The Murder That Never Was: A Forensic Instincts Novel

by Andrea Kane

  Unfortunately—or fortunately—it rarely took long for that to happen when it came to Jim Robbins. Even in death he seemed to reach out to her, and she somehow knew that his soul was neither dark nor light but more of a muddied gray. He’d been a foolish, greedy man, but he hadn’t been evil, and he certainly hadn’t deserved to die in such a violent manner.

  Violent…agonizingly violent.

  Poison.

  That was the first certainty that crystalized in Claire’s mind. Along with it, she felt shooting pains rip through her gut, cutting off her very breath.

  She refused to give in and release the medal. She was going with this, come hell or high water. The images were clear, and she was living inside them. Jim…writhing on the floor of an elegant room with a long, polished table. He was contorted in pain, animal groans emanating from his throat, foam frothing at his mouth. The torture went on and on, until with a final shudder that racked his body, he went still.

  Death…death…

  Claire gasped, fighting her way to the surface. She was drenched in sweat, shaking so violently she could hardly hold on to the medal. But she wasn’t letting go. Nor was she losing her focus.

  Now she was outside Jim’s lifeless body, aware of his immediate surroundings as she hovered over him.

  Gleaming hardwood floors. Burgundy velvet drapes hanging at the windows. And the mahogany table—it was a dining room. A dining room in the mansion she’d pictured. Mountains in the distance. Rippling water. Acres of untouched land. Green. Green. New England.

  The awareness of the location popped into her head just as the vision vanished.

  Another took its place.

  Someone was standing in the dining room. He’d watched Jim die with a dark and hollow soul.

  A man. Tall. Lean. Cast in shadows. Faceless. Nameless.

  The leader. The killer.

  Claire tried to force something more tangible, but it wouldn’t come. He was shrouded by anonymity, a cold-blooded monster, and he was central to FI’s investigation. Yet she couldn’t see him, couldn’t perceive more.

  Except for one thing.

  He’d kill again unless they stopped him. And it would be one of them who died.

  CHAPTER THIRTY-TWO

  Office of Forensic Instincts

  No member of the Forensic Instincts team was surprised to see Hutch sitting at the conference table when they filed in. They’d all been briefed that Casey had spoken with their clients and that Lisa and Miles had been thrilled that FI could convince their FBI contact to play a more comprehensive role in their case. All of them, particularly Shannon, were badly shaken by the attempted kidnapping, and, extra security or not, they rarely ventured out of the apartment or the gym. The overwhelming fear and anxiety were wearing on them, and Casey could sense that a meltdown was imminent.

  All the more reason to include Hutch in the mix.

  “Hey, guys,” Hutch greeted the team.

  They all responded in kind.

  “Another play-by-the-rules guy—I feel less lonely already,” Patrick said, settling himself in his chair, coffee mug in hand. His banter was light, but his mouth was drawn, and there were dark circles under his eyes. He was worried and exhausted from his long hours of safeguarding their clients—and less than optimistic about the odds of no further violent attempts being made. He took a belt of coffee. “Although somehow I doubt that either one of us will be playing within the confines of those rules.”

  “I’d say that’s a safe bet.” Hutch spoke with his customary candor. “But, as usual, you guys make it impossible for me to mind my own business and stay honest.”

  He folded his arms across his chest and leaned back in his chair, waiting patiently until everyone was caffeine-fixed and seated. Then he addressed the group.

  “I want to set some ground rules, just so we’re clear, not only about this case, but about my overall role here. Yes, I’ve moved to the Big Apple, but I’m not a member of Forensic Instincts. I work for the FBI. That being said, I happen to be in love with Casey. So my loyalties are sometimes divided. But that doesn’t mean I’ll be compromising myself, or you and your commitment to client confidentiality, on a regular basis. That’s precisely why I rented Marc’s apartment rather than moving in here. Your firm and I need our separate space. I’m sure that, at times, we’ll call on each other for help. But I’m trying to keep some sort of line, however blurry, in the sand. I already know where Patrick, and obviously Casey, stands. I hope the rest of you are on board with this.”

  “You’ll call on us?” Emma leaned forward, eyes sparkling. “Does that mean we’ll be some kind of confidential informants on your cases?”

