by Tom Holt
I began to record the history of the city, on a piece of parchment that had come wrapped round a large cheese. I recorded our first harvest, the first couple of deaths and births, the first major theft, the first rape, the first sale of land— It wasn’t anything special, in fact it was mostly downright primitive. But it was alive.
Extraordinary...
CHAPTER TWELVE
When my son was a year old, I chose a name for him. I’d left it rather late, putting off the chore for a variety of insubstantial reasons — perhaps at the back of my mind I believed that if I ignored his existence he’d go away. Why I should want to think like that I have no idea; I wasn’t conscious of not wanting the child, or not feeling the usual degree of paternal affection. Maybe it had something to do with the fact that Theano and I weren’t getting along particularly well, though there’s no logical connection there that I can see. On the other hand, logic doesn’t usually have much to do with anything in such circumstances, as far as I can tell.
I named him Eupolis; nominally after his great-grandfather, the Comic poet, but really because Eupolis means (or can be made to mean) ‘from the best of cities’;
it was a propitiatory sacrifice, an act of dedication for the colony itself, as well as a pun on the highfaluting ‘official’ name the Founders had chosen. As such, it was well received and taken by my honest neighbours as a vote of confidence, or an act of faith. Something like that, anyway.
Fair play to us; we built that city quickly and well. I believe that a large measure of our success was due to the fact that the Founders, having settled every last theoretical detail from the names of the streets to the colours the statues were to be painted before the expedition left Macedon, left us alone once we actually got there, and we were therefore able to ignore everything they’d decided, which was a great help. As for all that wonderful theorising about the ideal form of government for the ideal colony, all the model constitutions and draft law-codes we drew up and then tore to bits over someone else’s wine and chickpeas, in practice it all turned out to be about as much practical use as a tiny, pearl-encrusted gold pickaxe. We didn’t bother with any of that stuff; no need. The problem we had wasn’t deciding how best to impose the orders of the ruling class on our subordinates; quite the reverse. Where we ran into difficulties was in finding anybody who was prepared to give any orders at all.
Odd? Well, it was an odd set-up, I suppose. What made the difference was that, whether by random chance or disguised good fortune, we arrived on the Black Sea coast with a profound shortage of expertise. We had farmers, and a handful of people who knew a bit about building things, and that was about it; all the other technical knowledge pooled between us lay in the fields of killing and toss-arguing, and neither discipline (we quickly acknowledged, thank the gods)
helps much when you’re trying to put a roof on a barn or mark out a wall in a straight line.
Now, if we’d all been as useless as each other, I expect we’d have wiped each other out in bitter feuding within a week or so, as each faction of opinionated ignorance tried to bring its rivals round to its way of thinking by force of arms, like they do in real cities. But we did have experts, though not nearly as many as we’d have liked, and so pretty soon we had a workable system of government. Each expert was in charge of the project that needed his expertise and the rest of us kept our faces shut and did what we were told. As oecist I theoretically had the right to interfere, veto and command; but as they say, just because you’ve got ten fingers doesn’t necessarily mean you can play the harp. Like every farmer I knew a bit about everything, just enough to be able to see that there are some things you’ve got to entrust to the man who knows what he’s about.
The system worked because none of our experts wanted to give orders — after all, who wants responsibility when he’s got to live with the consequences himself?
Agenor the sculptor, for example, knew about dressing stone, and as much practical architecture as a site foreman needs to do his job. He wasn’t an architect; but we made him be one. The first thing he did, accordingly, whenever called upon to build anything, was to make it clear that he wasn’t an architect, and that he’d much prefer it if somebody else told him what to do Having reluctantly accepted the commission, he proceeded with extreme caution, like a cat walking along a branch of a thorn tree, happily listening to all relevant suggestions and actively canvassing opinions from anybody foolhardy enough to express them. In short, quite by chance, we’d hit upon that golden mean we philosophers had been babbling about for generations: a society where the people who didn’t want power were landed with it, and all decisions were reached cheerfully by consensus. Trust me; it works. Whether you could make a go of it in any context other than that of a completely new settlement, a bunch of people with tools standing on a grassy field with no food or shelter apart from what they contrived to make for themselves, I have no idea. That, by the way, was another beneficial side-effect of the settlement process; it cured me for ever of the pernicious urge to speculate about things I don’t know spit about.
The Founders, meanwhile, kept pretty much to themselves, as I mentioned a moment ago. By some happy chance, they realised of their own accord that they were hopelessly out of their depth here, and that any prospect of getting fed, clothed and housed depended on the efforts of the rest of us, who’d do a far better job of providing for them if not interfered with.
‘We have a problem,’ my friend Tyrsenius informed me, as we shared a jug of wine under the shade of the east wall of our nearly completed temple.
(Temple, singular; where the original Foundation plan had provided for no fewer than fourteen temples, we’d edited and modified a bit, coming to the conclusion that the gods were going to have to muck in like everybody else in this colony, share a house and learn to get along with each other without squabbling.)
‘Really?’ I said, with my hat over my eyes.
