Crossroads 5: Show Me What Love Is (Siren Publishing Ménage Everlasting)

by Dixie Lynn Dwyer

  He reached up and caressed her cheek. “That’s beautiful, baby. We can take you together. Make you ours together.”

  She pulled her bottom lip between her teeth as her pussy quaked from his words and from the images floating around in her head. Riley, Collin, and Chancellor making love to her.

  His fingers stroked her pussy. His lips kissed her belly as he lifted up.

  “Take my cell phone off my hip,” he told her very calmly.

  She swallowed hard, and her heart continued to race.

  “Hit one on the speed dial.” He gently glided his digits in and out of her cunt. His shoulders kept her legs wide open.

  “It’s your choice. Let them come here and allow us to explore these feelings together and go as far as you’re ready for, or call it a night.” He continued to tease her pussy before he lowered down and licked her pussy lips.

  “Chancellor.” She moaned, eyes closed and holding his cell phone in a death grip. She was scared, nervous, aroused, intrigued, and she hit number one.

  “What’s up?” She heard Collin’s voice.

  She didn’t say a word.

  “Hello?” Collin repeated.

  “Get Riley and get to Bethany’s house. The front door is unlocked,” Chancellor said aloud and then stroked a finger from her pussy to her anus, and she moaned aloud, giving away exactly what was happening at her place.

  She dropped the phone onto the table, her arm falling to the side.

  “Keep your arms above your head. Offer me this body, Bethany. Offer it to my brothers when they get here, too.”

  It was wild, the way he gave orders but made it sound as though she was making the final decision.

  She slowly raised her arms up, and he lowered his head and began to feast on her cunt.

  She tilted her head back and moaned, then jerked when she felt his tongue lash against her anus.

  “Chancellor.”

  He stroked fingers into her cunt and pressed his thumb to her anus.

  “Every part of you is going to belong to me and my brothers. Every gorgeous, sexy inch of you, do you understand me?” he asked in a tone and with an expression that did something carnal to her insides.

  “I never felt like this.”

  “Good. We’ll be the first men to finger that ass, to fuck that ass and to take you in every hole together as brothers, as one.”

  She felt the tears fill her eyes as the desire, the intrigue, and excitement filled her to her soul. She wanted to feel loved, to feel like she was part of something, of someone, instead of always alone.

  He continued to stroke her pussy then alternate tongue and fingers.

  “Undo the jacket, and tell me, baby, are you on the pill? Do we need protection?” he asked her.

  “I think we should use something anyway. You guys are more…”

  She swallowed hard. She didn’t want to think of them being ladies’ men, but she wasn’t stupid. She knew Chancellor’s reputation, and he and his brothers had years on her.

  “Don’t believe everything you hear, Bethany. I’m clean and so are my brothers.” He pressed his slick finger to her anus as his other finger pushed into her cunt, and she cried out another release.

  The front door opened, and she gasped and lowered her arms as Riley and Collin came into sight. They looked wild, carnal as they closed the door, locked it, and pulled off their jackets.

  She tried closing her legs and sitting up, but then Chancellor stroked her a little faster and eased over her.

  “Look at me,” he said to her, and she dragged her gaze away from Collin and Riley, who were pulling off their coats and coming toward them.

  “You want this. You want us as badly as we want you. We’re not going anywhere. This isn’t a one-night stand. I can tell you that right now. Let’s explore these feelings together, baby. Now, arms up.”

  She looked at Collin and Riley, who were now closer to the couch. Riley knelt down beside her hip, and Collin placed one knee onto the couch and stroked her cheek. She tilted her head up to look at him.

  “Are you sure, baby?” he asked her, and she felt her gut yell yes and her heart lift with excitement.

  “I’m scared. It’s been so long. I’ve been alone for so long,” she whispered.

  “You’re not alone anymore. Never again, Bethany,” Riley told her, and then leaned down and kissed her lips.

  “I think we need more room,” Collin said, and Riley released her lips and looked into her eyes.

  “Want us to take you to your bedroom, where we can spread out and explore you fully?” he asked with a small smile.

