by Ryan Ruby
That sound.
Nothing, baby, he says. It was nothing. Just a car backfiring.
I never learnt where Zach found those pistols. Where does one buy a handgun anyway? Estate sale? Antique shop? The black market? I hadn’t asked, and if I hadn’t asked it is because I’d rather not know. When Bernard told me that the Inspector from the Thames Valley Police had managed to trace the pistol (he said pistol, singular, and I certainly wasn’t about to correct him), I let it be understood with a wave of my hand that I preferred to be kept in the dark about certain aspects of the case. Still, this hasn’t prevented me from speculating. Whoever sold the firearms to Zach would surely have told the Inspector about the second pistol. Unless he bought them from two different people. Unless: he stole them. It wouldn’t have been the first time, after all.
The pistols were small and old. Their black barrels were no longer than my outstretched index finger, the sort of weapon my grandfather might have stripped off the corpse of some Nazi officer during the war. They looked ridiculous to me, but Zach was quite serious about them, as he was about any technology the rest of us considered antiquated. When I asked him if they even worked, his expression soured. Of course they do! He’d tested them to make sure. Yanks and their bloody guns. Whatever else they may feel about them, they’re all obsessed by them. Even Zach, the latchkey kid born and bred in downtown Manhattan. When he collected me from Prelims, one pistol weighing down each pocket of his dinner jacket, he must have been the most heavily armed person in all of Oxfordshire.
RITUALS OF SUSPENSION.—The ritual that can withstand the deadening weight of its own unbroken repetition has yet to be choreographed. Any ritual so rigid that it fails to include the means of its own periodic suspension is bound to go extinct.
Pembroke is one of the smallest and poorest of Oxford’s colleges. The Cotswold stone buildings seem to turn inward, away from bustling St. Aldate’s, as if ashamed of the plainness of their features. The Old Quad, where I was given rooms, lies quite literally in the shadow of the fairer sister over the road. Tourists would come from round the world to visit Pembroke Square, only to turn their backs on our Porter’s Lodge so they could have a better angle from which to snap a photograph of Tom Tower, the lavishly ornamented gateway to Christ Church.
The college was old enough to have produced a few notable alumni, but the most famous of them, Samuel Johnson, was sent down after a year for a lack of funds. Today, its students are better known for the speed of their oars on the Isis than the speed of their pens in the Exam Schools. It is largely made up of those like me, who have what the Student Union euphemistically calls non-traditional backgrounds, and who were only able to attend the oldest university in England by grace of what the Bursar called, rather less euphemistically, hardship grants. (Mine in particular were financed by the sale, a few years previously, of Man in a Chair, an early painting by Francis Bacon, a poster of which was the only decoration on the walls of my rooms.) Rounding out the Junior Common Room were the thicker products of the public schools, Erasmus scholars from the continent, and Americans on their year abroad.
Of this last group there were around twenty, paying American tuition fees to add English polish to their CVs. The reason for their presence at Pembroke was nakedly economic, a way for a college whose endowment consisted almost entirely of subsidies from its wealthier neighbours to generate a bit of additional revenue. They were lodged in the back staircases of the North Quad, on the main site, with the rest of us first years. Though they were only two years older than I, and though they were living, many for the first time, in a country not their own, this slight difference in age lent them an air of cosmopolitan sophistication; I certainly wasn’t the only one to regard the visiting students, as they were called, more as elders than as peers. For better or worse, they generally had the run of the place.
Zach was not long in distinguishing himself, mostly through skirmishes with various members of the college staff concerning the finer points of college etiquette. The first time I recall seeing him, he was being reprimanded by Richard Hughes, the Head Porter, a lean and sallow-faced man in his fifties, whose fingernails were worn longer than his sense of humour. I remember looking out my window to see what the fuss was about below. Zach, it seems, had walked across the immaculate square of lawn in the Old Quad on his way to the pantry. Not content to defer to authority—or local custom—he was demanding, in those flat syllables I’d come to know so well, the explanation for such an absurd rule. The one he was given (“only fellows and newlyweds are permitted to walk on the lawn of the Old Quad”) didn’t satisfy him. He demanded another. The exasperated Head Porter told him that it was “out of respect for the sleep of the dead monks who are buried there.” To this he nodded, convinced and perhaps a tad impressed. But whenever he walked through the Old Quad, he made sure to toe the cobblestones near the edge of the lawn, not seeming to care, now that he had been reprimanded, that he was liable to pay a fine if he lost his balance.