  Hutch’s lips twitched. “You never know.”

  “Well, I’m certainly cool with that.”

  “No problems here,” Ryan said.

  “Not with me, either.” Marc met Hutch’s gaze. “Aidan emailed me a few hours ago and said he’d be calling soon with solid information. Once he does, I’m sure we’ll need your help.”

  “And you’ll have it.”

  “I’m on board with everything Hutch said,” Claire put in. This time there was strength in her voice, and she was the old Claire again. But, rather than a lost, faraway look in her eyes, there was genuine fear. “I also have some new information of my own.”

  Everyone looked at her.

  “Last night I sat down with the training medal Marc brought me from Jim Robbins’ apartment. Once again, I got some clear images. They were nightmarish. I saw Jim Robbins poisoned to death. And I saw a veiled image of the killer as he watched him die. Robbins was killed in this man’s home—the manor I told you about last time. The death was prolonged and agonizing.” She shuddered.

  “You saw the killer?” Casey was all over that one. “What did he look like? Is he Russian? Did you sense that he owns RusChem?”

  “I wish I could answer those questions.” Claire sighed. “The truth is, I just don’t know. He was only a shadowy figure. I couldn’t make out any of his features. All I can tell you is that he’s tall and lean.”

  “That’s not Slava,” Emma said at once. “He’s built like a Humvee.”

  “True,” Marc concurred. “Anything else?”

  “One new thing. This time, when I saw all that green acreage and the surrounding mountains, I got a general location. New England. I know it’s not much.”

  “It’s more than we had before,” Casey replied.

  “It makes sense.” That idea clicked with Hutch. “There are tons of rural places in New England where someone can stay invisible.” His forehead creased in a frown. “I just wish we could narrow it down further.”

  “Hopefully we’ll get some help from Aidan on that.” Casey’s gaze was narrowed on Claire, and she studied the apprehension in her eyes. “There’s obviously more. What is it?”

  Claire wet her lips with the tip of her tongue. “The killer is feeling threatened. We’re making him feel threatened. He’s going to come after us. And right now…all my instincts are screaming that one of us is in danger of dying.”

  A heavy silence greeted Claire’s ominous premonition.

  “Shit,” Ryan muttered at last.

  Along with that expletive, Marc’s cell phone rang.

  “It’s Aidan,” he announced. He punched on the phone. “You have everything now? Good. We’re all here. I’ll put you on speakerphone.”

  He pressed the speakerphone button and placed the iPhone in the center of the conference table. “You’re on, Aidan.”

  “This one was tricky,” Aidan began. “I got what you needed, but my sources seem to feel that our probing didn’t go unnoticed.”

  “So RusChem knows we’re checking into them?”

  “Yup. I don’t think they know who’s doing the probing—not yet. But that’s only a matter of time. And given what I’m about to tell you, we’re all going to have to watch our backs.”

  “Go on,” Casey said.

  “RusChem’s owner is a scientific gen
ius named Maxim Lubinov,” Aidan reported. “You can Google the guy to get his public persona, including a photo and bio. Harvard pedigree—college and medical school. He’s now a foremost expert in microbiology and stem cell research. He’s basically reclusive and doesn’t make many public appearances, but he did recently speak at the Marriott Marquis on scientific advances in increasing cell energy production. You can read the summary of his presentation yourselves.”

  Ryan was already on his computer, calling up the readily available data.

  “And his private persona?” Casey asked.

  “Father’s a high-ranking military officer. I’m sure that’s provided his son with necessary contacts throughout the Russian Federation. Lubinov’s initial career was as a research scientist—a fact that’s conveniently missing from his bio because he pushed ethical boundaries to the point where he resigned before the company could fire him.”

  “What’s the company name?” Ryan asked, his fingers still flying.

  Aidan supplied it but then said, “You won’t find much there, and I wouldn’t waste my time. What’s more important is that Lubinov used the opportunity to fly solo. He developed a series of health supplements and sold them to Osen Pharmaceuticals in a lucrative deal.”

  “Osen Pharmaceuticals is huge,” Marc murmured. “Lubinov must have scored a bundle.”

