The Murder That Never Was: A Forensic Instincts Novel

by Andrea Kane

Ryan shot off a salute. “I aim to please.”

  “This is Patrick Lynch,” Casey introduced, waiting as Patrick shook hands with each of them. “The magnificent bloodhound lying over there and staring at you is Hero. And over here is the team member who’s responsible for getting you here—Emma Stirling.”

  CHAPTER SEVENTEEN

  Emma’s head shot up. Casey was giving her full credit and opening the door for her to lead the way. Emma couldn’t, wouldn’t, let her down.

  Composure in place, Emma rose to shake their hands. “I’m so glad you’re here,” she said. “I know we can help you.”

  Miles and Lisa both looked puzzled by this turn of events and taken aback by Casey’s announcement.

  “I thought Ryan was our ticket in,” Milo stated bluntly.

  “Nope.” Ryan shook his head. “I was second on board with this case. Emma zeroed in on you, did all the initial research, and brought the case to me—to us. She’s a very tenacious and loyal investigator. You’re very lucky; she came to your rescue before you even knew you needed rescuing.”

  “You lost us,” Lisa said.

  “Not completely,” Milo corrected her. “I did a background check on each of you. Emma’s past bore a striking similarity to ours, Lis. Foster care and all.”

  “Oh.” Lisa was clearly surprised.

  “I’ll fill in the blanks,” Emma offered. “Let’s all sit.” She paused, then figured what the hell. She didn’t have to be a receptionist to be cordial. “Can I get you some coffee or something?”

  “We’re fine.” Lisa was already settling herself at the conference table, sitting next to Emma and directly across from Ryan and leaving the empty seat beside her for Milo.

  Once they were seated, Emma explained everything, touching briefly on her own previous life but concentrating mostly on how she’d stayed connected to Chicago, and how, as a result, she’d found Lisa’s obit.

  “The rest was obsessive on my part,” she said in her endearingly shoot-from-the-hip manner. “I was so pissed that Lisa Barnes was being dismissed like a strung-out junkie because of a juvie record and a life in foster care that I couldn’t leave it alone. I didn’t know about Miles—all the detailed discovery was on Ryan’s part—but I knew that Lisa deserved better than what she got. I had so many questions, and I felt such a strong connection to her—to you,” she amended, addressing Lisa, “that I couldn’t let it go. Thankfully, my team is exactly that—a team. They all jumped in to help me. Which is how Ryan found the connection between ScoobyDoo and Miles, and between Miles and Lisa. When he and Marc visited you in Upper Montclair, they saw you were freaked out and in trouble.”

  “Wow,” Lisa said. “That’s nothing like the story I was expecting to hear. We thought you were working for whoever’s after us. And all along this was happening because you felt like we were kindred spirits.” She swallowed. “Thank you.”

  “No problem.”

  “A lot has happened since we saw you, and before we saw you,” Milo told Ryan and Marc. “But I want you to sign a confidentiality agreement. And we’ll sign whatever contract you need us to.”

  “They’ve been prepared.” Casey slid several sheets of paper across the table. “Ours are already signed. The contract is waiting for your signature.”

  Milo took the pages and scanned them, passing them to Lisa. “Just so you know, this whole situation found us. We’re innocent of any wrongdoing.”

  “That’s not quite true,” Marc said. “You’re guilty of identity theft. But we’re not the police. So that information stays in this room.”

  “I appreciate that,” Lisa said, signing the documents and passing them back to Milo. “And, for the record, the identity swapping was completely spontaneous and all me. Milo wasn’t involved. I saw Julie Forman shot dead. Given some of the things I’ve done—”

  “Your drug running,” Ryan supplied.

  A brief pause. “Yes. Anyway, I assumed it was my past coming back to haunt me. So I was desperate to have the people I’d worked for think I was dead. I took Julie’s wallet and cell phone, and planted mine on her. I was too freaked out to function. I ran to Milo.” She gave a small, self-deprecating laugh. “I always have and I always do.”

  “And Miles did the rest,” Emma murmured. “He cleaned up after you and created new identities and new lives for you.”