A fortnight later, I was sitting alone at what had already become my regular seat at my regular table, reading whilst I waited for Formal Hall to begin. I was dressed subfusc—jacket, white bowtie (in my case poorly knotted), black commoner’s gown—the requisite attire. Zach arrived in the company of Gregory Glass, in the middle of a heated political debate.
“I can’t believe what I’m hearing!” Gregory was saying. The other visiting student from Columbia, Gregory was short and barrel-chested, with long curly brown hair that was held off his face, no matter what time of day, by a sporty pair of sunglasses. I’d already seen him several times at macroeconomics lectures, furiously scribbling away in the front row. That term, not a single lecture would conclude without Gregory raising his hand to ask a question, or rather, to give a meandering observation in an interrogative tone.
He asked me if they could sit at my table and, without waiting to hear my answer, continued talking to his friend. “Don’t tell me,” he said, in a voice that could be heard from one end of the hall to the other, “you’re going to throw your vote away on Nader!”
“I’m not throwing away my vote,” Zach replied, perfectly calm. “I’m not voting.”
“But it’s your duty to vote! You complain about the government all the time, but when you’re given the chance to actually change things, you throw it—”
“See, that’s where you’re wrong. My vote doesn’t actually change anything. Nor does yours, Greg. You and I are registered in states that have already pledged their electors to Gore. And anyway, on the major issues there is a consensus between the two parties that differs only in rhetorical emphasis. During the presidential debates, the questions are never How should we organize our economy? but What flavor of capitalism would you like? Never What role should the United States have in the world? but How blatant should we be about our empire? Third-party candidates like Nader, who at least would give the election the veneer of choice, are marginalized into irrelevance by unregulated campaign finance laws and”—here he pointed a finger at Gregory—“the bad-faith scare tactics of pseudo-leftists and lesser-evil socialists like you.”
Fuming, Gregory tried to respond to this accusation, but Zach sped to his next point before he could get a word in. “So don’t tell me it’s my duty to accept this state of affairs. It’s not my duty to give legitimacy to this farce we call democracy. Under the present conditions, voting is one of those customs more honored in the breach than the observance.”
Gregory looked like he was going to lean across the table and grab Zach by the bowtie to get him to stop talking. To make sure he wouldn’t be interrupted again, he almost shouted his rejoinder. “Man, you’re so full of shit! I’d rather be a ‘pseudo-leftist’ than the beautiful soul who’s scared to get his hands dirty in actual politics. You think of yourself as a purist, but you’re just a cynic with a trust fund. You talk about not being able to opt out of capitalism? Why would you even want to? You’re its beneficiary! I’ve never met anyone more bourgeois than you
.”
“As Marx defined bourgeois, maybe,” Zach said, with a dismissive twirl of his wrist. “But not as Flaubert defined it. Speaking of cynicism, Comrade Glass, let’s say for the sake of discussion that your socialist dream is realized on earth. Poverty is eradicated, exploitation rooted out, war declared a thing of the past, and total freedom of thought is granted to all. That’s the idea, right? Now, will mankind hunt in the morning, fish in the afternoon, raise cattle in the evening, and criticize after dinner, as Marx predicted?” he asked, counting off each activity on his fingers before answering his own question. “No! They’ll shop in the morning, fill their prescriptions in the afternoon, watch TV in the evening, and die of boredom after dinner! Stupidity is not just the result of false consciousness and organized oppression. It’s the natural condition of the vast majority of mankind. It’s the one thing that is equally distributed among the rich and the poor. Solving our political and economic problems will do nothing to answer the question, Why bother? In fact, all evidence suggests that it will only make that question more difficult to answer.”