  “He did,” Aidan replied. “More important still is what he did with his newly acquired financial gains and stream of income.”

  “He launched RusChem,” Casey guessed.

  “Right. And he’s gone to great lengths to keep all details of the company under wraps, including who they are and what they do.”

  “All this is a smoke screen for cashing in on some PED distribution?” Patrick asked, brows raised. “No way. This is much too elaborate a setup for just that.”

  “You’re right,” Aidan agreed. “Lubinov’s goals are much loftier than cash for drugs. From what I was able to gather, he’s heading up some kind of grandiose research project involving über-PEDs. He’s secreted himself away at a private estate in Burlington, Vermont, where he converted a massive, twelve-thousand-foot home into a boutique sports medicine and training facility. His employees are few and unconditionally loyal. He says jump, and they say how high. Clearly, there’s a lot more going on in that mansion than I’m privy to. But he’s obviously on the verge of coming up with a breakthrough formula that he believes will rock the world.”

  That important chunk of information sank in for a minute.

  “Burlington,” Claire murmured. “That’s in the Green Mountains. And Lake Champlain is nearby. That’s the place I was seeing.”

  “I’ll give you the coordinates, Ryan,” Aidan said.

  “Good.” Ryan scribbled down the information Aidan provided him with.

  “Hi, Aidan, it’s Hutch.” Hutch knew Aidan through his friendship with Marc, a friendship that dated back to Marc’s FBI days.

  “Hey, I didn’t know they let you in,” Aidan returned dryly.

  “Just lucky, I guess.” Hutch was simultaneously processing what Aidan was saying and pondering another, equally important offshoot of Lubinov’s work. “I’ve got a good handle on Maxim Lubinov. What I want to know is, where does Eurasian Criminal Enterprise fit into this? Is Lubinov hiring mob members to act as RusChem employees, as well as to eliminate any potential threat to his work?”

  “Absolutely. He needs them for both. This way, his name isn’t associated with RusChem, and he doesn’t have to get his hands dirty protecting his interests. He’s got Slava Petrovich—that guy you asked me to look into—doing both. Petrovich is Lubinov’s cleaner, as well as his front man for RusChem. Petrovich hires the right people to kill off the wrong ones, and takes care of the bigger jobs himself.”

  “Maxim Lubinov is a hands-on killer when he has to be,” Claire amended. “He’s poisoned someone himself.”

  “Oh, I have no doubt that’s true,” Aidan replied. “Lubinov will do anything to protect his venture. If murder is necessary, so be it. He’s not a guy with a conscience.”

  There was a brief pause and the sound of Aidan turning a page. “Getting back to Slava Petrovich, I checked with my former FSB contacts about his background. He’s one terrifying SOB. His nickname is Slava the Slayer, and he was known in the FSB for taking care of problems using whatever means necessary. No further explanation required. But, guys, this bastard is dangerous, and he has skills, so you’d better be careful.” A pause. “On the other hand, I don’t see how you can avoid tangling with him if you want to get to Lubinov. This is an ugly situation all ways around. Are you sure you don’t want to cut your losses on this one?”

  “Not happening,” Casey replied firmly. “We’re going to stop Maxim Lubinov and secure our clients’ safety.”

  “The hell you are,” Hutch shot back in a no-bullshit tone. “You and Forensic Instincts aren’t immortal. Nor are you expendable. You’re not becoming collateral damage.”

  “Okay, this is where I hang up,” Aidan said. “I’ve given you everything I know. What you do with it is up to you. But, for the record, I agree with Hutch. Not to mention that Madeleine, and especially Abby, would kill me if anything happened to Marc.”

  “Nothing’s going to happen to me, Aidan,” Marc replied.

  “Good. Because I’ve spent a hell of a lot of time with Ryan planning your bachelor party. You’re going to be there to endure every embarrassing minute.”

  “Good-bye, leatherneck.” Marc’s middle finger was already on the cell phone button.

  Hutch pulled over a laptop the minute Aidan hung up.

  “I want to read Lubinov’s bio, the public details of his life, and the transcription of his conference speech firsthand. No offense, Ryan.”