‘You bet,’ Tyrsenius replied. ‘If only you’d listened to me earlier, of course—’
‘Quite,’ I said. ‘Refresh my memory. What’s the matter?’
Tyrsenius sighed. ‘We’re broke,’ he replied. ‘Worse than that, we’re up to our ears in debt. I was going over the accounts this morning, and—’
I sat up and pushed my hat back. ‘We’ve got accounts?’ I said, startled.
‘Of course,’ Tyrsenius replied irritably. ‘I’m your treasurer. What do you think I do all day?’
I shrugged. ‘That’s wonderful, Tyrsenius,’ I said. ‘And what’s in these accounts of yours?’
‘Our borrowing,’ he replied grimly. ‘What we owe to the other cities, Odessus and Olbia City . Think about it; we’ve been buying food and building materials and gods know what else from them since the day we arrived here, on the assumption that King Philip’d bail us out and send money.’
I yawned. ‘Which he has done, bless him,’ I said. ‘Thanks, in no small part, to the incredibly persuasive letters I send him every month—’
‘Well, you haven’t been persuasive enough,’ Tyrsenius replied. ‘To be precise, you’ve failed to carry conviction to the tune of twelve talents, three minas.
And that’s what I’d call a problem.’
I poured a little more wine. ‘The cities don’t seem all that worried,’ I said.
‘They keep supplying the stuff, and I haven’t noticed them badgering us for money. Don’t worry about it.’
He scowled at me. ‘Of course they aren’t badgering us,’ he said. ‘It’s all secured on land. Our land. And interest is running, let me remind you—’
‘So?’ I shrugged. ‘What do you think is going to happen? Are the Odessans going to show up one morning with spades and buckets and dig up all the land and cart it back to Odessus? Don’t see it myself. If they want more land, all they’ve got to do is go out and take it, right in their back yard. There’s more than enough for everybody. You’re thinking like we’re still in Greece , my friend.’
He shook his head. ‘Y
ou’re telling me their security’s worthless, then.’
I nodded. ‘For all practical purposes,’ I replied. ‘It comforts them to know there’s mortgage stones all over the fields here; I suppose it helps them balance their books and all. But in real life they know they’re going to have to wait till we’re on our feet and producing before they get their money. They trust us. Everything’s all right.’
Tyrsenius blew out through his nose, like a horse. ‘You reckon,’ he said.
‘Sure,’ I replied. ‘One thing they won’t do is anything that’ll make life difficult for us — like trying to call in the debts. If we go under, they’ll never get paid. So they’ve got to keep supporting us. Good for us; in the long term, good for them. Plus, they’ve got King Philip as guarantor at the end of the day, and his credit’s good, I’m sure.’
‘You think so?You think he’ll hold still and be sued if we default on a loan?’
I smiled. ‘What an enticing mental image that is,’ I said fondly. ‘But no, that’s not what I mean at all. Be realistic. What they’re getting in return for goods and services delivered is the most valuable currency in the world —
Philip’s awareness that they’re doing him a favour. Have you been listening to the news from Greece lately?’
Tyrsenius looked puzzled. ‘Not sure I follow,’ he said.
‘All right,’ I said. ‘Suppose you lived in Sicily or somewhere like that, where they have those villages perched on the rim of a giant volcano. Now, suppose that the next time the volcano starts rumbling and burping fire and generally giving notice that it’s about to play war, you’re in a position to whisper in its ear, so to speak, that you’ve been going out of your way to be nice to the volcano’s pet nephew; the volcano recognises this, so when it erupts, the other villages get swallowed up in the lava flow, but you don’t. Worth a few bad debts, —’don’t you think?’
Tyrsenius thought about it for a moment, then snuggled his back against the wall and put his hands behind his head.
‘My point exactly,’ he said.
I’m not going to write the history of Philip’s piecemeal gobbling-up of the Greeks. It’s a long and tortuous story, and to be honest with you I’m not sure I can remember the details after all this time, particularly since I wasn’t there when it was happening. What you need to know is that my royal patron had worked his way down through Greece , stirring up trouble and then stepping in to stop the resulting brawls; and once he was in somewhere, it proved rather difficult to get him out again. He was everywhere, the voice of sweet reason, agreeing with everybody at the same time. His operating system reminded me a lot, in fact, of those same Scythian archers who kept the peace back home. When a fight broke out, they didn’t rush in and intervene, thus uniting the warring factions in the common cause of beating the shit out of them. Instead they waited till the fight was over, and then stepped in and arrested anybody who was still standing. That was Philip’s way, except that he’d also started the fight.
It was, of course, that wonderful diplomatic skill of his that made it possible, and somehow everybody played along, though they must have seen for themselves what he was up to. In Athens , for instance, my old colleague Demosthenes harangued Assembly nearly every day with ferocious, entirely accurate accounts of Philip’s evil cunning. I gather that Demosthenes’ speeches were so popular that the City ground to a halt, with everybody who could manage to squeeze into the Pnyx hanging on his every word. When he’d done they’d applaud him till the ground shook — then proceed to vote down his proposals and do what Philip wanted, for the simple reason that if they didn’t, it might give him a pretext for declaring war, and that would be that.