  “Exactly.”

  “How did you meet Julie Forman? You were obviously close if you were living in her apartment.”

  “Not at all. We only knew each other for a week.” Lisa went on to explain Julie’s part in getting her a job at the gym and giving her a temporary place to live. “Our resemblance to each other was a fluke.”

  “So you think the cartel figured out the truth and they’re now after you?” Patrick asked.

  “That’s what we thought at first,” Milo replied, sliding the fully-executed agreements across the table to Casey. “And it’s still possible. But there’s a hell of a lot more going on here than we knew. We walked right into a completely separate but potentially explosive situation.”

  “Which is?” Casey asked.

  Milo hesitated. He glanced at Lisa, seeking her permission to fully confide in the Forensic Instincts team. “I trust them, Lis,” he stated frankly. “But you have to also.”

  Lisa chewed her lip and then nodded. “Emma sealed the deal. Knowing who set the wheels in motion—and why—convinces me that she and her team are in our corner. So, yes, I trust them. Go ahead.”

  Emma was practically glowing. “Thank you,” she said. “We’ll come through for you, I promise.”

  “I believe you.”

  With that, Milo told the team everything, from the private messages sent by Shannon—including the audio tape she’d attached of her argument with Jim Robbins—to her impending runaway trip to Upper Montclair, to their visit from the Montclair police.

  “Now we’re leaning toward the fact that it really was Julie they wanted to kill, not Lisa,” Miles concluded.

  Casey leaned forward. “Let’s dismiss the audio tape. From what you’ve told us, there’s nothing solidly incriminating on it. Lisa, tell us what you remember about the shooting. You obviously were up close at some point if you swapped IDs with Julie. Did you see her approaching the apartment? Did you see the vehicle or its occupants? Anything you can remember could help.”

  Lisa dragged nervous hands through her hair and stared down at the table. “I haven’t wanted to relive that day, that moment. It was the most horrifying thing I’ve ever seen.”

  “Try. You’re in a safe place now.”

  Swallowing, Lisa forced the memories to resurface. “I was sitting outside on the front steps of the apartment. I saw Julie coming. But she wasn’t herself. She was furious, shaking, striding to the apartment like she was about to punch someone. I remember that, because I was scared to death that she’d found out about my past. She was gripping a bag and her purse. In a nanosecond, a dark car came speeding down the street and right up to her. The passenger door opened, and a big, creepy guy with tattoos on his arms got out. He was holding a gun. Before Julie even had time to react, he put two bullets straight into her head.”

  “Two gunshots and no one came running?”

  “I guess he used a silencer. He had to, because the shots were like muffled pops. Julie crumpled. Everything in her purse flew out. Blood was splattered everywhere. The guy jumped back into the car, and they took off.”

  “You’re sure no one else was around?”

  “Very sure.” Lisa’s eyes were damp. “I double-checked before I ran to the body. There was blood pooling all around her head. She wasn’t breathing. I checked her pulse. I had to make sure…but she was dead. That’s when I took what I needed from the stuff that had been in her purse—her wallet, her cell phone, her keys, her checkbook—anything tied to her identity. I planted my ID on her body and bolted.”

  “Did you take the bag?” Marc asked.

  Lisa blinked, processing his question.

>   “You just said she was gripping a bag,” he reminded her in a quiet tone that pressed her just enough to get answers without flipping her out. “It must have fallen out of her arms. Did anything spill out? Did you do a quick check to see if there was anything in it you should have? Did you take it? Leave it?”

  Prodded into remembering, Lisa shook her head from side to side. “It wasn’t there.” She paused. “The guy who shot her took it.”

  “So you have no idea what was in it?”

  “No.”

  “Which is probably why you’re still alive,” Marc said. “They figured that nobody else knew anything.”

  “I didn’t—not then.”

  “Okay,” Ryan interrupted. “So Julie must have, unfortunately, walked into a situation involving a dangerous PED distribution ring—the one that that young gymnast, Shannon Barker, was PMing you about.”

