by Lexi Archer
Then again wasn’t I already considering hopping into the sack with Tiffany if she came along with the package deal that William provided? Was getting with Brandy really all that different from getting with him? Sure it was weird because she was my roommate, but I’d made out with friends before.
“Um, Melody? Are you still with us?” Brandy asked. She was waving her hand in front of my eyes.
I shook my head. Damn. I’d zoned out there. I’d gone to a very interesting zone, at that. A zone where Brandy and I were pressing together as our mouths met and our tongues…
“Melody?” Isaac asked.
Oops. I did it again. I needed to be careful about that or things were going to really get out of control. Well, more out of control than they already were. Which was pretty out of control. I could feel the situation slipping through my fingers and I wasn’t sure if I liked that.
“So what’s going on here tonight?” Brandy asked, a mischievous twinkle in her eye. “Are you two having company over? But then again you couldn’t be having that sort of company over. If you were then you would’ve sent me a text telling me to stay away for the rest of the night as per our roommate agreement.”
“Why would she need to go?” Isaac asked.
I looked between him and Brandy. Jutted my lip out in a pout. Usually that pout meant that I would get my way with him, but from the way he was looking my roommate up and down it didn’t seem like I was going to be getting my way tonight. Not when he knew what was on the table. What was going to happen as soon as William and Tiffany got here.
Did he want something like that to happen with Brandy as well? Why did I feel jealous and turned on by that idea at the same time?
Not for the first time I found myself wondering if perhaps I’d gone a little too far in agreeing to this. If I’d agreed to way more than I thought I was agreeing to when I said I wanted to invite William over.
And yet at the same time I knew it was far too late to go back. There was no stopping this now. The genie was out of the bottle and there was no way we weren’t going through with this. I needed to be with William that badly. So badly that I didn’t care what the consequences might be for my relationship.
“I think if Brandy wants to stick around that’s just fine,” Isaac said. “After all, you’re having a friend over aren’t you?”
Damn it. I was well and truly caught. I hated that he’d caught me like that too. Though now that I was caught I guess it was time to go with this and enjoy it.
“What are you talking about?” Brandy said. “What friend are you having over?”
I wanted to sink into the floor. I didn’t know exactly why, but for some reason I didn’t want Brandy to know William was coming over. That I was finally giving in to his charms. After all, how many times had she talked about how I needed to get with him, and how many times had I said that Isaac was the only guy for me?
I guess right there was a big reason why I didn’t want her to know I was having William over for that sort of fun. It would be admitting that Brandy was right all along.
It was too late to put a stop to anything even as that realization hit me though. There was a knock on the door. I squeezed my eyes shut as a wave of excitement ran through me. As a wave of terror ran through me. This was happening, and Brandy was a part of it now like it or not.
“Now who could that be?” Brandy asked, a mischievous look on her face. She sauntered over to the front door and pulled it wide open.
“Why William! Fancy seeing you here tonight!” Brandy said, her voice growing louder. Almost theatrically so. It was obvious she was overdoing it just for me.
Or maybe she’d just had that much to drink tonight. That was possible too. I think everybody here right now had a little too much to drink, and that was probably a good thing unless it was a bad thing. I couldn’t decide which it was, and the fact that I couldn’t decide probably showed that I’d had a little too much to drink tonight too.
I just didn’t know. Everything was so confusing. Again, too much to drink. It wasn’t doing much for my critical thinking ability.
“Well well,” William said, that cocky arrogance dripping from his voice. “If I’d known you were going to be inviting more girls to the party… Well I can’t say I would invite another guy to be honest. After all, this means more girls for me!”
He looked across the room and seemed to see Isaac standing there for the first time. “Well, I’m sure there will be plenty to go around. After all, you’re the one who has the fantasy of watching me with your girl, right?”
My mouth must’ve been hanging open. William looked over at me and he shook his head and laughed. As he laughed whole body shook. God he was so hot. Watching his muscles rippling under his shirt was intoxicating even when he was laughing at me and Isaac. I didn’t really care for the way he was laughing at us, but I also felt like it was too late. Seeing him here in my apartment I was too far gone. This was happening.
I didn’t even care if Isaac wanted to call it off, but from the way he was smiling and shaking his head it didn’t look like he was interested in calling anything off either. The surprises just kept coming tonight.
16: Fun With Friends
Isaac:
“How did you know?” I asked.
I wasn’t exactly a fan of the way this guy was constantly laughing and walking around like he owned the place, but at the same time I was so ready for this fantasy to become a reality that I was willing to put up with a little more bullshit than I would have otherwise.
Besides, the way he was acting, like an arrogant asshole, was sort of playing into the fantasy. At the end of the day I knew that Melody was going to be coming home with me. Or, rather, I suppose it would be more accurate to say she would be staying home with me. Or I would be staying at her apartment with her.
Whatever. The point I’m trying to make is we were the ones who were going to be together at the end of the night. This William guy could fantasize about having a relationship with her, but it wasn’t happening. That was enough to keep me under control. To keep me from rearranging his face like he deserved.