Meanwhile, the hall had filled up with students and the fellows of the college had taken their places at the High Table. In a slow roll, the current of conversation ebbed and the hall flooded with the sound of bustling chairs as we all stood to hear the Classics Tutor recite the Latin Grace. All save Zach, that is, who remained seated. He took the opportunity to slide my book close enough to him to get a better view of the cover. He tapped the title with two fingers—I was reading The Birth of Tragedy—and nodded with approval. Grace concluded, the sound of conversation and sliding chairs and clanking cutlery resumed. The waiting staff appeared and began to place the starters on our plates.
Gregory returned to his seat and gave Zach a stern look.
“I bet you were the kid in homeroom who refused to stand for the Pledge of Allegiance.”
“We didn’t have homeroom at The Gansevoort School, Greg.”
The Hall Manager had also noticed the sole seated student and went to enquire into this breach of conduct. The Hall Manager was called Mr. Stroop, a squat man well past middle age, whom I couldn’t stand. Stroop had worked at Pembroke for over a decade, but was far less convincing than the Head Porter in performing his role as the guardian of the college’s traditions and values. It was precisely in his comical assiduousness that he betrayed his working-class origins. No one who belonged at Oxford, who was slated to go there from birth, from before their birth, cared half so much for the college’s traditions and values as he did. This confounded and perplexed him, but as he did not understand why it was the case, he was undeterred in his mission. Queuing up at the pantry one day, I heard him correct the pronunciation of an American who had ordered his sandwich without tomato. “It’s toh-mah-toe,” he said. “Not toh-may-toe. You’ve come all this way to receive a proper education. You should at least learn how to order a sandwich.” A proper education. One he himself had not received. A fact that was not lost on the American, who sneered at this bit of servility and told him to bring the sandwich “without toh-mah-toe. Right quick!” Which Stroop did, causing me to wince.
Implying he couldn’t hear what was being said over the general din, though he must have known quite well what the Hall Manager was there to discuss, Zach motioned him closer to his ear. Stroop stooped as he was told and the whole table quieted down to listen to what promised to be a duel of insincere politeness.
“Mr. Foedern—”
“How may I be of help, sir?”
“I couldn’t help but notice that you—and you alone—were not standing during the recitation of Grace.”
“Yes, sir, you’ll have to forgive me. You see, I don’t speak Latin.”
“Don’t speak Latin? I’m afraid I don’t see what that’s got to do with it.”
“I’ll explain. To stand means to assent, no?”
“To stand? Yes, I reckon…”
“Well, there you have it. I can’t assent if I don’t understand what’s being said. And I can’t stand if I don’t assent. So perhaps you’ll be so good as to translate the Grace for me so I can decide whether I assent or not.”
Zach batted his eyelashes with feigned innocence and, receiving no response from the flustered Hall Manager—whose only Latin, needless to say, was Veni vidi vici and Dominus illuminatio mea—tucked into his prawns. Mr. Stroop interrupted him to escort him to the High Table so the Classics Tutor could translate the Grace for him. I watched Zach listen gravely, exchange a few words with Stroop, and return to his place at the table. But he did not sit down. He poured himself another glass of wine and drank it in a single swallow.
“Now that I understand,” he told us, “I definitely do not assent.”
“Where are you going?” Gregory demanded.
“To Hassan’s,” Zach said, referring to the kebab van on Broad Street. “I’m sure they will agree with my position on the Latin Grace.”
I never again saw Zach attend Formal Hall, but I noticed that during every subsequent Grace, one or two students remained seated, small acts of rebellion that would plague Mr. Stroop until the end of the year.