  As Ryan spoke, he was already thinking about the next steps he had to take. “Yoda,” he said. “Do a cursory search on Shannon Barker and Jim Robbins…”

  “Yoda doesn’t need to waste his time,” Milo interrupted. “I’ve done an in-depth search on both Shannon and Robbins, as well as on the Apex Olympic Gymnastic Center, where Shannon trained, and on Yuri Varennikov, who was Shannon’s manager.” Milo pulled out his laptop, flipped it open, and turned it on. While it booted up, he glanced quickly at Ryan’s business card to verify his email address. “I’ll send you everything I have right now.” A corner of his mouth lifted. “Should I cc Yoda?”

  “Was that humor, Ryan?” Yoda inquired. “Or is a response in order?”

  “It was humor, Yoda,” Ryan replied. “Not to worry. I’ve got this.” He frowned thoughtfully as Milo began to email material to him. “You hit a brick wall so far on who Robbins could have been working for?”

  Milo nodded. “But, like you and Marc said, whoever it is, Julie must have found out more than she should have.”

  “Agreed.” Ryan was still frowning. “But how did Julie get involved in the first place? For Shannon?”

  “Her actions were a part of who she was.” Claire had that faraway look in her eyes. “Julie Forman was a nurturer. She took Lisa in and got her a job, and Lisa is a grown woman. Shannon, on the other hand, is a teenager and one of Julie’s charges. Julie felt committed to finding out the full scope of who was responsible for harming Shannon—and to doing something to stop them.”

  “All of which spells trouble,” Marc said, rolling his coffee mug between his palms. “Julie must have found some paper trail—physical evidence that was in that bag she was carrying. The big guns had to get that bag and shut Julie up before she had a chance to share what she’d found with anyone else.”

  “Where do the Montclair police fit in?” Lisa asked, her palms upturned in question. “Why did they show up at my door? Do they really think I’m a murderer? And who tipped them off to me? I can’t imagine it was Shannon—that doesn’t fit.”

  Ryan shook his head. “Shannon’s all about being under Julie’s protective wing. She’s her only ally. The last thing she’d want is to turn her over to the cops. No, the police were just doing their job. I hacked into the Chicago Police Department records, specifically to read the Lisa Barnes homicide file. It was being kept open pending finding Julie Forman and eliminating her as a suspect or a witness. My guess is that they found out where Julie was and asked the Montclair police to pay her a visit. Their energy on this seems pretty low, so I’m guessing they’re not really investigating hard-core.”

  “We’ll coach you on what to say if they show up again,” Marc added. “But I agree with Ryan. I think they’ll give Chicago their report, and they’ll all call it a day.”

  “Of course,” Emma muttered. “Why bother with a thorough investigation of a piece of trash like Lisa Barnes?”

  “Hey, kid, don’t knock it,” Ryan said. “I know how passionate about this you are, but the best thing for Lisa is if the cops go away. There’s enough of a tangled web here for us to sort out, and enough enemies we have to find and expose.”

  Casey rose and poured herself another cup of coffee. “Let’s get to your next hurdle,” she said to Lisa and Milo. “Shannon Barker. She’s showing up on your doorstep tomorrow. She’s going to see that you’re not Julie. She’s going to have a million questions and be completely freaked out. We need to coach you on how to handle her so that you keep her contained and on your side. It’s more than doable; you just need the right method to do it. That’s where I come in.”

  Milo nodded. “I guess I was wrong. I do need a behavioral specialist, maybe not to read my body language but to teach me how to read somebody else’s.”

  “This isn’t just about body language,” Casey corrected. “You’re going to have to guide her in her thinking, as well as her actions.”

  “I wish we knew more about Julie’s thought process when she was killed—what she found, what she planned on doing with it—things like that. It would help a lot in handling Shannon’s insecurities. As it is, we’re kind of shooting blind,” Milo said.

  “That’s where I come in,” Claire responded. “Hopefully, I can give you some of those answers so you know more about what you’re dealing with. How many of Julie Forman’s personal items do you have? And I don’t mean her ID, cell phone, and computer. That’s the tech stuff, Ryan’s department. I mean truly personal items—clothing, family photos, jewelry, even her perfume. Those are the tools I need.”