  “None taken. You’re the profiling expert. Do what you need to.” Ryan was staring at his own computer screen. “I’m concentrating on the coordinates Aidan gave me so I can zero in on Lubinov’s estate.”

  The reasons for Ryan’s actions were obvious. Still, he stopped short of voicing them aloud. Hutch didn’t need to hear something compromising, even though he knew damned well what FI was planning.

  His disapproving stare bored into Ryan, who just kept his gaze fixed on his computer screen. A weighty silence filled the room.

  With a muttered oath, Hutch went back to his analysis.

  The team exchanged glances. There was no doubt in their minds that Hutch was going to stand in their way. And maybe he was right to do so. This case had spiraled out of control. What they were now facing was really scary stuff, extending far beyond the scope of their expertise. Former KGB agents now employed by Organized Crime, a megalomaniac who killed on a whim… This was the stuff meant for the FBI. But how could they involve the Bureau when all the proof they had had been illegally obtained? What the hell were they going to do?

  Abruptly, Hutch sat back in his chair. “Okay, you wanted my professional assessment, so here it is. Based on everything Aidan said and on what I’m reading here, my belief is that Lubinov suffers from narcissistic personality disorder.” Hutch ticked off the telltale traits on his fingers. “He’s arrogant, haughty, and consumed with his own importance. He expects to be treated in a superior fashion. He only respects those he feels are his equal, and that includes pretty much no one. He’s obsessed with his own brilliance and his indisputable path to success. He is unwilling to recognize the needs and feelings of anyone else and will take advantage of whoever he has to in order to achieve his goals.”

  “Isn’t that like a megalomaniac?” Emma asked.

  Hutch nodded, still deep in thought. “Megalomania is the term that was once used to describe this disorder.” He frowned, clearly not finished with his assessment. “But I think there’s more to Lubinov than just that. In my opinion—again, based on everything I’m hearing and reading—he’s also ruthless enough to have antisocial personality disorder.” Once again, Hutch elaborated. “He has a disregard for right or wrong. Rules and laws don’t appl
y to him; they’re for others. Based on Claire’s vision, there’s evidence of hostility, aggression, and violence—plus, he displays a total lack of empathy for others and lack of remorse about harming them.”

  “A.k.a. wack job,” Emma muttered.

  “No.” Hutch shook his head. “Understand that personality disorders are not mental illnesses. Lubinov isn’t crazy. He’s fully functional and can strategize and carry out whatever plans he devises.”

  “In some ways, that makes him even more dangerous,” Casey noted aloud.

  “You bet,” Marc said. His gaze was sober as it found Casey’s, and he spoke to her as only her right-hand man could. “I totally agree with what Hutch is saying. Which means I strongly suggest that, once Ryan figures out where Lubinov’s estate is, you squelch his urge to go all GI Joe on the place. Anything we might or might not contemplate doing will take the same level of strategizing and implementing as Lubinov is capable of.”

  “Absolutely.” Casey didn’t bat a lash.

  “Gee, why doesn’t that make me feel better?” Hutch asked.

  Casey turned to him, decisiveness written all over her face. “You’ve been more than wonderful. Thank you so much for your help. It was invaluable. But you need to leave now.”

  He arched a brow at her. “Why? So you can plan an illegal invasion of Maxim Lubinov’s compound—one that will put all your lives at risk? I’m not going anywhere.”

  “Hutch, we’ve already put you in an untenable position,” Casey replied quietly. “Whatever we do from this point on, you can’t be involved.”

  “She’s right, Hutch. This is where you get off.” Patrick’s words were few, but the look he gave Hutch conveyed it all. Hutch had given them the analysis they’d asked him for. He hadn’t crossed any indelible lines—not yet. All he had was supposition. If he walked away now, he’d be clean. If he hung around, he’d be blatantly violating his obligations to the Bureau.

  “I’ll take things from here,” Patrick added, still holding Hutch’s gaze.

  “Son of a bitch.” Hutch slammed his fist down on the desk. He read Patrick perfectly. He knew—and hated—the fact that he was right. He also knew that, no matter what he himself did now—and what he’d said earlier—ultimately, he wasn’t going to be able to keep his promises—not to Casey and not to the Bureau.