  “Yes.” She felt Chancellor pull his fingers from her cunt and ass, and then he lifted her up into his arms as if she weighed nothing at all, even in her coat and fully dressed.

  She hugged him tightly as he carried her down the small hallway and into her bedroom.

  Chancellor placed her feet onto the hardwood floor. She held on to his waist as he began to undress her, first her jacket, and then Riley unzipped the back of her dress and they stood still as it fell to the floor. She stepped from her stretched-out panties, destroyed from Chancellor’s exploration in the hallway and on the couch.

  “My God, baby, you are gorgeous.” Collin cupped her cheek and drew her closer for a kiss. His beard tickled her skin yet aroused her so much as she swayed between the three men.

  She felt the hands exploring her ass and her breasts. Riley unclipped the front of her bra, releasing her breasts from confinement and then latching onto one with his mouth and teeth.

  Collin released her lips and ran his palm along her ass.

  “You have one hell of a body, baby. You were made for us.”

  She felt her cheeks warm, but then as she lowered her eyes and turned, she spotted Chancellor, naked and stroking his long, thick cock.

  Her lips parted, and she stared in admiration. He was muscular, tan, physically fit, and drop-dead gorgeous. Riley released her breast with a plop and then stood up straighter. He placed his hands on her hips.

  “Are you ready for us?”

  “I don’t think I can handle this. I mean, three of you together. I’ve never…” She lowered her eyes, and he cupped her chin and tilted it up toward him.

  “Don’t hold back, and be honest. If anything we do scares you, we’ll stop.”

  She was shocked by his words. They were men, and they had needs. Curran had always taken from her when he wanted and never asked what she liked or whether it hurt or made her uncomfortable. These men were perfect, and she didn’t know how to react other than to wrap her arms around Riley’s shoulders and hug him.

  He lowered her to the bed as he hugged her back, and then lifted up and kissed her lips. He explored her mouth, her chin and jaw, then neck tenderly before lowering to her breasts, tasting each mound. She glanced to the right and saw Collin stepping from his boxers, stroking his cock, and then he joined them on the bed. He was huge, muscular and had lots of tattoos and a dusting of hair along his chest. He looked untamed, sexy, and the inner goddess in her felt compelled to tame him and make him all hers. Then she gasped, feeling the tongue against her clit as Riley began to explore her pussy.

  “So sweet. So fucking delicious,” he said, lowering down.

  Chancellor joined her on her other side, and he and Collin caressed her arms and then clasped their fingers with hers before they slowly raised them up above her head. The move caused her breasts to stick out, her thighs to widen, and her hips to arch upward. She felt sexy, stimulated, as Riley licked her from pussy to anus, back and forth. He pressed fingers to both holes, and she cried out another release.

  Collin leaned over and licked her right breast as Chancellor licked and feasted on her left breast. They tugged and pulled, causing an imaginary string to hit her cunt and making her spill more cream. Riley was there to slurp it up and use her juices to lubricate both holes as he stroked into them.

  “Oh, God. Oh, Riley,” she cried out again.

  “God, you’re so
responsive and so sexy. I need in, baby,” Chancellor told her.

  “Yes. Yes, Chancellor.” He leaned over and kissed her on the mouth. She felt Riley’s fingers pull from her body, and she immediately felt the loss.

  Chancellor stood up and stepped between her legs. He ran his hands up and down her thighs as he spread them wider. He stared at her as Riley undressed the rest of the way and then joined her on the bed with Collin. Both men caressed up her thighs and spread them as Chancellor aligned his cock with her pussy.

  “No turning back. From tonight on, you’re ours, and we’re yours.”

  “Yes,” she whispered, and then he slowly began to ease his thick, hard cock into her cunt. He clenched his teeth and lowered slightly as he eased into her. When Collin and Riley both pinched her nipples, she cried out, and Chancellor thrust all the way into her cunt.

  “Jesus, you’re so fucking tight. My God, baby, you’re sucking my cock so hard. Jesus.” He eased in and out, eyes clenched and hands gripping her hips.