  Lisa stared at her, fascinated. “Milo says you’re a psychic.”

  “I actually said she was a claircognizant,” Milo corrected. “It’s a more precise definition, one that doesn’t conjure up images of crystal balls and séances.”

  Claire’s smile reached her eyes. “Thank you for that. Very few people make that distinction. Claircognizance—clear knowing—is a metaphysical sense in which I simply know something to be true, even though I can’t back any of it up with fact or provide an explanation as to how I know it. It’s not that the term psychic is wrong, it’s just that it’s so overused and in all the wrong ways.”

  “And handling Julie’s things can trigger your awareness?” Lisa asked.

  “I can’t promise you results, but, yes, that’s usually what happens.”

  “Well, producing a bunch of Julie’s personal items is no problem. I have some of her photos, books, costume jewelry, and workout clothes. We wanted to make the identity switch as real as possible. So Milo collected the most significant things he could find from her apartment—along with all the tech stuff Ryan needs—right before we took off.”

  “Good. Can you get all that to me with time to spare before Shannon’s arrival tomorrow evening?” Claire asked.

  “Sure,” Milo said. “As soon as we get home, I’ll pack up everything I took from Julie’s apartment. Then I’ll hop an early train here first thing tomorrow morning and bring it to you while Lis is running the gym.”

  “That’s not happening,” Casey replied. “We’re going to be here most of the night prepping you, not only for when Shannon shows up but for what you should do to stay safe and below the radar. No more media coverage for your gym, for example. Nothing that puts you in the public eye. I’d be willing to bet that whoever killed Julie knows exactly where you are. They’ll be keeping an eye on you, making sure you’re a good girl who started a new life far away that’s of no threat to them.”

  “Do you think they know they killed the wrong woman?” Milo asked.

  “It’s a definite possibility. Either way, they’re going to be vigilant.”

  “Are you going to help keep us safe?” Lisa’s eyes were wide with fear.

  “Absolutely. That’s part of what we need to discuss. Marc and Patrick are the go-to people for that. They’ll need to know every moment of your schedules so they can work out a system to protect you. So you’ll need to spend a chunk of tonight meeting with them. While that’s happening, Ryan will be reviewing all the material Miles just emailed him and digging even deeper. He’ll come up with
more, believe me, and some of what he finds might impact how we instruct you.”

  Casey turned to Emma, letting her know that she hadn’t been sidelined. “And Emma’s going to have her own agenda. She has the tightest personal connection with the two of you. She’ll think of tactics we won’t. I’ll leave that in her hands. But, any way you look at it, you’re not leaving until you’re ready for what you’re about to face and how to manage it—and extract what you need to from it. That kind of prep could mean you’ll be here till dawn. So we’ll have to find another way for Claire to get what she needs—which, incidentally is of vital importance, just like everything else I just specified.”

  “I’ll go to Upper Montclair now,” Claire offered. “Just give me your address, your keys, a list of what I’m looking for, and where I can find everything.”

  “That’s not happening.” Patrick was shaking his head adamantly. “I’m sure their apartment is being watched. And you have no training in this area, Claire. We have to get in and out without being spotted. I’ll drive to Upper Montclair. It’ll be faster than the train. I’ll be back in two hours. Marc can brief me on whatever I miss.”

  “Okay.” Lisa handed him her apartment keys and took a pad and pen out of her handbag. “Give me two minutes. I’ll compile the list and locations of what you’ll be looking for.” She was already scribbling, with Milo peering over her shoulder and muttering add-ons.

  Five minutes later, Patrick was out the door and on his way.

  “Okay, you two,” Casey said to Lisa and Milo. “You’re up first with me.”

  CHAPTER EIGHTEEN

  Burlington, Vermont

  It was a cool May night in the breathtaking Green Mountains.

  Max’s focus wasn’t on the panoramic view. It was on the taste of success.

  He sat in his study, sipping his Hennessy Privilege V.S.O.P. He was savoring not only his cognac but the promising weekly status report he’d received, summarizing the progress of all his prospects.