THE FEAR OF THE INEXPRESSIBLE.—Language doubles: it transforms the physical into the metaphysical, the specific into an instance of the general, the particular case into an abstract idea. Naming marks the creation of an entirely new ontological region that shadows the old one, coextensive yet distinct. Access to this doubled world is what makes transcendence possible, but this access is never total, nor is it ever complete. This is precisely what is so terrifying about the inexpressible. The inexpressible is the sliver of the material that resists all colonisation by signification; it is the remainder par excellence. Greek mathematicians, for instance, were so intimidated by the inexpressible that they did not hit upon the simple solution of making nothingness disappear by assigning it a number.
At seven in the morning, the receptionist is the only person in the lobby, and even he is still asleep. His hands are folded on his heaving chest; his feet, crossed at the ankle, hang over the corner of his desk. Doing my best not to disturb him, I reach over the top of the desk to pull a strip of paper, on which the computer’s login and password are printed, from the pile he keeps in a blue-and-white cup that says WE ARE HAPPY TO SERVE YOU in ochre pseudo-Hellenic font. I manage nonetheless to knock the cup onto his lap. His eyes fly open and he straightens in his chair, giving me a glazed and irritated look. Sorry, sorry, I say, backing slowly away from the desk, palms in the air. The receptionist smacks his lips and stretches, then starts to put the slips back into the cup.
I sit down at the computer terminal, type the address of Oxford Nexus into the browser, and scan my inbox for new messages. There is one from the editor of a London poetry journal informing me that the sonnet “Eadem, Sed Aliter” I’d submitted with Mr. Zachary Foedern has been accepted for publication in the Autumn issue. Had I received it only a month ago, this news surely would have made me swell with pride—it’s the first time my name’s going to appear in print, after all. But the knowledge that my co-author isn’t here to celebrate with me renders the editor’s congratulations more bitter than sweet. I look at the other address in the recipient field and think of Zach’s inbox, filling up day by day with emails like this one, messages that will go forever unread.
There is one from my father, confirming receipt of the email I sent yesterday informing him I had arrived safely at my destination, and requesting, with typical curtness, that I ring him or Mum as soon as I was able to purchase a phone card.
And there is one from Claire.
In the short time we’d known each other, how many hundreds of emails had I exchanged with Claire? This is the first that has ever filled me with dread. The subject line meant that she was no longer in Oxford, but had gone with Tori to the latter’s parents’ house in Greenwich. Yesterday, whilst I packed my luggage, she quietly slipped into Tori’s bedroom, where the lights had been off for days, to check on our grieving friend. She came out
again to kiss me goodbye when it was time for me to walk to the bus station at Gloucester Green. Her face was pale with worry; we kissed like we’d never see each other again.
FROM: [email protected]
TO: [email protected]
SUBJECT: From Greenwich
Writing to you from Tori’s. We took the train and arrived last night. The mood here is grim. No change from when you last saw her. She slept fourteen hours yesterday. When she’s awake she’s absolutely inconsolable. She’s lost half a stone in the past week and it shows. Her parents are alarmed, but none of us know what to do with her. Mrs Hardwood suggested she see a therapist, but she wasn’t having it. Last night, before we went to sleep, she told me she feels guilty, that she’s responsible for Zach’s death. She would have liked to have gone with you to the funeral, but she felt it wouldn’t be appropriate, because she thinks she’s the cause of it. All she talks of is Commems. How she wished she hadn’t pressured him into going. Anyway, the point is moot. She’s in no condition to travel.
I know it’s absolutely horrid of me to say, but Tori’s grief is becoming overwhelming. It’s as if no one is allowed to be sad but her. I know your relationships with Zach were much closer, but I loved him too and I haven’t been able to show it. I can’t keep it in all the time. It amazes me that you have so far. I had to tell someone this and you’re the only person who would understand. We carry other people’s burdens and then there is no room to carry our own so we drop it off on someone else. I’m sorry it had to be you, darling, because you’re carrying the heaviest burden of all.
Take care of yourself there. Try to take a moment to enjoy yourself if you can. I know that sounds blasphemous or somehow disrespectful of the dead, but we still have lives to live. Never forget that. Never ever forget that.
I’ll keep you posted on what’s happening here.