Barely.
“You think this is the first time someone has asked me to be a third in their relationship?” William asked, the cockiness oozing off of him in waves. “No, I know exactly what’s going down when some girl with a boyfriend calls and asks me to come over. Especially on a night when I saw her leaving with her boyfriend.”
“What if she just wanted to cheat with you?” I asked.
William shook his head. “No way. I saw her leaving with you. I knew the two of you were together. And I’ve seen how frustratingly faithful she’s stayed to you all summer long. No, I knew exactly what was up. It’s not my first time doing this sort of thing with a taken girl and I’d rather have her all to myself, but I’m happy to help out if that’s what you need.”
His eyes ran up and down Melody’s body and I shivered.
“Yeah, I’m more than willing to help out,” he said as he licked his lips. I imagined what that tongue could do to Melody’s body. From the way her breath was coming in quick gasps it looked like she was doing a little imagining of her own!
I laughed. “Well thanks for the help.”
William looked around the room. He took in Brandy standing in the center of the room with her mouth hanging open. It was pretty fucking obvious that whatever Brandy had expected, it wasn’t the admission that I wanted William to come over here so I could watch him fuck my girlfriend and Brandy’s best friend and roommate. She seemed astounded by the revelation.
Then I realized there was somebody standing behind William the entire time. I recognized that face. I recognized that body. That had to be Tiffany back there. I guess that made sense. She’d been with him earlier and I doubted she’d give up her chance with him just because he got a call for a more pressing engagement. I almost felt bad for her. This would be the second time this summer Melody upstaged her with a guy she was about to get with.
&nb
sp; Well it didn’t have to go that way. She could join in on the fun. The more I looked at this little gathering the more I thought the more the merrier!
“You can go ahead and come in Tiffany,” I said.
Tiffany hesitated and finally she stuck her head in around William. She looked like she wasn’t sure of herself. Like she didn’t even know if she wanted to come in here.
“What kind of kinky shit are you two planning for tonight?” she asked.
“The kind of kinky shit that involves three girls, two guys, and a whole lot of fun,” William said.
He glanced at Melody and Brandy one more time and then back to Tiffany. He let out another one of those barrel chested laughs. God. This guy was so full of himself, but then again if he got asked to do this thing pretty regularly then I suppose it wasn’t entirely out of character for him to be that cocky. He had a good reason for being that cocky.
And he continued showing off that cockiness as he walked across the room and demonstrated exactly what kind of “kinky shit” we could expect this evening. He grabbed Melody and she let out a squeal that wasn’t entirely friendly but it was also ever so slightly delighted. He pulled her around and literally swept her off her feet.
One leg went into the air and wrapped around him and I was focused with laser precision on that spot where their bodies made contact. Where his cock had to be pressing against the warm welcoming forbidden spot between her legs. Her pussy. That sweet wet treasure that only I was supposed to enjoy this summer, and yet here was William enjoying her treasures just as much as I had. Maybe more so considering this was the only chance he was going to get at her.
At least I told myself it was the only chance he was going to get at her. I suppose there was a part of me that always knew there would be more than tonight if this went well, but I ignored that aroused voice.
I felt jealousy rage inside me as he moved down and kissed her. As her mouth opened to him while her hands wrapped around his neck and they explored one another for a long silent moment filled only with the wet sound of their mouths coming together while everybody else in the room stared at them dumbfounded.
It was clear nobody in the room could believe this was happening. Myself included.
I might not believe what I saw happening right in front of me, but I sure as hell was going to enjoy it! I watched Melody making out with him and delivering on the promise that had started on that fateful evening on the bus when another guy watched us fuck. I was giddy with anticipation as I thought about all the deliciously naughty things the two of them might do with one another as the night wore on.
“Holy shit,” I heard Brandy whisper.
Holy shit was absolutely right. I didn’t think I would actually see this. I guess the entire evening I hadn’t been sure that Melody would go through with making out with him, let alone doing more. I still couldn’t quite believe that this was actually going to happen when she got on the phone with him.
And yet here we were. It was happening right in front of me, and I couldn’t fucking believe it any more than Brandy could.
Yet there was the proof right before our eyes. The incredible arousing proof that had me dealing with one hell of a painful hard on. I licked my lips as they continued sucking face. As it seemed as though both Melody and William had completely forgotten everybody else in the room.
I felt somebody approaching me from the other side. I looked and saw Tiffany standing there staring at me with an odd expression. It was almost lust. She looked over to William and Melody and then back to me. Looked me up and down, and it was clear she wasn’t upset about Melody moving in on another guy she’d been interested in.
No, it seemed she was willing to take the opportunity of Melody distracting William, and William distracting Melody for that matter, to move in on the guy who’d interested her from the beginning of the summer.