The only city that openly defied him was Sparta ; and he only tolerated them, I think, out of sentiment. You see, Sparta wasn’t the world-class power it had been in Grandfather’s time. It had, quite simply, grown old; it was a little, wizened shadow of what it had once been, and Philip made a point of treating it with the respect due to an honoured but rather senile ex-hero, tolerating its tantrums and threats with a broad smile that told the rest of Greece that he knew exactly what the realities of the situation were. At least the Spartan sense of humour was still alive and kicking; when Philip sent a long and beautifully reasoned letter to the Spartan high council, demanding various concessions and backed with a delicate infusion of blandishments and threats, the Spartans duly considered it and sent back a reply, which read In reply to yours: no.
But plucky little Sparta was an exception. The rest of Greece knew what was going to happen, but there was nothing they could do. They were on the edge of the volcano, roasting chestnuts in the glowing ash while they could and waiting for the sky to turn red.
The other day I came across one of the letters Alexander wrote me at about that time — I was patching my oldest and most highly prized pair of boots, not for the first time, and when I came to peel off one of the many layers of parchment I’ve pasted on the underside of the uppers over the years, there it was;
three-quarters legible, and the rest easy enough to guess from the context.
There was nothing special about that letter, beyond the fact that it had managed to survive so long and so much; just like me, I suppose. It’s absolutely typical of the letters he sent me while he was trailing round Greece acting as Philip’s adjutant; my theory is that he treated his letters to me as practice exercises, to make sure he didn’t forget how to conduct a formal correspondence with a respected elder of lesser rank, They read like the examples you get in those Complete Letter-Writer books, the sort that provide a model letter for every conceivable occasion — letters from fathers to sons; letters from ambassadors to kings; letters from creditors to debtors, class one (apologetic), class two (dismissive), class three (overbearing and arrogant); letters from husbands to wives; letters from recently appointed stewards to their masters informing them of increased annual yield or reports of dishonesty among the casual labour — but I knew for a fact that Alexander was far too proud to copy out forms and precedents written by somebody else, because when I told him to back in Mieza he flatly refused, and told me why in no uncertain terms; so I guess he was in effect writing his own and using me as a kind of quality control.
His letters were always meticulously constructed:
1) Formal greetings;
2) Conventional enquiries about my health and brief report on his own;
3) Admirably lucid and concise precis of the state of play in the current campaign — excellent practice for writing dispatches, and clearly showing that he’d taken to heart what I’d taught him when we did class exercises in military prose composition back in the old days;
4) Interesting and informative observations on matters of geographical, political, anthropological and botanical interest that had come to his attention since his previous letter; why he sent these to me rather than Aristotle (who liked that sort of thing) I don’t know, unless he wrote the same letter to both of us, changing only the name at the top and the address on the outside;
5) One amusingly whimsical anecdote, human interest story or similar lighter note, also serving to reiterate some point or statement made earlier in the letter about some major current topic, thereby completing the structural loop;
6) Exhortations to reply and best wishes.
Of their kind, they were perfectly good letters — easily B, often rising to B+, and always a straight A for presentation and handwriting; I’d dutifully reply in the appropriate manner, singling out the good bits for elegantly muted praise and tactfully drawing his attention to omissions or infelicities of style (‘I was fascinated by your account of the black sticky substance the olive-growers of Thessaly use to protect their trees against rats, but I think I may have missed the part where you say whether it actually works or not. Does it?’);
throughout our correspondence, which lasted until Philip died, I can’t say I learned anything about Alexander that I didn’t know already, or ever read a word that couldn’t just as fittin
gly have been written to somebody else.
We had one good harvest, followed by a bad one, followed by one that was just about good enough. The problem, we found, was the seed-corn; Greek seed wasn’t used to the rich and productive soil, and something went wrong with it in the second year. For the third year we bought about half our seed from Odessus; by a strange coincidence, about half the crop came up.
In the third year we cut down all our olive trees and burned them. It was obvious they weren’t going to come to anything, and we needed the space. It was at this point that someone pointed out that the Greeks bought their Black Sea grain with olives, because olives didn’t grow here.
That apart, there wasn’t much for me to record in the official history. We carried on building and borrowing, we gradually ploughed up more land without any protests from the Scythians, who stayed out of our way so completely that we wouldn’t have known they were there. The days were full, and at night we were too tired to do anything except go to bed.
Like everybody else, I’d been allotted thirty acres, with the right to stake a claim on any unclaimed land I liked provided I ploughed and sowed it within a year. Like nearly everybody else, I had my work cut out coping with thirty acres. For one thing, it wasn’t like thirty acres in Attica , which would work out on average as seventeen acres of usable soil and thirteen acres of bare rock. I only wish my father could have seen it; so much flat, fertile, deep-soiled ground, enough to provide a good living for a whole damn dynasty.