  “Fuck,” he exclaimed and she cried out as she released more cream, easing his strokes.

  “Let him in. Let him have all of you,” Riley ordered with that firm, law-enforcement expression of his that obviously drove her insane.

  “Take me, Chancellor. More,” she chanted, and Chancellor began to stroke into her faster, deeper. In a flash, she was calling his name and gripping his shoulders as he leaned over her and pounded into her cunt. Her bed rocked and creaked, never experiencing such a carnal love session, or any love session, for that matter. Riley and Collin leaned back and watched. She saw them, and she sensed them surrounding her, protecting her, and it aroused her beyond understanding.

  “Chancellor.” She came again, and Chancellor grunted and then came inside of her.

  She felt so wild, so needy. It was like a barrier was broken, a safeguard destroyed, and she was allowed freedom to express love and be loved and cherished, and she wanted these men to fill her up with more. They did this to her. They turned her on, made her want happiness, companionship, a connection other than life to earth until death.

  “So perfect. My God, baby, you’re perfect for me.” He leaned down and kissed her as he eased his cock from her pussy.

  Riley was there to take his place. He ran his hands along her thighs and then aligned his cock with her cunt.

  “Mine,” he said so very seriously and then stroked into her cunt in one smooth, deep stroke.

  She grabbed onto him and moaned as he immediately began to thrust into her pussy. She wrapped her legs around his waist as best she could, but he was thick, wide, and filled with muscles. Her groin tightened, her thighs aching from being spread so wide to accommodate his size between them, but his strokes took over all her focus. His cock was thick, hard, and long. It tapped her womb and made her gush more cream and cry out until she had no voice left.

  “Fuck, you’re incredible. My God, baby, you complete me,” he said to her as he grunted and came.

  He lifted up and kissed her mouth. He plunged his tongue in deeply, and they battled over the kiss as he eased from her cunt. He kissed her breasts and tugged on her nipples before smiling at her and stroking her chin.

  “Take care of my brother. Don’t hold back. Give him all of you,” he said, and she turned to look at Collin as he climbed between her legs and lowered over her. He placed his hands on her cheeks and stared down into her eyes.

  “You’re the most beautiful, sexy woman I’ve ever laid eyes on. That isn’t a line, baby. It’s the truth, and I haven’t been with a woman in quite some time. I want you to know that, to know that these feelings are real and tonight is so damn special. You’re special, and now, you’re mine.” Collin kissed her lips as he eased his thick cock into her cunt. He nudged and stroked multiple times, trying to fit into her tight channel. She widened her thighs, trying to accommodate his girth, and then she felt his finger pinch her nipple and she moaned as he sank all the way into her cunt.

  Riley was relentless with his strokes. He started off slowly, deeply, rubbing his pelvic bone against her pussy. Then he eased up on one side, leaning on his forearm as he used his other hand and fingers to manipulate her breasts.

  He then eased her hips lower, and she wound up on the edge of the bed, her ass feeling the cool air drifting against her sensitive anus. He stroked faster, then eased a finger over her puckered hole and began to nudge at the opening. She moaned and held on to him tightly, countering his thrusts and easing her ass over his finger. She was intrigued, ready to try anything and take these men any way they wanted. They were sexy, charismatic, powerful men, and she felt so feminine and desirable that she pressed her ass harder until his finger stroked into her ass.

  “That’s it, baby. Your body knows. It knows that it’s made for the three of us. It feel good?” he asked.

  “Yes.” She moaned, and he thrust his cock faster, deeper as he pushed his finger in and out of her ass.

  “Riley. Oh God, Riley, it feels wild and naughty.”

  “I like wild and naughty and you together,” Chancellor told her as he joined them on the bed.

  “Me too. Sounds like a good time,” Collin said, and both men cupped her breasts and played with them as Collin stroked into her pussy and her ass. She was teetering on the unknown when all three men worked in sync, pinching her nipples and stroking her when she cried out and came.

  “Sweet mother, she is incredible,” Chancellor exclaimed, and Collin grunted and stroked, then pulled his finger from her ass, shocking her as he gripped her hips and pounded into her pussy at record speed. He cried out her name, “Bethany!” as he came, spilling his seed inside of her.