She reached out and took my hand. Gave it a squeeze as we turned and watched my girlfriend and this giant hunk of a man with his model good looks sucking face. I felt my cock growing harder and harder at that touch, and I was hardly surprised as I felt somebody taking my hand on the other side. I looked over to see Brandy giving me an uncertain smile. She also looked me up and down and that was a look that really surprised me.
Brandy and I had gotten to know one another over the summer. It was only natural that we would. She was my girlfriend’s roommate, after all. But it was surprising the way she was at me now. She’d always been a firm supporter of the dividing line between actors and non-actors. She always gave Melody grief and said she was only joking, but it had annoyed me all summer long. To see her staring at me, one of the definite have-nots even if I took pretty good care of myself thank you very much, was an odd experience.
Maybe it was all the sexual energy in the room getting the best of her. Maybe it was that she’d harbored some feelings all summer long and she’d been hiding them. Maybe she’d been afraid of them.
At that moment I didn’t give a fuck what the reasoning was. All I cared about was that she was looking at me like she meant business.
“Looks like you’re not the only one having a bit of extracurricular fun this evening Melody,” I heard a deep voice say from the other side of the room.
I was pulled out of the spell cast by that moment with Tiffany and Brandy. I looked over and realized Melody and William had stopped their kiss. He was looking over at us with that stupid cocky grin on his face. Melody was staring and her expression was unreadable, but she didn’t seem happy. I felt a flash of irritation at that.
After all, I was letting her get with another guy. She was going to fuck another guy. Sure, she was fucking another guy because of my fantasy, but still. It seemed like it was only fair that she would give me a little bit of the same consideration.
“Are you okay with this?” I asked her. I figured it was best to have everything out in the open. Best to make sure we were on the same page. I’d rather find out she wasn’t okay with this now. It might be unfair, but I didn’t want to completely torpedo our relationship for the rest of the summer either.
Melody thought about it for a long moment. Long enough that I worried she might actually say no. Finally she bit her lip and looked up at William. Looked back at me. I could almost hear the same thoughts running through her mind that had been running through mine, and then she nodded.
“Yes,” she said. “I guess I am okay with it.”
“So what would you say to us moving this to a bedroom?” William asked.
Brandy spoke up this time. “We don’t really have a bedroom that’s big enough to fit all of us.”
“Well that’s fine,” William said. “You two go off and have your fun with the boyfriend and I’ll enjoy myself with Melody here. She can tell you all about it later. That’s what you guys are into, right?”
Anger and panic rose inside me for the first time that evening. Not panic at the sight of my girlfriend making out with another man. Not panic at the idea of her cheating on me, even if it was cheating with my permission. No, I suppose it was a sign of just how powerful this fantasy was that the first sense of panic that I felt that evening was at the idea that William and my girlfriend might get it on and I wouldn’t get to witness any of it.
Thankfully, Melody stepped in and saved me. She shook her head.
“Not a chance in hell,” she said. “The deal was Isaac gets to watch me doing whatever it is we do, and I want to watch him doing whatever it is he’s going to do with my friends.”
I nodded. “Yeah, what she said. We might be stepping out, but we’re stepping out together or not at all.”
William shrugged. It didn’t seem to bother him one way or the other. I guess to him it really didn’t matter as long as he had a chance to get into Melody’s pants. He didn’t seem like the sort of guy to give much of a fuck as long as he was getting what he wanted, and it was clear from the way he was looking her up and down that Melody was very much what he wanted right now.
“I thought you
might say something like that,” he said. “So why don’t we just move some furniture aside in here and put some blankets down?”
The next few minutes were a scramble as everybody moved around the apartment trying to find enough blankets and pillows that we could all have a good time. Finally we settled on a solution that was elegant even if it took a little bit of extra work. Brandy and Melody both had twin sized beds in their rooms, and so we pulled those mattresses out and threw them on the ground in the living room where there was just enough room to fit both of them. It was going to be a tight squeeze to get five people on there at the same time, but then again getting everybody on those beds in a tight squeeze was pretty much the whole idea, wasn’t it?”
William and Melody were the first to fall down together on a mattress. They took an entire mattress to themselves and I found myself staring, intoxicated, as they rolled around. As there was a frantic movement as they tried to get their clothes off. And yet even though it was frantic, at the same time there was a slow and deliberate process to the way William ran his hands all over my girlfriend’s body. He moved at a deliberate pace, and it was obvious that he had experience savoring the pleasures of a taken girl. It was obvious he knew what he was doing.
I liked to think I was pretty good with the ladies myself, but watching him work was like watching a master, and from the way Melody was sighing and moaning under his touch it seemed like he was doing a good job.
He pulled her shirt up and took her bra right along with. A moment later her tits bounced out and they were perfect. They were even more perfect because they were in another man’s hands. My cock twitched as I watched his hands covering her tits and exploring her body. He looked up at her with reverence. It was obvious he’d been with plenty of girls over the years, but at the same time it was obvious that he was treating Melody in particular as though she was the crown jewel of all of his conquests.