satisfied gloating. Crawford greeted them with his impersonal cordiality, and me as well. He seemed more than ever secure, not in the least surprised by what had happened; he took it for granted that it was right.
‘Eliot,’ Nightingale addressed me. He had not spoken to me directly for months.
‘Yes?’
‘I suppose you’ve heard about Pilbrow.’
‘Of course.’
‘I had a note from him this afternoon,’ Crawford announced.