  * * * *

  Bethany hugged him tightly as Collin lay over her, absorbing the aftereffects of their lovemaking. He and his brothers had shared Bethany. They’d made love to her one after the next and began to claim her as their woman. It was happening. After all those years and desires of wanting a woman to share, to love, and cherish between them, it was happening with Bethany. He felt so possessive, protective of her as he eased out of her cunt and drew her to his side after Riley moved off the bed. A moment later, Chancellor was there with a warm washcloth and began to clean Bethany up. She grabbed his hand and sat up.

  “I can do that. Oh God, I should have done that immediately.” She pressed her hair behind her ear and scooted toward the edge of the bed. Her reaction and behavior shocked Collin.

  He snagged her around the waist and hoisted her back up against his side. He kept her in place as she tried struggling to get free. He plastered a hand over her ass.

  “Stay here. I want you right here beside me. I don’t want you out of my sight after that. I need you.”

  She held his gaze as she eased up and pressed her hands to his chest. Behind her, Chancellor spread her thighs and cleaned her. Her cheeks turned a nice shade of red, and Riley cupped her cheek. He held her gaze.

  “You belong to us. You’re our woman now, and we take care of what is ours.”

  “But I should take care of that stuff.”

  He shook his head. “It’s our job to care for you. Now lie down against Collin and help him to calm his nerves,” Riley ordered, and Chancellor chuckled.

  “I knew she was perfect. My God.” Chancellor pulled on his boxers.

  “Hey, what’s wrong?” Collin asked her as she held on to him and had tears in her eyes and a shocked expression on her face.

  “I’m not used to this,” she whispered, her lips tickling the skin of his chest.

  “Not used to three men making love to you and caring for you afterwards?” Riley asked, pulling on his boxers and sitting on the edge of the bed facing her. They surrounded her, and Collin felt her tighten up again.

  “No.” She sounded sad.

  Chancellor caressed her back and her ass. “Well, get used to it, sunshine, because, being our woman, you’ll be catered to and cuddled with often.” He leaned down and kissed her shoulder. She looked at him and then at Collin and Riley.


  “Are you for real?” she asked, and Collin felt his gut clench.

  “Baby, you mentioned someone hurt you, an ex, I assumed. Was he not caring after sex?” Riley asked, and Collin felt immediately angry when shook her head and seemed about to cry.

  “Talk to us. Tell us what he did so we know what upsets you or makes you feel uncomfortable.” Chancellor leaned over and ran his hand along her hip and ass. He was caressing her, and they surrounded her. Riley clasped his hand with hers, and Collin held her against him.

  “Tell us,” Riley pushed.

  “I can’t,” she whispered.

  “You mean you won’t,” Riley challenged.

  “After what we just shared, you can’t explain this fear from your past?” Chancellor asked.

  “I can’t do this. I can’t pour my soul out to you.”

  “Why not?” Riley asked.

  “Because just letting you into my heart, into my body, was more than enough for right now. I haven’t had sex in years, Riley. Years. I haven’t let another man, another person, close enough to even trust or let my guard down. In less than a week’s time, I met the three of you, began to feel alive, protected, and not alone anymore, and then slept with you. That’s three men and something I’m not used to. I don’t want to ruin this. I just want to bask in it, enjoy it, take it for whatever it is.”

  “It’s something special. It’s something that can last, but only if you’re honest with us,” Collin said to her.

  Riley caressed her cheek. “We don’t want to do what he did to you. We don’t want us to remind you of him and what sounds like a very sad and scary time of your life.”

  She was silent a moment as she looked at them and really seemed to be struggling. He was scared. For the first time in years, he felt scared.

  “Don’t ever hit me or try to kill me and you won’t remind me of him.” A tear rolled down her cheek.

  They were shocked as the three of them widened their eyes, looked at one another and then down at Bethany. All Collin could do was pull her closer and hug her as the three of them caressed her and kissed her everywhere their lips could touch.